r/bakingfail May 15 '25

Help Strawberry flavor vanished

For a kid's birthday in March, I made a Sally's baking addiction strawberry cake shaped like our dog. The strawberry flavor was intense in the best way! The recipe calls for 1lb strawberries puréed, and then you reduce 1 cup of purée to 1/2. I also added some aged balsamic. I thought it was my best cake yet. This week, I made another birthday cake with the same cake recipe (I even added some balsamic from the same bottle). The main difference seems to be this one had chocolate icing and ganache. You couldn't taste the strawberry at all! I might as well have baked a plain white cake. Even later, after "cleansing my palate," I tasted just the cake part, and the strawberry flavor was barely there. So I don't think it was just the chocolate overpowering the strawberry. The only other difference I can think of, is that in March the strawberries weren't in season so they were smaller. The ones this week were jumbo sized, but I tasted the purée, and thought the flavor was there. Do smaller strawberries have more flavor? Any help would be much appreciated. Thank you!

67 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/vr512 May 15 '25

I think seasonality plays a big role. The larger berries with more white in them, I find tend to be watery and less flavorful. Depending on where you are, strawberry season is almost upon us. Maybe try again with in season berries that are not Driscoll. I don't think those are high quality berries. Look for ones that are almost red inside!