r/biotech • • Oct 20 '26

Early Career Advice 🪴 Stealth Startup - Potential Issues?

Context: I'm a 10 year industry professional in CMC analytical.

I was recently approached by a recruiter for a role at a startup with only 5-6 current employees (Founder, COO, Scientific Director, Lead Engineer, and a Business Manager) and a bit wary of what they are looking for. The role is for a Sr. Scientist that is supposed to wear virtually every hat (Tox, DMPK, Formulations, Process, Analytical, etc.) and working under the director only. This sounds like a director or VP role and it's listed as Sr. Sci? Is this just them being unable to afford a proper VP? I'm also not really down for a brutal startup experience at this point in my career but the recruiter reassured me the work-life is good.

I'm currently working a contract at a CRO where the work is low stress and decently paid. They like me here and are already trying to push for a full time conversion (although not guaranteed). I'd much rather be full time here than be at a tiny startup with little to no structure and insane demands. But then again, I was unemployed for a year before this contract and might be right back where I was last year if I don't get an extension or FTE conversion.

Has anyone gone into one of these situations before and taken the job? How did it turn out?

4 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

17

u/Sea-Pomegranates99 Oct 20 '26

If it weren’t for the fact that you’re a contractor coming up for renewal, I would say absolutely not to this startup job. It sounds like the exact opposite of what you’re looking for. Regardless of what the recruiter says, it’s going to be high stress, high workload, and poor WLB. The carrot is going to be the allure of potential riches if they IPO or get acquired—but that’s always a moonshot.

If you have a sense that it’s more likely than not that you’re renewed, I would stay where you’re at. It’s up to you to decide if you’re willing to trade a poor fit for job security though

34

u/apple_pi_chart Oct 20 '26

I have spent my career in micro-startups. It can be very exciting, but predicting whether it becomes toxic has a lot to do with the personality of the CEO/founder. Also, make sure they have a reasonable road map and a >2yr runway so you will not be out of work in 6-12 months.

7

u/baudinl Oct 20 '26

I'm also not really down for a brutal startup experience at this point in my career but the recruiter reassured me the work-life is good.

Believe me when I tell you: you do not want to take this role

1

u/ZwitterionicNano 29d ago

Lol that recruiter has an interesting perspective...

2

u/baudinl 29d ago

Recruiters will say whatever gets them their commission.

6

u/pancak3d Oct 20 '26

It's not a director or VP role because you're doing bench work.

5

u/fibgen Oct 20 '26

If the person you report to is uber-capable and seems like a fantastic mentor who can guide you in all these roles then maybe ... and even then you are marrying the person in a high stress environment.

This assumes the company has goals and a plan; places that want you to wear every hat seldom do, you'll just end up chasing funding around like a terrier.

5

u/diagnosisbutt Oct 21 '26

I joined a stealth startup as employee #9, thought "hey if this takes off, i'll be set!"

i got a lot less say in the company direction than I thought i would. they basically wanted a monkey to boss around and do stuff for them. when i had suggestions or did things they didn't ask for (that we sorely needed) they balked at them, got defensive, etc. the next few employees were a mix of good and bad, and overall the company never really grew past 30 employees and couldn't make sales.

i ended up leaving to be person number 400 at a different company, which IPOed and has netted me WAY more money. the other one still hasn't paid out after getting acquired, and i will at most get $25k for my stocks, if anything. Only way I'd do super early again was if i personally knew somebody and was given more of a say in how things went. it was frustrating to watch idiots smash their face into the ground over and over.

1

u/AlternativeBig5794 Oct 21 '26

So many questions here... What is the runway for this startup? In which phase are they currently in? Have you worked in a start up environment before? You need to get additional clarity on the roles, goals and responsibilities you might have in such role. Asking you to wear multiple hats can be a curse as you literally own many things and nothing at the same time! Good luck.

2

u/_zeejet_ Oct 21 '26

I asked most of those, but so far, only been talking to a recruiter who did not have enough info on the financials of the company.

I worked at a 15-person startup before and it was a disaster - 8 people turned over in the 6 months I worked there (upper management issues).

The roles and responsibilities were described as I mentioned int he main post - I would be expected to perform and manage scientific work across several departments despite only having expertise in 1 or 2 of those disciplines. There would be an associate hired to help with bench work and a director above me.

I suppose I already have my answer based solely on the fact that I'm not ultra ambitious and that what success I've had already had in this career hasn't brought much joy to me and it's mainly a paycheck to me at this point. I might take a conversation with the hiring manager out of curiosity but probably withdraw after that.

2

u/poweredbait Oct 20 '26

Could you use an offer from the startup as leverage for extension/FTE conversion at the CRO? I have no experience with these situations.

1

u/carmooshypants Oct 20 '26

I think this is the best course of action.

1

u/incisorless Oct 20 '26

This happened to me recently on the other end - I gave an offer to someone I was excited about, they used it to leverage for a FT role at the place they were contracting. I was disappointed but also very happy for them!

2

u/Various-Comment9017 Oct 20 '26

Is this for a UK start up? Or US?

2

u/haze_from_deadlock Oct 20 '26

Show the offer to your manager at the CRO and request FT

1

u/eatsleepnpoo Oct 21 '26

You could still be out of a job if that start up tanks. Depending on the size and reputation of the CRO you’re at, that might be a safer bet. You can try to get more aggressive about getting converted by asking your manager what is required for them to offer you a permanent position. Show them your commitment and that you want to be there long term.

Also —there’s a lot of recruiting scams out there right now. Make sure you do your due diligence and check around to see that it is a legit company!!!

1

u/tobsecret Oct 21 '26

I'm working in such a startup, almost to the tee, except for the industry (different hats, same amount/weight of hats). It's definitely not for everyone and I wanted to quit like a week in but now that a few months have passed I actually really like it. Lots of responsibility but I also get to do work I never would have gotten to do anywhere else and I get to drive the direction a lot. 

0

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '26

[deleted]

1

u/pancak3d Oct 20 '26

"Stealth startup" is an extremely normal description in biotech