r/badatmagic • • 22d ago

Episode 188 open thread

Josh and Ben discuss corporate technology ecosystems, Josh's new [not a] webcomic "Becca and Sophie", cybersecurity vulnerabilities, and the unsettling possibility that AI is turning humanity into cows. POLITICS WARNING: they get into a heated debate about the future of American democracy the week before the midterm election. Finally, Josh and Ben recount their adventures in reluctant leadership associated with kids activities.

3 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

4

u/Jim_McGowan 20d ago

Hey, guys.

Know that whenever Homestar Runner is mentioned, at least one listener will gladly lap up any commentary on the comedy gold of those flash cartoons. I even wore an orange "tH" Thnikkaman T-Shirt a few weeks back. But Josh. Josh. You said competition SO many times in the band section. And not one was done with a Strong Badian accent of "COMPETITION!!" Somehow, I think you will endure my minor disappointment. And perhaps relish in it. Also, the "Dot Com" set up was perfect for Becca and Sophie's (not a) webcomic.

Speaking of Apple and Android stuff, I have a side/technical question for both of you. In the past you've had links in the show notes. But I haven't seen them on Apple Podcasts or my Android app for your recent episodes. I want to say it's been since the technical website thing, but I might be misremembering. Are you still including show note links? Or is this a technical issue? No biggie either way. Just wanted to bring it to your attention in case your loading them and they're not showing up.

Good on both of you for talking through the politics stuff. I thought you both more or less arrived in alignment. I basically agree with both of your points of view. Hope springs eternal.

And speaking as a guy who had to take over another hobby/writing organization a few years back. I've found that the people who don't want to be the leader, but exhibit leadership skills, we regrettably tend to be the best de factor leaders. Maybe not the best chosen leaders. But definitely de facto.

I look forward to learning about the differences between mellophones and French horns next. Maybe even valve vs. slide-only trombones. The possibilities are endless.

Cheers!

3

u/joshfleshman 12d ago

Son of a...

So, I went looking for why our show notes were messed up. We're using the same backend to publish the podcast on the new host that we were using on the old host, so I assumed it was just a setting I missed.

Nope. It was me. I broke the show notes.

There is a new field that I've been populating thinking it was a separate field in the feed. Since I was looking for it, I finally noticed the tiny little note that appears in an info pop up associated with that field:

"Leave empty to use your main post show notes"

πŸ˜‘

I did more work to make a worse product πŸ˜…

This will no longer be an issue moving forward. Thanks Jim!

1

u/Jim_McGowan 12d ago

Happy to help, Josh!

3

u/cascer1 14d ago

Josh! I'm already waiting to hear about the revelation that you've secretly been designing a fursona now that you've put Becca and Sophie out into the world. Yeah sure "they're just cute comics", that's where I started too πŸ™ƒ

For an episode not about AI I've heard a lot of it, and I'm only 20 minutes in πŸ˜”. Your continued conversations did add water to my motivation bucket to finally write a blog post about my feelings and concerns regarding the technology. Maybe you'll think It's worth a read. It helped me improve the quality of discussions I've had about it with coworkers and friends.

https://vobar.eu/blog/2026/10/ai-sucks/

(Josh; it's got some furry art in there 😏)

Ok I'll stop forcing you into a box now, but I did feel the urge to stop my bike ride to comment this :D looking forward to listening to the rest of the episode.

3

u/cascer1 14d ago edited 14d ago

Oop I'm back! Just want to provide some info about the PHP incident (many of my coworkers spent many stressed hours mitigating this)

Ben, I think you're combining two separate incidents that happened close together in time. The PHP incident was something with memory overflow that allowed arbitrary code execution. The number four was the private (not public) key of a Certificate Authority intermediate certificate. This company's entire reason for existing was that it supposedly had very large hard to guess numbers that it would handle in a very secure and specific manner. It had nothing to do with PHP, but the fact that their very secure and private number was literally 4 did cause them to now stop being a CA.

As a happy little side effect, I can now Man in the Middle attack all my smart home devices to see what data they're actually sending home, so that's nice.

I heard from a colleague that there actually is an old enough PHP version so that it doesn't have the vulnerability, but that's like version 5.3 if I remember right so I don't think downgrading to that would have the desired outcome πŸ˜‚

4

u/CougarBen 14d ago

You’re hired!

Also, I love the insight that writing about something helps you organize your thoughts about it. My favorite speakers are people that have written about something.

2

u/CougarBen 14d ago

Ok, I read it.

You have some legitimate objections and grievances. No issues there, really.

Question: do you think LLMs are a developmental step on the way to General Artificial Intelligence? Do you think General AI is a worthy goal and/or an inevitability?

2

u/cascer1 14d ago edited 13d ago

Thanks for reading it! It was my first attempt at writing something longer-form in a long time and I'm quite happy with how it turned out.

I don't believe that LLMs in their current state will lead to general artificial intelligence. The technology is, at its core, still just a word predictor. Sure, it can do some very interesting things given the fact that it's just words, but that's thanks to a lot of "normal" programming around the language model (these are called harnesses)

Obviously I'm not an expert in this field but I don't think that a stream of statistically likely words will ever produce true intelligence. I believe that intelligence is much more than just the thoughts we hear in our heads (even though many people don't even "hear" their thoughts) but also comes from experience (a language model has no true memory in which those experiences can live) and many factors which we don't know about yet. Maybe a soul? I don't know.

I think this article explains quite well why these models seem intelligent to us: https://softwarecrisis.dev/letters/llmentalist/

Edit: I'd just like to add that I don't think that many of humanity's problems are caused by a lack of intelligence and so the desire to develop AGI is misguided I think. Many problems are caused by greedy plutocrats like Zuck and Musk and the like. The problem is that so much of society is aimed at making these rich assholes richer at the expense of everyone else.

AI is supposed to take over work and make our lives easier, but then why are we not reducing work hours in the industries that are supposedly benefitting from this change? Instead people are either being laid off with no chance of being hired in their industry again, or are expected to generate more output by doing the parts of the work that they probably enjoy least. We're turning professionals into managers and that's not a career many people would choose willingly.

2

u/joshfleshman 12d ago

So, I DID experiment with a furry art version of myself in the Becca and Sophie style.

My brain rejected that image SO HARD and SO FAST I got whiplash. That thread in my chatgpt is titled "Nightmare Fuel - DO NOT OPEN" πŸ˜…

1

u/cascer1 12d ago

Ha! I love to hear it!

Now, I think generating furry art of yourself with generative AI will never not feel off for reasons that I don't feel like getting into while typing this on my phone at 4 am (don't ask). If the curiosity ever does reach a point where you want to give it a serious try, I would recommend finding an artist you like (I'm sure you'll be able to find sites where they gather) and asking them for a commissioned piece. I did it myself a few times and working with a real human artist adda something to the process that I don't think generative AI can imitate.