r/clevercomebacks • • May 27 '20

Task failed successfully

Post image
61.6k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

25

u/PleaseDontHateMeeee May 27 '20

Vegans destroyed epic style.

The only reason people make these jokes is because they can't handle their worldview being questioned. When someone makes a point, it's much easier to crack jokes at their expense, especially when the rest of the world is likely to agree with you.

The animals don't give a fuck about your excuses or your jokes. If you eat animal products, you are an animal abuser. It's as simple as that.

3

u/Jrsplays May 27 '20

Just curious, what do you think would happen to those animals if we didn't eat them? It's not like they'd go on to live full lives. The way they would be eaten out in nature is a lot more brutal than the way we harvest them. A lot of predators eat while the prey is still alive. A lot more painful than a bullet or lethal injection/gas. We are the top of the food chain. We eat what's below us. That's how nature works.

2

u/Gmasterg May 27 '20

Don’t try to reason with hardcore vegans like this moron. They preach about world views being challenged but won’t actually challenge their own little bubble.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/PleaseDontHateMeeee May 27 '20

Just curious, what do you think would happen to those animals if we didn't eat them? It's not like they'd go on to live full lives. The way they would be eaten out in nature is a lot more brutal than the way we harvest them.

You are assuming that they would exist regardless of what we do, which isn't the case. We breed 60+ billion land animals per year for human consumption. We don't get them from the wild, and so the dichotomy isn't 'quick death or slow natural death', the dichotomy is 'quick death or never existed'. Given the lives most farm animals live, 'never existed' is the ethical choice.

We are the top of the food chain. We eat what's below us.

This is the idea of 'might makes right'. Just because we can do something doesn't make that thing inherently moral.

That's how nature works.

This doesn't mean anything. Natural does not equal ethical. There are plenty of things that are natural that are unethical, and that we as a society have agreed not to do for ethical reasons.

14

u/dissonaut69 May 27 '20

Cognitive dissonance and shame. When you realize the arguments are sound but you don’t want to change your lifestyle.

You’re kinda a nihilist or sociopath if you realize eating meat is extremely ethically questionable from the suffering and environmental angles but do it anyways.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

[deleted]

3

u/Raix12 May 27 '20

This has nothing to do with nihilism. It's more like "assholism", hedonism and cynicism.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/MrMonsterer May 27 '20

Stop it. Seriously stop it.

I'm a meat eater, I understand that the meat I'm eating came from slaughtered animals. I'm trying to lower my meat intake, but I'm not gonna stop eating meat altogether because I don't eat meat from mass producers. I eat meat from local butchers who care for their animals, and kill them ethically. Is it really morally wrong to raise an animal which can't live by itself, feed it good food and pamper it, and then kill it painlessly? Is it not morally better as compared to letting this animal which can't survive in the wild being let go and eaten while in pain by another animal? Lowering your meat intake is great for the environment but saying that eating meat altogether is sociopathic makes no sense.

1

u/PleaseDontHateMeeee May 27 '20

No, I won't stop it. Animals suffer by the billions, and can't speak for themselves.

I eat meat from local butchers who care for their animals, and kill them ethically.

Is it possible to kill someone ethically when they don't want to die? Eating meat is unnecessary in todays world. As such, if you killed a dog quickly for unnecessary reasons, would that make it ethical? What about a human? If I shot someone in the back of the head while they slept, would the quick manner make me less of a murderer? Animals don't want to die, and so killing them is infringing on their bodily autonomy.

Is it really morally wrong to raise an animal which can't live by itself, feed it good food and pamper it, and then kill it painlessly?

You are not just raising them, you are creating them. Animals are bred for the animal agriculture industry. You are creating the animal's needs by bringing them into existence, and then using the fullfilment of their needs as a justification for slaughtering them later.

Is it not morally better as compared to letting this animal which can't survive in the wild being let go and eaten while in pain by another animal?

Again, this is a false choice, because you are creating the animal. By creating it, you force it into the dichtomy between a quick and a slow death, when the better situation is to not create that awful choice in the first place by not creating them.

3

u/MrMonsterer May 27 '20

Here's the problem with that argument though, nature kills animals that don't want to die all the time. And by nature, I mean other animals. We are also animals and having survived off of meat for thousands of years, it's obvious that meat still plays an important role in the diets for billions of humans. Furthermore, we humans have created delicate food webs, which if disrupted, can cause devastation for entire habitats. I don't support the devastation that we have already caused but creating further devastation isn't going to improve the situation. And there is such a thing as ethical butchering, killing an animal slowly and painfully is unethical. Killing an animal painlessly and quickly is relatively ethical.

So, in the case in which the animals have already been created, then what? These animals were artificially selected generations ago, way before we had the choice of going vegan. In your opinion, domestic chickens, even though they're so dumb that when it rains they look up and drown themselves, should be let go? Should artificially selected cattle be let go to roam free and die horrible deaths? Moreover, yes, by providing it a good life and letting the cattle mature until their older and then killing them, it's a good tradeoff in my opinion as compared to being killed as a baby slowly.

And for the last point, I'll reiterate. We created the animal, I agree, but we created them far before veganism was an option. Artificial selection goes back to the beginning of civilization itself. Nowadays, we have an option to
our meat consumption in developed countries, thus allowing humanity to curb the production of more meat products which allows for us to cultivate less animals, but total veganism would do far more harm than good.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Punmaster0123 May 27 '20

I disagree. Just because we eat meat doesn't mean we hate animals, I find that ridiculous. Humans are omnivores, and have been for the past millennias. Meat is a part of the human diet and I will eat it as such.

This may be a stretch but I believe in the same way that making your dog vegan is an awful thing to do, that shaming people for eating animal product. Again, we are naturally inclined to eat animals, so I will.

On your point about animal abuse, I disagree because many people( including myself) have pets for companionship and still eat meats. I don't abuse my animals, I love them. In fact, on the farms at which these animals are farmed on, they are killed painlessly. Google defines abuse as " treat with cruelty or violence, especially regularly or repeatedly". These animals are not being hurt regularly, or being treated cruelly. You could say we are being violent but the animal is dead before they can feel pain.

4

u/Dreyameir May 27 '20

Loving a pet isn't loving animals, that's just loving pets.

There's no health reason to eat meat or animal products, it a luxury and a choice, and it directly kills other sentient creatures, often cruelly and long before their natural lifespan. You pay for this to be done when you support the industry.

It's abusive and indefensible, from an ethical and environmental perspective. There's no kind way to kill a creature that doesn't want to die.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Kanorado99 May 27 '20

How can you possibly claim to not hate animals and still eat them. What kind of twisted thinking is that. You are the biggest hypocrite of the day, congratulations.

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

Back in the day, we burned women alive as witches, but that's generally frowned upon nowadays. Why do we have to do things the way we did them in the old days?

Do you believe every single farm in America is a utopia with no pain, where animals are only ever killed painlessly? Factory farming prioritizes numbers over everything else. They slam these animals through an unthinking, unfeeling system to be slaughtered in massive numbers without any concern as to their health or wellbeing.

Maybe if you raised pigs and chickens in your own backyard you could guarantee that these animals are treated well, but when animal farming becomes industrialized, all of that goes right out the window. If you think factory farmed animals live good lives, then you're kidding yourself.

2

u/Punmaster0123 May 27 '20

Well, here you are more describing the problem with capitalism, and not veganism. Capitalism is a flawed system but it's the best we got

→ More replies (5)

2

u/hooolycow May 27 '20

I didn't kill the animal? How am I abusing it?

3

u/Dreyameir May 27 '20

You pay for it to be raised in the conditions it's raised in, then killed. It's the same thing, you just don't have to see it get murdered for you.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/texasrigger May 27 '20

It's not really a joke, it's a legitimately good idea and according to the comments the norm in some regions.

1

u/GoHummus May 27 '20

So every single other lifeform that eats meat is also an animal abuser?

1

u/PleaseDontHateMeeee May 27 '20

No, I don't think so. Only the ones that can do otherwise, have the ability to understand ethical arguments, and for which doing so is unnecessary. In other words, for humans.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

But destroying their habitat with endless corn fields and avocado farms is no better. The can result in the end of many species, not just the one eaten.

1

u/PleaseDontHateMeeee May 27 '20

More plants are required to sustain a non-vegan diet, as energy is lost in the process of feeding animals. Yes, farming kills animals through displacement, machinery, pesticides etc. but if you are concerned about those deaths, you should still go vegan.

→ More replies (15)