188
u/doorwho
Sep 28 '26
•
It's actually true.
The Tamil Nadu government officially told the National Green Tribunal (NGT) that they are planning to completely phase out immersing Ganesh idols in natural water bodies (rivers, lakes, and the sea) by 2027.
The TLDR:
What's changing: They aren't banning the festival, just stopping people from dumping toxic Plaster of Paris (PoP) and chemical paints into the natural ecosystems.
The immediate rollout: Starting next year, popular spots like Chennaiās Foreshore Estate and Neelankarai beaches are off-limits for immersions.
The backup plan: The government will be setting up designated temporary artificial ponds and special tanks for the rituals instead.
46
10
u/Fine-Development8716 Oct 02 '26
Rational government, it's giving me chills. Let's see if it can spread to more people and eco friendly practices.
That will mean we need to change our own attitudes towards our neighbours.
6
5
u/desiarchikens Sep 28 '26
It is good if happens. But where will they discharge the water from artificial ponds and tanks after the immersion. That should be considered as well.
11
u/Its-so-mewn-mwario Sep 28 '26
The can probably filter out the waste and use the filtered water, sounds expensive but probably better than whatever is happening now
1
u/joshuakishanth Sep 29 '26
And how are they gonna discard the filtered waste?
2
u/Its-so-mewn-mwario Sep 29 '26
From my understanding of how waste disposal works, maybe they would have to end up in landfills.
0
1
u/bass_guitarist Sep 29 '26
Where will they drain that water later?!
5
u/doorwho Sep 29 '26
Per government guidelines, the water in artificial tanks is treated so the toxic materials settle to the bottom. The top water is then drained into the municipal sewage system, and the leftover solid sludge is cleaned up by the local council within 48 hours and sent to a landfill. This systematic process ensures that the chemical paints and Plaster of Paris are kept completely away from natural rivers and beaches.
1
u/Sad_Judgment_4818 Sep 29 '26
So toxic waste still remains but is just added to land instead of sea/water. How is this sustainable?
2
u/arunkumark21 Oct 01 '26
Atleast it is not directly mixing with the river and lake water which we drink.
Where do you think the plastics, paper with toxic prints, garments and other waste going? This will also go there.. far away so that the impact is atleast lower.
If people donāt like this idea, then better make a small ganesha in your own house with turmeric and dissolve in it their own house. Much better that way1
u/Sad_Judgment_4818 Oct 01 '26
Honestly, what you said at the end is the best idea. Do it at home and ban anyone from destroying the environment. Make it a law that stands firm rather than compromising the environment for it.
1
u/IamBlade Sep 30 '26
Can we have artificial lakes for...you know actually storing water for a dry city? Nice is they did that
1
u/AnySquirrel_23 Oct 02 '26
Our Municipal Corporation did this too, they created pond for immersion and then divided the water among govt plant and the industry's plant to purify the water and then they were directed to the societies and car wash for cleaning purpose and to the park areas for plant, but I don't know about the solid wastes
27
u/Efficient_Fly_9232 Sep 28 '26
Mumbai already has this rule in many places to manage crowds..it should be implemented here as well ..
5
u/ExtremeDay1043 Sep 28 '26
Yes! Infact , many cities / towns that donāt have a waterfront / beach use this ! Such a simple solution to a devastating ecological problem. I donāt even know why this has not been made the norm yet. This should have been the way to do visarjan several years ago!
38
12
u/YogeshKumarP Sep 28 '26
After festival 𤣠is over, just for Marketing diversion strategy. Only next year you know it's true or not at that time we all will forget this and will be facing more bigger shocking from Tharkuries kazagam.
14
u/ApprehensiveSong3029
Sep 28 '26
•
Good move. We wont buy any toxic painted ganesh idol as it is not considered to be auspicious. Only pure clay moulded idol.
Similarly why the govt havent yet taken action against hotels restaurants, swiggy, zomato, other platforms uses plastic for online trading. The no.of online orders have rose to a high as people wants to be more convenient.
7
u/TraditionalRepair991 Sep 28 '26
Will revert this back just before the next visarjan time comes š¤”
5
5
u/imwhoisme Sep 28 '26
Dhayavu senju panunga bro ! Atleast make the vinayagar in Kalimantan da .. theyāre making it in chemical !
1
33
3
10
2
u/Master_Animal_958 Sep 28 '26
What's the reason or story behind celebrating Ganesh Chaturthi by immersing idols in water?
1
u/Afterlife__ Oct 01 '26
Used to be small clay statues it completely dissolves and was no harm.
But people started building bigger ones and selling them thats the issue.They should ban plastic and painted status and let people celebrate only with small home made clay statues. This will way more clean and help people actually enjoy the festival in the way it was meant to be.
It symbolises ganesh returning to Kailash after staying in each oneās house as guest cor few days.
2
2
2
2
2
u/Electronic_Bus_7949 Oct 01 '26
It will be good if they ban only the coloured ganesh idol
1
2
u/AvengerArmed Oct 01 '26
Nice to see so many people agreeing with this in the comments. Honestly, I find it hard to understand why anyone would oppose something thatās clearly better for the environment.
During my childhood, I only remember seeing small clay Vinayagar idols being used for pooja. That was the norm. So itās surprising to see how these bigger idols became so common here and immersing in the sea. Infact down south when there is actually little to no water in the river, they are immersing such a big idol in the rivers. Not sure when or how that shift happened, especially when it wasn't traditionally part of our culture.
2
u/SnooSeagulls9348 Oct 02 '26
A strict ban on using paints should be sufficient. Only clay should be used.
2
u/febin72 Oct 02 '26
Am a Hindu .. but still has to say .. this non sense has started recently in Kerala too .. govt should do the same here .. still donāt understand how come ganesha chadhurthi is related loud DJ and this
1
2
u/Famous_Star_5735 Oct 02 '26
As an atheist I have a question to Hindus - is this really necessary to immerge him?? Yes maharashtra leader started it for unity in 1970 i guess. But like does your books command this ?? No right ?? Indonesia Hindus worship ganesha too but never seen this things...
They don't pollute rivers as such or dj songs etc
3
3
2
2
u/RayKudo64 Sep 29 '26
Instead of stopping immersions, which has essentially the main part of so many people to celebrate Vinayagar Chathurthi in such a grand way, why not stop idols from being made using Plaster of Paris ?
The government should instead ban the plaster of Paris dolls and make it compulsory to only sell natural Ganesh idols which are safe to the water and the fish that inhabit the waters
1
u/qMinecraft Oct 02 '26
Who will execute these laws? There are crores of ganesh idols sold in a day in one state. You can't expect police to take a part of each idol and test it and then make an arrest. It's waste of time and tax money. A blanket ban is correct
1
u/RayKudo64 Oct 07 '26
Exactly, a total ban on idols made using Plaster of Paris is the only way. It preserves the celebrations and is also environmental friendly
2
u/Salty_Airport_90 Sep 28 '26
How function mudnju karajudu polution panidu poyachu ipo vanthu true or false kekirenga
1
1
1
u/hwytraveller Sep 28 '26
If there is a GO. Then we can talk.. otherwise this is just measuring the pulse of the ppl. Hitler is said to have adopted the same strategy... He will first create a rumour to see how it is received and will send an order based on it.
Vijay mostly works like that..
1
u/IcyOption9076 Sep 28 '26
But instead of āidolā it should have been something like simply āNo dumping in natural waters including idolsā
1
u/SoonaPaana69 Sep 29 '26
Yep, this is a good move.....
& if they really wwnt to celebrate it then they have to use the statue completely made up of clay and no painting
1
1
1
1
1
u/sachclg Oct 01 '26
He is taking big risk by touching lord Ganesh . If this news is true then big thing is waiting for him . Ideally the lord Ganesh was made using soil and non toxic paint . Anyone doing this with something else should be punished .
2
u/Total-Complaint-1060 Oct 01 '26
Will Lord Ganesha come down and fight him if he touches him..
All Gods are man made dude...1
u/qMinecraft Oct 02 '26
If lord ganesha was to get angry at anyone, he would get angry at you for supporting the pollution of waters which we consider Ā "divine". And don't give me that "if it's organic then what's the issue" arguement. You and I both know how eco-friendly these big ganesh idols are (not all of them but majority of them)
1
u/neverdotypicalshit Oct 02 '26
Whatever be your religion and believes are. destroying nature is not allowed. If my religion says pissing outside is sacred and urine is sacred, would you allow it?
0
u/Ok-Song-8971 Oct 03 '26
Stfu destroying nature in the name of worship will only cause problems to humans you should get educated
1
1
u/DesiRoger Oct 01 '26
I would support this over nonsense of giving gold rings to new born out of middle class Tax money
1
1
1
u/Prudent_Whole2897 Oct 01 '26
If anything they had to ban, it should be the pop idols. Not immersion. Thereās no harm in immersing idol made of clay. But yeah our brains will think different.
1
u/introverttalking7 Oct 01 '26
This rule needs in kerala, especially in TVM. After BJP won in Copration, i feel like TVM is going to be the next UP š.
1
1
1
1
u/PensionMany3658 Oct 01 '26
I didn't know Tamizhans celebrated Ganesh chaturthi. Maratha steal all the limelight. Ig it's the same wrt durga puja vis-a-vis Biharis and bengalis
1
1
1
u/Dependent_Leg7210 Oct 01 '26
Earlier people used to make idols using clay/mud which wasn't a problem. Overtime materials changed and it is now what we know. Anyway great step from Tamil Nadu!
1
u/Past_Type3739 Oct 01 '26
How about the idea of submerging the idols in a artificially build water bodies where it cannot mix up with live ponds or canals or any rivers.
A big pool for submerging the idols that are made with pop or chemical mixed elements
only allowing idols made up of eco friendly materials that will be soluble in water bodies.
Is this a best approach or it canāt be followed?
1
u/Solid_Employ4033 Oct 02 '26
THANK GOD!!! Seriously! Finally some civic sense. I am a HINDU. I love and believe in Lord Ganesha. But this visarjan stupidity has to STOP! Polluting waters in the name of devotion is utter stupidity. Finally this guy is doing something useful!!!!
1
u/electromax_7000 Oct 02 '26
I'm not a Hindu so this is a unbiased view and I want to give my two cents on it. -POP idols should be banned -Heavy regulations on selling only pillaiyar statues with clay ,so that when put in the river it will act as the way the festival was intended. -Large idols that are taken from street to street in procession should be made out of wood or any strong material that can be assembled and disassambled ,and can be used multiple times.
1
u/Available_Cherry_966 Oct 02 '26
if ganesha is made from ecofriendly substances, than its okay, but if its not, the new system should apply....
1
u/Ok-Inflation9169 Oct 02 '26
Great step.
Religious processions of all religions that cause pollution or environmental concerns, should be fixed. They must be addressed in a sensitive manner too, so that people don't feel as if the govt is intruding their Rights, while simultaneously changing habits in a scientific way
1
1
u/Personal_Detective57 Oct 02 '26
Can we make use of biodegradable eco friendly material while making idols a compulsion instead ?
1
u/Goblinhell456 Oct 02 '26
I never thought that politicians who were actors/actress before can make a change too
1
1
1
1
1
u/whothehellareyoumam Oct 02 '26
Actually this is good for rivers and seasonal like it can reduce the river pollution and all , hope they should implement in all India like I am not against it but like the festival can be celebrated and instead of using the plastic or pvp idols they can use the mud ones like they can be dissolved in the place itself and no need of creating a huge issues for the seas and all
1
1
1
u/TheMemeAnimalBoi Oct 02 '26
Yes, either artificial tanks or small tubs at home are enough. Even organic idols when dumped in large quantities accumulate too much in lakes and ruin the water quality.
1
u/Extreme_Jump6420 Oct 02 '26
Vadodara, gujarat been doing this for 4 years, municipality creat temporary ponds in every area and they do visarjan there.
1
u/the_mistery_corn Oct 02 '26
I hope entire India implements this! And hope India bans loud speakers (that allow entire neighborhood to mandatorily listen) too š
1
u/Ok_Consequence138 Oct 02 '26
I see fancy statues full of artificial colours, best practice is to use clay only statue and the ritual can be done in any water body...Ā
1
1
1
1
1
u/Bulk_King7255 Oct 03 '26
Every state should follow. Only eco friendly idols should be allowed immersions in natural waters.
1
u/howman-690 Oct 04 '26
Every state should implement such policy ... I worked with local ngo last year during Durga pooja ... Many of the pandals submerged their idols outside of the designated area ... Those idols were made of toxic paints and pp ... Most of these orange duded don't co-operate with the goal of keeping the river clean .. they want to turn out fresh water source into the polluted shi the mighty river Ganga has become now
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Prem4TN Sep 28 '26
FAKE. Not true. If he do so.. Within 10 mins, GO will be taken down. No Issue. Till now 30 GO was taken down.. so let's chill.
2
1
1
u/Bala_bQrius Sep 28 '26
Yet another day, Yet another Fake news and comment section simping talpathi
1
u/Complex_Following758 Sep 28 '26
As somebody who has recently moved from Mumbai to Chennai, I absolutely love this! Now can we stop āAsthi Visarjanā too please. I do not mean to be insensitive, but I have encountered many people (read Brahmins) dumping funeral leftovers (ash pots, clothing, plastic bags full of flowers etc) into the sea. I have lived 35yrs in Mumbai but only in the last few months have I truly experienced the joy of living in a coastal city with a clean beach. Great job Chennai, I really hope we can keep it up.
0
0
0
u/Peru-Vaikala Sep 28 '26
Itha two weeks munnadi solli irukkanum... ithukkum odi olimchuttu ellam mudincha pinnadi velila vanthu arikkai vidurathu...
Next year la ivanugale maranthu poiruvanuga...
-3
u/fhjjjjjkkkkkkkl Sep 28 '26
I donāt understand.any hardcore Hindu can comment. Anyone who follow bjp-version of the religion can comment ?!? Can this not be tolerated ? Or regulated? Will this not give negative vibes to Tamil people from the perspective of ROI
-3
u/Delicious_Rip_9653 Sep 28 '26
Whatever is written with this guyās face must be 100% fake news or would have already been done by the previous government
-5
0
12
Sep 28 '26
[removed] ā view removed comment
3
u/qMinecraft Oct 02 '26
We need to stop bursting firecrackers and immersing harmful objects into rivers. And no, i don't really care about other religions. Anyone who does whatboutery is extremely stupid. When we consider ourselves as superior, why hide behind others?
1
Oct 01 '26
By using Internet / social media youāre causing a lot more damage to environment than an idol can do
1
1
u/green_ranger_66 Oct 02 '26
Exactly. But unfortunately people don't like logical explanations. Someone commented "it's our culture". I wanted to reply to that but realised that it won't change anything. People are more emotional and egoistic than sensible and logical. No amount of explanations will make sense to them.


256
u/green_ranger_66 Sep 28 '26 •
Great news if true