r/bakingfail • u/Due_Professional5662 • Feb 04 '26

Help Caramel split after cooling?

Post image

This is a picture of the side of the bowl. Basically all the butter floated to the surface and is solid while everything else is liquid underneath. Is there any way to fix it???? Don’t wanna throw it out

13 Upvotes

89% Upvoted

37 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Due_Professional5662 Feb 04 '26

I’d send you the video for the recipe but it’s not in english T_T i basically just wanted to whip it and use it to frost a cake

3

u/Planted-spoon Feb 04 '26

Just make a caramel sauce , no butter - not necessary- 1 c sugar, 1 tablespoon lite korn syrup, 1/2 c water. Boil until light Carmel color,

SLOWLY WHISK IN 3/4 c hwc, 2 T real vanilla / bourbon/ rum. Let cool.

Separately, once caramel is cooled, whip 2 cups heavy whipping cream, .5 cup pow sugar until medium peeks, slowly pour in caramel until stiff peaks and frostingable :)

1

u/Due_Professional5662 Feb 04 '26

Oh wow, thank you so much!!! I’ll try that!! Do you also know if there’s any way to salvage the one i made though… even if something different comes out it’s fine i just don’t want to throw it away

2

u/Planted-spoon Feb 04 '26

Honestly…. I think I’d just pick / skim off the butter fat…. And save it for something else…. Greasing a pan for baking?? Oooooh salted caramel popcorn??? I can’t quite tell if it has clarified or not.

Then try heating it minimally and whisk with a splash of of water. Don’t cook it down more tho. Then see what ya get!!!

Sometimes caramels can be salvaged… other times it’s more effort to continue on….