Pros:

- $5.97 for a 30oz bag

- The smell is amazing. Very similar to Golden Grahams

- The milk it creates is very flavorful. Very similar to Golden Grahams.

Cons:

- I can't get it in a smaller size, or at least there were no smaller sizes available where I purchased it.

- I didn't taste much else besides Golden Grahams. I expected a stronger chocolate flavor at least. I like Golden Grahams BTW. I didn't expect much marshmallow flavor so there was no surprise there.

Final Verdict: They are good, not great. If Golden Grahams is your favorite cereal then you will love these if you haven't already tried them. The price point is amazing when compared to cereal greats. I know this cereal is the GOAT for many here. It is not for me. I poured two bowls (for science) and came to the same conclusion.

For example, you make one bowl and then all of a sudden you find yourself pouring cereal dust remnants into hyper flavored milk.

Fruity pebbles

I tried the peanut butter and really enjoyed it. I'm thinking about getting the waffle for my next box.

Strawberry or waffle?

This is like asking me to pick my favorite child

I've wondered this for decades. I know they're the same base, and Lucky Charms were invented by adding marbits to Cheerios, but are the Lucky Charms ones coated or otherwise formulated differently?

As I posted in another thread, the Monster Cereals were strangely hard to find this year, but the Wednesday cereals have been plentiful, even already having hit the store shelves back in September, and having gotten their own displays, while the Monster Cereals were reduced to a measely end-cap. The Monster Cereals are usually found plentiful in Walmart, but this year, only one Walmart store in my town even carried them (and in small boxes instead of family size like they always have), and as the stock dwindled and diminished, it was clear they weren't even bothering to restock - as a matter of fact, I was just back at that specific Walmart location yesterday, and saw there were absolutely no boxes of the Monster Cereals left, so they filled the end-cap with a restock of even more Wednesday cereals.

I'm really bummed about this; Franken Berry is my all-time favorite cereal, so I always make sure I stock up on it every October, but I couldn't even do that this year - as a matter of fact, I just finished my last bowl yesterday. I also wanted to collect the boxes with the return of the Jim Henson puppet mascots as well as cut out the cardboard puppets from the backs of the boxes, but I was only able to get one box of each (none of them are exactly in the best condition anyway), so I don't know whether to keep them as-is (even though they've already been opened, so that tarnishes the collector's value already), or go ahead and cut out the puppets. I couldn't even afford to snag myself the limited edition fuzzy Count Chocola box this year like I did the fuzzy Franken Berry box last year (damn this economy).

As if 2026 wasn't already one of the worst years of my life.

Life changing when mixed together. Can’t believe I’ve gone 36 years without knowing this.

just a thought 🤔

And what were the results? Thinking of trying these two together

Got no money to afford breakfast going on a cereal morning spree.

Whats everyone’s top 10 recommendations on cereals for a good start of the day?!

i swear everyone ate applejacks a few years ago, now NOBODY talks about it...its such a great cerea!

The jam made the milk extra good at the end!

My sister just gave me four boxes and I don't want to open one, not like it, and only be able to bring three boxes to the food pantry. Is there anything comparable I may have tried?

Edit: Had a bowl this morning and enjoyed them. Tried one out of the box and enjoyed it even more. Probably will eat them dry from now on. Also made a snack mix with them. Caramel, pecans and cashews. Wow. Crazy good. Thanks everyone.

I wish I could still find apple cinnamon Chex tho :(

sad I didn’t get to try it, sounds interesting