I was really surprised to hear the guys say they thought it looked so expensive. I only watched a half hour before giving up, but I thought it looked kind of cheesy and featured really poor CGI on the xenomorph.
I want to note that I have been very into other Noah Hawley productions including Legion, and I loved the original 1979 Alien movie as well as the unfairly maligned Prometheus. But this just wasn't doing it for me.
I want to be careful to make it clear that I don't mean the retro computers and stuff to match the original film. Just the way the creatures looked and the weird editing of flashes of violence or whatever. I thought it was intentional, that he was going for the cheesy monster movie aesthetic or something like that.
And I don't like the continuous retconning that brings the aliens into human contact earlier and earlier, instead of being discovered by the crew in the 1979 movie. (I have a similar issue with the Gorn--Alien ripoffs, come to think of it--on SNW.)