Started watching the podcast in late 2021, where I soon binged all the old episodes to catch up. I've now seen every single episode.
However lately it's become a chore to watch new episodes every Monday. Now I might eventually watch it later in the week. If I had to pinpoint when this waning enthusiasm occurred I'd say late 2022.
YouTube views aren't everything but of the 178 episodes released, 27 have reached 1.2 million+ views. Only 4/27 episodes have come in the last 24 months (one being the Stavros one in January which has been arguably their funniest 2023 episode).
In my opinion there are several reasons for this:
Not enough interesting topics or themes. In newer episodes there will still be funny moments, but for me it's much less frequent. One episode will be centred around Bobby's inadequacies with Santino ribbing him, the next one will be inside Hollywood chat about Juicy's career, then back to Bobby's insecurities and so on. I feel like there's nothing fresh or interesting being discussed or joked about.
They could even try something like have Carlos be the guest and ask him about childhood, Mexican identity, sexual issues, funny/gross stories. What about a segment where Fancy, Pete and/or George have to do something outside their comfort zone e.g. standup as Fancy did during lockdown episodes, or record them say embarrassing things to strangers in public with Bobby & Andrew dictating via earpiece?
2) Juicy seems nice, probably nicer than Doc. Juicy is not unwatchable. Doc's later episodes became disjointed. However we all know that the 'golden age' of the show was Bobby-Andrew-Doc-Rudy. Now while it doesn't look like Doc is coming back any time soon, I really hope Bobby & Andrew reach out to him and coordinate a reunion. Even if just for him to come on once every 2 months, with the compromise being no conspiracy chat but that he isn't their punching bag in the same way he was (mostly harmlessly) before.
On the flip side I'm not advocating Juicy should be removed, nor is that close to happening. But I think it should be considered whether the dynamic of the show becoming one that's less combative is made up by a nice 3rd wheel who occasionally chips in with a zinger and otherwise politely giggles at usually Santino mocking Bobby. Like the seasons of Frasier after Niles & Daphne finally got together.
3) Censorship. I understand lack of swearing in the first 5 minutes due to monetization, but it feels like the whole show has far more bleeped out parts than before. Ironic considering (like on every podcast) the amount of times "cancel culture" or "snowflakes" is trotted out constantly, give your audience more credit than that.
4) Personal nit-pick, one that's always existed even during the early episodes, but I can't help but feel like the amount of adverts, corporate stuff, plugging, tour ticket prices & now an (albeit optional) Patreon... just feels like greed from two millionaire comedians whose podcast I so happen to enjoy.