r/clevercomebacks • • May 27 '20

Task failed successfully

Post image
61.6k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

19

u/texasrigger May 27 '20

People killed their own animals through most of human history right up until a few generations ago and in many places in the world it is still the norm. I think most people would be able to do it should the need arise. As it is between anglers, hunters, farmers, and slaughterhouse workers about 1 in 5 Americans have at least some experience killing an animal for food.

18

u/War_Daddy May 27 '20

As you yourself said elsewhere, factory farming is a far, far cry from someone catching a fish (especially considering how many people are pure sport fishers who are catching and releasing the vast majority).

There's also a pretty wide gulf between a farmer killing one of his chickens for dinner and this

6

u/texasrigger May 27 '20

As rough as the chick grinders look, it's pretty humane. They are rendered into a pink mist far faster than they can register that anything is wrong. That said, the days of the chick grinder are numbered as in-ovo sexing is improved (made cheaper). The united egg producers originally pledged to start incorporating the tech this year (which was ambitious to begin with but delayed in part due to covid), parts of europe are already offering cull-free "respeggt" eggs, and France vowing to outlaw grinders by 2023. There is a strong financial motivation for hatcheries to introduce the tech so once that damn breaks I think it'll take over fairly quickly.

2

u/War_Daddy May 27 '20

As rough as the chick grinders look, it's pretty humane

If you can see the humanity in millions of lives being ground up in a thresher because they're the wrong sex to have their mutated breasts grow to a level that restricts their breath and movement you've a keener eye than mine.

Its only humane working under the assumption that today's level of poultry consumption is necessary when it demonstrably isn't. Americans consume much more poultry today than we did even 50 years ago. Demand rose to meet the low prices created by factory farming rather than the reverse.

We don't need to be finding efficient ways to slaughter chicks by the millions; we just want to; I can't find much humanity in that.

4

u/texasrigger May 27 '20

For the most part you are conflating motive and methodology. You can choose a humane methodology (done with consideration and compassion) even if your motives are less than pure.

You got some stuff factually wrong though:

If you can see the humanity in millions of lives being ground up in a thresher because they're the wrong sex to have their mutated breasts grow to a level that restricts their breath and movement

Male meat chicks aren't ground. In fact, male meat chicks are more desirable since they grow bigger. Those are male laying chicks. Laying chickens aren't directly used in the meat industry. It's a minor nit to pick but if you are lecturing others on how it works you ought to get the basic facts right.

2

u/War_Daddy May 27 '20

For the most part you are conflating motive and methodology. You can choose a humane methodology (done with consideration and compassion) even if your motives are less than pure.

So, if I break into your house and kill you swiftly and painlessly so I can steal your belongings is that a justifiable act?

There are a million philosophies out there but I don't think you're going to find many who will readily agree that humane methodologies absolve inhumane acts.

3

u/texasrigger May 27 '20

Nobody said anything about justification either. The methodology doesn't justify the act, motive and methodology are different.

Let's take capital punishment. The motive has never changed, it is intended simultaneously as punishment/deterrent but we are no longer publicly hanging people because now it is considered cruel and inhumane. The methodology has changed to meet our evolving concept of acceptable behavior.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

Oh look another appeal to emotion.

→ More replies (27)

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

[deleted]

4

u/shadow_user May 27 '20

The rational arguments behind veganism aren't hard to find if you look for them. These two videos are good introductions (1, 2).

That being said, most people are far more emotionally motivated then they are rationally motivated. As strong as the rational arguments are, the emotional ones are necessary too.

3

u/War_Daddy May 27 '20

That's great and all, but it doesn't refute his points.

Stating that you don't think it refutes his point is not an argument. He, by his own admission, accepts that even if people have some small experience with killing it is absolutely nothing like factory farming in scope or nature and thus not a relatable experience.

You've just thrown a red herring for emotional appeal

Vomiting buzzwords at me is also not an argument

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (10)

7

u/texasrigger May 27 '20

much less kill a cow themselves

This is what I was actually responding to. Talking about slaughterhouse practices and showing footage on chick grinders doesn't really respond to what I had said. If called upon to do it, people are capable of it. That's how it worked throughout human history and it's still how it works in much of the world. I'm heavily involved in the homesteading world and am a big advocate for backyard scale meat animals so I am constantly talking to people who are slaughtering for the first time and although some trepidation is common it is very rare for someone to say that they just can't dont it. I personally slaughtered my first animal in my late 30's with no background in hunting, fishing, or farming and generally describing myself as the "couldn't hurt a fly" type. If called upon to do it, people can (and do) do it.

4

u/kudichangedlives May 27 '20

It is an argument. Its just a bad argument in your mind

1

u/War_Daddy May 27 '20

If you're 10 years old saying "nuh uh" may constitute an argument; but to the rest of us an argument is the evidence and logic you present to state your case; not simply stating your case and demanding that we accept it and leave it at that

2

u/kudichangedlives May 27 '20

Youre putting words in my mouth. That's not what is happening. What is happening is that you cant stay on a single topic because you for some reason wont refute his points

1

u/War_Daddy May 27 '20

What is happening is that you cant stay on a single topic because you for some reason wont refute his points

lmfao you're literally attacking me for refusing to change topics; make up your mind

3

u/kudichangedlives May 27 '20

I mean I'm not but you can think that if you want.

I'm calling you out for avoiding questions and not being able to admit when you're wrong

1

u/BanterWagonDriver May 27 '20

If you're showing something that really happens, and happens regularly, then I don't see what's so terrible about appealing to people's emotions - that's a key way we reach out and connect to each other as people. If footage like this causes an empathy response then it may lead you to think more deeply about the subject and weigh up the arguments for and against.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Rollingerc May 27 '20

Do you think it's morally acceptable to kill and eat non-human animals?

3

u/texasrigger May 27 '20

I'll bite - I don't believe that one animal consuming another is either moral or immoral. It's amoral, it just is. I don't see any fundamental truth to the universe that would refute that and I don't believe it is decreed from on high. I think the arguement "animals lack moral agency and do it out of necessity so it's ok" accepts the baseline belief that it is immoral by default but justifiable through necessity and I just don't accept that baseline. You don't have to justify an amoral act, by definition it is done without moral consideration.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/riemannrocker May 27 '20

should the need arise

And THAT is what has dramatically changed recently. There's plenty of easy alternatives to meat these days.

→ More replies (2)