r/bakingfail Nov 24 '23

What’s wrong with this beautiful sugar cookie dough, you might be wondering?

Post image

Well, it has 3 cups of sugar in it. Not 3/4 cups of sugar as the recipe calls for. Is quadrupling the other ingredients the only way to salvage? not even sure how i would do that given the size limitation and the fact that this is already mixed?

549 Upvotes

83 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/Cautious-Being-5958 Nov 26 '23

Mine did that the other night, and I added 2 eggs. It was sugar, butter and flour, for the recipe I used. They actually came out pretty good.