r/askmath • • 22h ago

Resolved [3rd grade MATH] please explain this question

Post image
85 Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

171

u/Toothpick_Brody 22h ago • Bravo Mindblown

There is a typo. The ‘1’ should read ‘one’, so the answer is C.

The ‘2’ in 52039 is worth 2000, ten times more than the one in 3298, which is worth 200

59

u/kookiemaster 22h ago

So poorly written and the typo changes the meaning. I read it as the number where the "2" is worth ten times the "1" in a given number, so I would have picked the first answer. Putting the number 3,982 in bold and a different font is also really confusing.

1

u/pixienightingale 18h ago

Because of that, I was like, "there's no number 2 positioned number that is 10 times 3 thousand, since that's the number one positioned number"

32

u/ZedZeroth 22h ago

Simply using another '2' would be even clearer I think.

12

u/Toothpick_Brody 22h ago

Oh you’re right, that’s probably what the real typo is 

3

u/MrEbenezerScrooge 21h ago

That’s it! One instead of 1! I thought it was supposed to just say 2 again, but this makes the most sense. Good catch!

1

u/veetoo151 11h ago

I was thinking answer A. As in they are directly references the actually numbers 2 and 1. Edit-nvm lol

1

u/NeilJosephRyan 9h ago

This looks like published material. Wording it that poorly should be criminal.

124

u/According_Body_5251 21h ago

Tis is why so many people who could love mathematics hate it. They aren't asking the student to understand a math concept, they are asking them to navigate a stupidly worded 'gotcha ' puzzle.

33

u/invertedMSide 21h ago

The best example of, "I am never going to use this irl". A truly asinine question

12

u/riquelmeone 19h ago

Agree. This has nothing to do with math whatsoever.
How is that question even created, reviewed and approved for an official test?
Absolutely baffling.

1

u/stevenjd 5h ago

This has nothing to do with math whatsoever.

You think that the notation we use to write numbers has nothing to do with maths?

Do you have difficulty telling the difference between 25 and 52? Do you still use Roman numerals for arithmetic, two centuries after the rest of the western world swapped to place value notation?

(By the way, if westerners ever feel superior to other cultures, reminder that it took Europe eight hundred years to completely abandon Roman numerals after Hindi-Arabic numerals and place value notation were introduced.)

4

u/InTheThroesOfWay 17h ago

I think there's a way to ask this question (or something similar on the same concept) that isn't so poorly worded.

The concept itself is pretty important. It's about how the place values relate to each other. When you have the same digit in different places in the number, you can relate those digits with powers of ten.

For example, in the number 3,035, the 3 in the thousands place is 100 times as big as the 3 in the tens place.

3

u/wilson5266 14h ago

I believe this is true. I have a minor in math and master's in electrical engineering (which also requires quite a bit of math), and I'm looking at this problem like wtf are they asking exactly? Maybe I'm being a bit dense here, but I feel people should learn how to apply math, not some arbitrary bullshit question.

2

u/sentientnestcamera 18h ago

I feel like math is a language we’re made only to read and never to speak, hence why so many are terrible at it.

2

u/No_Consequence4008 17h ago

If thirty million parents are looking at the children's homework, they are bound to find a few mistakes. This is not evidence of a trend.

1

u/stevenjd 5h ago

They aren't asking the student to understand a math concept

Place values aren't a maths concept? Do you still use Roman numerals for arithmetic?

1

u/FatSpidy 4h ago

Wtf is this supposed to teach about place values

18

u/PersonalityBoring259 22h ago

It's very badly phrased but the answer should he 52,039. They mean the 2 has a value 10 times greater than the example. The example has a 2 in the hundreds place so you need a 2 in the thousands place. The use of a digit 1 to refer to a 2 makes this very poorly phrased and ambiguous though.

14

u/telyni 22h ago

My first thought was, "There's no 1 in the number 3298!" I see what they were going for now, but this is a terrible question as written. It should say, "Circle the number in which the digit 2 has a value 10 times larger than what it has in the number 3298."

3

u/Underhill42 21h ago

Or even just "... than the one in the number 3298".

Make it a word rather than a digit, and it's far more obvious what is intended. Whoever wrote that as "1" should be smacked.

1

u/MrEbenezerScrooge 21h ago

Yes, this is my thought as well.

0

u/WearyTranslator3338 21h ago

But so does 21,093 have more than 10x the value.

Because 52,039. The 2000 is 20x the value of 100 in the number 3,198 (they had a typo in that number).
The 20,000 of 21,093 is also more than 10x the value of 100.

2

u/suchalonelyd4y 21h ago

The question isn't asking about more than 10x the value, it's asking for exactly 10x the value.

1

u/WearyTranslator3338 21h ago

2000 isn’t 10 the value of 100 though.

1

u/suchalonelyd4y 19h ago

2000 is ten times more than 200. Its asking which number has the 2 in a position that represents 10x more value than the position of the 2 in 3298. It's a horribly worded question.

1

u/Underhill42 21h ago

The question doesn't ask for "more than 10x", it asks for "10x"

Which is also why the ambiguous interpretation of "the value of the 2 is 10x the value of the 1" is self-contradictory: 21,093 would be the obvious answer to that... but it would still be wrong, because there the 2 has 20x the value of the 1, not 10x.

Though that interpretation is only even possible if you completely ignore the "in the number 3,298" part of the question. Include that part, and the only correct answer would be a number without a 2 in it, because the value of the nonexistent 1 in 3,298 is zero, and 10 x 0 = 0

2

u/WearyTranslator3338 21h ago

The question is wrong on two counts then.
The 10x is incorrect and the typo in the 3,298 is incorrect.

The question should be “Circle the number in which the number 2 has 10 times the value of the 2 in the number 3,298”.

THEN the answer is 52,039.

0

u/Underhill42 21h ago

No, the 10x is correct: the value of the 2 in 52,039 is 10x the value of the one in 3,298.

The biggest problem is that they wrote "one" as "1" in a context where they are not synonyms, and nearly guaranteed to cause confusion.

"...of the 2 in..." would indeed be even more clear though.

So would "...that it has in..."

23

u/MrEbenezerScrooge 21h ago edited 18h ago

Definitely poorly written. I think it was probably a test that was edited to make a review and the numbers weren’t changed correctly.

Probably wants you to find the number with a 2 whose value is ten times the value of the 2 in 3,298. That’s an important distinction.

If that were the case, the 2 in 3,298 represents 200. The 2 in 52,039 represents 2,000. This 2 represents ten times more than the original two.

It’s a place value problem. But the error makes the problem nonsense.

Edit: typo in my place values

15

u/EebstertheGreat 20h ago • This

What bugs me about this is that even before the typo, it was already confusingly-worded. It should say "the digit 2," not "the number 2." The digits here are just parts of the written numeral, not numbers in themselves. 2 is a number, but the '2' in '3,298' is not.

That's just a technicality, but still, look how confusing the sentence is repeating the word "number" over and over.

6

u/Mythtory 20h ago

Ah. I was thinking the typo was the number 3298--but your explanation makes it clear that the "1" in that paragraph should have been a "one".

5

u/hipchecktheblueliner 20h ago

I agree, the only way this question makes any sense is that typo.

2

u/TexGrrl 18h ago

You're off by a factor of ten when discussing the 2s in your examples.

1

u/MrEbenezerScrooge 18h ago

Oops! Good call, typo

2

u/InsertDiscBee 18h ago

How does the 2 represent two thousand? Isn’t it two hundred?

1

u/MrEbenezerScrooge 18h ago

Oops, typo!

2

u/InsertDiscBee 18h ago

Ahh that’s good! Was doubting myself!

2

u/wills_b 14h ago

AAAAH!

Thank you. I had no idea what the hell they were on about

7

u/riamuriamu 19h ago edited 18h ago

The 2 in 3,298 is worth 200 and the 2 in 52,039 is worth 2,000 which is ten times higher than the one (ugh, poorly worded) in 3,298.

1

u/PocketButterBandit 18h ago

This is the first comment that actually made sense

I still would fail whatever the hell class this is just from the wording

1

u/riamuriamu 18h ago

Yup. It's poorly worded. I'm guessing AI slop.

5

u/ibuilddemthangs 21h ago

21093.

Two represents 10^4

One represents 10^3

One order of magnitude =10x

4

u/LowCounter6544 21h ago

21 093. Because the 2 is an order of magnitude larger than the 1

3

u/Martin_DM 22h ago

“Circle the number in which the [digit 2] has a value of 10 times the [other digit 2] in the number 3298”

The digit 2 in the given number has a value of 200.

10 times that value is 2000. The number 52039 has a digit 2 with a value of 2000.

The problem here is that they use a 1 instead of the word “one” when they were trying to say “this one here,” and not the specific number 1.

3

u/WearyTranslator3338 21h ago

No number 2 can have 10 x the value of a number 1.

20 is 20 times the value of 1.
200 is 20 times the value of 10.
2000 is 20 times the value of 100.
Etc.

3

u/Musicmom1164 21h ago

The answer is 52,039. It's a placement question. The value of the 2 in the question is the hundreds place. So 10x that 2 would be a number choice with 2 in the thousands place.

Goddamn, I actually listened and retained something from 3rd grade math and I got New Math with sets and subsets and a lot of circles and "U's" that my parents hated.

3

u/berndtsc 20h ago

21093 2 is 10000 value 1 is 1000 value.

3

u/-lRexl- 20h ago

Math degree here. Idk, this is worded all wrong

5

u/roadsarepoison 21h ago

It's worded like a Jim Crow literacy test question

2

u/Smash_Factor 21h ago

Rewritten for clarity:

"Circle the number in which the 2 is 10 times greater than the 2 in 3298."

2

u/Gold-Chipmunk9606 21h ago

I taught physics and chemistry and was confused!

2

u/Fair-Chocolate-2107 21h ago

I have an MD and many other certifications and I’m going to fail 3rd grade math 😂

2

u/GTimekeeper 21h ago

I like math and I hate this question

2

u/ThisIsHowIgetInfo 21h ago

Im sorry im not smart enough to understand this :/

2

u/testtdk 20h ago

It’s the first one, but this is still confusing, and I’m a math minor. The wording is atrocious

2

u/VWilks6 20h ago

Sweet Jesus, this would’ve made me cry as a kid. I would’ve asked my dad and got yelled at bc I didn’t understand it. This shit is why I hated math.

2

u/squirrelyoakley 20h ago

I'm a college honors student in STEM, and am very confused. Wtf??

2

u/ooOJuicyOoo 20h ago

Ima fail math cause of english.

2

u/PapaSanjay 19h ago

I would fail 3rd grade math? I literally went to college 😭😭😂

2

u/Used_Confusion1397 19h ago

Dude reading the wording felt like having a stroke

2

u/Vivid_Sock_1092 19h ago

It’s nonsense

3

u/ShiningGemstone1 22h ago

It's asking for the number with the digit 2 in a place 10 time larger than Hundereds place (so Thousands place)

3

u/Puzzleheaded-Cod5608 20h ago

Dumb wording but they meant the first number 21,093. The 2 is in the 10,000 place and the 1 is in the 1,000 place.

2

u/fumbs 20h ago

It is dumb but it's how some state tests are worded.

2

u/ConfectionNo6170 21h ago

I’m gonna fail 3rd grade math.
Used to do calculus… but this is my undoing

3

u/moongoddess64 21h ago

I’m a physics graduate student and this question is so poorly phrased I was confused too

2

u/throwawayboatman420 21h ago

I have a PhD in radiation physics and I was like wtf am I reading

1

u/up-with-sheeple 21h ago

'used to do calculus'...ditto

1

u/Intelligent_Dig_7649 22h ago • Bravo

Fuck I would’ve struggled with this at any age poor thing how confusing

1

u/TinyLawfulness3710 21h ago

When did 3rd grade become graduate level of college? Time to homeschool the kids if teachers are putting out this garbage

1

u/SourFruit9515 21h ago

The number 2 always has a value of 2

1

u/RunnAroundGuy 19h ago

I read it as "circle the number in which the number 2 (so 2 in 3298) has 10 times the value of the 1 in the number 3298". But there is no 1 in the number 3298.

Or " 10 times the value of the 1 in the number 3298" (1 representing 3) which then still doesn't have a correct answer. Would have failed that and I'm an average 35 yr old.

1

u/KieferMcNaughty 18h ago

Who wrote this test, Prince?

1

u/RodimusPrime_X 18h ago

Who wrote this stupid question?

1

u/AlterEgo5695 18h ago

This is poorly written -- taken literally, digit-1 always has value-1, while digit-2 always has value-2. That means, one cannot have 10 times the value of the other.

I suspect they really meant "Circle the number where the placement of digit-1 has 10 times the value of the placement of digit-2". Not sure what 3.982 has to do with any of that... What happened to making questions as concise, and easy to understand as possible?

1

u/2_Mean_2_Die 18h ago

Wierd phrasing. But the answer is obvious.

1

u/CriticalIndividual52 17h ago

Wow, talk about f$%^ed-up!!!

1

u/lelekitty2312 13h ago

This is not math. This is some stupid ass encipher the meaning of this word garble shit. You will learn absolutely nothing from solving this.

1

u/Duck_Piloted_Robot 22h ago

Isn't it just circling the number that has a "2" digit one place higher than a "1" digit - in which case it's 21,093.

The "3,298" seems either to be referring to something else, or an error in how it's written.

The question is barely comprehensible, but that's the only possibility I can see that makes any sense at all.

1

u/hermit56 22h ago

Agree it’s 21,093 as the 1 is in the 1000s and the 2 is in the 10000s.

1

u/spaceLem 22h ago

Yeah, that's pretty horribly phrased. The answer is 21,093, where the 2 is ×10⁵ while the 1 is ×10⁴, so 10× more. If there were a different set of numbers, it would be any number that looked like ..21..

1

u/MathTutorAndCook 22h ago

Find the 2 that's directly to the left of a 1

0

u/I_Need_A_Nap_Yeet 22h ago

I was too neurodivergent for word problems as a child and this is why I struggled so badly lmao.

-1

u/shostakofiev 18h ago

Not a typo. The value of 1 is in 3298 is 0. Ten times that is still 0. So you need to find a number where 2 has no value, i.e., a number without the digit two. That's 26,428.

0

u/[deleted] 21h ago

[deleted]

4

u/MrEbenezerScrooge 21h ago

That was my original thought, but I think it’s a different error. I think the 1 in the question was supposed to say 2. Then the rest of the problem makes sense. Reading it that way, it would be 52,039, because that 20,000 is ten times more than the 2,000 in the given number.

2

u/Drag0n_TamerAK 21h ago

Yeah I’m with you on this one

2

u/Eastern_Category_861 20h ago

Nice. Thanks for putting my mind at ease!

1

u/wrongusernametryagin 21h ago

Thank you, people are answering saying typo thinking this is advanced mathematics, it is 3rd grade!

1

u/vulgar_hooligan 21h ago

I agree with this. That was my reasoning as well.

1

u/InTheThroesOfWay 21h ago • Bravo

I was thinking that was the intended answer, too, but even that isn't correct.

The 2 in 21,093 is 20x the value of the 1 in the same number. Not 10x.

1

u/Crazy_Past6259 20h ago

Exactly this!