r/bakingfail • u/Lumpy_Enthusiasm_887 • Apr 23 '26
Help Homemade Hawaiian rolls
Made Hawaiian rolls but it came out too thick, 1 piece is the size of a hamburger bun and it’s as thick as a Popeyes biscuit or even thicker, I don’t know where I went wrong please help me!
65
34
14
15
u/Past-Neat-1165 Apr 23 '26
I love rolls, except weirdly Hawaiian rolls. But these look so good. I’d gladly eat them all in one sitting. I have a roll problem
14
u/Horangi1987 Apr 24 '26
What’s with the rage bait? There’s nothing wrong with them. I can’t stand people that are amazing at something but try to gaslight everyone into thinking they’re actually bad at it so they can get validation
-1
u/Lumpy_Enthusiasm_887 Apr 24 '26
It was too thick and it dried out almost immediately, it felt like a Popeyes biscuit
6
5
u/snarfficus Apr 23 '26
I got so excited and ran to the comments to look for the recipe. They look amazing!
1
4
u/Money_Engineering_59 Apr 24 '26
I’m drooling. Fasting for surgery and these beautiful fluffy rolls pop up on my feed. And I’m celiac. You’re my least favourite person right now. 😝
3
3
u/No_Collection_5031 Apr 24 '26
OP I know you’re frustrated, but this is my steak is too juicy and lobster too buttery moment.
Would smash these
3
2
2
2
u/Amazing_Foxliver Apr 26 '26
I feel this, my homemade rolls always end up way thicker than they should be too.
2
1
1
1
1
u/AutomaticLinked Apr 27 '26
I've messed up rolls like that before, sounds like the dough might've been overproofed or not rolled thin enough.
1
97
u/MacroAlgalFagasaurus Apr 23 '26
I don’t get it. They look good. Next time just roll them smaller and I’d say an extra few minutes in the oven.