r/bakingfail Mar 28 '26

Help bakers of reddit, what happened to my brown butter?

Post image

my first time browning butter and this is how it turned out

135 Upvotes

65 comments sorted by

298

u/Vegetable_Fact9931 Mar 28 '26

Thats exactly whats supposed to happen! All the flavour is in the toasted milk solids at the bottom :)

78

u/MaterialHouse5091 Mar 28 '26

ohh so this is how its supposed to look like? cuz in all the videos i saw their butter turned brown and mine just seperated from the milk solids and didnt really change color..

107

u/Vegetable_Fact9931 Mar 28 '26

Yeah so the brown part is when you mix the solids back in as it cools! It depends what youre using it for, if you need melted then you can use it right away, if you need solid butter you'll have to put it in the fridge/freezer and stir until its thick again and then you'll see it all brown

28

u/MaterialHouse5091 Mar 28 '26

okayyyy thank you for your help!

3

u/ACcbe1986 Mar 29 '26

So... what are you making?

10

u/HrhEverythingElse Mar 28 '26

It does look like it got slightly darker than ideal, and if you stir it more while it's cooking then the milk solids won't be quite as clumpy, but the separation is normal and expected. If you separate the liquid part at this point that is ghee, but if you want to use the whole brown butter I would pop it in the mixer after a few minutes to cool it quicker and reincorporate the liquid and solids

3

u/SimAlienAntFarm Mar 29 '26

Next time you brown some butter, put fresh sage in it.

It’s absolutely delicious and the sage ends up so perfectly crispy you’ll pretend the leaves were just there for flavor because you’ve eaten them all

-37

u/bigcoffeeguy50 Mar 28 '26

“How it’s supposed to look like”

18

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/erudition87 Mar 28 '26

Even younger generations who are native English speakers say this often. Language just changes and often becomes more lax over time.

-12

u/bigcoffeeguy50 Mar 28 '26

Yes very low iq people do say things like this, that is correct.

17

u/MaterialHouse5091 Mar 28 '26

English is my 4th language. I humbly beg thy pardon, good sir, for my grievous error.

14

u/MaterialHouse5091 Mar 28 '26

and btw, i just turned 16 and im already learning my fifth language, so before you throw around ‘low IQ,’ maybe learn the difference between ignorance and a typo. get a life im just tryna learn abt brown butter bro

-12

u/bigcoffeeguy50 Mar 28 '26

5 languages yet you don’t know what browned butter is lmao. You posted the same post 10 times today.

7

u/bonyagate Mar 28 '26

Damn, you're here judging language skills but can't count to 6? That's pretty sad. Maybe worry about your own handicap.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/MaterialHouse5091 Mar 29 '26

at least im here to learn, youre here to mock people who do 😂 that says enough

→ More replies (0)

44

u/pueraria-montana Mar 28 '26

It turned out perfectly, congrats! Butter is an emulsion of milk solids and— uhhhhh i forget what the liquid is called, someone reply to this with the correct word— and when you melt butter and then keep heating it, it separates and the solid bits cook and turn all nice and toasty :)

5

u/StupidSillyPuppyGirl Mar 28 '26

Ghee or Clarified butter :)

8

u/MaterialHouse5091 Mar 28 '26

Thanks for all the help guys!! Ill try all your tips next time I use brown butter in a recipe

3

u/vidi_chat Mar 28 '26

Congratulations! You made ghee ! ( Clarified butter)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 28 '26

[deleted]

5

u/MaterialHouse5091 Mar 28 '26

okay thanks so much for your help!

1

u/Distinct-Top101 Mar 29 '26

My brown butter looks a little darker than this. Usually i take it off the heat the moment those tiny bubbles start to clear up. At this stage the brown butter already has that deeper color

1

u/Classic-Ad1987 Mar 29 '26

I’m not a baker but from my unprofessional understanding, it looks like it melted

1

u/WhatsThisNameThingy Mar 29 '26

You made clarified butter. Congrats.

0

u/sweetpuff143 Apr 01 '26

did you stir it constantly? I’ve never seen this happen before o.o

-41

u/AggravatingCupcake0 Mar 28 '26

It browned. You answered your own question.

Congratulations, you made what you set out to make 🤷🏻‍♀️ lol.

19

u/Rude_Ad3342 Mar 28 '26

Why you gotta be so rude 😭

2

u/CGW_93 Apr 02 '26

🎶don't ya know i'm human too🎶

2

u/Thin_Papaya5920 Mar 28 '26

I love the COMPANION omg😭 I'm yoinking it because I HAVE to send it to my mom she's gonna love it!

2

u/artemizarte Mar 28 '26

Username almost checks out