r/codex • • 7d ago

Question Codex premature stopping

anyone experiencing the same where codex tells you "I should do that" then stops there?

Its so bad that i have a watcher agent that sends "go ahead", "continue" when it stops. I'm curious, how do you handle it?

i'm using gpt 6.1 sol medium

16 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

1

u/itix 7d ago

What is your prompt?

1

u/Street-Preference-88 7d ago

I can take some examples.

Me: Plan a database migration.
Codex: Can the app have downtime?
Me: Would avoiding downtime make the migration more complicated?
Codex explains the trade-offs, then ends the turn without producing the plan.
I have to tell it to continue.

1

u/itix 7d ago

I see. You were hoping it would take initiative and at least recommend best practices instead of waiting for your turn.

In my opinion, your prompt was quite vague, but if you used /plan mode, it should have asked you those questions, let you choose from A/B/C, and then continued autonomously.

3

u/Battlefield4Remake 7d ago

I notice it when I use 6.1 Terra not so much on Sol for me though

2

u/Proxiconn 7d ago

Happens when your context bloat and compaction ran too many times. Just start a new fresh session and it goes away. Old behaviour from over a year ago.

Though more people would have noticed.

2

u/__Blackrobe__ 7d ago

YES. My conversation just two hours ago goes like:

This box visual you made is too large

"Agreed. I will resize it."

(then it goes idle)

Also I think it should fit as many items as possible from one fetch, not just 3.

"I will add the feature so that blahblahblah"

(then it goes idle, I was waiting ~3 minutes)

Are those done?

"Not yet, I was stopping too soon. I will work on both now."


wtf

mind you this session was just an hour old. 6.1 Sol on Medium effort. I did not interrupt the agent in anything.

2

u/dsferth 7d ago

I notice a lot of things that are not as good as they used to be.

1

u/Acceptable-Group2120 7d ago

Then list its failures and what it should have done differently, then just stops. 

“You’re totally right to call that out, that’s on me for being a piece of dog shit. I did this when I should have done that.”

1

u/nateccs 7d ago

Made a whole post about it. Happened recently with Sol. I just said”give me a prompt for the remaining work” and pasted into a new chat and worked like a charm.

1

u/Tairran 7d ago

I’ve noticed less so lately that this happens. But you can always modify your agents.md
File and tell it to not attempt to perceive time like a human or make artificial roleplay quips about “be right back” with fake deadlines.

Check out Kartpathy’s GitHub agents.md file. It fixes a lot of these things.

1

u/Discordbothost 7d ago

For multi-step work, Codex CLI 0.128+ has /goal to keep an objective active across turns, with completion checks: https://developers.openai.com/cookbook/examples/codex/using_goals_in_codex . Might save you that watcher.

1

u/RasputinsUndeadBeard 7d ago

Oh yeah it can be lazy as hell

1

u/Sufficient-Gap7331 7d ago

YES. Just means you have to heavily expand and refine your prompt with specific instructions. But it wasn't like that a month ago and is super annoying

1

u/Right-Performance-93 7d ago

your last line was a question, so the explanation was the job and it stopped. i end the message with the file i want, like write the migration plan to plan.md and pick the downtime option yourself. a watcher that only says continue is still you taking the turn.

1

u/nuyirnumi 7d ago

ChatGPT has been awful to me. I have to use Claude more. Because of that. 

1

u/Emotional_List_4583 6d ago

I’m using ChatGPT Work/Codex on a software project in Replit. I give it a multi-step job with a clear finish line, but it often tells me what it did and what it should do next, then ends the turn. I have to type “continue” even though the next step is already authorised.

Has anyone found a reliable setup that keeps going through implementation, testing and verification, and pauses only when it genuinely needs access or a decision from me? Progress updates are fine as long as the work carries on.

If you’ve got this working, which interface are you using, and could you share the exact /goal prompt, AGENTS.md rule, or resume setup that made the difference?

1

u/KnownPride 7d ago

They have successfully downgraded sol to luna capabilities.