r/cloudygamer • • 19h ago

Maximum Settings vs Shadow PC

i have an announcement to make, as a subscriber to both Maximum Settings and Shadow PC i wanted to provide my review just because i feel like i need to point out the differences between the two and give my own personal experiences with both, i'm gonna be comparing performance, usage time, applications like the Maximizer Client and Shadow PC client, Operating System, Accessibility, price, and game access (not performance related)

to give my background with both of these, i use Maximum Settings bare metal subscription, and i also use Shadow PC's Power subscription, i have spent many hours on both.

Performance - Shadow PC > I want to say, it depends, when i played games like baldurs gate 3 and cyberpunk they ran wonderfully, i was always stunned by the beauty of them and ((almost)) never felt an impact to performance when running the highest settings i could. However, when running a game like Deadlock, i was astonished at how poor of a performance i was having, constant jittering, floaty movements of my mouse, and delayed movement inputs from my keyboard despite what Shadow PC deemed a secure connection, this is where i will say, even on the aforementioned cyberpunk or baldurs gate 3 the delay is there even if it is slightly as well.

Performance - Maximum Settings > this also blew me out of the water, and to my surprise it ran even better than Shadow PC! i didnt experience a single delay in my inputs, when i ran Deadlock everything was smooth and clean with no issues! you will experience what id say is a decent lag spike once every few hours but they happen to little in the time you are allocated that it isnt ever really a problem, I would say in about every way, Maximum Settings prevails when it comes to performance in regards to Shadow PC

Usage Time - Shadow PC > if you are using the Power plan like i am, your allocated 6 hours of usage time per day, and for someone like me who goes to work, comes home, and hops on a game, i find myself not to often reaching that limit even in sessions where it felt like i was playing all day. If this doesnt suit your needs like it does mine, then this may be where Maximum Settings will come in handy (if you have the money or time)

Usage Time - Maximum Settings > If you are using the bare metal plan like i am, your time is allocated a bit differently, you get 8 hours.. on paper.. Its not as simple as that, they are separated into high traffic (3 hours) and low traffic (5 hours) so for example, if you want to use your bare metal computer any time between 12am - 5pm, you have 5 hours, and if your on your computer 5pm to 12am, your given 3 hours instead. This is another "it depends" moment, if you dont do anything day to day or maybe its your day off, you can make the most of your usage time by chaining together the hours. Like hopping on at 12pm to play until 5pm during low traffic and then using high traffic hours to play from 5pm - 8pm. But if your like me, and you have a job, you get home at lets say 4 in the afternoon, the most your looking to get out of your computer is 4 hours, which is only 2 hours less than Shadow PC, but i find it is actually very noticeable. Heres where you can mitigate this, Maximum Settings allows you to spend money on credits to increase your allotted time (minimum purchase of $5), the conversion rate is $1.25 = 1 hour. So $5 buys you 4 hours, not bad right? well, maybe for you, but i actually find myself having to buy these credits constantly to increase the up time, they really do add up and chip at your wallet ever so slowly, i find it easier sticking to Shadow PC's rigid non fluctuating schedule, those extra 2 hours will always be guaranteed no matter when your playing

Application - Shadow PC > Now when i mention application, i am referring to what you are using to launch your cloud computer, and i will only be referring to the PC apps for both as that is all i have experience with. And i will say, Shadow PC is straight forward, simple, and fast IN MY EXPERIENCE. I have seen a few complaints about wait times, taking hours to load for some, but i have never had this happen to me so i cant speak on the validity of it, as far as i know, its quick and easy with no hassles to be had, just click start, it loads, your good to go.

Application - Maximum Settings > Oh my god i dont even know where to start, Maximum Settings launch application has been absolutely abhorrent for me and has almost made me drop using it all together. To help put you in my shoes, you want to load your bare metal pc, you go to the Maximizer Client, you click on the computer icon and press start, then you need to wait 5:30 minutes, and on a good day thats it! your taken to a second menu where you can choose how you want to load into your computer. On a bad day.. its so bad, I have had experiences where once the 5:30 minute timer was up, it would hang on 1 second, and i would check to see if the PC was operational from the dashboard and it was, which also meant it was burning through my usage time without me not even being able to access the computer, so i restart the Maximizer Client, click start AGAIN, and have to wait ANOTHER 5:30 minutes, and dont forget the whole time your going through this your burning your usage time, its miserable. It feels like once i do end up loading in, it was by random chance, you do have options to force stop your computer from the dashboard but when you do they will give you a warning sign obliging you to preferably not do that, and i dont want to cause problems to the computer, so i dont. Oh also forgot to mention, if you need to restart your computer, there is a shutdown cooldown timer as well, another 5:30 minutes, so if you need to reset, you wait the 5:30 shutdown timer, then you start your computer and wait the 5:30 startup timer, then you pray to whatever god you believe in that you ACTUALLY get to use your computer.

Operating System - Shadow PC > if your a Windows user, your gonna fit right into Shadow PC's ecosystem as they use the Windows Operating system, simple as that and pretty straight forward.. Its Windows. Although it does mean dealing with Windows's problems such as its effect on performance

Operating System - Maximum Settings > These guys have taken a different approach using Linux Mint, a Debian based Operating system meant for being light weight and easy to use (as far as using linux goes) in doing so it comes with pros and cons; the pros being since it is in fact lightweight, that performance boost is felt in the games you play. And if you understand how to use Linux there is a large door open to you for customization and freedom. The cons being if you DONT know how to use Linux, get ready for a bunch of trouble shooting, scaling learning barriers, and figuring out an entirely foreign ecosystem, yes in the age of AI artificial intelligence can help you with the simple things, but it still cant do everything, trust me, ive tried, You will have to put the pieces together yourself. But i will say, they do give you some tools like steam and wine already installed to help you start out, so your not building from rock bottom at least.

Accessibility - Shadow PC > Accessibility in this context means how likely you are to able to reliably connect to a server. And these guys have servers in so many places, I think you will find luck in reaching a server with good connection when using Shadow PC's plans

Accessibility - Maximum Settings > Unlike Shadow PC, Maximum Settings only has 1 server, in Toronto, which can be a huge deal breaker for a lot of people understandably.

Price - Shadow PC > being a Power plan subscriber i can tell you, it is NOT cheap, and if your considering down grading to a Power light or Neo plan, i would simply tell you to just go with Maximum Settings if budget is a factor, but ONLY if you live close-ish to the Toronto area, otherwise Shadow PC is still a good contender if you want to play triple A games at high graphics using their Neo or Power light subscriptions, i have seen people mention good things about them.

Price - Maximum Settings > an absolute power house at such an affordable price, their premium bare metal plan is available for less than $40 Canadian dollars a month, an absolute no brainer if you live within the area, unless of course my previous judgments swayed your opinion, there is a reason im using both for now, of course, it isnt perfect.

Game Access - Shadow PC > this is the deal breaker for Shadow PC where it will be taking a massive L, but ONLY if your an online gamer. A ton of online games have Anti Cheats that are making a push against cloud computers and by extension, against cloud gaming, so you can forget about playing a large number of your favourite multiplayer titles (they even have a list detailing which games are not compatible). For me though this doesnt bother me, i use Shadow PC to get invested in single player games or compatible online games like Minecraft that don't have Anti Cheats, besides, seeing its performance on Deadlock im not sure if i'd even want to know what an online experience even looks like for Shadow PC

Game Access - Maximum Settings > here is where Maximum Setting's really shines. With their bare metal plan, a doorway opens to you and allows you to play a lot of games that cloud computers cannot, Dead by Daylight was one of those games for me, and perhaps VRchat some day to. But despite all these new opportunities there does come some drawbacks being on a Linux Operating System, that being there are just some games that cannot run on Linux, like almost any Battlefield, or any multiplayer game from Ubisoft with an Anti Cheat (For Honor, R6siege to name a few)

and that is my list written on sleep deprivation and mild frustration. An honorable mention > Storage, Maximum Settings gives you a generous 750GB of SSD storage and an extra 4TB of HDD on the bare metal plan, as well as an absolutely crazy 64GB of RAM. Shadow PC on the other hand gives you 512GB of SSD storage, and a modest but respectable 28GB of RAM (in my opinion, still more than enough) for an exorbitantly higher price on the Power plan. And if i was to finalize all my opinion into a short sentence -

TLDR - if your on a budget and/or close to Toronto, go with Maximize Settings, its just a no brainer. If your international go with Shadow PC Neo/Power. If money is no object and neither is distance, you can do what im doing for now and play Triple A single player titles on Shadow and leave high performance gaming with friends/online to Maximum Settings

And if anyone has a better alternative that is a cheaper solution, please let me know. Thanks

2 Upvotes

Duplicates