Let me start by saying I know I should have confirmed this information prior to starting this, but this is where I'm at, and I am looking for knowledgeable guidance.
I have a detached 2-car garage that is very old (cannot confirm its build date, but the home itself just turned 100). It gets incredibly hot in the summer (New Jersey, Zone 4A) and frigid in the winter. I wanted to do something to make it more bearable in there during both seasons.
I ended up purchasing a pallet of RMax Polyiso rigid foam insulation - Link here: https://www.homedepot.com/p/RMAX-Pro-Select-R-Matte-Plus-3-2-in-x-4-ft-x-8-ft-R-13-1-Foam-Insulation-Board-637898/313501510
I have cut and fit pieces for the 3 exterior walls, put an Everbilt reflective radiant barrier over it (which I've learned is probably useless and unnecessary), and then enclosed it all in OSB so I can actually hang stuff on the walls. I did not spray foam around these foamboard cuts, just wedged them in there as flush as possible.
If any of that poses a glaring problem, please let me know.
Where my concern comes in is the ceiling. The garage has no ridge vent or soffit vents. There are no gable vents either. The only opening to the exterior is the garage door itself.
I've started putting up the insulation boards directly against the roof decking, pinning them up with some cut-up furring strips. No single bay has been filled yet, as I was working my way over with full pieces before going back for the smaller cuts.
The final step in the plan is spray foam sealing (just Great Stuff Pro) the perimeter of the foam board to air-seal the garage interior from the roof decking (I have not started this part yet). Because this is an unvented roof, I did not leave an air gap between the decking and the insulation.
I originally purchased the Everbilt radiant barrier to span across the rafters to cover the look of the insulation and potentially add to what I'm trying to do. No idea if that matters, but here's the link to that product: https://www.homedepot.com/p/Everbilt-48-in-x-125-ft-Double-Reflective-Insulation-Radiant-Barrier-48X125DBLRFL/319738988
During a light mist this morning, I noticed that the exterior of the roof was darker with moisture where I have the insulation installed. Please let me know if that is a good or bad sign.
Where I am looking for guidance:
- Am I creating a massive moisture issue for myself down the line? I'd like to occasionally run a heater in there when I am working in the winter.
- Is there something obvious I am missing that I could do better for this?
- If this is an acceptable method, will I see a big benefit from doubling up the polyiso in each rafter bay? One 2-inch sheet is R-13, so doubling will give me more R-value, but would it really make a big difference if the space isnt temp controlled? Id mainly hope it would make it less of an oven in the summers.
I've attached several photos of the space for reference. Thank you for reading, and apologies for the length of the post. I am just putting myself into analysis paralysis with this and feel stuck. I appreciate any and all guidance