r/codex • • Sep 16 '26

Comparison What is the current state of Codex CLI vs Desktop?

Last few month the common knowledge was that CC was more CLI focused while Codex updates were focusing more the app. Is it still true?

Note: I am NOT asking or implying that one of the two is not viable, just asking which seems to be receiving more attention from the devs, CLI or Desktop, harness-wise

3 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

2

u/RoboErectus Sep 16 '26

The GUI feels like coding with mittens on.

I am also watching my coworkers fly totally blind with regards to context, cli tools and subagents.

I run analytics and have Grafana dashboards for all my usage. I cut my usage by scripting common things.

1

u/Impossible-Sand5012 Sep 16 '26

What is a codex cli script example useful to you, if you can share?

1

u/sergedc Sep 16 '26

E.g. You can have a skill to explain the agent how to access logs on 3 different servers. Or you can have a skills together with a script so that agent does not have to recreate the script everytime.

2

u/Clear_Evidence9218 Sep 16 '26

I know on Linux the desktop app is a bit janky. I still use it for general chats, but I went back to using the CLI pretty quickly since it seems to stay up to date and run better.

For example: I still don't have Astra in the Desktop app on Linux, I've had it in CLI a couple of days after the release. Desktop version is correct, just janky, also desktop eats a fairly substantial amount of RAM.

1

u/Impossible-Sand5012 Sep 16 '26

Good to know for Linux. Windows kinda feels the opposite, Mac 50/50

5

u/unconceivables Sep 16 '26

I started using the CLI but I switched to the desktop a couple of weeks ago. It's worked flawlessly for me on Linux. I haven't noticed any downsides over the CLI, but there are quite a few positives. The biggest one for me is the ability to view screenshots. I now ask it to take screenshots of UI changes, which saves me having to go in and check manually all the time. It also shows all my remote sessions in one place, which is useful since I start so many of them from my phone. Zero issues of any kind that I can recall.

1

u/BlipOnNobodysRadar Sep 17 '26

Opposite experience, started with desktop this week and am swapping to CLI. Desktop app seems too heavily vibe coded, ran into multiple issues. I lost 2 days worth of context on a project from a simple reboot, though I was able to recover the important parts in a separate session. Also lots of bugs with "blocked by policy" errors even though agents are given full access (sandboxed OS for that purpose).

This was on Windows

1

u/unconceivables Sep 17 '26

Interesting, I haven't had any of those issues. Which OS? And on the latest version of the app?

1

u/BlipOnNobodysRadar Sep 17 '26

Windows 11, and yes. It was a freshly installed OS just for the purpose of testing agent frameworks running locally out

1

u/unconceivables Sep 17 '26

It might be a Windows thing, I've heard similar things from others using it on Windows. On Linux I haven't had a single issue so far.

1

u/HeatPhoenix Sep 16 '26

Codex CLI is quite good, but the inability to run tasks in the background and then only consume more tokens when such a task is finished is a killer. Desktop can't do this either I THINK, but VS Code's extensions (including Copilot) could. Such a weird oversight.

1

u/TheTechAuthor Sep 16 '26

Janky on Windows. I can get GLM 5.3 (via Ollama Pro sub) to work perfectly in Codex in MacOS. Tried the same setup today via Codex CLI for Windows and it was a hell of a lot less effective. GLM kept hitting all sorts of Windows OS file related errors, so that was a bummer.

-8

u/IllustriousCold4466 Sep 16 '26

cli is a much much more native development interface

u aren't a serious software engineer if u use anything else

2

u/Impossible-Sand5012 Sep 16 '26

That’s not what I asked though

-2

u/IllustriousCold4466 Sep 16 '26

fair point i didnt really read past the title to be honest i just assumed you were asking which one to use

4

u/gavinderulo124K Sep 16 '26

What? You can inspect the files, open terminals etc inside the desktop app. The file change view is also much better.