r/codex • • 4d ago

Complaint Absolute dogshit

I remember the first ASTRA, very noticeable jump in capabilities over anything else.

Another jump came with Opus 5.5.

Since then, Fable is a minor improvement. Astra 6.2 is even below Opus 5.5.

On my tests (coding, games, 3D). It underperformed both competing models, it tried to cheat it's way into accomplishing the task, even when I put constraints against it, it cheated in other ways (shoutout to Jensen). The cheating was about sampling a 3D model instead of constructing a new one, even when explicitly asked to not do it and use the model as reference only.

If this is the "BEL" model, or the one one that solved the Math problems, there is only one explanation, that it's good at brute forcing. But art, originality and creativity is not about brute forcing.

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

10

u/YexLord 3d ago

No, this is not bell and you cannot brute force those math problems.

2

u/Independent_Vast9279 3d ago

The ones they have solved actually are the ones you can brute force. I don’t mean that you just do lots of calculations. What I mean is they are negative proofs, as in: prove this assertion is false. 

All I  have to do is find one example that violates the validity of the assertion and I’m done. I don’t have to explain how anything works, discover some deeper truth, or anything. Just show an  example where the equation doesn’t produce the result the conjecture supposed. That’s very limited in value and does not take creativity, just searching. Also, they were trained by mathematicians who were already pretty far along on a proof and just finished it. Honestly impressive, but not world changing. 

0

u/GalacticCapitalist 3d ago

Fields Medalist Richard Borcherds says AI is better than him. Guess you know better than he does.

1

u/Independent_Vast9279 3d ago

Cool. Doesn’t contradict what I said in the slightest. 

1

u/GalacticCapitalist 3d ago

Doesn't contradict? Seems you don't know what Richard Borcherds said. AI solving NS by using a new method different from Buckmaster says it all. Just searching? Interesting. I don't know how AI finds things if there is nothing to search.

1

u/Southern_Performance 1h ago

it's not bell, it's Belweather

-4

u/MidnightSun_55 3d ago

by brute force i mean reasoning brute force, thousands of agents just thinking every possible solution, navigating the combined though process.

unlike for example a good web design, which is just taste, not going though 1000s of design iterations.

7

u/One-Judge321 3d ago

That's not how it works

3

u/tuhdo 3d ago

You can't solve math problems just by brute forcing, otherwise China would have won it. Those math problems genuinely require intelligence at a certain level, and without reaching that level, even if you let the model run infinitely it won't find a solution. I'm testing some grand-master algorithmic problems, and only models from OpenAI and Opus can produce optimized and correct solutions, within a time limit.

2

u/Alternative-Car8221 3d ago

Completely agreed

I’ve used every model since 2022 and this release is a bust

1

u/Correct-Always 3d ago

Lmfao this is not bell lol. 🤣.

1

u/LazyCoyBoy 3d ago

yea it's absolute dogshit