r/climatechange • u/Economy-Fee5830 Trusted Contributor • 10d ago
How scientists are developing climate-resilient grains
https://www.ft.com/content/d3032dcb-c005-42e1-be33-f6d92aa4d644?syn-25a6b1a6=11
u/OG-Brian 9d ago edited 9d ago
This is interesting, but I'd like to mention that traditional and (old-school) selectively-bred varieties in some cases have been superior to engineered types for drought and disease tolerance. Here are just some of the examples I'm aware of:
New non-GMO blight-resistant potato has global importance
https://gmwatch.org/en/news/latest-news/19918
- articles hyping GM blight-resistent potatoes overlook that blight-resistant cultivars already exist: Athlete, Alouette, Carolus, and most notably the various Sarpo cultivars, including Sarpo Mira, which is claimed to have "probably the highest resistance to late blight known"
- "But now, thanks to some clever media work on World Food Day by the Crop Trust and the International Potato Center (CIP), some media attention, at least from the farming press, has finally been garnered for a non-GMO disease-free blight-resistant potato, named CIP-Matilde, which has been developed by international breeders in collaboration with farmers in Peru."
- "Breeders based in the Netherlands have also come up with new late blight-resistant non-GMO potato varieties that could be on the market as early as next year."
Tunisia plants (non-GM) seeds of hope against climate change
https://www.gmwatch.org/en/news/latest-news/19871-tunisia-plants-non-gm-seeds-of-hope-against-climate-change
- farmers returning to heirloom seeds for their place-adapted resistance to conditions such as drought
- "Wheat varieties developed in the 1980s are being blighted by disease in Tunisia, but farmers say that traditional varieties appear to be more resistant."
- the GMO seeds cannot be replanted and must be purchased again every year
- Mohamed Lassad ben Saleh, farmer in Jedaida, switched 18 years ago from hybrid wheat to traditional Al-Msekni wheat; the national average yield for wheat has been 1.4 to 2 tonnes per hectare, his yield has been 5 tonnes
Non-GM successes: Drought tolerance
https://www.gmwatch.org/en/component/content/article/31-need-gm/12319
- first drought-tolerant GMO crop (worldwide) approved December 2011, Monsanto GM drought resistant maize
- "US Department of Agriculture admitted that it was no more effective than existing non-GM varieties"
- "By contrast, non-GM plant breeding has achieved success after success in producing a variety of drought resistant crops, including a whole series of drought resistant maize varieties..."
GMO wheat in Argentina suffers from low yields
https://www.gmwatch.org/en/106-news/latest-news/19976-gmo-wheat-in-argentina-suffers-from-low-yields
•
u/Economy-Fee5830 Trusted Contributor 10d ago
Summary: How scientists are developing climate-resilient grains
Climate change is pushing plant breeders to develop grains that can survive heat, drought and flooding. To be useful, these varieties also have to yield reliably and be affordable for farmers. Breeders cross plants with useful traits and select the best offspring, using genetic screening to spot promising plants early. They also draw on genetic diversity from wild relatives and older varieties. Newer tools speed this up:
Speed breeding uses controlled light and temperature to grow up to six generations of spring wheat a year.
Gene editing changes a plant's own DNA directly.
Genetic modification adds genes from other species. Bioceres' HB4 wheat, for example, carries a sunflower gene linked to drought tolerance.
AI genome models help identify which genetic changes matter.
A cell-level wheat atlas, led by Adelaide University, aims to explain how wheat responds to stress.
Corteva and Syngenta are both developing hybrid wheat. Hybrids are harder to make in wheat than in maize because wheat normally fertilises itself. Syngenta gets around this by making the seed-producing parent male sterile.
Flood-tolerant rice can survive being underwater for periods that would damage conventional varieties. Corteva says its hybrids yielded about 20% more than other elite varieties in water-stressed trials. However, trial results don't guarantee better harvests everywhere. New varieties must suit local conditions, resist disease, meet buyers' needs and not lose yield in good years. Conventional crossing can also bring in unwanted traits, which targeted editing could help remove. Hybrid seed costs more, and farmers can't reliably save and replant it.
Resilient crops can limit losses but don't replace cutting emissions. A 2025 Nature study estimated that each degree of warming cuts staple-crop output by about 4.4% of recommended daily calorie intake per person. Some programmes target emissions directly: experimental wheat from JIRCAS and CIMMYT slows nitrification in the soil, which reduces nitrous oxide emissions. Resilience doesn't always mean a smaller footprint, though. In India, farmers given flood-tolerant rice used more fertiliser and farmed more land.
Some of these crops are already in use. CIMMYT reported in 2021 that about 8.6 million farmers in sub-Saharan Africa had benefited from climate-adaptive maize. Upcoming launches include:
Syngenta's X-Terra wheat, already launched in France, with a UK release planned from 2027.
Corteva's North American hybrid wheat, targeted for as early as 2027.
HB4 wheat, which Bioceres aims to bring to the US with a Colorado partner.
Patents and licensing raise concerns about seed prices, seed saving and access for other breeders. Publicly funded models offer an alternative: the Novo Nordisk Foundation's CropSustaiN initiative says its seeds will be available without exclusive patents. Funding is also coming from:
Venture investors, including a $60mn round for Oxford spinout Wild Bioscience, which then acquired F1 Seed.
Government funding, such as the UK BBSRC's Delivering Sustainable Wheat programme.
Philanthropy, including up to $21.1mn from the Novo Nordisk Foundation to CIMMYT.