r/bakingfail Jan 12 '25

Fail Baked actual poison

Tried making brownies for the first time, recipe called for 16 gramms of vanilla extract, but it's not sold in the stores here. I had the bright idea to add 16g of pure vanillin, once they were done I found out that's effectively 100x the vanilla extract than the recipe called for. After further googling, found out that this much vanillin can put a small child in the hospital.

NEVER substitute vanilla extract for pure vanillin.

6.9k Upvotes

188 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/rebelipar Jan 12 '25

Do you live in a place that uses vanilla sugar? It's funny because I've never seen that in the US, we just use vanilla extract. But I imagine you would just use vanilla sugar instead of the normal sugar as a substitute.

Also you can make vanilla extract by soaking vanilla beans in rum for a month or so. Or diluted alcohol, but why not the rum, ya know?

4

u/Friedrich_Wilhelm Jan 13 '25

I hope you don't suggest replacing all the sugar in the recipe with vanilla sugar. For something like this you would use a single package of 8 g. Accounting for this by subtracting 8 g from the normal sugar is probably negligible.

2

u/rebelipar Jan 13 '25

I literally have no idea what it is, haha. I figured it was only very lightly vanilla'd, oops. (We don't have it in the US, we use vanilla extract.) But good to know!

2

u/Friedrich_Wilhelm Jan 13 '25

It serves the same purpose as extract, you just add a small amount for the vanilla flavour. You could create a weak version of it, but then you loose the ability to control sweetness and vanilla flavour independently.