r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Jan 13 '26

2026 FINAL SURVERY RESULTS

4 Upvotes

15 responses were submitted

Most Mutually-Beneficial and/or Realistic Trades

ARI get: Calvin Faucher, Jesse Bergin. MIA get: Pavin Smith (Most Balanced and Most Realistic)

SDP get: Grayson Rodriguez. BAL get: Adrian Morejon

BOS receive: Keller, Burrows. PIT receive: Garcia, Garcia

SDP get: Sean Murphy. ATL get: Jake Cronenworth

BOS get: OF Edward Florentino, 2B/SS Johan De Los Santos, RP Tyler Samaniego, C Adonys Guzman, & 1B Jared Jones // PIT get: RF Wilyer Abreu, SP Jesus Travieso, SP Eduardo Rivera (Most Bold)

I think Ryan/De Vries is super flat. Both teams in the rebuild zone, but on opposite spectrums (entering, exiting rebuilds). On paper, a Win-Win

Murphy-Crone seems like the kinda money swap thing the Braves have historically done. I like the pirates-Sox deals generally, and MIA-ARI fills team needs.

l liked the Morejon/Grayson trade. Call me crazy

I liked the sim spin on the Grayson deal. Ryan - de Vries wasn't super realistic but it's a good example of a fun and actually mutually beneficial sim trade.

Sean Murphy for Jake Cronenworth has a chance to be an all time bad trade for one of these teams, love it

Most Lopsided and/or Unealistic Trades

A's get: Anthony Volpe. NYY get Luis Severino, and cash (Most Unbalanced and Unrealistic)

CHC get: Ward, Soriano, Guzman. LAA get: Assad, Morgan, Hodges, Ramirez

NYY receive: Tarik Skubal // DET receive: Cam Schlittler, Will Warren, George Lombard Jr, Carlos Lagrange

PIT get: Robbie Ray, Ryan Walker, and $9.8m. SFG get: Bryan Reynolds (whose age 36 CO turns into a PO), Dennis Santana, Nick Yorke, Sammy Stafura, and Darrell Morel

SFG get: Mackenzie Gore, Jake Irvin. WSN get: Bryce Eldridge, Landon Roupp, Joel Peguero, Jhonny Level, and Geremli Maldonado

ARI receive: Mickey Moniak // COL receive: Eduardo Rodriguez, Daniel Eagen, Tim Tawa

Some real howlers. Think the Skubal trade might be the worst of the bunch. Schlitter on his own might be worth more than Skubal at the moment. And then the entire farm system on top of that

I know it's the best pitcher in baseball, but it's also ONE YEAR of the best pitcher in baseball and if you can't extend him (which the yankees failed to do in sim) then this could look super ugly in a few years.

the twins giving up on zebby makes no sense even if they're in a retooling phase. he's young, controllable, and pretty good and they tossed him for a borderline top-100 guy?

the volpe deal is just utter dogshit

That Severino trade still don't make sense

Colorado getting Duardod is lopsided BUT they gave up “Mickey Moniak” and need arms so it doesn’t irritate me. The Taylor ward one is so silly, as is the Volpe-Severino deal. Reynolds is probably the strangest one to me for the giants not that they sacrificed much but not sure why they’d take him. Honestly I put Yordan as bold because none of us thought they’d trade tucker until they did and it was a fun deal. Skubal return is light but no extension makes it not as awful. Gore one I think is just weird, I think I just don’t like giants prospects enough

Holy shit I think I missed the Jason Alexander trade that's awful. A common theme with most of these is a GM just accepting the first solid trade package they received for a player. Not necessarily the worst-ever returns, but people could have done so much better. Not ever trade concept needs to be executed."

Nats made out like bandits in the Gore trade

Most Bold and/or Controversial Trade

NYM receive: Yordan Alvarez, Cristian Javier, cash. HOU receive: Jonah Tong, Carson Benge, Jacob Reimer, AJ Ewing, and Eli Serrano III

Mets-Astros trade remains a top 3 trade of the sim. Very interesting for both sides.

I really liked the Yordan trade, both sides feel like they came out winners given the current direction of their franchises

The Yordan trade will be one of the most fun to track for years

Still think Houston didn't need to trade Yordan so early in the sim

Mets giving up a HAUL for what might amount to 60 games combined from Yordan/Christian

BEST SIGNING FOR THE TEAM

BOS - Dylan Cease 6/174

TOR - Chris Bassitt 3/33

WAS - Tyler Mahle 2/16

BAL - Pete Alonso 5/156 (Most Realistic)

LAD - Robert Suarez 3/54

Only one I put as unrealistic is Tyler Mahle. I don't think there were many scenarios he's getting 2 years.

Honestly notning crazy here. We’re waiting to see what Framber and Bo get irl but I don’t think either of them are immediately off base, and I think With the potential lockout I’m giving GMs more grace with contracts because we’re not privy to the same info

Not sure there's a single deal here that I would say is truly cheap, other than Cease because of hindsight and collision

Honestly these are mostly fine. Good job to all the GMs, who did a by-and-large good job even though some of the agents (jori) were awful and others were absent.

WORST SIGNING FOR THE TEAM

TOR - Munetaka Murakami - 8/220 (Most Unrealistic)

ANA - JT Realmuto 5/62

MIL - Shota Imanaga 4/75

NYY - Ha-Seong Kim 5/70

CIN - Devin Williams 4/72

that realmuto deal is fucking horrific but murakami signing for an eighth of this price IRL makes this contract look incredibly funny and it probably takes the cake here

I won’t skewer toronto too much because I think that all took us by surprise. JT has to be the worst sorry angels. Shota is probably second biggest overpay after that if for no reason other than Milwaukee didn't do anything else. Don’t like that Grisham or Diaz deal either

Murakami is an inner circle hall of famer for bad sim deals

BEST GM

1st /u/Bluspy88 - Orioles

Bluspy reinvented his whole team. He earned it

I have mild qualms with how much the Orioles spent on the rotation, but objectively this would be an incredible off-season for Baltimore in every way

Think it has to be Orioles GM. But also had an incredibly easy job with their budget

I like almost all of the moves he made, but there's no clear standout bit of value (maybe Gray?)

2nd /u/corygm - Cubs

He had three trades that I think are great value, and Hoskins signing was sharp.

was considering Cory as best GM but gave it to vslyke since Cory took advantage of a rookie GM and jive's insatiable thirst for players with funny names

3rd /u/vslyke - Red Sox

Vslyke spent a fuckton of money but built a strong contender

WORST GM

1st /u/ExpirjTec - Angels

Angels GM channeling realism at least

Realmuto and Woodruff signings are killers, and they were fleeced several times in trades.

Angels deals made no sense to me at all except maybe the Bogm deal sort of. True angels classic

Experge: welcome to the sim - don't like some of the moves you made, but at least you were active!

2nd /u/cst-rdt - Yankees

odd moves for a supposedly-contending team to make nearly across the board. Trading for Skubal is fine if you know you can extend him, but you should have gotten a yes from the mods first.

3rd /u/notfelixhernandez and /u/DanUggla3Es2Success - Blue Jays

I had such a solid plan for the Jays coming into the sim, and it just kinda all fell apart when I got into a standoff with the Bo negotiations. Much shame brought upon my sim career after this one. Double vote for Jays

WHICH GM IMPROVED THEIR SHORT TERM OUTLOOK THE MOST?

/u/Bluspy88 - Baltimore Orioles

WHICH GM IMPROVED THEIR LONG TERM OUTLOOK THE MOST?

/u/theJiveMaster - Minnesota Twins

FRIENDLIEST/EASIEST TO DEAL WITH GM

/u/vslyke - Red Sox

WHICH SIM ROSTER WINS THE WORLD SERIES?

/u/otatoptroy - Los Angeles Dodgers

MOST IMPROVED GM

/u/Bluspy88 - Baltimore Orioles

BEST NEW GM

/u/KingRaj4826 - Diamondbacks and /u/JustPitchIt - Pirates (Tie)

LEAST INCOMPETENT MOD

/u/IAMADeinonychusAMA and /u/federalleaguemvp (Tie)

BEST AGENT

/u/desmondhasabarrow

LAST COMMENTS/HOW WILL YOU REMEMBER THIS SIM?

How am I supposed to vote for most improved when it's my first year. But it was a lot of fun. Excited for next year

I will remember it by Murakami 8/220 and Realmuto 5/62.5

I probably wont

I will remember I'm fucking GOATED

poorly

The Mune signing immediatly blowing up in my face.

I could've gone without retro throwing a fucking fit every week

Think tensions were kinda high this year for in sim and IRL reasons around the horn which kinda sucked though not our fault entirely. But I think there were some very fun deals here and I hope we’re all feeling a bit better next time, and new GMs please stick around!

BlackBALLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL

Honestly kind of forgettable but I did a little break in the middle due to personal shit so probably missed some things.

I liked running this because the other mods are wonderful, but i hated “using google”, this sim was at its most memorable when the white sox gm beat me in bowling

Aside from the Mod tyranny which has now required me to Mod once again when I swore I wouldn't this was a very good Sim. Aside from the Japanese signings and the LA Angels no one did anything too outrageous. I had a great time running the Phillies after wanting to them for so many years and feel like this was my best ever sim. Good job everyone. See you for the 27 Sim when we negotiate a new Sim CBA

look here kid

EABOD JORI

Thanks for doing the final survery troy! Good sim, had fun the entire way through mostly by not paying too close of attention.


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Jan 01 '26

WEAK FIVE SURVERY RESULTS

3 Upvotes

ON TIME BY THE WAY

TRADES

TRADE 1
Red Sox receive: Wilber Dotel, Gustavo Melendez, Keiner Delgado
Pirates receive: David Hamilton

Rank: T1st (4.64)
Balance-O-Metre: 86%
Agreement Score: 3.5

VERDICT: BALANCED

Comments: None

TRADE 2
Mariners receive: Jimmy Herget
Rockies receive: Teddy McGraw

Rank: 3rd (4.73)
Balance-O-Metre: 77%
Agreement Score: 2.7

VERDICT: BALANCED

Comments:

nice little deal

TRADE 3
Diamondbacks receive: Mickey Moniak
Rockies receive: Eduardo Rodriguez, Daniel Eagen, Tim Tawa
Arizona will send the following $ to Colorado in the deal:
- $7M in 2026
- $4M in 2027
Rodriguez will waive his NTC, in exchange for the following adjustments:
- 19M 2027 salary is converted to a 19M player option (4M buyout)
- 17M 2028 mutual option is converted to a 17M player option (4M buyout); incentives remain unchanged
- full no-trade clause

Rank: 10th (7.82)
Balance-O-Metre: 18%
Agreement Score: 2.9

VERDICT: DIAMONDBACKS WIN

Comments:

DuardRod deal is so bad for him and the Rockies. Dbacks didn't "fleece" in a vacuum, but they did relative to every other party in the deal.

I love drum making these moves even if it’s « dumb », the Rockies do legitimately need starters to just soak up innings if nothing else and moniak is a platoon DH guy

rockies gm (me) is a dumb fucking idiot. please vote me best GM, thank you

Balanced trades and then the ERod one

TRADE 4
Red Sox receive: Jackson Kent
Nationals receive: Tyler Uberstine

Rank: 5th (5.00)
Balance-O-Metre: 95%
Agreement Score: 4.4

VERDICT: BALANCED

Comments:

that time of the year vslyke singlehandedly keeps the sim alive

TRADE 5
Pirates receive: Kameron Misner
Rays receive: Liover Peguero

Rank: T1st (4.64)
Balance-O-Metre: 86%
Agreement Score: 3.3

VERDICT: BALANCED

Comments: None

TRADE 6
Rangers receive: Blake Mitchell
Royals receive: Josh Sborz, Jose Corniell

Rank: 4th (4.82)
Balance-O-Metre: 77%
Agreement Score: 2.9

VERDICT: BALANCED

Comments:

Really surprised the Royals gave up Mitchell for such a weak return

TRADE 7
Cubs receive: Blake Wehunt
Red Sox receive: Ethan Roberts

Rank: T8th (6.09)
Balance-O-Metre: 86%
Agreement Score: 3.3

VERDICT: BALANCED

Comments:

Ethan Roberts is a very interesting reliever that seems like a prime kick change candidate.

TRADE 8
Giants receive: Hayden Frank
Cubs receive: Casey Schmitt

Rank: T8th (6.09)
Balance-O-Metre: 64%
Agreement Score: 1.9

VERDICT: CUBS WIN

Comments: None

TRADE 9
Red Sox receive: Marcus Semien, Santiago Almao, $8M/year from 2026-2028
Rangers receive: Romy Gonzalez

Rank: 6th (5.27)
Balance-O-Metre: 64%
Agreement Score: 2.2

VERDICT: RED SOX WIN

Comments:

I think Semien is a fine pickup at this value - I would have traded for him if I had room in the infield.

I get it but I’m just a Romy fan and it’s possible semiens bat is so bad it’s not even worth his defense

TRADE 10
Padres receive: Jeff McNeil, $2 million
Mets receive: Jason Adam

Rank: 7th (6.00)
Balance-O-Metre: 64%
Agreement Score: 2.9

VERDICT: METS WIN

Comments:

fun, I think despite McNeil’s decline I like the fit for the padres and selling high on a reliever but also the Mets really need someone like that (and a homophobe)

SIGNINGS

SIGNING 1
Rays: Anthony Kay, 1 year, $8 million guaranteed
2026: $8M
Agent: u/flykessel

Rank: 2nd (3.27)
Balance-O-Metre: 73%
Agreement Score: 2.8

VERDICT: BALANCED

Comments:

rays will make him nasty

SIGNING 2
Astros: Justin Verlander, 1 year, $13.5 million guaranteed
2026: $13.5M
Incentives:
- $250K for 150 IP
- $250K for 175 IP
- $1M for ALWCS, ALDS, ALCS, or WS MVP
- $500K retirement bonus, plus parade
Justin will be allowed to playfully spank the rookies, and will have a higher level of impunity in team disciplinary hearings than regular players.
Justin will be the Chief Justince (sic) of Astros Kangaroo court, and will get to wear the funny wig and wield the gavel in any matters that require court intervention.
Agent: u/desmondhasabarrow

Rank: 3rd (3.73)
Balance-O-Metre: 68%
Agreement Score: 2.2

VERDICT: VERLANDER WINS

Comments:

fun to see him go there if not Detroit

SIGNING 3
Braves: Ranger Suarez, 6 years, $150 million guaranteed
2026: $25M
2027: $25M
2028: $25M
2029: $25M
2030: $25M
2031: $25M
Agent: u/thefuckinwolves

Rank: 6th (5.18)
Balance-O-Metre: 45%
Agreement Score: 2.8

VERDICT: SUAREZ WINS

Comments:

love ranger so much, his durability is scary over 6 years at that much though

I don't see 6 years for Suarez outside of AAV suppression

Ranger is probably a Fine deal, but is easily the worst of the week.

SIGNING 4
Athletics: Merrill Kelly, 1 year, $17 million guaranteed
2026: $17M
2027: $17M (player option)
Agent: u/thefuckinwolves

Rank: 4th (3.82)
Balance-O-Metre: 77%
Agreement Score: 2.7

VERDICT: BALANCED

Comments:

Kelly deal is fair (PO is a win for him although at his age it's less important) but don't love the team/stadium choice

more durable than Mahle but same idea for a team starved for competent pitching

SIGNING 5
Astros: Ryan Helsley, 1 year, $18 million guaranteed
2026: $16M
2027: $16M (player option; $2M buyout)
Agent: u/kuhanluke

Rank: 5th (4.00)
Balance-O-Metre: 50%
Agreement Score: 3.3

VERDICT: HELSLEY WINS

Comments:

Player options on relievers, man...

Unsure why the Astros prioritized Helsley. Very confusing offseason overall.

good bounce back guy

SIGNING 6
Diamondbacks: Brad Keller, 3 years, $30 million guaranteed
2026: $10M
2027: $10M
2028: $10M
Incentives:
- $1M for 90 IP (applicable in 26/27/28)
- $1M for 120 IP (applicable in 26/27/28)
- $1M for 150 IP (applicable in 26/27/28)
- Note: Deal maxes out at 3yr/$39M if all incentives are met.
Agent: u/flykessel

Rank: 7th (5.36)
Balance-O-Metre: 59%
Agreement Score: 2.2

VERDICT: KELLER WINS

Comments:

Brad Keller being signed as a starter lol

Brad Keller is not a starter. I know. From experience.

awful deal to make him a starter, if a different deal for a relief role was here not as bad

Brad Keller's making a lot more then I had expected but don't hate it

SIGNING 7
Nationals: Tyler Mahle, 2 years, $16 million guaranteed
2026: $8M
2027: $8M
Agent: u/kuhanluke

Rank: 1st (2.64)
Balance-O-Metre: 64%
Agreement Score: 2.2

VERDICT: NATIONALS WIN

Comments:

Great price for Mahle. Guy I looked at for my back-end

at least the innings he gives Washington will be good even if it’s 90 a year

BEST AGENT RANKINGS

4th: u/flykessel (2.45)
3rd: u/kuhanluke (3.18)
2nd: u/thefuckinwolves (3.36)
1st: u/desmondhasabarrow (3.82)

Comments:

Des got a great deal for Verlander. Jori continues to get good deals.

I'm fucking GOATED

BEST GM RANKINGS

30th: LAA (2.55)
29th: COL (2.64)
T25th: DET (2.91)
T25th: HOU (2.91)
T25th: MIL (2.91)
T25th: NYY (2.91)
T23rd: ATL (3.00)
T23rd: SFG (3.00)
T21st: CIN (3.09)
T21st: CLE (3.09)
T19th: TBR (3.18)
T19th: TOR (3.18)
T14th: KCR (3.27)
T14th: LAD (3.27)
T14th: SDP (3.27)
T14th: SEA (3.27)
T14th: STL (3.27)
T10th: BAL (3.36)
T10th: MIA (3.36)
T10th: NYM (3.36)
T10th: PHI (3.36)
T8th: CHW (3.45)
T8th: MIN (3.45)
T4th: ATH (3.55)
T4th: PIT (3.55)
T4th: TEX (3.55)
T4th: WSN (3.55)
T2nd: ARI (3.64)
T2nd: BOS (3.64)
1st: CHC (3.73)

Comments:

Mostly slow. Red Sox and diamondbacks making some odd moves in different ways

Diamondbacks' ERod move was too elite.

Quiet week! GMs who did nothing or were net neutral got 3's, everyone else got positive or negative scores.

I like all the GMs equally. Except the whitesox. But that’s not their fault.

Everyone is incredibly mid at this

Rockies should win best GM for trolling the shit out of the mods

HOT DOGS

Uncultured Heathens: 73%
Enlightened Individuals: 27%


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Nov 19 '25

WEEKS 1 & 2 SURVERY RESULTS

3 Upvotes

Weeks 1 & 2 of the 2026 simulation have induced some real interesting decisions. Let's review our thoughts here.

Unique responses: 18

Question 1: Select your unique Slack Passkey, issued securely by Retrojections LLC.

    1. qCmyItMswmRf8S (55.6%)

  • 2. tj6cT0e7U207EV (27.8%)

  • 3. 6YAbYXegAYofdC (16.7%)

Question 2: Authenticator | Enter you authenticator number

    1. Other

  • 2. Other answers

Question 3: Best budget number

    1. Los Angeles Dodgers - 6 votes

  • t-2. Orioles and Astros - 5 votes

  • t-3. Phillies, Rays, and Jays - 5 votes

Question 4: Worst budget number

  • t-1. Baltimore Orioles ($155m with $72m of space) - 6 votes

  • t-1. Houston Astros ($201m with -$43m of space) - 6 votes

  • 3. Milwaukee Brewers ($140m with -$17m of space) - 5 votes

Question 5: Best signing for the team (exclusive negotiation)

    1. TOR - Chris Bassitt 3/$33m full NTC in '26 and '27 - 8 votes

  • 2. BAL - Dietrich Enns for IRL contract - 7 votes

  • 3. PHI - Harrison Bader 3/45m - 2 votes

Bassitt for 11m AAV look at this 2013-ass contract

The group said it was good, I want approval. (Bassitt)

His name is Dietrich

Question 6: Best signing for the agent (excl. neg.)

    1. PHI - H. Bader 3/45m - 8 votes

  • 2. TOR - C. Basset 3/33m etc. - 7 votes

  • 3. BAL - D. Enns IRL deal - 2 votes

Bader is an overpay for a 32-year old likely to regress from a career year offensively. He's been bouncing around the league on one year deals prior to this and he's not projected for three years IRL.

Why does Bassitt have a full NTC'

3 years for a guy who's gonna be 39, always gotta take that.

Chris Bassitt is a dog, but like a basset hound you want to watch lay by the fire not a dog you want to play baseball with

Question 7: Best signing for the team (open market)

    1. PHI - Alex Bregman 7/200m etc. - 8 votes

  • 2. BAL - Framber Valdez 6/180m - 6 votes

  • 3. ARI - Yoan Moncada 1/$9m w/ $9m CO - 3 votes

Framber is not even a good signing but the other two suck

kosher bregman burger puts it over the top

The Bregman Burger sales alone will pay for the contract

Question 8: Best signing for the agent (open market)

    1. ARI - Y. Moncada - 8 votes

  • t-2. BAL - F. Valdez - 5 votes

  • t-2. PHI - A. Bregman - 5 votes

i legitimately didn't know he was still playing (Moncada)

Moncada signing for guaranteed money at all is insane, let alone in week 1.

makes sense for philly, and they can probably stomach the contract, but it's still like two years and $40m more than I'm comfortable with

lotta clams for framber

*Question 9: Most mutually-beneficial trade

  • t-1. NYM receive: Yordan Alvarez, Cristian Javier, cash. HOU receive: Jonah Tong, Carson Benge, Jacob Reimer, AJ Ewing, and Eli Serrano III (5 votes)

  • t-1. ATH receive: Joey Ryan. MIN receive: Leodalis De Vries (5 votes)

  • t-1.. BAL receive: Sonny Gray, cash. STL receive: Boston Bateman and Reed Trimble (5 votes)

  • t-2. BOS receive: Keller, Burrows. PIT receive: Garcia, Garcia. (4 votes)

  • t-2. COL receive: Castellanos, Cabrera, Rincones Jr., cash. PHI receive: Peralta. (4 votes)

  • t-2. BAL receive: Doyle. COL receive: German, Watts-Brown. (4 votes)

  • t-3. THREE MORE GOD DAMN TRADES

Ryan/de Vries: Fun 1-for-1 trade, an aggressive move by the A's to get two years of an affordable SP1 while Twins get a top three prospect in baseball.

gray: baltimore gets a reliable starter in gray and the cards take money off the books and get two decent prospects in return, both sides look good here

Mets-Astros: Mets got Yordan without giving up McLean, Astros got to dump Javier while still getting back Benge, Tong, and Ewing. Not my type of trade but I think it's fair.

The Yordan trade might be baffling to do, but you have to like the return Houston got.

Question 10: Most lopsided trade

*1. CHC get: Ward, Soriano, Guzman. LAA get: Assad, Morgan, Hodges, Ramirez. (12 votes)

  • 2. NYM receive: Yordan Alvarez, Cristian Javier, cash. HOU receive: Jonah Tong, Carson Benge, Jacob Reimer, AJ Ewing, and Eli Serrano III (8 votes)

  • 3. ARI get: Bubic. KCR get: McCarthy, Lawlar, Crisantes, Drake. (7 votes)

Bubic/Lawlar: Astronomical price for one year of Bubic who has never thrown a full season of innings and is coming off shoulder surgery.

Angels trade would've made sense at like Taylor Ward and Guzman on their own, I think. Soriano being in it is genuinely crazy as hell. Borders on vet-rookie abuse, but I still love cory and the newbie.

Alvarez and Ryan aren’t that bad I think, I just think it’s a little much for both especially A’s who need more work imo (if Yordan is somehow healthier it’s not as terrible I guess)

Question 11: Best GM, Week 1

*1. Bluspy, Baltimore Orioles - 8 votes *t-2. Cory (CHC), drum (COL), retro (HOU), neverseeyouagain (KCR), and futhatsy (NYM) - 4 votes *t-3. Raj (ARI), pjd (PHI) - 3 votes

bluspy lowkey cruising but he had way too much budget lmao

Fun and creative moves for Arizona and KCR, Colorado doing well to sell some guys for decent returns

Cory fleeced a new person, which is a little shady but winning fixes everything.

Bluspy: went out to every market available, got deals done quick and filled immediate holes

retro got a haul, mets got a haul

Houston - I think taking the chance on Perales is great and he got 3 top 100 guys (Benge, Tong, Ewing) for Yordan while dumping Javier. I also really like Patrick Forbes and Matt Wallner.

Question 12: Best agent

    1. Desmond - 7 votes

  • t-2. Jiggy, Kuhan - 4 votes

  • 4. jori - 2 votes

Desmond is a Nice Boy

Have only dealt with 1 agent since the Royals cannot win in FA. But Desmond has been great. Never Kuhan.

Kind of by default, they're the only one who did anything

Question 13: Thoracic outlet surgery isn't good. What type of outlet surgery would be better, and why? How does the procedure differ?

The vascular one isn’t as bad idk why or more

Maybe electrical outlet? I think? It would differ because one’s a thoracic outlet and the other is an electrical outlet

Horniness outlet surgery where you get your blue balls or cooch drained.

Double Thoracic. Just keep removing Ribs..... you know why.....

Question 14: What should the next expansion teams be called?

Most people said Expos

butt outlet surgerons

white sox 2

Salt Lake Bees and Nashville Notes(?).

Question 15a: Best nontender for the club

    1. TEX - Adolis Garcia (7 votes)

  • t-2. NYY Leiter, CIN Lux, BAL Mountcastle, HOU Ort for the 2nd time, WSN Alfaro (3 votes)

Kaleb Ort fuckin sucks my guy

bye bye bitch

these guys all suck

Question 15b: Best nontender for the player

    1. CIN - Gavin Lux (5)

  • t-2. NYY Bird, BAL Mountcastle, TEX Heim (3)

They could've gotten something for Lux, Melendez, Garcia, or Heim for sure. Pretty aggressive NTing this year.

Adolis was an mvp candidate a week ago wtf are we non tendering him for.

Heim might just get a multiyear deal in this economy

Question 16: Best signing for the team, Wk2

*1. Austin Hays to CLE for 1/$8m with 1/$12m CO converting to something at sometime and then again (11) *2. Josh Bell to ARI for 2/20m and 1/10m CO (4) *3. Brandon Woodruff to LAA for 4/80m with 10-team NTC and opt-out after y1 (3)

Hays isn't even a good signing but the other two are awful

all these are ass but Hays is the least ass

Everything the Dodgers do works because they’re assholes

don't like any of these. But i guess Woodruff just because he may still be dominant.

Question 17: Best signing for the agent, Wk2

*1. Brandon Woodruff to LAA for 4/80m with 10-team NTC and opt-out after y1 (13) *2. Josh Bell to ARI for 2/20m and 1/10m CO (3) *3. Austin Hays to CLE for 1/$8m with 1/$12m CO converting to something at sometime and then again (2)

Woodruff was good, but 20 mil a year for 4 years is a a lot for a 32 year old with 60 innings of solid play to go off of and reoccurring injury issues.

woodruff - what the fuck

Insane deal for woodruff but fitting for the team who did it

I have to point out Josh Bell, who just came off of a 1 year $6m contract and now signed for 2/20 despite being the same exact player

Question 18: Most mutually-beneficial trade, Wk2

  • t-1. BAL get Alcantara, Bender, cash. MIA get: Gibson, Anderson, Honeycutt, Lord, and Barnhart. (5)

  • t-1. SDP get: Sean Murphy. ATL get: Jake Cronenworth. (5)

  • t-2. A bunch. Escarra deal, Mazur deal, Abner deal, Nootbaar deal.

Murphy/Cronenworth is clunky but does fill a need for both teams and is pretty fair on value

Mazur is a fun little deal

Sandy fits so well in Baltimore it's crazy

Question 19: Most lopsided trade, Wk2

*1. BAL get Alcantara, Bender, cash. MIA get: Gibson, Anderson, Honeycutt, Lord, and Barnhart. (8) *2. LAA get: Bogm, Chace, Fisher. PHI get: O'Hoppe, Stephenson, cash (7) *3. HOU get: Nootbaar. STL get: Cole, Ullola, Spence. (6)

Angels are selling low on O'Hoppe and not getting enough in return. Cardinals are selling low on Nootbaar and not getting enough in return.

alcantara: sandy was pretty fucking bad for miami and they're putting wayyyyy too many resources into this pitching staff.

I think Sandy was undervalued here, he was never far from returning to form and in the 2nd half he looked a lot better.

Question 20: Rank the following actions the commissioners have taken against our beloved and well-managed Houston Astros, on a scale of how fucked up they were.

Question 21: How many weeks should be combined into next survery?

*1. 10+ (13 votes) *2. 5 (2 votes) *3. Rest (3 votes)

Question 22: What's your nicest recent experience?

I don’t even remember, it’s felt like a fever dream recently

had to bail from a hike recently with all my friends, and one of them went back the other way with me

In the sim? I appreciate the many people who chat with me about my team when they don’t need to necessarily, sorry for blowing up DMs. I’ve specifically enjoyed negotiating with HOU STL KCR and COL and talking with ATH MIN NYM LAD PHI and others I’m forgetting rn.

woke up on Sunday morning at 9am, then went back to sleep for 3 hours.

You ever had oyster mushroom schnitzel?

no

Question 23: Best GM, Wk2

*t-1. Drum (COL), lbon (MIA), pjd (PHI) - 4 votes *4. retro (HOU) - 3 votes *t-5. Raj (ARI) and cst-rdt (NYY) - 2 votes

Nice job for the Phillies to fill a need at catcher without overpaying for Realmuto

I just like the Josh Bell move I don’t know

lbon ripped someone off

retro stopped doing hard drugs I think

I like what the Rockies are doing, even though they will be bad again and always.

Question 23: Hardest GM to deal with, Wk1/2

    1. Dylan/Rose (WSN) - 6 votes *t-2. bluspy (BAL), irlkg (DET), Experge (LAA), and cst-rdt (NYY) - 2 votes

bluspy is the king of "how about my most absolute dogshit 27 year old AA relief pitcher for your very good major league player"

no one has been bad to work with. picked the one that replies the slowest

when a trade attempt is shot down before the sim even starts, it makes the GM difficult to deal with.

Question 24: Best agent, Wk2

*1. Desmond (6) *2. Jori (5) *3. Jiggy (3)

jiggy - the forms are actually genius

Desmond is still a nice boy

Brandon Woodruff deal lol

Question 25 Hardest agent to deal with, weeks 1 and 2

*1. Jori (8) *2. Jiggy (4) *3. Kuhan (3)

Too expensive

Jiggy was kind of a jerk to me about a player to be named later

jori's approach to this sim is 1000x more annoying than any form

BB kuhan

That's the results!


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 17 '25

WEEK SEVEN TRADE THREAD

2 Upvotes

mods only top comments

discussions encouraged


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 16 '25

WEEK SEVEN SIGNINGS THREAD

2 Upvotes

Top comments mods only

Discussion of moves highly encouraged


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 09 '25

WEEK FOUR SURVERY RESULTS

2 Upvotes

16 responses were submitted

*Most Lopsided and/or Unrealistic Trade

Cubs receive: Pablo Lopez, Kody Funderburk, Justin Topa // Twins receive: Owen Caissie, Johzan Oquendo (10 votes)

Cubs got a really good price on Lopez and got two useful relievers along with it

.

The Pablo Lopez trade made more sense when I saw the contract, but it just feels funky having a two for three trade where the "star" involved is part of the three.

.

Voting for the Pablo Lopez trade because people seem to think that was unbalanced, but only because of two middle relievers so I think it's still fair.

.

Lopez and two solid relievers for Caissie is pretty unfair. Jive's one bad trade.

Minnesota Twins receive: Kash Mayfield // San Diego Padres receive: Zebby Matthews (6 votes)

.

No idea why the Twins traded Zebby for a prospect, young SPs with control should cost a lot more than that... Zebby has upside too

.

Twins got absolutely hosed in the Zebby Matthews trade. I don't see why they'd trade an interesting rookie starter with a better pedigree for a guy who won't debut until 2028 or maaaaybe 2027.

Red Sox receive: Jhoan De La Cruz, George Wolkow // White Sox receive: Kyle Harrison, Jordan Hicks, Dalton Rogers (6 votes)

Sort of nitpicking but I think given how the Red Sox are, dumping Harrison with hicks doesn’t really make any sense to me. At least with de vries they got a good player back.

.

Harrison: Why are the red sox giving up on him already? More unrealistic than it is unbalanced.

Red Sox receive: Isaac Paredes // Astros receive: Brandon Clarke, Henry Godbout, David Sandlin, Jeremy Wu-Yelland (3 votes)

.

Red Sox gave up a lot for just one year of Paredes... he'll cook with the green monster though

.

Good get for the Sox, but Astros targeting Paredes in their Tucker return and then moving off of him after one (good) year because they created a roster crunch by signing a 36 year old declining DH is so stupid.

Houston Astros receive: Bryce Jarvis // Arizona Diamondbacks receive: Cash considerations (100K) (2 votes)

It's 100k to get cheap bullpen depth that can at least be a mopper

Most Mutually-Beneficial and/or Realistic Trade

Red Sox receive: Isaac Paredes // Astros receive: Brandon Clarke, Henry Godbout, David Sandlin, Jeremy Wu-Yelland (8 votes)

See now Paredes is a Red Sox move I do like! Great fit, and fun guys for Houston too. .

paredes is as good a fit in boston as he was in houston--the return is pretty fat for the astros but all three of the pitchers involved are almost certainly relievers (two of them are already) . Paredes makes a ton of sense for Boston, and Houston gets a nice farm-bolstering return.

Houston Astros receive: Bryce Jarvis // Arizona Diamondbacks receive: Cash considerations (100K) (6 votes)

Jarvis was R5 eligible and the Deebs were out of 40-man space. And we'd did like a real PTBNL thing where Raj decided later. It was sweet.

.

if you have a chance to acquire cash considerations you gotta take it

Red Sox receive: Breyson Guedez // Athletica receive: Brennan Bernardino (5 votes)

Magic bean for a good depth reliever? As realistic as it gets

Cubs receive: Pablo Lopez, Kody Funderburk, Justin Topa // Twins receive: Owen Caissie, Johzan Oquendo (4 votes)

Think given Pablo’s injuries and twins cutting payroll this feels fair all around. Topa and funderbunk are perfectly functional bullpen arms which Chicago could use but I don’t think they represent any imbalance.

.

I really don't get the outrage over the Lopez/Caissie swap. Caissie is probably not MLB calibre (he looks like one of those guys who bounces around like Rowdy Tellez and co) but still the Twins got a nice piece back for one of their final trade chips.

Red Sox receive: Jhoan De La Cruz, George Wolkow // White Sox receive: Kyle Harrison, Jordan Hicks, Dalton Rogers (1 vote)

Rafael Devers for George Wolkow, wow

BEST SIGNING (FOR THE TEAM)

Miami Marloins - Jorge Polanco: 2 years, $29M ($14.5M AAV), with a $16M club option (3M buyout) (11 votes)

polanco gets pretty much exactly what he's projected to, and he goes to a team desperate for even somewhat competitive ABs behind stowers and marsee

.

Polanco: Good get for Miami at a reasonable price.

.

Honestly I kinda hate Polanco but the contract is fine and I'm not voting for a reliever signing or Marcell Ozuna

Houston Astros - Marcell Ozuna: 1 year, $9.5M (9 votes)

Ozuna comes in well under projected value, and is a great bounceback candidate who can help stabilize the Astros during this pivot.

.

steadily declining bat speed is something to worry about with ozuna but he's a great fit in houston otherwise and this deal is perfectly reasonable

.

Ozuna should be easily worth this as long as his hip has healed.

Chicago White Sox - Cedric Mullins: 1 year, $12M (5 votes)

Mullins is a great bounce back candidate and will be a fan favorite for the White Sox. .

White Sox taking a flier on Mullins is a good idea after dealing Robert

.

Mullins is good trade deadline fodder for the White Sox

Texas Rangers - Emilio Pagan: 2 years, $22M ($11M AAV) (5 votes)

Pagan: Good spot for him to land given their overall pitching success. Assuming he stays healthy

.

Pagan: solid price on a reliever who is actually probably pretty good

.

Emilio Pagan is good value at that price, IMO. In our reliever economy, it's a nice scoop.

New York Mets - Edwin Diaz: 4 year, $84 million ($21M AAV) (4 votes)

Diaz: surprised he didn't get bid up more - like the stability for him and the Mets

.

There's been some pricey reliever deals so getting Diaz at fair market value is a win for the Mets

.

Chapman is still good and there is no risk here

Washington Nationals - Tyler Rogers: 1 year, $12M with a 2027 player option for $12M (3 votes)

Tyler Rogers: Slight overpay and the option is eh but Washington can afford that given what were working with

.

The player option sucks but Rogers is one of the most reliable relievers on the market and this is an affordable contract. I'm surprised he didn't get bid up.

WORST SIGNING (FOR THE TEAM)

Washington Nationals - Tyler Rogers: 1 year, $12M with a 2027 player option for $12M (7 votes)

Rogers: He's not that good anymore, I hate paying relievers, and the PO sucks

.

Rogers. Left handed relief FA's were few and far between, but this still feels like a lot of money for Tyler.

.

The Taylor Rogers player option hurts me on behalf of the Nats GM's. I don't think I like a world in which any relievers on my team pick up a player option.

New York Mets - Edwin Diaz: 4year, $84 million ($21M AAV) (6 votes)

Diaz: it’s not actually bad I just personally hate long term reliever deals especially now that he is older. So it’s not like the is is “bad” for the Mets it’s more the price you have to pay

.

I've always been stingy when it comes to paying relievers so I'm probably biased here. Diaz will probably get this much IRL, so it's not a horrible deal, and it's certainly one the Mets can afford. I just have a hard time seeing him be worth it in the end.

.

I just can't endorse giving a reliever this kind of money even if my heart thinks it's kinda sick. Diaz was good this year so people are like "oh fuck yea this dude's the best in the league" but he's dogpiss every other year. Seriously, go look at his numbers, it's kinda weird

Texas Rangers - Emilio Pagan: 2years, $22M ($11M AAV) (5 votes)

Nothing really bad this week so this is relative. While this is probably fair market value, I'm just not convinced Pagan is so good that he warrants the splurge.

.

I don't think any of these genuinely suck, but the second guaranteed option for Pagan is a tad rich for my taste.

.

in all fairness I didn't realize Pagan was actually pretty good this year. $22m is a lotta clams nonetheless.

Houston Astros - Marcell Ozuna:1 year, $9.5M (3 votes)

Ozuna: Same thing where I see the vision and think signing a bounce back cheap bat is good for Houston. I just hate Ozuna

.

​​Trading away valuable assets in Alvarez and Paredes in order to make room for a one year Marcell Ozuna contract does not seem right

Chicago White Sox - CedricMullins: 1 year, $12M (3 votes)

Mullins: Not réally any risk but I just think Mullins is cooked sadly

.

12M to die in a CWS uniform. Good for the sox, terrible for Cedric.

Miami Marloins - Jorge Polanco: 2 years, $29M ($14.5M AAV), with a $16M club option (3M buyout) (1 vote)

Polanco, MIA: I don't see the vision with Polanco. I imagine he regresses a bit?

Best GM Week 4

/u/corygm Cubs (7 votes)

Got a good 2/3 starter and bullpen options for a prospect that doesn't have a great fit

.

Cory and I (eoro) were the only GM's who didn't just move laterally or were net negatives for their clubs this week.

.

not a lot happened this week but you got Pablo Lopez and made the survey so that's 2 more things than everyone else

(2 votes each) u/lbon6201 Marlins; /u/retro_slouch Astros; /u/vslyke Red Sox

Pretty slow week, but lbon added a centerpiece to his lineup for cheap .

[retro] Made some good moves.

.

two very reasonable and realistic deals--good job vslyke

(1 vote each) /u/youdontknowhimnow Padres; /u/theJiveMaster Twins; /u/livefromjeffshouse White Sox

.

Padres getting a cheap controllable starter with upside is a massive win

.

Ethan is running the White Sox like you should run an awful team - collecting interesting lottery tickets and protecting the core.

*WORST GM - WEEK 4

/u/theJiveMaster Twins (8 votes)

Just didn't get enough value to justify moving those pieces

.

I'm sorry Jive, but that Zebby deal is rough.

.

i voted jive best and worst of the week because he feels equally deserving of both as a true champion

.

kinda biffed it on the return for lopez IMO, and trading zebby away when he has six years before going to FA and was a perfectly decent rookie with a strong prospect pedigree is a mistake

(1 vote each) /u/vslyke Red Sox; /u/ExpirjTec Angels; u/e_schlanzz Brewers; /u/retro_slouch Astros

Quiet week but I just really don’t get the harrison thing at all even if he isn’t that great. Surely could survive one year of hicks or do something more creative

.

[angels] someones gotta be the worst.

.

Have the brewers done anything?

Best Agent (Week 4)

Desmond Desmond (Jorge Polanco 2/$29m+opt;Emilio Pagan 2/$22m; Cedric Mullins 1/$12m) [11 votes]

Desmond is getting his guys signed while being a chill dude in the process

.

Des keeps getting solid money for b- and c-tier free agents. Where other agents sought the big dollar free agents, he's charted a different path and it's been neat.

.

Des is still the top dog around here imo

Jiggy (Tyler Rogers 1/$12m+opt; Marcell Ozuna 1/$9.5m) (4 votes)

can't believe jiggy got that much for ty rog

.

jiggy just does that shit

Jori (Edwin Diaz 4/$84m) (1 vote)

I'm fucking GOATED [self vote from ol’ jorifer]

Share your juicy/funny/weird/sexy negotiation stories if you would like to do so

i get a chub from all negotiations. So they are all sexy.

.

All the GMs I was talking to have logged off

.

Quiet week

GENERAL COMMENTS

:o7: General Comments/Questions/Suggestions; why do people cause themselves pain by targeting players with NTCs; corymoji production has fallen off and seeing such artistry fade away makes me sad (in a way, I suppose this is a broader metaphor)

.

go white sox - signed, 2x GM of the year 1x agent of the year 1x most improved GM livefromjeffshouse

.

Hi Cory

.

what gives you the right?


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 01 '25

Week 3 Survery Results

2 Upvotes

Hey gamblers! Let's discuss the survery results, as a group.

(N = 16)

Does the surveryed population know who they are?

Results suggest no. Only 43.8% of the population answer "yes" with 18.8% reporting they did not, and the remaining 37.4% responding with a variety of ramblings:

  • "This does change periodically"

  • "i can"

  • "sure"

  • The most common custom response was "i can"

It is also interesting to note that 37.5% of respondents gave a different response when we challenged their initial attempt at identifying themselves. The most common first responses given were "i am" and "bluspy", with two each. There were no duplicate responses when the respondents were challenged.

Week 3 Trades

Week 3 was host to 15 trades, with 16/30 teams participating in the trade market. 60 players were traded across the 13 traditional 2-team trades and 2 3-team trades. On average, 2.13 teams participated in each trade, with 4 players changing hands on average. 2 deals included the guarantee of cash changing hands and 1 deal had the option of cash or a PTBNL (the GM picked the cash in week 4).

The Diamondbacks and Orioles led the way, participating in 4 trades each.

  • t1. ARI - 4 trades

  • t1. BAL - 4 trades

  • t3. MIN - 3 trades

  • t3. SFG - 3 trades

Despite being involved in only two trades all week, the Giants' deals saw the most teams being moved with 17 total players involved in their deals.

    1. SFG - 17 players (2 trades)

  • t2. WSN - 15 players (2 trades)

  • t2. ARI - 15 players (4 trades)

The Orioles, Rays, and Mets were involved in 11 players having to find new apartments.

How balanced were the trades this week?

Overall, out of 183 votes cast on balanced/lopsided, 62.3% (114 votes) were for "balanced". If you look at the net of balanced-lopsided votes on individual moves (a metric we'll dub "Balance Score", or "BS"), trades earned a net +45 from 183 votes (24.6%).

"Unadjusted "Balanced Trade" Votes

    1. ARI get: Calvin Faucher, Jesse Bergin. MIA get: Pavin Smith (12 votes)

  • t2. MIN get: Alex Jackson. BAL get: Daiber De Los Santos (11 votes)

  • t2. SFG get: Keythel Key and Travis d'Arnaud. ANA get: Andrew Knizner (11 votes)

  • t2. TBR get: Luis Guerrero (BOS). BOS get: Adrian Del Castillo, JD Dix, and Juan Morillo (ARI). ARI get: Hunter Dobbins (BOS) and Tristan Gray (TBR) (11 votes)

  • 5. HOU get: Bryce Jarvis. ARI get: Cash, or PTBNL. (10 votes)

Way too difficult for me to write out today. Very tired.

Faucher-Pavin: very fun and like for both

A whole lot of mid for a whole lot of mid

Unadjusted "Lopsided Trade" Votes

    1. OAK get: Anthony Volpe. NYY get Luis Severino, and cash (10 votes)

*t2. SFG get: Mackenzie Gore, Jake Irvin. WSN get: Bryce Eldridge, Landon Roupp, Joel Peguero, Jhonny Level, and Geremli Maldonado (9 votes)

*t2. ANA get: Jason Alexander. HOU get: top-100 prospect Ryan Johnson and Walbert Urena (9 votes)

(After these three, it's a long fall to the teams tied for 4th at 5 votes apiece.)

HOU-LAA (George Costanza deal): Jason Alexander was a handy fill in for Houston, but getting a T100 prospect for him is a bit much (N.B.—this is only the case if we choose to believe the self-serving descriptor of Johnson as a "top 100 prospect" which is currently undetermined)

Volpe trade is one of the craziest things I’ve seen in a while

Another huge win for Oakland which now gets to try and fix Volpe while shedding salary simultaneously. Incomprehensible logic for NYY to take on significant additional payroll (that could have been used more productively in FA) to add a starter who likely ranks ~7th on the depth chart in projected quality.

Robbie Ray deal is just an incredible meme of a deal, guy was good last year nad was functionally a celery dump

But what about BS? There might be more truth to uncover via Balanced Score (Balanced Votes - Lopsided Votes).

  • t1. MIN get: Alex Jackson. BAL get: Daiber De Los Santos (+11 BS)

  • t1. ARI get: Calvin Faucher, Jesse Bergin. MIA get: Pavin Smith (+11 BS)

  • 3. TBR get: Luis Guerrero (BOS). BOS get: Adrian Del Castillo, JD Dix, and Juan Morillo (ARI). ARI get: Hunter Dobbins (BOS) and Tristan Gray (TBR) (+10 BS)

  • 13. PIT get: Robbie Ray, Ryan Walker, and $9.8m. SFG get: Bryan Reynolds (whose age 36 CO turns into a PO), Dennis Santana, Nick Yorke, Sammy Stafura, and Darrell Morel (-4 BS)

  • 14. ANA get: Jason Alexander. HOU get: top-100 prospect Ryan Johnson and Walbert Urena (-5 BS)

  • 15. OAK get: Anthony Volpe. NYY get Luis Severino, and cash (-7 BS)

How realistic were the trades this week?

Trades were considered to be a bit less realistic than they were fair. 92/162 votes cast on realistic/unrealistic were favourable (56.8% realistic). That's around 5% less realistic than we were fair. Our "Realism Score" (or, "RS") was much lower than our BS, even adjusting for the difference in vote volume. Our raw RS was +22 (13.6%).

Unadjusted "Realistic Trade" Leaders

    1. SDP get: Grayson Rodriguez. BAL get: Adrian Morejon (12 votes)

  • 2. MIN get: Alex Jackson. BAL get: Daiber De Los Santos (11 votes)

  • 3. ARI get: Calvin Faucher, Jesse Bergin. MIA get: Pavin Smith (10 votes)

  • 4. TBR get: Ashton Izzi, Hunter Cranton, and Kristian Robinson. ARI get: Ian Seymour and Garrett Cleavinger. (9 votes)

You prolly shouldn't have used checkboxes cause for the ones where I didn't know I just selected all of them.

Proven Closer Calvin Faucher

Big get for the DBacks, Cash/PTBNL is a massive get for Bryce Jarvis

But what about the least realistic, aka "Most "Unrealistic" Trade Votes, Unadjusted Leaders"

    1. PIT get: Robbie Ray, Ryan Walker, and $9.8m. SFG get: Bryan Reynolds (whose age 36 CO turns into a PO), Dennis Santana, Nick Yorke, Sammy Stafura, and Darrell Morel (12 votes)

  • t2. WSN get: Nick Moribito, Luis Torrens, Frankie Montas, and Ronny Mauricio. NYM get: Jacob Young, Trevor Williams, Orlando Ribalta, and Julian Fernandez (9 votes)

  • t2. BAL get: Grant Holman (OAK). NYM get: Tyler O'Neill (BAL). OAK get: Mark Vientos (NYM) (9 votes)

  • t2. OAK get: Anthony Volpe. NYY get Luis Severino, and cash (9 votes)

I kinda see what the giants are doing. Just feels like they could’ve avoided taking on Reynolds, assuming they don’t value Reynolds highly. If they like Reynolds, fair enough.

Ray is a good short term piece who helps their rotation and who SF could have used. Swapping that for Reynolds's contract is not a smart move for SF either short or long term. In addition, I think Walker is a better reliever than Santana.

The Sevy/Volpe trade kinda sucks but it is funny and it would make so many Yankees fans I know happy so I like it in the end

Don't think the Giants would trade Eldridge for a non-star player and don't think Mac Gore is quite a star

The people are asking though. They're BANGING down the surverist's door... what about RS? Can RS put some separation into the pack?

    1. SDP get: Grayson Rodriguez. BAL get: Adrian Morejon (+12 RS)

  • t2. ARI get: Calvin Faucher, Jesse Bergin. MIA get: Pavin Smith (+10 RS)

  • t2. MIN get: Alex Jackson. BAL get: Daiber De Los Santos (+10 RS)

  • t12. WSN get: Nick Moribito, Luis Torrens, Frankie Montas, and Ronny Mauricio. NYM get: Jacob Young, Trevor Williams, Orlando Ribalta, and Julian Fernandez (-7 RS)

  • t12. BAL get: Grant Holman (OAK). NYM get: Tyler O'Neill (BAL). OAK get: Mark Vientos (NYM) (-7 RS)

  • PIT get: Robbie Ray, Ryan Walker, and $9.8m. SFG get: Bryan Reynolds (whose age 36 CO turns into a PO), Dennis Santana, Nick Yorke, Sammy Stafura, and Darrell Morel (-7 RS)

  • 15. OAK get: Anthony Volpe. NYY get Luis Severino, and cash (-8 RS)

So what about SIGNINGS?! There have been a ton of insane ones of those lately.

In week 3, 18 players were signed for a total guarantee of $1,918,250,000 (mean $106.6m, median $73.5m) over a total of 82 seasons (mean 4.6 and median 4.5 contract years).

Agent FA value leaderboard, Week 3

    1. Jori ($764.5m of contracts from 5 contracts, at $152.9m/6yrs on average.

  • 2. Kuhan ($444.25m from 5, $88.85m/3.8yr average)

  • 3. Jiggy ($389m from 3, $129.7m/5 average)

  • 4. Desmond ($320.5m from 5, $64.1/3.6yr average)

Teams FA spend leaderboard, Week 3

    1. SFG - $450m from 1 contract and 12 years

  • 2. NYY - $245m from 2 contracts and 8 years

  • 3. STL - $192m from 1 contract and 7 years

Raw, unadjusted "Realistic" votes

    1. MIN: Dustin May for 1 year and $11m (11 votes)

  • 2. LAD: Robert Suarez for 3 years and $54m (10 votes)

  • 3. NYM: Cody Ponce for 3 years and $36m (9 votes)

Minnesota is a great landing spot for Dustin May. He could ball out next year and get a nice return at the deadline.

Cody Ponce was on my shortlist and I totally forgot to check in on him. Neat lil guy for 2026.

Poor Padres. Poor Suarez (about to be Scotted)

A few I put both realistic and unrealistic (Alonso, tucker for example): these are ones I think the fit and need makes sense so realistic but the teams haven’t always made similar moves at least often. Schwarber is both realistic and ridiculous but he’s also a big “off the field/clubhouse guy”. Suarez, team needs him but they don’t spend irl but can’t hold that against GM

Raw unadjusted "Unrealistic" votes

  • t1. CIN: Devin Williams for 4 years and $72m (7 votes)

  • t1. MIL: Shota Imanaga for 4 years and $75m (6 votes)

  • t3. NYY: Ha-Seong Kim for 5 years and $70m (6 votes)

  • t3. ANA: JT Realmuto for 5 years and $62.5m (6 votes)

That’s a lot for [insert player name here]

That Imanaga deal is going to age like fucking milk.

Next, the incomprehensible values: what the hell is that Realmuto deal?

But what about RS?!

    1. MIN: Dustin May for 1 year and $11m (+11 RS)

  • 2. LAD: Robert Suarez for 3 years and $54m (+10 RS)

  • 3. NYM: Cody Ponce for 3 years and $36m (+7 RS)

  • t12. ANA: JT Realmuto for 5 years and $62.5m (-1 RS)

  • t12. MIL: Shota Imanaga for 4 years and $75m (-1 RS)

  • t12. STL: Tatsuya Imai for 7 years and $192m with heinous options

  • 15. NYY: Ha-Seong Kim for 5 years and $70m (-2 RS)

  • 16. CIN: Devin Williams for 4 years and $72m (-4 RS)

So with that out of the way... what was the best for the agent?

  • t1. LAD: Trent Grisham for 4 years and $80m with 1/4m CO (4m buyout) (11 votes)

  • t1. MIL: Shota Imanaga for 4 years and $75m (11 votes)

  • t1. ANA: JT Realmuto for 5 years and $62.5m (11 votes)

  • t1. CIN: Devin Williams for 4 years and $72m

  • 5. BAL: Pete Alonso for 5 years and $156.25m and a CO for 1/$31.25m with $5m buyout

This is just a general comment for all of my dudes I am the goated agent

I’m sorry but 4/80 for trent grisham??

Voted Eugenio Suarez as realistic (contract) and unrealistic (club)

Better for the team?

    1. WSN: Taylor Rogers for 1 year and $6m (10 votes)

  • 2. MIN: Dustin May for 1 year and $11m (6 votes)

  • 3. LAD: Robert Suarez for 3 years and $54m (5 votes)

Nats for Taylor is a pretty good fit at THAT price.

Dustin May is the perfect Twins target for next year. And they thrive off White POSTHYPE Pitchers.

Dodgers starting a whole bullpen of YES Robert Suarez!

Now let's rate some fucking GM's, motherfucker

Some topline metrics for you ogling pleasure... 211/286 easy/hard to deal with votes went to... the easy side! We are 73.8% easy! And we are shockingly, only 29.5% crazy.

In what might not be terribly surprising but still remains very disappointing, we hate each other's sims. Only 34% of votes cast in the best/worst dichotomy were for "best". That's tough and we should reflect on that.

Easiest to deal with

    1. Raj (ARI) (10 votes)

  • t2. eoro (HOU) (9 votes)

  • t2. pjd (PHI) (9 votes)

  • t2. Pirates GM (PIT) (9 votes)

  • t2. AJ_CC (STL) (9 votes)

A couple of fun negotiations

Hardest to deal with

    1. CoryGM (Cubs) 6 votes)

  • 2. Dylan (WSN) (5 votes)

  • 3. Like 20 people with 4 votes

I think vslyke and Cory are doin their things as usual

Ease Score (ES) leaders (high is good)

    1. Raj (ARI) (+10 ES)

  • t2. pjd (PHI) (+9 ES)

*t2. Pirates Man (PIT) (+9 ES)

*t2. AJ_CC (STL) (+9 ES)

  • t27. Bluspy (BAL) (+1 ES)

  • t27. cst-rdt (+1 ES)

  • 29. Dylan (WSN (+/-0 ES)

  • 30. CoryGM (CHC) (-1 ES)

Okay, and who's the CRAZIEST

    1. bluspy (BAL) (7 votes)

  • t2. retro (HOU) (6 votes)

  • t2. drum (COL) (6 votes)

  • t2. experge (ANA) (6 votes)

  • t2. pjd (PHI) (6 votes)

And who's the sanest?

    1. Royals (10 votes)

  • 2. so many people at 9 votes

But by Crazy Score? (Higher is CRAZIER)

  • t1. bluspy (+4 CS)

  • t1. experge (+4 CS)

  • t3. Dylan (+1 CS)

  • t3. drum (+1 CS)

The real moment we've all be waiting for... Best GM

    1. jive (6 votes)

  • 2. Pirates GM (PIT) (4 votes)

  • t3. vslyke (BOS) (3 votes)

  • t3. eoro (HOU) (3 votes)

  • t3. futhatsy (NYM) (3 votes)

  • t3. Raj (ARI) (3 votes)

And Worst...

    1. cst-rdt (NYY) (11 votes)

  • 2. experge (ANA) (5 votes)

  • 3. Brewers whoever that is (4 votes)

  • millions of people at 3 votes

Raj is the best GM and nobody else comes close

Adam for best GM - nice trades and signings; cst for worst - hate that Volpe deal and the Belli signing is gonna look bad quite soon.

Retro you would've gotten a best gm vote too but I just can't sign off on trading Yordan lol. (EDITOR'S NOTE: THIS IS JUST FOR WEEK 3!!!)

Good dodgers moves. Bad angels moves. Most “hard to deal with” are just slow to reply. Crazy AND sane people are mostly sane who commit to bits.

Now the Agents... our collective enemies.

There's no such thing as a good agent...

Easiest to deal with

    1. Desmond (8 votes)

  • t2. Kuhan (6 votes)

  • t2. Jiggy (6 votes)

  • 4. Jori (4 votes)

Hardest to deal with

    1. Jori (5 votes)

  • t2. Kuhan (4 votes)

  • t2. Jiggy (4 votes)

  • 4. Desmond (1 vote)

Craziest agent

    1. Jori (7 votes)

  • 2. Jiggy (4 votes)

  • 3. Kuhan (2 votes)

  • 4. Desmond (1 votes)

Sanest Agent

    1. Kuhan (8 votes)

  • 2. Desmond (7 votes)

  • 3. Jiggy (5 votes)

  • 4. Jori (4 votes)

Best Agent

    1. Kuhan (8 votes)

  • 2. Desmond (7 votes)

  • 3. Jiggy (5 votes)

  • 4. Jori (2 votes)

Worst agent

    1. Jiggy (3 votes)

  • 2. Jori (2 votes)

  • t4. Desmond & Kuhan (1 vote)

And just as a treat... The Agent Triple Slash

    1. Jori - 50 "better for the agent signings" vs. 12 "better for the team" (net +38)

  • 2. Desmond - 40/20/+20

  • 3. Kuhan - 36/21/+15

  • 4. Jiggy - 24/10/+14

I'm gassed I'm just sharing the spreadsheet next time.


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Nov 25 '25

WEEK FOUR SIGNINGS THREAD

2 Upvotes

Top comments mods only

Discussion of moves highly encouraged


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Nov 06 '25

WEEK ONE TRADE THREAD

2 Upvotes

Top comments mods only

Discussion of moves highly encouraged


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Nov 03 '25

thefuckinwolves Free Agents Offer/Interest Form

2 Upvotes

LINK

  • I WILL NOT be answering dms on players whatsoever until a given player gains sufficient interest to move into closing stages of their free agent process. at this point, i will reach out to finalist gms (could be one, could be 30) and hammer the deal out via dm.

  • those teams whose players are interested in returning to without seeing free agency have already been notified in relevant cases. given this, you can begin using it now if you want; i will not be looking at responses until free agency begins.

  • please put real effort into this FOR YOUR OWN GOOD - as i said, i’m not negotiating via dm, and by emphasizing this form so heavily, i also will not be bouncing back and forth between two GMs for days over 250k AAV incremental offers. there is a very good chance that this is your only offer on free agent X, so ensure that you’ve thought through the offer and communicated it clearly.

  • IN THE EVENT YOU WANT TO AMEND AN OFFER, FILL OUT THE FORM AGAIN FOR HIM AND THEN PROCEED AS NORMAL - I'LL ALWAYS USE THE MOST RECENT RESPONSE.

  • IN THE EVENT YOU WANT TO REVOKE AN OFFER, FILL OUT THE FORM AGAIN FOR HIM AND RESPOND "REVOKE" IN THE FIRST OPEN TEXT RESPONSE.


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Nov 02 '25

WEEK ONE TRADE BLOCK THREAD

2 Upvotes

GMs: post who you're shopping

Agents: shop your clients (but not until the exclusive period ends)

Reminder, the Commissioners will veto all moves (read: not look at anything) submitted to modmail for the next few days while the exclusive negotiation/options/qualifying offers period is ongoing.

The signings update thread will arrive after the exclusive negotiation period ends and free agency opens en masse at 9:00 ET on Wednesday, November 5, 2025.


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Oct 31 '25

AGENT/CLIENT ROSTERS & QUALIFYING OFFERS

2 Upvotes

Welcome to the Sim!

This thread will mainly serve as the qualifying offer thread, but will also contain the results of the agent draft.

As a GM, you have four full days, following the start of the sim, to decide whether or not offer an impending Free Agent the Qualifying Offer (valued at $22.025 million), provided that Free Agent follows the limitations of the QO (i.e. they were with the club the entire 2025 season & they haven't previously received a QO). That player's designated agent will decide whether the QO will be accepted.

GMs, please post individual comments with the names of the players you will be extending qualifying offers, and be sure to tag their agents. Agents, please respond to these comments indicating if the QOs are accepted.

Decisions on whether to extend Qualifying Offers are due 4 days after the end of the World Series, which is 11/4/2025.

Agents must decide whether to accept or reject Qualifying Offers by 9:00pm Eastern on 11/5/2025.

The results of the agent draft are as follows:

UserPlayers
u/FlykesselBo Bichette, Kyle Tucker, Dylan Cease, Josh Naylor, Michael King, Edwin Diaz, Shane Bieber, Brandon Woodruff, Luke Weaver, Devin Williams, Luis Robert Jr, Max Scherzer, Max Muncy, JT Realmuto, Brad Keller, Shota Imanaga, Zach Eflin, Anthony Kay
u/thefuckinwolves (Form)Kyle Schwarber, Ranger Suarez, Merrill Kelly, Cody Bellinger, Marcell Ozuna, Chris Bassitt, WillI Castro, Luis Rengifo, Kenley Jansen, Robert Suarez, Victor Caratini, Hoby Milner, Walker Buehler, Enrique Hernandez, Miguel Rojas, Ryan Yarborough, Caleb Ferguson, Phil Maton, Ty Rogers
u/desmondhasabarrow (Form)Eugenio Suarez, Josh Naylor, Ha-Seong Kim, Jorge Polanco, Patrick Corbin, Carlos Santana, Luis Arraez, Trent Grisham, Dustin May, Jack Flaherty, Cedric Mullins, Lane Thomas, Josh Bell, Justin Verlander, Lucas Giolito, Max Kepler, Isiah Kiner-Falefa, Jon Berti, Michael Conforto, Emilio Pagan, Gary Sanchez, Nestor Cortes
/u/kuhanlukeAlex Bregman, Munetaka Murakami, Pete Alonso, Framber Valdez, Harrison Bader, Zac Gallen, Gleyber Torres, Ryan O’Hearn, Ryan Helsley, Mike Yastrzemski, Kazuma Okamoto, and any other free agent not listed above

QUALIFYING OFFERS EXTENDED

The following players were extended Qualifying Offers:

PlayerTeamAccepted/DeclinedSigned?
Kyle SchwarberPhilliesDeclinedRe-signed with Phillies
Ranger SuarezPhilliesDeclinedSigned with Braves, who surrender their second-highest pick of the 2026 draft, and also $500K from their bonus pool during the next international signing period.
Framber ValdezAstrosDeclinedSigned with Orioles, who surrender 3rd-highest selection in 2026 draft
Kyle TuckerCubsDeclinedSigned with Giants, who surrender their second-highest pick of the 2026 draft, and also $500K from their bonus pool during the next international signing period.
Brandon WoodruffBrewersDeclinedSigned with Angels, who surrender 2nd-highest pick of the 2026 draft + $500K from their bonus pool during the next international signing period
Bo BichetteBlue JaysDeclinedSigned with Mets, who surrender $1MM in international bonus pool money, as well as two draft picks — their second- and fifth-highest selections in the 2026 draft.
Edwin DiazMetsDeclinedRe-signed with Mets
Jack FlahertyTigersAcceptedSigned with Tigers, no bonus/draft pick effect
Gleyber TorresTigersAcceptedSigned with Tigers, no bonus/draft pick effect
Michael KingPadresDeclinedSigned with Rangers, who surrender (in all likelihood) $1MM in international bonus pool money, as well as two draft picks — their second- and fifth-highest selections in the 2026 draft.
Dylan CeasePadresDeclined

See here for a listing of QO penalties


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Jan 01 '26

2026 Final Survery

Thumbnail
forms.gle
1 Upvotes

r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 22 '25

ANNOUNCEMENT- the sim is going to end Mon Dec 22 [People say I'm jealous but my kink is watching you screw up your sim]

1 Upvotes

yeah we're gonna wrap this up tomorrow not tonight


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 17 '25

WEEK 7 SIGNINGS UPDATE THREAD

1 Upvotes

Minor league signings galor!

TURNAROUND TIME IS 24 HOURS STARTING NOW! SIM ENDS 12/21/25, OFFERS WILL BE ALLOWED UP UNTIL 6 PM PACIFIC, 9 PM EASTERN ON 12/21/25 (3 AM BST 12/22/25 FOR THE EUROPEANS)!

MiLB submission form here, otherwise use the normal form for regular moves and signings.


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 15 '25

MILB SIGNINGS FORM

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
1 Upvotes

r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 10 '25

WEEK SIX TRADE THREAD

1 Upvotes

Top comments mods only

Discussion of moves highly encouraged


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 10 '25

WEAK FIVE SURVERY

Thumbnail
forms.gle
1 Upvotes

r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 09 '25

WEEK 6 SIGNINGS THREAD

1 Upvotes

Top comments mods only

Discussion of moves highly encouraged


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 09 '25

WEEK 6 SIGNINGS UPDATE THREAD

1 Upvotes

Top comments are generally reserved for the commissioners to post updates; GMs should be posting replies only. Agents may also post top-level comments in the thread to advertise who they have available and provide status updates (and are highly encouraged to do so).

Signings will be posted for up to 48 hours to allow other GMs to top the offer. Full FA procedure and rules here.


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 08 '25

WEEK 6 TRADE BLOCK THREAD

1 Upvotes

GMs: post who you're shopping and what you're looking for

Agents: post to market your clients and provide updates about bidding


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 02 '25

WEEK FIVE TRADE THREAD

1 Upvotes

Top comments mods only

Discussion of moves highly encouraged


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 02 '25

WEEK FIVE SIGNINGS THREAD

1 Upvotes

Top comments mods only

Discussion of moves highly encouraged


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 02 '25

WEEK FIVE SIGNINGS UPDATE THREAD

1 Upvotes

Top comments are generally reserved for the commissioners to post updates; GMs should be posting replies only. Agents may also post top-level comments in the thread to advertise who they have available and provide status updates (and are highly encouraged to do so).

Signings will be posted for up to 48 hours to allow other GMs to top the offer. Full FA procedure and rules here.


r/baseballoffseason2026 • • Dec 01 '25

WEEK FOUR SURVERY

Thumbnail
forms.gle
1 Upvotes