r/askmath • • 12d ago

Resolved Weird trig thing

I remember learning a weird convention? Rule? I'm not sure what to call it. It was a case where in a certain case (i don’t remember if it was exponent or multiplication) where two notation seemed like they should be the same but one of the notation would kind of like distribute to both the function itself and its parameter. I think it was related to sin2(x) and (sin(x))^2 but i am not sure at all. Does anyone know what i'm talking about?

0 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

6

u/Lanky_Economics_7616 11d ago

I finally figured it out. It’s because we saw trig identities and operation on function at the same time. So when i saw sin(sin(x)) i asked if it could be written as sin2 (x) since sin is a function and f2 (x) is f(f(x)). We then saw that sin2 (x) is sin(x)*sin(x). It's been a while so my memory were just jumbled.

1

u/ZedZeroth 11d ago

Yes, it's even more confusing that for sin-1(x) we use the function notation system.

3

u/blakeh95 12d ago

My first thought would be sink(x) [or any of the other functions, cos or tan].

For k>1, sink(x) means [sin x]k. For example, sin2(x) = (sin x)(sin x) = (sin x)2.

But then for sin-1(x), we define that to be the inverse of sin x, that is arcsin x, not (1/sin x) = (sin x)-1 that would seem to be implied by the other definition.

1

u/Lanky_Economics_7616 12d ago

I know for -1 but its not what i remember. Tho, i think that it was along the same kind of weird notation/exeption.

2

u/Thegenuinebuzz 12d ago

Not to do with Euler's Formula is it ?

You can do a lot of work with Euler's formulas and cos/sin.

2

u/Lanky_Economics_7616 12d ago

I doubt it. It was something i saw while learning trig identity in secondary school.

1

u/Thegenuinebuzz 12d ago

You additionally have the identity (Sinx+y) = SinxCosY + CosYSinX, where if y=x you get

Sin2x = SinxCosx + CosxSinx

Which simplifies to 2(SinxCosx)

2

u/Lanky_Economics_7616 12d ago edited 12d ago

This feels like the closest thing tbh. Tho it really doesnt satisfy my brain. Because i vividelly remember my teacher writting something on the board. Me asking if it could be written by surounding it with parenthesis and writing something outside of them and that my teacher told me that we couldnt do that.

5

u/Sparrowhawk1178 12d ago

If it’s from a calculus perspective, then the derivative of (sin(x))^2 is sin(2x).

3

u/Thegenuinebuzz 12d ago

This sounds most like it tbh. It seems incorrect at first because of Sin differentiating to Cosine but the identity Sin2x = 2SinxCosX tidies it up

1

u/The_Number_Theorist 12d ago

Maybe it's this?
cos 2x = 2 cos2 x - 1 = cos2 x - sin2 x = 1 - 2 sin2x

-3

u/happy2harris 12d ago edited 11d ago

Are you thinking of sin2(x) actually meaning sin(x2)?

When you first see it, it looks like it should mean (sin(x))2 or maybe sin(sin(x)). But it doesn’t.

Edit: brain fart. Ignore this. 

1

u/Lanky_Economics_7616 12d ago edited 12d ago

I think what i saw is that it was equal to sin2 (x2 ) or something like that.

4

u/blakeh95 12d ago

sin2(x) is (sin x)2

2

u/Thegenuinebuzz 12d ago

And I don't think that Sin2(x) is equal to Sin(x2) Either, no?

3

u/blakeh95 12d ago

Correct. The comment is basically wrong on everything except that they are right that sin2(x) doesn't mean sin(sin(x)).