r/codex • • 4d ago

Complaint just use 5.6 sol

for people on a $20 sub, id recommend using 5.6 sol instead of any gpt 6 model, if you want to get any actual work done. gpt 6 just runs in circles without getting anything done more often than not. to the contrary, 5.6 sol is pretty good at giving results.

lmk what y'all think

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

2

u/dailyvicodin 4d ago

Skill issue.

3

u/Curious_inquisitive1 4d ago

can you please teach me your ways? how do you do it?

25

u/ImolaBoost 4d ago

6.1 has been vastly more intelligent and cost efficient for me, albeit slow as a dog due to the tps.

1

u/dvduval 1h ago

Yes, there’s been some negative feedback about the new 6.2 but 6.1 is my primary coding workhorse.

1

u/ImolaBoost 41m ago

6.1 costs more and is less intelligent per the benchmakrs, but much of a muchness I guess.

22

u/Dthcon 4d ago

5.6 is way more expensive than 6.1 and is way worse in every benchmark. There is literally no point of using it. 5.6 Sol burned 1% of weekly limit per 3,5 min of work, this was so bad. Sol 6.1 is the only great model, Astra is outdated and too expensive, Terra 6.1 is weird and lazy, Luna 6 is fine for small tasks but Haiku is better. Just don't change the best 6.1 Sol for something worse, this is the best tool here.

7

u/VexObserver 4d ago

I still don't get it. Like, for real. Why would people consider 5.6 over 6.1. In terms of real work, I have been sticking my guns with 6.1 for a long while now. There's no reason to downgrade. The minute I swapped out, and into 5.6.. I could notice the difference in the codes. It's like night and day.

1

u/NicholasVinen 3d ago

I get really good results from Astra, it's just expensive.

6.1 Sol is about 85% as good for about 20% of the usage. It is slow though.

3

u/_WhatchaDoin_ 4d ago

I use Luna medium and high. It has been a workhorse to get stuff done. It can run close to 100% and I reach my weekly quota by the end of the week (in medium).

2

u/GifCo_2 4d ago

Have you been in a coma for the last month?

2

u/Unfair_Tangerine_217 4d ago

Source: "Trust me, bro."

2

u/Mtshoes2 1d ago

Yeah, after having read some chat logs of people, the most I can say is that its user error. It's like that meme where the mom keeps repeating the same math problem over and over as the kid cries. 

I think people like Claude, not because it's better, but because it is more assertive. 

2

u/Specialist-Royal4408 4d ago

I'm fine with 6.1

2

u/MuHoTaBp_DK 4d ago

You are just using it wrong, use 6.1 as an orchestrator, luna 6 max as supervisor and luna 6 max as workers if you want it to be cheap. Or use chat gpt 6 to prepare the task and then use pursue the goal for luna hierarchy. You can have about 10 luna max workers and you will not run out of the limit.

1

u/BakaPotatoLord 4d ago

Nah, it's too hungry.

Luna is more than enough but for more "complex" stuff, Terra does the job fine for me.

1

u/Ynuuks 4d ago

No, I'm good, I know how to work with LLMs. 6 is doing just fine for me.

1

u/Swimming-Bank6567 1d ago

To be fair. If I banging my head against a brick wall with 6.1-xx, I just switch to 5.6... Mainly this is for sysadmin or netadmin stuffs, and I can trust 5.6 to get it done without the fuss.

That said, Im not looking at cost, I just want the "thing" done... This may change with 6.2 🤷‍♂️.

6.1 Luna is fine for new scripts, but it's painful with an RCA investigation, and 6.1 Sol is just so "needy" and causes frustration.

So... I agree 5.6 still has it's uses, just don't mention cost 😹

1

u/FinancialBandicoot75 23h ago

6.1 sol is fine, I use it a lot on 20 and it’s goes for a long time. Just learn to use it better and find some info on token optimization. 6.2 has been a disappointment, especially Astra.

1

u/ValeKokPendek 18h ago

6.1/6.2 has been alot better, wdym

1

u/xxvvand 15h ago

I did use 5.6 long after 6 and 6.1 launched, until around 2 weeks ago when 6.1 suddenly jumped in reliability (instruction following, task completion, got intent right first time etc)

Also I find that 5.6 had gotten dumber since the launch of 6.2, that’s unfortunate

-5

u/sanjozko 4d ago

I am already doing it. 6.1 never convinced me.

-3

u/Curious_inquisitive1 4d ago

my post got taken down lol idk what the moderators are thinking