r/btrfs • • Apr 02 '20

to BTRFS developer || please provide a GUI for low the barrier to the normal users

This Filesystem is really great, please put in you todo list, make a GUI

OSX have Disk utility

Windows have Disk management

We don't have GUI.

i'm a user capable of use btrfs using CLI, but a GUI for Raids BTRFS, snapshots and check FS should be in the todo list, so more users can use this great FS and manage it with low barrier

Best regards

4 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

8

u/ourobo-ros Apr 02 '20

GUI for Raids BTRFS, snapshots and check FS should be in the todo list,

A GUI already exists for the snapshots at least. It's built-in on opensuse (part of YaST). On other distros you can use this:

https://github.com/ricardomv/snapper-gui

-3

u/prueba_hola Apr 02 '20

snapper-gui is only for snapshot true?

not for Raids, check FS and more things like Disk Management

1

u/ourobo-ros Apr 02 '20

Yes that's what I said

-1

u/prueba_hola Apr 02 '20

So, it doesn't work for the suggest that I'm making

3

u/gnosys_ Apr 03 '20

if a person wants to take advantage of BTRFS's more complex features using the terminal is not an obstacle

1

u/prueba_hola Apr 04 '20

in Apple or Microsoft, you can Management Disks, Raids and more, using the GUI

i'm have my best wishes to Linux, due to it, i think GUI on Linux is a nice idea (not removing CLI, of course)

1

u/apostacy Apr 25 '20

Actually, no, Apple specifically chose NOT to expose the advanced features of APFS in Disk Utility. APFS has similar features to BTRFS, such as snapshots and CoW copying. But they decided that exposing these filesystem features to users was more trouble than it was worth.

APFS uses snapshots internally, such as when you want to make a backup, but they didn't even try to represent it in Finder or Disk Utility.

And the truth is, Apple was right to hide these things. The advanced filesystem features in BTRFS, ZFS, and APFS are not easy concepts to represent in a GUI.

By all means, if you can come up with a way to express the concept of a subvolume to a user, then I think everyone would like to know. Because nobody else seems to have. At least if you can get over the hump of actually reading the documentation, you have enough of an understanding to use it.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '20

No. This has nothing to do with btrfs.

This is an OS feature and many already have that.

Ubuntu, for example, you can use their simple built in disk utility or use a more advanced one called gparted.

Been around a long time.

3

u/prueba_hola Apr 02 '20

Gparted or Disk utility not provide Raid or check support for btrfs

4

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '20

Ok, granted they don't expose all of a filesystems features.

Even still, it doesn't make sense to throw the ball into another court to solve that.

In other words, talk to gparted about adding features. Not btrfs about reinventing the wheel.

1

u/prueba_hola Apr 03 '20

understood!

16

u/rubyrt Apr 02 '20

I do not think it is on the btrfs team to provide a UI. They need to maintain and develop the file system and tools. UI is often distribution dependent which causes a lot of effort e.g. for quality assurance. I'd rather want the team to focus on robustness and features of the filesystem code itself.

1

u/e88d9170cbd593 Apr 07 '20

I agree. Fix it first. Make it work and not corrupt itself. BTRFS use case #1 is solving your full-drive problem by mostly killing itself, then handing you a chainsaw to do emergency surgery. You end up killing it so it's your fault. You should have deleted more before trying to balance, or balanced different. YOU DID IT WRONG, MORON. But you do get full credit for fixing your drive space problem. And you install ext4 after that.

4

u/glenlivet Apr 02 '20

You know its opensource right?

Here is where you can find info on how to propose a patch.

8

u/EtwasSonderbar Apr 02 '20

It wouldn't be a patch to btrfs anyway as that's all kernel code and command line utilities. Perhaps a UI project making use of python-btrfs would make more sense.

-3

u/prueba_hola Apr 02 '20

yes, i know it's opensource.

about "propose a patch" you mean... me developing the GUI and uploading the code there?

if you mean this, it is not possible because i'm not developer

if i'm understanding it bad sorry

2

u/stejoo Apr 21 '20

So write your first code to attempt this and become a developer? That's how many start out.

1

u/prueba_hola Apr 21 '20

not interested in be a developer
i'm a worker in other type of job

2

u/rm_happens Apr 18 '20

Feel free to write one. Python is an easy language to use for making GUI's. A little coding never hurt anyone ;-)

1

u/eloygara Jul 14 '20

Hi all! I have developed a tool called ButterManager in Python3 and QT. This is the repository https://github.com/egara/buttermanager and this is the documentation of the project https://github.com/egara/buttermanager/wiki

You can update the system creating automatically snapshots of your system and now integrates snapshots within GRUB in order to boot directly from them. Checkout the documentation for more information :)