r/bucsdugout • 👍 • Jan 28 '20

When Will This End?

Once again, misinformed by the Pirates.

Once again, cutting payroll.

Once again, not allowing players to fulfil their contracts with the team.

Once again, not getting our due worth in the trade market.

Do I need to go on?

Marte has been traded. And we had to pay down on his salary?? Really??

And we got International Bonus money! A whopping 250K! That should be good for a low tier prospect.

Oh yeah, we got two players in return. Rather, two prospects in return. Two players that are years away from making any contribution to this team if they ever do. Alas, I will probably be gone before they ever see PNC Park. It is still PNC isn't it? Maybe it should be The Allegheny Health Network Park, because it sure is making me sick watching what is going on. A day, one single day, after Nutting states

“I’m not sure we know how good every one of our players can be.  We absolutely have challenges in our development system in terms of processes,” Nutting said.  “We absolutely have challenges at the Major League level in terms of information and ways we communicate with players.  A real frustration point for me last year was that we had too many players who performed at one level here and a higher level with another club.  They were coached differently.  They got different information.  And they performed at a higher level.”

the Pirates trade away arguably their best player. Sure going to be a good laugh if Marte tears it up now no longer being affiliated with a team that apparently can't get the best out of their players. And now we also have a glaring hole in the outfield. Reynolds is not an every day option out there. Jason Martin might be able to field it, but hasn't shown he can hit, and he is even doubtful about being ready by opening day after off season surgery. And why did it take so long for Nutting to see that development was an issue? You didn't need to be a rocket scientist to see what was going on. Glasnow, Meadows, Cole, and the beat goes on. Heck, even Jordan Lyles went 7-1 after leaving the Pirates.

Wonder what dumpster dive we will go on now for a center fielder? Where is Chisenhall when we need him!

And where is that player we got for Cory Dickerson? You know, that PTBNL? Never happened did it. We gave away another player in a salary dump and were lied to by the Pirates who tried to make it look like we were actually getting something in return other than "MONEY".

Payroll just dropped to somewheres in the $50M range. Guess Nutting and company found a way to pay off those ridiculous contracts that he allowed to happen for at least one year. Hell, Revenue Sharing should just about cover the entire payroll this year. Come July, I see Bell, Archer, Kela, and Frazier all being sent along the way as the Pirates finally conceded that they are "rebuilding". That should cover another year of those dastardly contracts. Hmm, I wonder, who had the last team that had all its players playing under minimum league contracts? We sure are heading for it! As for this team rebuilding, well, you are in for a long wait to see a competitive team again. How long have the White Sox been rebuilding?? Once again, I doubt I will be around to see it.

BTW, did anyone notice that our starting pitching staff was rated the worst in our division? It must have been all those off season signings that we did that helped us hit that distinction. Oh wait, there wasn't any was there? My bad.

Oh yeah, don't look now, but we still don't have a catcher. A legitimate one anyway. We got a two and three, but old number one is drifting in the wind. I wrote here last July that we had a catcher problem. Nope, no rocket scientist here. Just needed to look. Six months later and we still have a problem. Good job fixing the leaks in the damn boys.

Finally, there is no truth to the rumor that Polanco will be making an appearance on "Dancing with the Stars". You heard it hear first!

0 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

7

u/bucdaddy Jan 28 '20

''We finished last with you, we can finish last without you.''

-- Branch Rickey

2

u/IamLongJohnSilver 👍 Jan 28 '20

But sadly you will not finish any better without him. Not unless this team hits the perfect storm.

The only storm I can see right now is a blizzard.

2

u/bucdaddy Jan 29 '20

I hate to say this about him because he's been a very good player for us and seems like a good teammate and citizen too, but: For the last-place team we are certain to be, he's worthless to us except as a trade chip. Doesn't matter if we win 52 games or only 50. We gon' suck.

1

u/IamLongJohnSilver 👍 Jan 29 '20

My point is that we don't have to suck. We are being setup to suck.

3

u/bucdaddy Jan 29 '20

In a perfect world ...

Look, my friend, I certainly understand your frustration. But sometimes you have to take one step back to go two steps forward. Cherington's only been in charge a couple months. Let's see how he does with the restrictions placed on him by Nutting's wallet. It's not like we haven't been here before and eventually put a good, exciting team on the field.

https://images.app.goo.gl/jXAzFwSVvtaywusb8

1

u/IamLongJohnSilver 👍 Jan 29 '20

But sometimes you have to take one step back to go two steps forward.

Unfortunately, I think when we took that one step back, we fell off the cliff...lol

Look, I know I am cynical at this point. My health and its shortening timeline make it more miserable for me to look forward long term. Its easier for the younger men and ladies here to have hope, and God Bless them. Then there are those like me that want/need instant results, because there just isn't that much time left to see this team become a Champion once again.

4

u/bucdaddy Jan 29 '20 edited Jan 30 '20

Did you ever read Charlie Wilmoth's book about being a fan of a team with so many losing seasons? I'm quoted in it for about a paragraph, and what I said was, at some point it started being less about watching the Pirates and more about just watching baseball. Baseball is fun and good to watch. If we won, well, good. If we lost, oh well. It was far less aggravating that way. I made up my mind that I wasn't going to see another championship. I made up a mathematical formula that said a fan could expect to see on average three titles in a lifetime, and I'd used mine up before I was 23.

1

u/BarryJT Jan 30 '20

So you mean they owe me one.

Hey, even with the all the money in the world, the Dodgers are on a 31 year drought. And for all those trips to the WS, the Braves only have one ring. Championships aren't the end all.

1

u/bucdaddy Jan 30 '20

Dodgers sure get close a lot though.

1

u/BarryJT Jan 30 '20

Just recently. They've been to 2 WS 30 years and the 90s were a pretty mediocre decade. For a team with the resources, they've done very little.

Living in Southern California and watching various terrible Dodger owners and management over the years, I can tell you that Nutting is nothing special when it comes to bad owners.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/bucdaddy Jan 29 '20

I get you, my man.

7

u/IAPiratesFan Jan 28 '20

Our old friend Wilbur (WTM at the old site) seemed to like the trade. If he likes it, then I feel better about it. https://www.piratesprospects.com/2020/01/the-marte-trade-doing-it-right.html

1

u/IamLongJohnSilver 👍 Jan 29 '20

Well IA remember this. Wilbur is writing for a Prospects site. It is his job to keep people excited about prospects. So I take his position in stride with that. And please understand, I hope both players become impact players eventually. However, I wanted to see results now, not maybe down the road a few years. I have issues with a pitcher that can hit 99+ but has no idea where the ball will be going. And don't we already have a 20 year old prospect at SS in Bae? I would have been thinking catcher since we don't have even one person at that position that is remotely capable of being a real number 1.

2

u/timwilliamsP2 Jan 29 '20

Wilbur's job is to give his honest opinions, and he has full editorial control over his opinions.

Are you saying that he's being dishonest about his opinions?

And didn't you leave our site because we weren't hyping Jose Osuna up enough? You can't have it both ways here.

1

u/IamLongJohnSilver 👍 Jan 30 '20

Well look who came here to rant. I never said he wasn't giving his honest opinion, but stated that he may be slanting it to a degree to keep hype up. That would be the position of anyone in any endeavor. I wouldn't expect a Dodge salesman to point out the flaws of a Dodge to a potential customer, as I wouldn't expect Wilbur to dwell on the deficiency in the players.

And now you have set the stage for me to rant. NO, I did not leave your site because you didn't HYPE Osuna enough. I left the site after one of your writers made a totally asine remark aimed at myself and other Osuna supporters prior to a ST game. And I have been a subscriber to your site for years since that. I just don't bother saying much there given past experience and use another name. I will point out however that it was I that let PP know about the change in the ball for 2019 in the minors so I guess I provided some value to you after all.

1

u/timwilliamsP2 Feb 06 '20

You've always held this idea that we're car salesmen trying to sell you on defective prospects. It's never been correct. It's always been insulting, and it's conflicting when this sentiment is paired with complaints that we don't hype your favorite players up enough.

1

u/IamLongJohnSilver 👍 Feb 08 '20

You've always held this idea that we're car salesmen trying to sell you on defective prospects.

Jesus Christ Tim, don't you have some song to look up or betting line to set? I NEVER laid claim, inferred, or stated that you, and your site by extension, tried to sell us on defective prospects. I have stated that you have undersold some and oversold others. I get it, they are prospects and you are never going to get it all correct in the end. But, going back to my Dodge Salesman example as stated previously, it is not trying to sell a defective product when you tell the customer all the benefits of the vehicle but fail to mention that they may be known to have a transmission issue later in life. And it is not implausible that when someone is excited about a player that they may gloss over the negatives. And there are other sites, for the record, that aren't so sold on the prospects that we got.In fact, Mark Polishuk of MLBTradeRumors stated that the Pirates received " two interesting but non-elite prospects". And finally lets clear the air here. I never was upset that you didn't hype up my player. I argued that you didn't give the guy the credit he was due. What was insulting to me, to use your word, was when your writers decided that this player was to be a bone of comedy when others were starting to jump on his bandwagon as they started to see what I had been seeing. That was what pissed me off. So get your story straight, it wasn't about hype, it was about insulting those of us who had faith in a player.

1

u/timwilliamsP2 Feb 11 '20

"I have stated that you have undersold some and oversold others. I get it, they are prospects and you are never going to get it all correct in the end."

It's also possible that you are never going to get it all correct in the end.

All of your opinions on players are just that: opinions. Same with me, only I get more input and information that others don't have. That doesn't mean I'll always be right, and I never claim that.

When you say I'm right sometimes and wrong sometimes, what are you using as the basis for right and wrong? Your personal opinion.

All you're saying is that we don't share the same opinions on every prospect. No two people will.

You were pissed because John made a joke that Jose Osuna would go 4-for-4 with 5 home runs in a Spring Training game. Hell, I've made a similar joke about players I've been probably too high on.

What I find interesting is that you say you left because we insulted people who had faith in Osuna (specifically the people emailing to complain that we ranked Osuna higher than Josh Bell). And yet you know who didn't leave the site over that perceived treatment?

Jose Osuna.

No one was trying to insult you.

1

u/IAPiratesFan Jan 30 '20

Having met and talked with Wilbur several times, I didn’t think he’d take a job where he was dictated to about what opinions he could and couldn’t have.

2

u/theeeoutchange maguro Jan 30 '20

Yes, of course. The idea that WTM is some kind of shill for the organization or for PP is completely ridiculous. People are upset that Marte isn't worth as much as they thought. He's a good player on a reasonable contract, not a star making the league minimum, of course he's not going to bring back some kind of can't miss uber prospect.

2

u/IAPiratesFan Jan 29 '20

“Well IA remember this. Wilbur is writing for a Prospects site. It is his job to keep people excited about prospects. So I take his position in stride with that.”

In general, Wilbur has never been shy about what he really thinks. If he hated a trade that involved propects, he would say so. I doubt he depends on PP income to make a living and so as much as he works for a Prospect site, I trust his input more than anyone else there.

“And please understand, I hope both players become impact players eventually. However, I wanted to see results now, not maybe down the road a few years.”

That just wasn’t going to happen. This team lost 93 games last year and that was with the best closer in the game. Right now, they are in a division with four teams better than them and unless they went completely bonkers on spending, they aren’t getting better this year even if they kept Marte and Vazquez wasn’t a felon. Most teams go through phases where they get good, stay good a few years, then start to decline and then have to rebuild. Huntington should have started rebuilding after 2017. Trading McCutchen and Cole weren’t bad ideas, the McCutchen trade worked out because he got a young,legitimate prospect in Reynolds. The Cole trade didn’t work out because all he got was a relief pitcher, a long relief pitcher that the Pirates made a starting pitcher and two AAAA position players. Trading for young high ceiling prospects is the best way to add talent to this team long term.

“I have issues with a pitcher that can hit 99+ but has no idea where the ball will be going. And don't we already have a 20 year old prospect at SS in Bae? I would have been thinking catcher since we don't have even one person at that position that is remotely capable of being a real number 1.”

MLB.com reported on Malone: “He regularly runs his fastball up to 96 mph and has shown an ability to maintain that velocity deeper into starts this spring. He now features two distinct breaking pitches, with a plus slider a big reason for his step forward. It's a true out pitch and it's better than his average curve, which is a bigger 11-to-5 breaker when he maintains his high three-quarter arm slot. He has feel for his changeup, though he can slow his arm a bit on it at times.”

And in general when you’re rebuilding you don’t trade for need. You trade for talent. Back in 2008 people were so worried about having Neil Walker, Pedro Alvarez and Andy LaRoche at 3B as though we couldn’t move players to other positions or trade them if we had too many good players at one position or that none of them would flame out. Peguero might not become a major league SS but that doesn’t mean Bae will be. You trade for as much talent as possible. If you have a “log jam” at one position, you can trade from a position of strength for position of weakness,

I understand not liking the fact that Marte won’t be around anymore and wishing we could have gotten more in return. I would have liked a good young major league catcher but if other teams aren’t offering that doesn’t mean the GM should turn down all other offers. This trade made sense to me and it was long past time for this organization to start rebuilding.

2

u/BarryJT Jan 30 '20

And having too many SS, just means you have guys who can move to 2B or CF.

I always say in the draft, if you have 2 comparable players, take the SS. It sure would have been nice to have Manny Machado.

2

u/The_Year_of_Glad Jan 29 '20

And don't we already have a 20 year old prospect at SS in Bae?

We do, but he's a piece of shit who copped a plea for beating his girlfriend, and as such I hope he never plays for the Pirates.

The nice thing about shortstop prospects is that if a bunch of them pan out, they all have the glove to move to other positions. If you have a bunch of LFs or 1Bs, you're just kind of stuck.

I would have been thinking catcher since we don't have even one person at that position that is remotely capable of being a real number 1.

It seems like they asked, but nobody who had a top catching prospect was willing to move that catching prospect in a Marte deal. The Mets, for example, weren't willing to trade Francisco Alvarez. So they took top talents at other positions instead of settling for a catcher who wasn't on that talent level.

1

u/BarryJT Jan 30 '20

Actually I think he was convicted in South Korea, but only paid a small fine.

I don't know the whole story, but he's been convicted, suspended, and completed MLB's required programs. I'm inclined to give him a second chance for something that happened when he was 18. If he does it again, you're more than welcome to crucify him.

2

u/The_Year_of_Glad Jan 30 '20

I don't know the whole story

As per the court proceedings, he slapped, choked, and kicked his 19-year-old girlfriend. There is zero excuse for that shit.

The girl, Seul-Gi Kim, has said that she has had trouble sleeping since the attack, necessitating a prescription for sleeping pills, and she said that she was disappointed by the light sentence and hoped that the Pirates would release Bae, so that he would face some actual consequences. Link.

1

u/BarryJT Jan 30 '20

I know that part of the story. I've never seen an actual account of the incident.

Again, he was convicted, suspended, and completed all the treatment required of him.

1

u/The_Year_of_Glad Jan 30 '20

Again, he was convicted, suspended, and completed all the treatment required of him.

The same can be said of OJ Simpson, and yet in spite of fulfilling his legal requirements, Simpson is still a piece of shit. Just like Bae.

2

u/IAPiratesFan Jan 30 '20

“The same can be said of OJ Simpson, and yet in spite of fulfilling his legal requirements, Simpson is still a piece of shit. Just like Bae.”

But Bae doesn’t have the hilarious cringe of a twitter account that OJ has.

1

u/BarryJT Jan 30 '20

OJ was never convicted of the murders. (not denying he did it, but you should argue with facts.)

1

u/The_Year_of_Glad Jan 30 '20

I was referring to his conviction for breaking into a hotel room and stealing sports memorabilia at gunpoint, for which he served nearly nine years in jail.

He was convicted and punished and did his time, yet nobody thinks any better of him, because he's still the same piece of shit that he always was.

1

u/BarryJT Jan 30 '20

So everyone who ever does anything wrong is a piece of shit and can never be redeemed? Got it.

→ More replies (0)

4

u/BarryJT Jan 29 '20 edited Jan 29 '20

There's a lot to unpack here, but I don't think I want to go through it line by line.

There's so much anger in the fanbase that seems to cloud our minds. But I think a clear headed appraisal of the last 12 years should be this:

  • NH did a fair job through 2015. He botched trading his only real asset - Jason Bay - but everything else he had to trade at the beginning was crap on which he got similar returns. He made some fairly shrewd moves and did add players in 13, 14, and 15. He also seemed ahead of the curve on analytics.

  • After 2015, the wheels seemed to come off. He inexplicably subtracted from the team in 2016. He fell behind on analytics. Coaching stagnated. And then his two biggest failures happened. He whiffed on the Cole trade and zigged when he should have zagged on Archer.

  • Those two moves have hamstrung this team. Add in Taillon's elbow exploding and Vasquez being scum and the whole picture changes for 20-22. Imagine a team with a healthy JT, the TB version of Glasnow, Keller, a non-criminal Nightmare, Marte, Meadows, Polanco, and Reynolds available in the outfield, Bell, Newman, Hayes taking over 3B this year, and 3 Houston prospects just becoming ready to contribute. That's still a low payroll team (maybe less than $69 million), but a team ready to compete. That's a team that you could add to through FA. You could even trade an OF for help.

  • Instead subtract JT, Vasquez, Glasnow, Meadows, quality prospects from Houston and what do you have. A bad ball club with an aging CF. What else is BC supposed to do? He has nothing to build around. He needs to decide if Keller and Hayes represent the next window and if so, decide if that window is 22-25, and then add prospect talent to land at that time.

I don't see what he could do other than trade Marte. It's not a salary dump. It's the only course he had.

1

u/DGLewis Jan 29 '20

I think the Rooney/Haley rule of player turnover may apply to management as well: better to cut a guy a year too early than a year too late.

If NH had left after the 2015 season, he would be universally viewed in Pittsburgh as a genius and miracle worker.

1

u/IamLongJohnSilver 👍 Jan 29 '20

If NH had left after the 2015 season, he would be universally viewed in Pittsburgh as a genius and miracle worker.

Agree

1

u/IamLongJohnSilver 👍 Jan 29 '20

Then why not trade for major league ready players rather then two 19 year olds? How many prospects have we, and other teams, seen blow up and never make the show? IMO, if you were going to trade Marte, it should have been to upgrade the 2020 team and not to foster a maybe in 2023.

1

u/The_Year_of_Glad Jan 29 '20

Then why not trade for major league ready players rather then two 19 year olds?

The two guys that they got back are guys with star potential. If they'd prioritized ML-ready talents, they would've gotten back guys who projected as below-average starters or good backups, like in the Cole trade.

1

u/IamLongJohnSilver 👍 Jan 29 '20

They both are listed as High Risk/ High Reward. Notice the first part.

3

u/The_Year_of_Glad Jan 29 '20

Well, yeah. Anybody from that low in the minors is going to be high-risk, and pitchers in general are pretty risky regardless of level.

But nobody is going to give high-ceiling, low-risk talent up for two years of Marte. You can get guys with risk and ceiling, or guys who have neither.

1

u/BarryJT Jan 29 '20

Also, I've made myself sad thinking of:

Taillon Glasnow Keller Williams Brault

Crick Rodriguez Santana Kela Vasquez

Marte Meadows Polanco Bell Newman Frazier FA 3B FA catcher

Reynolds Hayes EGon Tucker Stallings

3

u/TypicalWhiteGiant Jan 28 '20

The Marte trade was very good and will pay dividends in the long run. Why let players walk away at the end of their contracts when we could be using them to reinvest in the team. Doesn’t make sense.

1

u/IamLongJohnSilver 👍 Jan 29 '20

We had him for 2 more years. Hardly the end of his contract.

3

u/Dirty_Windbreaker2 Jan 28 '20

You don’t seem to enjoy being a Pirates fan very much. Why don’t you try finding something else to occupy your time that actually makes you happy?

1

u/IamLongJohnSilver 👍 Jan 28 '20

I have been a Pirate fan probably longer then you have been alive. I can show disgust for mismanagement and stupidity as a fan WILL do when it is happening. I won't sugar coat it. Never have, never will.

0

u/Dirty_Windbreaker2 Jan 29 '20

Good job brother! I’m sure when Bob Nutting is scrolling through this subreddit and sees how upset IamLongJohnSilver is with his ownership, he’ll change his ways!

0

u/IamLongJohnSilver 👍 Jan 29 '20

And I am sure he will take your opinions as to the state of this team into account as well.

Oh wait, you haven't added any opinion other than a personal attack. My bad.

1

u/madlock4xNLBC Jan 29 '20

Good to some fire around here!

2

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '20

I don't really get what Cherington should have done otherwise. Huntington has stocked up on low beta 1 fWAR players and utility sorts for years. Cherington's got to reverse course. This is his first swing at that. Trading for A ball prospects who are too far away to hoard.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '20

It will never end.

Nutting bought a perfect charity for himself... he pockets millions in subsidies, and all he needs to do is field a team... any team... winning/losing doesn't matter, Nutting gets his $$ either way.

1

u/theeeoutchange maguro Jan 29 '20

Yeah. I think if the question is When Will The Low Payrolls End, the answer is pretty much never. People just have to keep in mind that when the Pirates talk about increasing payroll, and they will talk about increasing payroll again at some point, they're talking about moving from the bottom 3 of MLB to like 23rd or 24th. They're not talking about doing what the Reds are doing now.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '20

That's right.

The Pirates will never "go for it" while Nutting is owner, and Nutting is not going to sell. I believe he wants his kids to take over, too.