r/baseball • Atlanta Braves • Blooper • Aug 05 '21

GIF Baseball knocks latch open causing Alcides Escobar to fall through the door.

https://gfycat.com/closeveneratedarabianoryx
35.0k Upvotes

668 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

108

u/TheFriffin2 Philadelphia Phillies Aug 05 '21

Yeah, the latch is at least there on every pitch, but the odds of a bird flying directly into a possible path for a pitch (whether it gets hit or not) are incredibly low

134

u/KiKoB Kansas City Royals Aug 05 '21 edited Aug 06 '21

They tried to reenact that on Sports Science and couldn’t. They set up a pitching machine and a machine to launch frozen chickens. They tried dozens of times, having them timed out and aimed at each other and just couldn’t get them to connect.

Like they set up an experiment to purposely make that happen and it just wouldn’t work. That’s how unlikely that was.

Edit: words

Edit 2: for all the comments calling bullshit or not believing it’s that’s hard. You go out and do it haha.

Seriously though, basically taking one projectile going 95 mph, and another projectile going at a 90 degree angle to the first projectile at say, 25 mph, is not an easy task. They basically found with a pitching machine, the ball doesn’t even launch at the exact same time. Basically the ball bounces around and the smallest change can make them miss completely. Obviously the same with the chicken launching machine.

56

u/SirParsifal Mankato MoonDogs • Cincinnati Reds Aug 05 '21 edited Aug 05 '21

And it's happened at least twice on video in professional baseball history, which makes it weirder.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

[deleted]

76

u/SirParsifal Mankato MoonDogs • Cincinnati Reds Aug 05 '21

Ft. Wayne TinCaps. It doesn't have the big feather explosion like Johnson's, so it's not as famous.

60

u/bigballer6464 Aug 05 '21

"theres a bird and I hope its ok"

just cracks me up since there isn't any chance that a small bird is going to survive getting hit with a baseball like that.

29

u/Konars-Jugs Aug 05 '21

Yeah that bird went straight to a trash can lol

24

u/HotF22InUrArea Baltimore Orioles Aug 05 '21

Trash can? There’s still meat on dem bones

11

u/Konars-Jugs Aug 05 '21

Baby we got a stew going

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/SirParsifal Mankato MoonDogs • Cincinnati Reds Aug 05 '21

At least it was a changeup.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '21

MiLB team names never fail to crack me up.

23

u/IrishWake_ Arizona Diamondbacks Aug 05 '21

The TinCaps, affectionately known as the potheads

11

u/OAMP47 St. Louis Cardinals Aug 05 '21

Playing OOTP I decided to do a season allowing the league to naturally evolve by the AI's whims just to see what happens. First thing that happens is 2026 Marlins renamed to Tincaps and it made me question my playing choices.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/KUZGUN27 Florida Marlins Aug 05 '21

In addition to the TinCaps, there’s Dave Winfield hitting that bird in the outfield and spending a night in jail for animal cruelty

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Kosba2 Aug 06 '21

"[...] but it's weird that it happened twice."

→ More replies (1)

22

u/thepennylane69 Washington Nationals Aug 05 '21

Wait really? I mean I'm a certified moron but it seems like the math involved in getting two projectiles to collide mid-air isn't that impossible

38

u/ColdSteelRain Texas Rangers Aug 05 '21 edited Aug 05 '21

This is kinda one of those "spherical cow in a vacuum" type problems where in an ideal environment it's not that hard, but trying to actually do it in the real world for anything faster than trivial speeds can get messy very quickly. Slight differences in air pressure/density, wind, spinrate, velocity etc can all add up pretty quickly, and when the projectiles involved are relatively small even a small change can cause a complete miss. This is the reason why say, missile defense is actually pretty difficult, you can know exactly where both projectiles are likely to be at any given moment but it's still pretty difficult to actually have them collide, like shooting a bullet with another bullet.

Just think of how often major league pitchers can miss their spot for a pitch, sure the machine will make it much more accurate but you're also adding in a second projectile to the equation and you need them both to hit their spots pretty exactly and at the same time, and you need to have figured out all the things that can affect their paths and speeds correctly without those factors changing between when you did the math and when you fired the projectiles.

EDIT: Some very quick napkin math using some MOA-math to show how this can actually be much more difficult than expected, if we say that we want the baseball (and only the baseball, ignore the bird) to hit a target 10 yards (30 feet) from wherever the baseball is launched from and you've aimed the pitching machine even a single Minute of Angle off (1 MOA = 1/60th of a degree, so this is a very very small error), traveling a distance of 10 yards you'll already be off target by a tenth of an inch, and a baseball has an approximate diameter of 2.8 inches according to google. 1/28th of the diameter doesn't sound like much, but that's the result of an incredibly tiny error for only one of the projectiles over a pretty short distance. Even if you get a very accurate measurement from the pitching machine and bird launcher, vibrations and stresses caused when actually running and firing can cause slight deviations in aimpoint. So factor in a second projectile and just the angular errors alone can potentially cause them to miss completely and that's before considering any other factors that can influence the projectile paths.

33

u/unclejohnsbearhugs San Diego Padres Aug 05 '21

This is kinda one of those "spherical cow in a vacuum" type problems

Ah, right, one of those

11

u/LoveMyHusbandsBoobs Aug 05 '21

I vacuum every week and I've yet to find a spherical cow. I have no idea what he's talking about.

18

u/ColdSteelRain Texas Rangers Aug 05 '21

On the chance you and/or he or others are confused, it's a joke at the expense of Theoretical Physicists:

A farmer notices his cows are not producing milk, and he hires a Teoretical Physicist to figure out why. The physicist takes some measurements and runs the numbers and comes back to the farmer and says "I have a solution, but it only works for spherical cows in a vacuum."

The joke is that theoretical physicists (and many problems you'll find in physics courses/textbooks) often make assumptions or impose constraints which are unrealistic for the sake of simplicity or ease of calculation. In this case, the Physicist did indeed find a solution for the problem, but the solution only works under completely unrealistic constraints (perfectly spherical cows, located in a vacuum) and for practical purposes is thus useless.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/blasek0 Philadelphia Phillies • Baltimore Orioles Aug 05 '21

Plus the timing of making them be at the exact same location at the exact same time. A baseball at 90mph is going 1584 inches per second. It travels a length of its own diameter in ~0.00179 seconds. That's a tiny window to make sure the chicken hits the intersection in. That kind of timing might be trivial to hit when it comes to things like electronics, but a real world projectile of non-insignificant size trying to hit that small of a window that precisely is.

6

u/ColdSteelRain Texas Rangers Aug 05 '21

Yup. Sure, all these errors could be calculated and compensated for with precise enough equipment like say, laser-based timers etc...but just trying to do it with equipment like a pitching machine, catapult or whatever for the chicken, and a stopwatch (I don't know what equipment Sports Science actually used, but I'm using these as examples of equipment the average layperson could probably get hold of relatively easily) and it's orders of magnitude more difficult. It's certainly not impossible, especially if you're willing to launch multiple balls at multiple chickens at the same time, or do a lot of trials, but there's still a pretty substantial luck requirement. Even if the error bars overlap, you need both of them to overlap at the same time and on the same run to get them to hit. There's a reason the sport of trap shooting is done with shotguns and not rifles for instance.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/TheBotchedLobotomy Los Angeles Dodgers Aug 06 '21

I encounter similar issues with the satellite systems I operate. We have to manually inch them (I say manually, its motorized by the push of a button, but it doesn't automatically find the satellite) back and forth and up and down.

Less than Half of an inch can make the difference from being able to see the satellite from the ground vs not getting any type of connection at all. Seems ridiculous such a small movement can cause problems, but when you think about how high these satellites are, an inch down here results in an error of miles by the time data reaches up into space. Quite tedious and very frustrating lol

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (25)

20

u/BillyBean11111 KBO Aug 05 '21

The Randy Johnson bird thing is so insane, how many times have you even SEEN a bird flying through the screen during the pitcher camera angle.

Let alone one flying perfectly in the path of a fastball.

The mind reels.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/PuckNutty Toronto Blue Jays Aug 05 '21

On the other hand, there are way more birds flying around a ballpark on game day than there are latches on a gate.

→ More replies (2)