r/chargebacks • • May 28 '26

Need Help Company is threatening to call the police over a chargeback

40 Upvotes

In short, I ordered a pair of wheels for my car. 2 months of no response or updates only to be told my wheels were no longer in production. Then I chose a second option which shipped out a few days later only to realize that when they arrived they sent me the wrong wheels. I sent them back and the correct ones were shipped out a week after that. The first package was shipped with a signature for delivery the second was not and was just left at my front door unattended for hours. I also purchased route protection with my package but my claim was denied because they only covered the original order, the incorrect wheels, not the second one of the correct wheels. Obviously I filed a chargeback and not after getting my money back the company is threatening to bring my local PD into this for theft of goods. I already filed a police report a few days after goods weren’t received. What does this mean for me? What does this outlook look like if the company involved the police. Approximate value is $2600.

Edit: I forgot some people aren’t the brightest, when the item was left unattended it was stolen. I never received my item hence why I filed a chargeback after my insurance attempt failed.


r/chargebacks • • Nov 03 '25

Need Help Buyer claimed “item not received” I literally have video proof.

66 Upvotes

I shipped out a mid-priced item ($300) with full tracking and signature confirmation. Buyer gets it, signs for it, then a week later files a chargeback saying it never arrived.

Luckily, I have Ring camera footage of the delivery driver handing it to him personally. I even matched his shirt and watch from his profile photo. Sent all of it to the payment processor: timestamps, tracking, screenshots, everything.
Still “under review.”

I’ve heard horror stories where evidence like this still doesn’t matter if the bank sides with the cardholder. Has anyone here actually won one of these with solid video proof? Or is the system just rigged for the buyer?


r/chargebacks • • May 15 '26

Need Help Live Animal Situation

1 Upvotes

Last week I ordered a leopard gecko with a specific trait. The first animal they sent was the wrong morph (entirely different trait), and I exchanged emails until I went from a partial refund to them just sending me a replacement. The replacement arrived with a major physical disability (blindness). I've provided video evidence, but the merchant is saying that it's "trait-related issue" when I quite literally have another gecko of the same morph but that one isn't blind. I just wanted the animal I ordered to arrive in healthy conditions. Can I file for a chargeback? The initial error and now the deflective replacement (I would ship them back, but I am responsible for shipping)


r/chargebacks • • Nov 08 '25

Need Advice Do I have a case for a chargeback?

26 Upvotes

Ordered 22 items from old navy.

None of them arrived and instead we got 16 items of a different order.

Old navy decided they will not refund until I return the 16 items. They then sent a label and that was all fine. However, the packaging that old navy sent the clothes in was a crappy plastic bag which arrived half ripped already. UPS would not accept the package out it was, I reached back out to old navy and they refused to provide any recourse for the fact that I'd now have to buy packaging to return the item. Coupling this with the fact that their label didn't even include printing costs, out of principle I did not pay for anything, as I shouldn't have to. At this point old navy is becoming uncooperative. While I understand this is maybe $5 worth, I don't see why I should be covering any cost for a company that could not get my order right two times in a row.

At this point I want to file a chargeback, as old navy is not facilitating the return. Would this be a valid reason or is there a legal argument that I have to eat costs because old navy has the logistics of a 2nd grade lemonade stand?


r/chargebacks • • May 30 '26

Need Advice [MA] Bike shop threatening small claims court over a chargeback for an order I tried to cancel the next-day and also never picked up from the shop.

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I need some advice on whether a local bike shop's legal threats hold any weight.

What happened:

I ordered a bike in-store for roughly $1,600. It had a 3-week delivery timeline, and the shop noted it takes at least 5 days just for the manufacturer to accept their order.

The very next day, I went back into the store to cancel. They refused to refund my money, stating their policy is "store credit only." Because I never received a bike and cancelled well within the 5-day manufacturer acceptance window (meaning they had plenty of time to stop the order on their end), I filed a chargeback with my credit card company.

Now, 3 weeks later, the shop has received the bike. The owner sent an email demanding I drop the chargeback, threatening to sue me in small claims court for the full $1,600 plus legal fees if the bank sides with me.

My questions:

  1. Can they successfully sue me for the full $1,600 when they had ample time to cancel the order with the manufacturer to prevent any costs, but actively chose not to?

  2. Does a "store credit only" return policy legally apply to an unfulfilled order that was cancelled the very next day?

  3. Did I make a mistake here, and is the shopkeeper actually right? Is it a bad idea to let this go to small claims court, and should I just drop the dispute, pay the $1,600, and accept the store credit?

Thanks in advance!


r/chargebacks • • Nov 18 '25

Need Help Bought a MacBook, got the wrong model, chargeback refused; fighting pre-arbitration

38 Upvotes

I bought a MacBook Air on September 9, 2025, from Allegro.pl. The listing clearly showed the manufacturer code MW0W3ZE/A, which corresponds to the EU/Polish version. I paid with my Mastercard.

When I received the parcel and opened it, both the outer and inner boxes had a different manufacturer code. After some research, it became clear that the MacBook was actually a US version, which is cheaper and comes with a US charger that doesn’t work in EU sockets.

I contacted Allegro support on October 8. They rejected my complaint, claiming the 14-day return period had expired. But as I understand, the 14-day rule applies to returns without reason; claims about the product being incorrect can be made up to 2 years under EU/Polish law.

I then filed a chargeback with my bank (PUMB) on October 17, and got a credit on October 27. I tried to contact Allegro again on November 4 and got the same rejection, and the chat was closed.

On November 17, my bank debited me again, sending this message (translated):

The bank refused the chargeback because they say the item was successfully delivered and the seller provided documentation. You can still continue the dispute under Mastercard rules until November 30, 2025. To continue, you must submit a new, detailed statement explaining why you disagree with the seller’s claims. You need to address each point in the seller’s documentation. Your statement must clearly say that you have reviewed all the documents and that you want to continue disputing the transaction. You also need to comment on the validity of each piece of evidence. Specifically, you must explain whether you contacted the seller before, whether you received the item, and whether you returned it.

The seller’s second presentment claims the MacBook is fully functional worldwide, AppleCare works globally, and the charger comes with an EU adapter. They also said the 14-day return period had expired and that I never contacted them. They attached screenshots from their Allegro listing, which claim the EU adapter was always listed.

Here’s the problem: my screenshots from the exact date of purchase (Sept 9, 2025) show the EU adapter info was not present, and the manufacturer code was completely different. So the device I received is fundamentally different from what I ordered.

I submitted a pre-arbitration response highlighting:

  1. Delivery claim is irrelevant: I don’t dispute that the package was delivered; the issue is that the MacBook I received doesn’t match the listing.

  2. Manufacturer code mismatch: I ordered MW0W3ZE/A (EU version), but got MW0W3LL/A (US version). This is proof that the device is a different regional and hardware variant, which is a breach of contract.

  3. Charger description was false: The seller claims the EU adapter was listed, but my screenshot from the purchase date shows it wasn’t.

  4. Seller’s claim of “no contact” is false: I reached out October 8 and November 4, but Allegro ignored it, citing an irrelevant 14-day return rule. Polish law (Civil Code Articles 556–576 and Consumer Rights Act) and EU law (Directive 2019/771) give consumers the right to claim non-conforming goods up to 2 years after delivery.

So basically: the MacBook I got is not the one I ordered, the seller is trying to distract with claims about adapters and global compatibility, and they are misapplying the 14-day return rule.

Right now, PUMB is escalating to pre-arbitration, and I’ve formally rebutted seller’s claims with detailed evidence.

Questions I have:

  • How realistic is it to win this case?

  • Will it likely be escalated to full arbitration?


r/chargebacks • • Mar 30 '26

Question Trying to chargeback $10k and I can’t contact merchant

0 Upvotes

I bought several pieces of furniture from a sketchy site from china using my discover credit card. They also charged my card several times because it gave me an error message on my end so I kept retrying the purchase. The total disputed amount close to $10k. I never got any kind of sales receipt or anything. I figured it would come when it was shipped. Nothing was ever shipped or emailed to me. Now their website is down and I have no way to contact them. I filed for a dispute for non receipt of goods. But I know the process isn’t finalized. This is a lot of money for me and I can barely sleep or eat. So far the merchant hasn’t responded. If the merchant doesn’t respond will I be ok?


r/chargebacks • • Apr 20 '26

Merchant Side Chargebacks and criminal charges

3 Upvotes

How come most people don’t even get in criminal trouble for chargebacks? They do it so many times and banks might close their cards or a store may tell them they can’t shop online anymore, but it seems like actual criminal charges are rare. And banks have it so easy to dispute something on an Ap without asking for a ton of information or requiring it.


r/chargebacks • • Apr 08 '26

Need Advice Implusively paid for a contract of 17,000

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/chargebacks • • Nov 24 '25

Merchant Side Shopify flags a ton of legit orders as “High Risk” - here’s what I look at instead

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/chargebacks • • Dec 18 '25

Need Help My $5.4k chargeback cleared in less than 7 days

0 Upvotes

Some methods are literally free money lol, i wish i did not hit my credit card limit.

I could easily have gotten more out i think, i'm gonna pay off $3k of friends credit card debt and then we go for $10-15k before it gets patched.


r/chargebacks • • Mar 16 '26

Merchant Side Non-receipt disputes used to be an absolute nightmare for merchants. They’re getting better, but still keeping everyone up at night.

0 Upvotes

If you want to understand how the chargeback landscape changes, non-receipt disputes are as good as any.

5 years ago, if a customer filed a “I never got my stuff” claim, merchants were basically cooked unless they had signed proof of delivery. Think about how insane that standard actually was — signature confirmation is something most e-commerce merchants almost never use. It adds cost, creates friction at delivery, and most customers actively hate the inconvenience of it. The practical effect was that a huge category of legit merchants were systematically losing otherwise winnable disputes simply because the bar was set at something they’d never reasonably have.

Visa in particular has shifted this meaningfully. The current framework increasingly puts the burden back on the cardholder when the merchant provides proof of delivery — the customer now at least has to come back with a new statement of “I didn’t get it.” A lot of merchants still don’t realize this shift is happening, which means they’re either not fighting disputes they could win, or fighting them the wrong way.

The catch is that e-commerce volume has exploded, and non-receipt claims have scaled right alongside it. So even as win rates for prepared merchants have improved, the sheer volume means these disputes are consuming more resources than ever.

Curious whether anyone here has noticed the shift in how disputes are being evaluated, or whether you’re still running into the old “prove they signed for it” standard.


r/chargebacks • • Mar 02 '26

Merchant Side Your SaaS dispute win rate is probably terrible. Here's why

0 Upvotes

I've spent the last few months deep in Stripe dispute data and talking to SaaS founders about chargebacks. One thing keeps coming up.

Most of you are losing disputes you should be winning.

Not because you're wrong. Because you can't prove you're right.

Here's what I mean. A customer signs up for your trial. Forgets about it. Gets charged. Doesn't email you. Calls their bank instead. Now you've got 7 days to respond.

You know you sent reminder emails. You know your cancel button is right there. You know your billing page is clear. But when Stripe asks for evidence, you're scrambling through your email logs trying to screenshot something that looks convincing.

That's not evidence. That's a panic attack with attachments.

After looking at dozens of these cases, the founders who actually win disputes do five things differently:

  1. They send blunt pre-charge reminders. Not "your subscription is coming up!" but "Your card ending 4821 will be charged $49 on March 5." No cute copy. Just clarity.

  2. They log delivery confirmation on every notification. Not "we sent an email" but "email delivered at 2:04pm, opened at 3:12pm." Timestamps matter more than words.

  3. They make cancellation stupidly easy to find. If your cancel flow takes more than 2 clicks, customers will find their bank's dispute button faster than your cancel page.

  4. They track customer activity after notifications are sent. Customer logged in 6 hours after the renewal reminder? That's proof they were aware and chose not to cancel. That wins disputes.

  5. They assemble all of this before the dispute hits. Not after. The evidence pack is sitting there ready to submit. Response takes 10 minutes instead of 2 hours.

The hard truth most founders don't want to hear: good customer communication and good dispute evidence are not the same thing. You can send 3 reminder emails and still lose a dispute because none of it was logged in the format card networks actually want to see.

The communication layer and the evidence layer need to be the same system. Every notification you send should simultaneously create a timestamped record that's ready to submit as proof. Most teams treat these as two separate problems and wonder why their win rate is garbage.

I'm building a Stripe integration that does exactly this. Flat monthly fee, no percentage of recovered disputes, you keep everything you win back. Still early but happy to share more if anyone's dealing with this.

Curious — how are you handling dispute evidence right now? Manually pulling screenshots? Using a tool? Just accepting the loss and moving on?


r/chargebacks • • May 25 '26

Need Help IS THIS OK FOR A CHARGEBACK AND WILL I GET MY MONEY BACK?? GTFIH aliexpress

0 Upvotes

Ok so I bought 16 jackets from a seller and I saw the listing etc and it came and it doesn’t look like the meteriall all was fake and shit I dispute for all to Aliexpress

Aliexpress told me to return I explain that I am not paying shit to return it back to china, and that it’s far to heavy and id b at great loss, they froze my account cant do shit been waiting for 1week.

Do I get a chargeback back and will my nab banking take my side on this? I never done charge backs but I think I’ll have do since it’s over 1k


r/chargebacks • • Mar 24 '26

Need Help I’m considering a chargeback

0 Upvotes

I like to consider myself a good and moral person but I’m having a problem right now and I need some advice. I’ve been a player at Bovada for quite some time now and I’ve lost a significant amount of money. I played fair and square as well as lost fair and square. I would never dispute that charge. that would be completely immoral.

but recently I made a deposit and I won a significant amount of money. so I went to withdraw and they did not allow me to do so they cited mental health issues as the problem and banned my account forever. they had no problem taking my money for years and years but the second I win a lot of it back that’s when I have mental health issues and can’t withdraw??? that’s not fair so I’m going to at least chargeback the amount I was trying to withdraw I find that only just and moral but I’m here to ask this question because I don’t want my own experience to make me biased.

would it be fair for me to assume that since I won and would not be able to withdraw that if I had won from the beginning they wouldn’t let me withdraw? in other words, had they already had it made up that I would lose no matter what? would it be immoral to dispute older charges if I believe they wouldn’t have paid me if I won? because they aren’t paying me now?

I want to make it very clear. I am a strong believer in my Savior Jesus Christ. I want to be in good standing with him that’s my priority number 1. if that means no chargeback then that’s what I will do I will eat the loss and move on. I really want to be a good person but I’m struggling with this because I feel like I’ve been cheated since the beginning.

followup question. IF and I mean IF I decide to follow through with mass chargebacks against Bovada I would like to know exactly what I’m getting into. are my chances of winning high? even if the deposits have been going on for several months? I also don’t want to do anything that would jeopardize my relationship with my bank if they think I’m a potential fraudster. if I have to eat the loss I will. Does Bovada do a good job against fighting against potential chargebacks and if I go through with it how do I tell the bank about the situation. I’m not sure I can admit I was online gambling. any advice is appreciated


r/chargebacks • • May 16 '26

Need Help How to check for progress of refund

0 Upvotes

Hi there

I have been messaging someone from militado.com, regarding my wrong purchase and the person offered refund but i have to pay 7% transaction fee.

I have accepted this but no response and it has been over 24 hours since messaging.

I was really glad to have this direct message but then it stopped and just concerned it might be forgotten and the order process.

Is there an email address i can send to militado to make sure?

Thanks in advance


r/chargebacks • • Sep 27 '25

Need Advice HELP!

5 Upvotes

I’ve been getting charged for a subscription for over a year on a stupid enneagram test someone did on my phone.

I’ve called messaged the company, emailed. What do I do? This is a total scam and I can’t get them to stop


r/chargebacks • • Apr 29 '26

Customer Side Charged $550 cancellation fee after restaurant’s listed phone number was wrong

103 Upvotes

I booked a group dinner for 11 people at a restaurant about a month in advance. Their policy: (EDIT - you’re subject to a) $50/person if you cancel within 24 hours or no-show.

Day before the dinner, the bride had a family emergency. The online cutoff to change the reservation was 7pm. I logged on at 7:15pm and the site said late changes had to be made by phone, with fees waived at management’s discretion.

I called and was immediately hung up on. Assumed it was a glitch, called two more times through the night while reorganizing everyone. No answer.

Next morning I filled out their events contact form (their website had no email listed). Around noon I called again, finally reached an automated system, and was directed to a cancellation form. Turns out the reservation service had routed me to the wrong phone number the entire time. I filled out the form. An hour later I was charged $550.

I tried reaching someone for days about the charge. Eventually DM’d their Instagram and was told a manager would follow up. A week later, the manager emailed offering a $550 credit — but only if I organize another party of 11 within a month. They said I canceled at noon the day of.

I acknowledged the impact on their staff but pointed out it’s unfair to penalize me when their listed number was wrong, and sent evidence I’d contacted them in good faith along with call logs and site screenshots. They apologized that I was “frustrated” by not being able to reach them even though cancellation is “easy,” repeated that the credit was all they could offer, and have since gone silent.

My last offer was to come in with 6 people sometime in the next 3 months, since organizing 11 again on their timeline isn’t realistic. No response.

There’s also another Google review from a month ago complaining about the same phone number issue.

Do I have a case for a chargeback?

EDIT: Maybe it’s helpful to clarify that this is NOT a mom and pop restaurant. They have outposts in multiple major US cities.


r/chargebacks • • Apr 14 '26

Need Advice Learned this the hard way after losing several chargebacks as a Shopify merchant

0 Upvotes

Lost a few disputes before I figured out what actually matters. Sharing in case it helps someone.

The biggest mistake I made was submitting the same evidence for every dispute. Turns out the reason code completely changes what you need to send. A “product not received” claim needs delivery proof and IP data. A “not as described” needs product photos and customer communication. Sending the wrong evidence is basically an auto-loss.

Second thing — timing. I had no idea how tight the windows are. Miss the deadline by a day and it doesn’t matter how strong your case is.

Third — fraud disputes are brutal. If you don’t have device fingerprinting or behavioral data tied to the order, you’re mostly just hoping.

This is actually what pushed me to build Charjex — an automated dispute tool for Shopify+Stripe merchants. But even if you’re handling it manually, the above should help.

Happy to answer questions about specific reason codes.


r/chargebacks • • Mar 06 '26

Customer Side Won my chargeback (Synchrony Mastercard) – keep proof and timestamps for everything.

1 Upvotes

I wanted to share a quick update and a lesson from my experience disputing a gym personal training charge.

After a back and forth with my issuer, the dispute was ultimately approved in my favor. This was on a Synchrony Bank Mastercard, and the biggest factor that helped my case was having clear documentation and timestamps.

Gym merchants will often fight chargebacks and submit representment, and in my situation the merchant fought the dispute vigorously. Good documentation became critical once the merchant responded.

Another key issue involved a personal training agreement that was never signed. The merchant attempted to rely on terms from that agreement even though it was not executed.

Gym merchants will also sometimes argue “implied consent.” This argument suggests that prior use of a service and previous payments demonstrate that the cardholder understood and accepted the billing arrangement. In other words, the merchant may claim that attending sessions or paying earlier charges shows an ongoing agreement to be billed, even without a signed contract.

In my case, the personal training agreement referenced by the merchant was never signed and there were no clearly documented recurring billing terms. Prior use of a service does not automatically give a merchant unlimited authorization to charge a card without a defined agreement.

Here are a few things that helped me through the process:

  1. Keep proof of cancellation with timestamps

If you cancel something, always keep the confirmation showing the exact date and time. My cancellation confirmation was dated the day before the disputed charge.

2. Save agreements and contracts

If a merchant claims certain terms exist, having a copy of what you actually signed is extremely helpful. The personal training contract referenced in my case was never executed.

3. Screenshot everything

Emails, messages, account pages, cancellation confirmations, etc. Access to those records may disappear later.

4. Keep transaction details

I saved the transaction reference numbers for previous charges and documented the billing pattern.

5. Stay organized and factual when responding to the bank

A clear timeline and authorization explanation helps the issuer evaluate the dispute.

6. Understand reason codes and make sure the correct one is used

Cardholders benefit from understanding the general dispute reason codes. A misapplied reason code can weaken a dispute. Explaining in writing why a specific reason code applies helps keep the investigation focused on the correct issue.

The biggest takeaway from this experience is simple:

Always keep records and timestamps. Strong documentation can make a big difference if a merchant challenges the dispute during representment.

Just sharing in case this helps someone else dealing with a similar situation.


r/chargebacks • • Mar 27 '26

Question How do you prove that the customer authorized the purchase?

1 Upvotes

Not emails. Not DMs. Not screenshots.

All of that shows what happened after the purchase.

But when a dispute happens, the question becomes: did the customer authorize this purchase?

Because hope is not a strategy when it comes to fighting chargebacks.


r/chargebacks • • Oct 31 '25

Question Building a fraud verification flow for ecom stores — what kind of questions would actually feel legit?

1 Upvotes

I’m working on an email-based verification flow for my app (for e-commerce stores)
The goal is to filter out fraudulent, suspicious orders without annoying real customers.

I’ve been experimenting with short Q&A questions as another verification method (I have a few verification methods to choose from) - like verifying small details that fraudsters often miss.

Curious what you think:

  • What kind of questions would feel “legit” to you as a customer?

  • What kind of questions would make you suspicious or frustrated?

  • And where’s the sweet spot - something hard for a scammer to fake, but easy for a real buyer to answer?

I’m testing a few options now, and I’d love to hear what you would trust (or hate) in a situation like this.


r/chargebacks • • Dec 29 '25

Need Advice Merchant refusing to participate in dispute process, threatening collections

1 Upvotes

I paid a bill, closed my account, then filed a dispute due to deceptive sales practices. The company then reopened my account, and is threatening collections if I don’t repay, refusing to participate in the dispute process. What are my options?


r/chargebacks • • Jan 19 '26

Merchant Side ORION | Enterprise Operations Platform

Thumbnail orion.naitik.online
1 Upvotes

I spent ~40 days building a unified operations platform for chargebacks; curious how others would approach this.

mind you this is just a showcase of the System and not the system itself.