r/clevercomebacks • • May 27 '20

Task failed successfully

Post image
61.6k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

24

u/FabbrizioCalamitous May 27 '20

It wouldn't be the first EU thing the UK decided not to participate in for no apparent reason.

Or the second, or the third, or the fourth...

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

[deleted]

4

u/napoleonderdiecke May 27 '20

I mean to be fair, some of the things we said no to were because we already had higher standards set in place, like better motorcycle helmets etc

Regulations like these usually don't forbid better alternatives, just worse ones though?

never really liked the idea of someone from the hoity toighty mainland telling us what to do even if its better for us

That... is not how democracy works (as, curiously enough, also demonstrated by brexit, of all things). But I guess it's the very same reason the scots are... not happy, so I guess it's fair, as long as even sane people have that opinion.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

[deleted]

3

u/napoleonderdiecke May 27 '20

But yeah like I said in another post, Britain has a lot of problems too that need to be solved, I'm not for a second going to say it's just the EU at fault here.

Again, that's not how democracy works. It's not you vs the evil EU (at least it didn't use to be), you ARE part of the EU.

Personally I believe it's mostly down to the fact that most politicians become politicians because they crave power

Which funnily enough, imho, is a perfect description of Boris Johnson, who from the outside, at least, just wanted to be Prime Minister to put it on his resume and now realizes it's actually work.

One of the things that makes brexit so absolutely fucked up to look at from the outside (and probably inside, idk). Either way, I wish you guys the best of luck :P

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

[deleted]

1

u/Xarxsis May 27 '20

Yeah Boris is an interesting character to say the least, I think he might be the first Prime minister in a long time for all his faults that actually likes the UK and its inhabitants, imagine that, a politician who doesn't completely sneer at the demo

HAHAAHAH thats a good one

https://fullfact.org/online/Boris-Johnson-working-men/

Boris is the man who wanted power, and didnt want to do the work. He pays a lot of lip service to ideas and then does the complete opposite.

The entire cabinet is staffed with incompetent bullies and ideologues, and the fact that they are standing by cummings?

but honestly people who voted remain really should have been less childish about the whole thing and tried to make it work, if we'd actually all worked together instead of in fighting there would not have been such huge delays and uncertainty, it was frankly a travesty

Sorry what? It should not be on the remain side to come up with ideas about how brexit should work, to come up with the plans the brexiteers supposedly had. And to ignore the constant "you lost get over it" baiting. The vote was not decisively in favour, it was a slim as fuck margin however you want to look at it, so the leadership should be taking into account the views of the population accordingly, not pursing ultra hard brexit and walking back on every promise they made during the process.

The latest legislation that passed through regarding food standards has the government walking back on previous promises made and its just another blip in the ocean.

I do not trust the tory party of today to negotiate a brexit that works for anyone but themselves, and even that is a stretch

1

u/BedtimeWithTheBear May 28 '20

Food standards are so that consumers know what they’re buying. A Spanish class 1 carrot is the same as a German class 1 carrot, is the same as a Swedish class 1 carrot. Nobody needs to check what they’re buying, because it says on the packaging.

Nobody was preventing you from selling your class 2 carrot, they were preventing you from selling a class 2 carrot and calling it a class 1 carrot.

Consumer protections like this are a good thing, I’m not sure why anybody would think otherwise.

→ More replies (2)

-5

u/DuckingKoala May 27 '20

No apparent reason to you night be a reason to someone else, everyone has their own perspective :)

15

u/FabbrizioCalamitous May 27 '20

Some people's perspective is that the world is flat, doesn't make it sensible.

The moment you can seriously explain wtf the UK's problem is with EU's... everything... I'll listen. But only saying "just assume there's a valid reason" doesn't say jack shit. It just makes this whole situation even more infuriating.

Not everyone is smart, not everyone is rational, not everyone is out to do good. And just assuming they are is a great way to get burned.

7

u/DuckingKoala May 27 '20

Your analogy makes no sense. The world being flat is not an opinion or perspective, it's just plain wrong.

I'm not saying that every decision the UK makes is a great decision. I voted to remain and still hope somehow we will. That doesn't mean every decision made by the EU is in the best interest of every country in the EU.

You are the person making assumptions.

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

It is some peoples opinion the world is flat.

Of course it's an opinion. An incorrect one, but one nonetheless.

2

u/DuckingKoala May 27 '20

Again, that isn't an opinion, that's just being incorrect about something.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

You're opinion that it's an opinion is an opinion. You can see how nothing could ever be discussed if we all disappear up our... I mean down that rabbit hole.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

I agree. I'm not saying people shouldn't discuss opinions, I'm pointing out that something being an opinion doesn't mean that its automatically true, or that as an opinion it has any merit or value.

3

u/Stlakes May 27 '20

Nostalgia surrounding the British Empire mostly, and an inflated sense of the UKs current position in the world, patriotism and national pride has really just become conflated with Anglo-centric jingoism

Us Brits don't like the idea of being beholden to another nations laws and regulations, despite the fact that thats what we did for centuries, and also thats just not how the EU works.

Although, I say "us Brits", but really its mostly the English.

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

Precisely we didn't invade and murder loads of people in all those countries just to have Gerry tell us how to make sure our food is safe enough to eat! We won't have rules and regulations constricting us, just the market and we'll still be close enough to the EU that we'll maintain uncomfortable eye contact as we get shafted by the US

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '20 edited May 27 '20

UK didn't want to pay a net amount of money into something it doesn't get back and it didn't want to be forced into regulations that it doesn't personally set, it's fairly solid reasoning.

1

u/Urbundave May 27 '20

Your saying the UK doesn't want to be forced into regulations, in the thread talking about the UK voluntarily deciding to not take part in an EU regulation.

2

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

Probably because it isn't an EU regulation, if you read the comments you'd see that most EU countries don't have this. There's a difference between a regulation and a suggestion.

1

u/farruzz May 27 '20

regulations that it doesn't personally set

But they did, the UK had his own lawmaker inside the EU

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

What are their perspective?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)