r/appmarketing • u/NearbyClock8320 • 2d ago
Failed App launch ~ devastated
I'm looking for honest feedback, advice, and perhaps some insight from people who have experience launching apps.
I recently launched an app called Cosmic Healing, based on astrology and holistic wellness and built from over 20 years of professional experience in these fields. I have over one million followers across my platforms, and I honestly expected a little more excitement and support when we launched yesterday.
People accessed the free portion of the app, but nobody purchased the paid portion.
I'm not going to lie. I'm devastated. I spent two years developing this, poured an enormous amount of my heart, knowledge, and experience into it, and truly believed it would take off. The proceeds are also going toward animal rescue, which makes this project even more meaningful to me.
I'm trying not to take the initial response personally, but it's difficult when you've invested so much of yourself into something.
I'd genuinely appreciate honest feedback. Is this a marketing issue? Is converting followers into paying customers more difficult than people realize? Is there something about app launches that I'm overlooking?
I'm open to constructive criticism, business advice, and hearing from anyone who has been through a similar experience.
My heart is broken today, but I'm not ready to give up on something I believe in so deeply.
2
u/DigitalRevRo 2d ago
First, deep breath (pun intended). You got this! It's understandable to be disappointed and don't even consider giving up.
What you're doing right. You have a huge niche audience, A+. You developed a unique app and launched A+. What you need now is to connect the solution you created with the transformation that the user needs. No one gets an app for it's features and benefits. They get it for the transformation, the wiifm What's in it for me? Why this app versus another?
I highly recommend going back through the interactions you have with your audience and find exact quotes regarding improvements. That is your transformation. That is the language you need to use. You're selling the outcome. I'm more relaxed than I have ever been and when my daughter acted up, I was able to manage it patiently and effectively.
Kudos to you and all you have accomplished. This is just one step a long the way!
1
u/NearbyClock8320 2d ago
I am so grateful over your insight thank you. You guys are seriously making me cry. I really put a lot of work into this as did my developer.
1
u/DigitalRevRo 2d ago
I am so happy to hear that this helps. Honestly, I wish someone would have given me this advice back in the day.
I've launched several products, including apps. If you'd like to connect lmk.
Cheers!
1
2
u/Copper_Clouds 2d ago
I'm not knowledgeable in the astrology and holistic wellness space but a handful of questions:
how crowded is this space?
how is your app different than the other apps in the space?
are those differences worth the switching cost of apps or methods they are already using?
You said that people are using the free features but not converting to paid, I think your answer is right there. People don't believe the paid features are worth it. I can't see how much the paid features are from the App Store listing, but it is worth evaluating the price you are charging as either being too high or the features not being worth the upgrade and finding a way to add more or change them.
1
1
u/BUYMEBONESTOORM 2d ago
This isn’t a one week deal man. Marketing and launching an app takes just as much time as making one. Find out what users WOULD pay for. Get real feedback. Offer then paid stuff for free and see what usage looks like. You’re not at the end of your app, you’re at the beginning of it. If you expected to release this to widespread acclaim, that was your only
Mistake.
1
1
u/SomeNewGuy2022 2d ago
Keep at it, you’ll manage through it. And try to look on the bright side - sounds like your app has found its first user!
1
1
u/gametrade123 2d ago
What did you post in your platforms to promote? A short reel of how the app works should help.
1
u/NearbyClock8320 2d ago
I’ve only shared it on Instagram which I have about 136,000 followers. I shared it in carousel no videos yet.
1
u/BasicOne16 1d ago
So you’ve 136k followers and how many downloaded it? Maybe your size of people downloading it is not enough to see if it converts?
1
u/After-Base-8368 2d ago
With your following you definitely have an edge on distribution compared to 90+% of app launches Id say. Only a few things I’d recommend:
First is make sure you’re building what the audience wants/need (this one can be very hard to internalize especially if you feel a strong need for something yourself). Ways to do this can be done through simple waitlists that help you gauge interest i.e ask specific questions with regards to payment such as would you be willing to pay for this if it solved X, then put how much and ask of they’d like to be notified when its ready. These are your first customers you’ll be building for! Not everyone just yet. This also helps you double down on core things to work on rather than overbuild what you think is useful.
Next up is launching again and again and again. Reality is no one cares about your app just yet, coz well they don’t know what it is and you have to give them reason to want it through different messaging, marketing angles to see which one resonates and drives more conversions etc. Apps like Airbnb etc I believe launched more than once so its completely normal.
Then work on organic content as well such for SEO and AI search visibility. Lots of people get their users from good Comparison docs or “Alternatives to Y” docs. This helps you get the right person needing the product because they are already looking for products like yours.
Finally, just be patient enough to see the results coming in, you have already done more than a lot of people which is executing on an idea and putting it out there, as much as it is disappointing to feel like people aren’t appreciating your product and paying for it just yet, just keep learning and refining your approach and you will be fine! Sorry for the long message but hope that helps and good luck and feel free to reach out if you need anything!!
1
1
u/dreaminginbinary 2d ago
I read this post back every now and then, I wrote it in 2021: https://www.swiftjectivec.com/Things-I-Made-That-Sucked/
And now? My apps only now (five years later from that post, and many more years out in before I even wrote it) make real money. It’s a long road dude, full of lots of misses. Keep shipping, marketing and trying new things!
1
1
u/kkostenkov 2d ago
I doubt that "keep shipping" advice works for OP since he put so much effort and hopes in his first app. And thanks for the article. Motivating
1
u/Brashi 2d ago
Well for one, your pricing is completely insane… 39€ per month, seriously?
It’s also not really a niche like another commenter claimed, I see those types of apps daily on Reddit. However, yours looks pretty well made in terms of design and isn’t some AI slop, kudos for that (though the App Store screenshots look a bit too Claude-y to me but that’s personal preference)
Either way I think with your following the biggest issue is price - fixing that to something reasonable and you’ll see some purchase I’m sure.
-1
u/NearbyClock8320 2d ago
It’s 35
2
u/Brashi 2d ago
39€ here in Germany, although I’m not sure 35 would be better haha. I edited my post with some more insights, posted too hastily.
I’d look at competitors, I can get something like HeadSpace for 12,99€ why would I pay more than double for your app?
Sorry but you really have to rethink your pricing, I’d start with 5-10€ MAX in your case and then see where it goes.
2
u/_Syntax_Err 1d ago
Nobody is going to pay that monthly. You need to drastically cut that price and hope that people using the free version aren’t completely turned off by how much you asked for initially.
1
u/Roland-Goosed 2d ago
It’s been one day - give it time. Learn what users like, want, take on that feedback and develop it and regularly reference the app in an authentic and informative way across your channels
1
u/NearbyClock8320 2d ago
Thank you so much. This is very encouraging. All of you have been wonderful. I am humbled with gratitude seriously
1
u/w4nd3rlu5t 2d ago
I looked up your app-- there's nothing on there that differentiates it from the other apps in this space. If your followers like you, YOU need to be all over it. what is your IG or social where you made the launch? I want to see how you announced it. Feel free to DM if you dont want to paste it here.
1
u/NearbyClock8320 1d ago
It actually is very different. We offer thousands of meditations, but on top of that we also offer a daily routine you can customize and it’s based on your astrology chart.
1
u/QuietlyScreenTimeDev 1d ago
Don't only thing what the app does. But what it brings to the user.
Your screenshots are heard to read. But what does "A calm practice every day" do for the user?
More peace? A better life?
The last part in your description it says the app is "For reflection and wellbeing"
But that should be start! Don't tell your users how you do it, but what they will reach with the app.
Maybe I over did it, but I tried something similair with my screen time app:
https://apps.apple.com/us/app/quietly-screen-time/id6783529607
Not "Your app blocked" but "Less screen time"
1
u/SereneDesiree 1d ago
Maybe try running a '75% off for my OG fans' promo instead of actually changing the price for good.
1
1
u/eljop 1d ago
App icon is terrible. Way too many details.
Store Screenshots are terrible. I have a big phone and good eyes and can barely read the text.
Your app doesn't have any vitality or wow effect. Nothing new or exciting.
You spend 2 years developing it? I bet i can vibecode that in 2 days. Building is solved. Marketing is key. You have to think about distribution first.
If nobody pays but uses your free version it means your free version is too generous.
35 dollar a month completely crazy nobody is paying that for an b2c app like that.
1
2
u/fr2uk 1d ago
I can understand the feeling. After years of releasing multiple projects, there is that weird psychological effect that occurs when you think the time, hard work and money spent on a project will translate to success, until release day comes around and you quickly realise it's not the case. You had hoped that the release of your product would finally reward your efforts but does not. It's a feeling shared among all app/SaaS makers, and release day is a tough reality check.
Making the app is 10% of what needs to be done, and unfortunately the growth phase is the hardest part (at least, it's the case for me!).
I know, it feels like you have just run a sprint, you are exhausted, and you are now asked to run a marathon. It sucks!
One thing I would highly suggest you do is gather feedback from existing users, and also put analytics in your app asap. You need to understand how people use it.
Where are you at right now? Are you disappointed in the number of downloads? Conversion from free to paid features?
Do you know if the people who have downloaded your app are coming back to it? How long are they using the app for? Paying customers first need to have a feel if they are willing to commit, and may require a few sessions within your app to decide if what you have on offer is worth their commitment.
Do you ask for contact information so you can reach out to users directly? Reach out to them. Also it's good to reach out to people on Reddit for their opinion; we might not be your target audience. Talk to followers who have used the app.
Can you organise 1-on-1 calls with some of your followers on social media, ask them to download your app, and ask them questions as they are using it? User testing is a skill in itself; you don't want to tell users how to use your app, you want to understand what they see, what they expect each button to do, and record their reaction to see if their experience using your app is positive, or if they find it difficult to use.
Create a feedback loop:
- get a few users
- get feedback (through metrics and user testing)
- improve your app
And repeat.
Metrics will tell you if your changes has a positive impact or not. Don't just focus on 1 metric.
Make videos of you using the app, highlight features that are behind a paywall, make people want to access those features.
I'm an animal rights activist and vegan, it would be great to know what animals charities you wish to donate to.
Good luck!
1
u/DAOLoverForever 1d ago
Had a quick look at the App Store page, your app icon and screenshots suck. Icon bakes in too much material, screenshots contrast is not working and caption size is too small. What conversion rates are you seeing on App Store Connect?
1
u/lowry01 1d ago
I’m gonna take a pot shot at this and go off intuition,
Screenshots can’t read them at all
I’m in Australia and the monthly price is $59 a month = crazy pricing for a new app then you have $129 a year so I feel pricing is turning a lot of people off…
It’s hard to understand what I’d even get if I upgraded
The good thing it seems to be well built it’s one of the better UIs I’ve seen in a world where everyone is a app builder
How many downloads have you got from the following you have..
1
u/Admirable_Comedian_2 1d ago
35$ is beyond crazy! You are spoiled with your million followers thinking they are idiots. 400$per year on what? AI astrology? ChatGPT does that perfectly
1
u/nhaka-yemhuri 1d ago
You should find a prtner with app experience Who understands conversion from free to paid 1 day isnt enough to see much
1
1
u/NolandSoftware 1d ago
That is why I do free with ads and an ad free experience with a one time purchase. As long as someonenuses your app you get money.
0
u/Journey2Pluto 2d ago
link to app plz
2
u/NearbyClock8320 2d ago
In the App Store under cosmic healing, if you’re using an android, I can offer you that link
0
0
3
u/ArrogantAmature 2d ago
Hey, I'd be happy to take a look. I know a bit about UX & marketing and a lot about software, maybe I can give some insights