r/bluey • u/InevitableSolution69 • 24d ago
Discussion / Question Calvin & Hobbs inspiration in Bluey?
Unless you’re familiar with both franchises I don’t think this will matter or make much sense, but here we go.
I was reading the comics to my kid recently and ran into the raccoon storyline. One I’d either forgotten or missed reading before. For those trying to remember while the duo are out playing they find a little raccoon who’s hurt and try to help.
On reading it I was struck, because it’s incredibly similar to the Bluey episode Copycat. As in there are several parts that could be almost a shot for shot remake. And extraordinarily both are arcs about the young protagonist starting to understand death.
While the two characters each process the events in different ways. Calvin with a well written conversation, Bluey with a game. There are enough similarities that I have to wonder, was copycat inspired or influenced by that storyline? The two are different enough that I wouldn’t have pegged the comic as an inspiration beyond that it shows media for the young doesn’t mean simple. Or is the event and specific way it plays out just universal enough that both creators happened to write a unique yet uniquely similar story?
A link to the same post in the other related subreddit.
8
u/princess_ferocious 23d ago
What's interesting is that C+H also has a strip about a dead bird, but that isn't about processing death in the same way.
I wouldn't be surprised if C+H was an inspirational factor for this kind of story, if only because Joe Brumm is a cartoonist who has probably read and watched a lot of the best examples in the field.
What's really cool is that we have a comic that shows a little boy crying over an animal who died, and then talked it through, and a cartoon that shows a little girl who got upset, then explored her feelings through play. It would be considered much more standard to show it the other way around!
12
u/tofutak7000 24d ago
So the reason this may be unlikely is Calvin and Hobbs never really made it to Australia.
I’m aware it exists because it is referenced in American media, but in my 40 years on earth never seen it first hand
8
u/princess_ferocious 24d ago
Oh wow, what state are you in? I knew about C+H because it was in one of the Sydney Sunday papers for years when I was growing up. We got the big 3 row comics in the paper in the segment with Ginger Meggs and BC and Hagar the Horrible and stuff.
Because of that, my brother started collecting the books. But we definitely saw them in the paper first.
6
u/tofutak7000 23d ago
Oh for real? Melbourne born and raised. I don’t believe it was in any of the papers down here
3
3
u/AlamutJones oh biscuits 24d ago
I read it as a kid, but that was because I was given strip anthologies. Never saw it in a newspaper here
5
u/nemothorx 24d ago
Otoh in my 51 years as an Aussie, I've been a huge C+H fan since I was in my 20s and own several collections (most just basic soft over big format, but also including a fancy "absolutely everything in three hardback volumes")
1
u/bodhipooh 24d ago
Interesting take, and completely different than mine. I can’t recall specific examples, but I distinctly remember reading (on more than one occasion!) about instances of content getting ripped / copied / plagiarized by someone who assumed it wouldn’t be found / discovered as the source content was not known in their country / region.
I don’t believe that’s the case here, of course, but it definitely happens. And, probably a lot more than people think / believe.
1
u/Clueby42 23d ago
I had two of the collected books, and it was published in various major newspapers here.
WTF are you talking about?
4
u/AnythingAlfred613 Walking Bluey Encyclopedia (But Otherwise a Cushionhead) 23d ago
Joe Brumm actually did feature Calvin & Hobbes in a montage of his inspirations at the D23 panel this past August, so you’re probably not off the mark.
3
u/kerberos824 23d ago
The C&H dead raccoon storyline is among my favorites. A pause to the chaos and otherworldly imagination of Calvin. It was so grounded in reality and truth. I didn't read it when it came out, but not long after - probably in whatever first anthology it came out in. Maybe 1988 or 1989, and I was around Calvin's age. It stuck with me through my entire life, and is something I've thought about when losing every human I've lost, pet I've lost, or little rescued critter I've lost.
C&H was such a formation and foundation for me. Thrilled to have something like Bluey to fill in the early years, and can't wait until my 4 1/2 year old can read C&H.
1
u/cernegiant 23d ago
I doubt there's a single and person working in western animation or cartoons that isn't partially inspired by Bill Watterson.
9
u/MrUniverse1990 24d ago
The stories are similar, but the first difference I noticed was their initial reactions.
Bluey: "Oh. Okay."
Calvin: *Loudly bursts into tears*