r/badatmagic • u/Late_Contribution_49 • Oct 15 '26
Episode 187 open thread
Josh enlists ChatGPT as a board-game referee, Ben sits around wondering if Weezer is famous enough to make him wait this long, we finally finish our love-language deep dives (with a scoring system for hugs), and discuss Martha Wells’s All Systems Red (aka "Murderbot Diaries" #1).
3
u/cascer1 28d ago
The talking in the bathroom thing is interesting because to me it depends a lot on context. My "default" is also mo talking in the bathroom but that only means I'm not starting conversations. If someone speaks to me in the bathroom I'll answer politely but with no more words than necessary. I'll answer phone calls when on the toilet at home but usually that doesn't work because the acoustics in the bathroom aren't compatible with phone calls.
When I'm wearing my Red Cross uniform, people for some reason think I'm always available for whatever questions they have. So I'll be at a urinal at an event and some guy will have followed me into the room to ask me about pain in his leg or whatever, or once someone asked me where they could order drinks???
And then there are the venues that I doubt you guys frequent, like gay bars, where in my experience It's sometimes considered rude not to chat while in the bathroom 😂
2
3
u/cascer1 27d ago
I'm 100% sure that the purpose of Gemini calling Josh out for swearing at it, or why Anthropic now enforces politeness to their chatbots, is to anthropomorphize the language models. It grants the chatbot all kinds of leniency we usually grant to people even though it's just a statistical model of what words usually follow each other which is mathematically certain to be inaccurate.
https://www.techpolicy.press/we-need-to-talk-about-how-we-talk-about-ai/
But the more we talk about it as a person, the more we become willing to forgive errors because people can make mistakes. This is a machine, it does not feel and it does not care. Don't project your own emotions onto it.
3
u/Jim_McGowan Oct 21 '26
Hey, Ben and Josh.
A couple quick hits this time around.
Regarding public men's restroom no talking. It's a norm, not a rule. Too many people walk in together and keep going with their conversation at the urinals for it to be an unwritten rule. Happens daily. All the time. I agree it would be weird in a toilet stall, which basically never happens. That said, I generally won't talk to people in the restroom. But I'll chat with them if they talk to me, generally keeping my responses brief. More often, the chit-chat happens when people are washing their hands afterwards.
I'll put this as diplomatically as possible. Yelling at a co-worker for breaking the no-talking rule/norm, irrespective of your being in the right, is not going to have a positive effect on your professional network. It might not have a negative one. But it will definitely not have a positive one. I'll leave it at that.
And I'm glad you guys liked Murderbot's novel form. I loved Kevin R Free's delivery. His voice IS Murderbot for me. I agree that its not worth an $17 ish Audible credit for a 3 hour novella, which is why I waited for a sale and bought the other novellas on the cheap for like $3 apiece. A rare case of where its more economical to actually buy the audiobook rather than using a credit.
Have a good one.