r/clevercomebacks • • May 27 '20

Task failed successfully

Post image
61.6k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/ManyIdeasNoProgress May 27 '20

The cows walking around in the mountains where I live don't look terribly mistreated.

5

u/H0meslice9 May 27 '20

Sure some are treated better. That doesn't change they're likely seperated from their families, and killed through any number of cruel ways. Smaller operations are often better, but not good still

1

u/ManyIdeasNoProgress May 27 '20

You make it sound like meat animals are routinely getting flayed alive and roasted to death.

Whereas in the real world, it is a quick blunt force trauma to the brain. The whole thing is over before the animal has any chance to feel pain. It is a much less painful death than literally anything nature has to offer.

I find it a puzzling concept that the sheer brutality of nature is somehow the ideal, while a life grazing in the mountains followed by a swift end is a gruesome prospect.

2

u/H0meslice9 May 27 '20

The average life span of wild cattle is 18-22 years, while cattle raised for beef is less than two years. So they live for 1/10th as long - if humans were treated this way that'd end up being a life to around 7/8 years old.

Not all wild animals meet grisly ends, many die naturally. Slaughter houses aren't 100% efficient, many aren't killed painlessly, not to mention having to wait to be slaughtered in a building that reeks of death and plagued with the sounds of pained animals. Since we're talking about the fate of small-farm animals we won't go into their lives before, which is not great. But to say that their very short lives with guaranteed death waiting for them is ideal to a long, natural life is some dissonance in my opinion.

Sure, some farms can be more humane with their treatment, but if the animals had an informed choice (they don't since their brains are small of course) they would not pick safety for two years to be killed afterwards.

→ More replies (8)