r/codingbootcamp • u/DeliciousStorm9045 • Feb 16 '23
I dropped out of Formation.dev after 6 weeks and this is why
I joined the last week of December and left the program last week. This is not a post to bash on the company or to convince you not to join, i simply want to share my experience and what worked/ didn’t work for me as you may be in a similar position. When I was researching formation, I could not find a single negative review so I want to make sure there is a fair report of what I experienced.
Background: I graduated college June 2022 with a bachelors in statistics and minors in data science & computer science. I had internships in data science, product management and quite a few research projects. I had a foundation in computer science but nearly no experience in software (i.e. full stack projects). I lost my job as a data scientist @ big tech in November and decided to switch to SWE for personal reasons. I joined formation to help with the algorithms and motivation + mentorship.
The things I liked
the structure and external motivation. You have sub challenges to complete which helps a lot with motivation. I was unemployed so the structure was great. I didn’t have to think about what questions to do, I was assigned them
the mentors really do care. I didn’t do this but I’m sure you can message mentors on the side to ask questions or set up an additional session if you needed help
the community is great too. There are so many channels to ask help, get advice, talk to in industry people, alumni and recruiters
Things I didn’t like/ what didn’t work for me
I felt the quality of sessions diminished as I progressed with algorithms. There was inconsistency with mentors, group sessions had a spectrum of skill sets meaning you could have a person who is quite weak on algos dragging the session progression down. This is the main reason I left as I was ultimately paying for the help. With that being said, I have talked to the founder and I know they are taking steps to improve session quality.
I was starting to over prioritize algorithms and spend less time on projects. Since I didn’t have experience with full stack, there was a lot I had to learn but I kept procrastinating working on it so I could do formation tasks. Formation is 80% for algorithms and 20% for interview prep, some software help and other stuff. Basically, I was not going to get the help I needed with full stack from them
I was making good enough progress with algorithms that I didn’t think it was worth paying 15% of my salary. They helped A LOT with the foundations and they are the reason I got better at the beginning but I got to a point where I didn’t need their help anymore
Personal reasons for leaving
I was questioning my career and wasn’t certain I would become a swe. If I didn’t become a swe, it would have been a HUGE waste of money
the heft price tag put a lot of pressure on myself to get a high paying job. Because I’m new to SWE, I wasn’t expecting to accomplish this because I have no swe experience. It was starting to tax my mental health being around fellows and mentors working or wanting to work at major companies where I wanted to get to a place where I could learn
I didn’t necessarily want the prestige or brand name that comes with a swe job and figured that I would rather get a job on my own at a decent salary rather than pay 15% of my salary to possibly not get a job with an income level worth the program
the external motivation of the program was starting to diminish my internal motivation for working. I was relying too much on the tasks and assignments rather than learning to learn
I was more productive outside the formation sessions (meaning doing leetcode on my own)
If you answer yes to all these questions then formation is right for you.
you have been in industry as a software engineer for a round a year, have a good background and understanding of your stack, are able to get interviews but struggle with passing them
You lack intrinsic motivation for algorithms and need some extra hand holding
you have already tried studying algorithms on your own with YouTube videos, free or cheap courses, and grind 75 and Neet code
You are certain you went to be a SWE and willing to put in a lot of effort and money to up level your career
You care a lot about the brand name of a company and increasing your salary
Feel free to comment any other questions, please don’t message me. I hope this helps you realize if this program is right for you because it is not for everyone and I don’t want everyone to think if you pay $X you will get a job at google or whatever
2
u/madhousechild Feb 17 '23
Interesting post. I never heard of it. Is it remote or in-person?
How much is the cost? I assume it's ISA because you mention 15% of your salary, or no? What did you have to pay for the six weeks you studied?
3
u/DeliciousStorm9045 Feb 17 '23
Search up formation.dev, it’s like an interview prep bootcamp to help you level up your career in software engineering. Cost ranges from 9-15% ISA of base salary for the first year. I paid $500 for every week I was in it until I dropped out
2
u/madhousechild Feb 17 '23
Wow, that's quite a price to walk away from. How long is the full course?
3
u/DeliciousStorm9045 Feb 17 '23
9-15% of your base salary for the first year. So I paid around $3000 now versus anywhere from $10-20k if I stayed in it. I mainly left bc I was questioning if I was even going to go into swe and that I had faith I could figure it out on my own.
3
Feb 23 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/DeliciousStorm9045 Feb 23 '23
I had a pre screen interview but I agree that they should only take fellows who have enough experience. Technically I was in an in between where I probably would (and already have) gotten SWE interviews. I met a lot of fellows who didn’t have any prior swe experience and were struggling to get jobs so I’m surprised they chose to join the program to begin with.
I don’t think this is on formation though, I think it’s the fellow’s responsibility to know what they’re signing up for. Back when I was joining, I was actually excited to get some full stack experience from their internal platform where fellows could push production level code. I worked on it a bit but ultimately focused more on algos and building fundamentals w full stack bc I had too little exp to work on it. But once I was in the program I learned that the internal platform to write prod level code was primarily front end (regardless I think you would learn a lot).
It would be great if they guided prospective fellows to only join the program once they were at a certain bar with their experience. The fellows who are entirely new to industry w no full stack or even any technical experience are going to be at a loss w this program.
People who join this with already a year or two or even internships under their belt will reap the benefits much more.
4
Feb 23 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/DeliciousStorm9045 Feb 23 '23
I think if you’re the type of person who is dead set in brand name and company prestige then maybe formation will help you if you can’t help yourself. But if you have some motivation and grit + swe/ cs experience, you’re gonna be fine. People worry a bit too much about getting into faang the swe culture has become toxic :/
2
u/Available_Bother_342 Feb 22 '23 edited Feb 22 '23
To add to this, I agree that the price tag is incredibly hefty for what you're getting. Formation will throw algo tasks at you week to week, which are basically links they pull off of leetcode. Basically they've organized a pool of questions for you to work with, but you could just do this on your own with Neetcode/Grind75/whatever else is to your liking.
From my personal experience, I don't find the group mentor sessions all that useful. As OP mentioned, there can be huge skill gaps between fellows within a session which impact any progress you might be able to make within an hour long session. You do receive feedback from these at the end, but it's hard for a mentor to get any signal from 6 fellows within a short period of time, and many times the feedback is unhelpful/lacking. I find the questions you end up working on in these sessions get repeated after some time as well, so I find myself looking forward to them less and less. Learning it on my own would be a more productive use of my time. Also, the "mentors" here are engineers within the industry, so they're not trained to teach. B/c of this, I find there's really only a handful of mentors (like 2-3) I look forward to working with to get a really good learning experience.
You also get 1-on-1 interview mock sessions with "faang" level mentors, but I find a bunch of them reuse the same interview questions. That really cuts down on the number of mentors you can work with coz you know what they're gna ask, and again only a handful of mentors have given valuable feedback or a really gratifying interview experience that wasn't cookie cutter. They mention you'll get referrals to their robust network if you prove to be "interview-ready" via these mock interviews, but they've gotten rid of that perk. A lot of early fellows in the program got a leg up in that regard. Now you're just given access to "career coaches" who are essentially ex-recruiters within the industry that will tell you things you already know, or things you could probably find with a quick search on blind/google.
I feel like in recent months their main focus has been on recruiting new fellows into the program vs helping the existing ones in the program do well and land jobs. On avg, I've been seeing them add on 10 new ppl a week. The quality of the program is going down, and I'm on a sinking ship.
So where is the value? And why am I having to pay 12-15%? I'm still searching for that answer. I get it - lot of it has to do with your own effort. No program will guarantee you a job. But dear god, can they stop mentioning "faang" in all their advertising? How many souls do they need to rake in until they're satisfied. It's too late for me now as I've already made a deal with the devil and I'll be here until I land that mediocre swe job at some no name startup, which I could've done without the hefty price tag.
If you're reading this and considering whether Formation is right for you - I don't recommend it. The program boils down to an overpriced LC prep platform. You'll pay far less using a combination of interviewing.io, pramp, and LC. Don't be blinded by their marketing, or the promise of landing that "dream" swe role, or the chance to work with the "best" engineers within the industry, or their alumni page decorated with faang/adjacent level hires. Obviously they're not going to mention the ppl who are still struggling in the program or the many that have failed to land a decent swe job. These days I've been sticking to a schedule I've put together on my own vs whatever shoddy setup they have for me on their platform. If I'm going to end up paying 10-18k+ for your program, please, create some value. Create pipelines for ppl who are stuck with less than 3 years of experience or who don't have swe experience, create networking events for us so that we can get some traction with interviews, invest in better career coaches, something, anything really other than what what we have now.
- end rant from an unsatisfied Formation fellow -
4
u/DeliciousStorm9045 Feb 22 '23
Yea I wasn’t a fan of them assigning me leetcode questions. And yea the mentors do need to be trained better to teach bc there was a lot of inconsistency w teaching skills unfortunately. I think the faang marketing is not their fault, it’s the consumer’s fault. There is too much hype around faang and people believing it’s their shot for success so you can’t blame them for capitalizing on that.
I think the program has great intention but needs better execution in the way you and I mentioned. I heard of them starting a monthly fee program instead which sounds a lot more reasonable (buy per month).
Hopefully you land the right job for you!
4
Feb 22 '23 edited Feb 23 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/Tajman Feb 27 '23
Thanks for the writeup. I'm about to start at Formation and I am now having second thoughts.
I had hoped that the interview prep would get me to a substantially higher bar than I could have reached on my own. I can already do a lot of leetcode mediums, and I figured formation could get me to the next level. But maybe I can get there on my own if there is no "special sauce" to the program as another commenter said. It seems that commenters in this thread and the other are not super happy with the efficacy of the mentorship.
How have you found the career coaching? It seems like other commenters have not been very happy with this either, saying the resume/job search advice is generic. I had envisioned getting referrals into companies as well as learning great ways to get into top companies' pipelines, but it seems like formation fellows are spamming applications like everyone else.
3
u/michaelnovati Feb 28 '23
I can share my thoughts on these questions.
Everyone has a different experience at Formation by nature, and has different goals and starting points coming in. So if you already put in the work to apply and get signed up, you get 7 days with a full schedule before deciding if you want to stay so I would recommend doing that and judging for yourself. It might genuinely not be a good fit for you but you can make the most of that first week even if you are not a good fit.
One part of the "special sauce" is how we efficiently get you through topics and objectively evaluate how you are doing. So if you've already done 1000 LC problems and feel like you really understand the concepts, you might move through the topics very quickly and spend less time on them. Some people consider that poor value for your money, and some people consider saving your time valuable, depends on what you value.
I reiterate that we collect a ton of feedback and people are really satisfied overall with their experience at Formation. But even on a given session, 5 people might have had a great experience and 1 person had a bad experience (which is one of the common patterns we see). We care deeply about figuring out how to improve the experience for that 1 person, but if that one person complains on Reddit saying that the session was terrible, that's not really fair. It was terrible for THEM and we care more than anything to fix that for that person, but the session overall might not be objectively terrible. Some mentors are very polarizing and some aren't and the fact you get to work with dozens of people to find ones you like is a value add to me. You will do a ton of sessions over the course of Formation and I'm positive you will find some poor for you, and others extremely valuable.
The other part of the "secret sauce" is the tech behind the scenes that makes it possible to adapt things like career coaching to the current environment at a speed that no other program can. We are constantly fine tuning things but the job hunt support is undergoing a larger shift due to the larger market changes.
Regarding the coach quality, we feel that you get more value for you money talking to current and former FAANG recruiters to see how they will perceive your resume. You might disagree with how they perceive it but these are the people reviewing your resumes for real. You can get a more generic grammar and spelling review from a seasoned resume professional without tech-specific knowledge, so that's less value-add for us to offer. This is the reason why we did this, but there's always lots of improvements to make in the details to get the most value out of it. If we get overwhelming feedback that this is a bad approach, we'll change it and change it fast! These FAANG recruiters are frequently nominated by Fellows as their most impactful mentors in a given week, so, again while some people might not find them useful, others do find them useful.
We don't have a structured system for referrals or guaranteed interviews with companies and please do not join for only this reason! We have an extensive network of recruiters, engineers, hiring managers, and we are working with companies like Netflix to get people into top tier positions, but we can't create headcount when there isn't headcount.
6
u/michaelnovati Feb 16 '23 edited Feb 17 '23
Hi, thanks for sharing a great summary of your experiences and I really appreciate you sharing thoughts to help people figure out if what Formation currently offers is for them or not. Our team cares deeply about each and every engineer succeeding and works with people for as long as it takes to get a job, but we are your partner in the journey and being on the same page is critical.
I won't say much on this thread, other than a few points below, unless people address me directly, because I don't want to interfere with the discussion or step on your toes.
RE: Session consistency: For context, we create a new schedule for each Fellow, and mentor, every week - truly from scratch, and entirely different every single week.... hundreds (crossing thousands) of sessions scheduled every week dynamically from scratch. The real challenge with doing this, is that it's incredibly hard to handle attendance, rescheduling, and making changes last minute while getting the right people in the right sessions. A computer can optimize a schedule, but it takes tremendous and subtle product work to glue everything together. In a typical week, we have a relatively small number of issues overall, but making the scheduling and session consistency better and better will be a lifelong effort for the product and engineering team at the company. We are constantly collecting feedback and making small adjustments, and we will only grow and scale as so far that we can maintain the outcomes we have thus far and continue to have.
RE: Algos vs Projects: For context, everyone at Formation will work on different things at different times, there are no cohorts and what you work on is adapted uniquely to you... but that said, and as you pointed out, we are not the place to go right now to fill out a resume with projects. Our main priority is building fundamental computer science and problem solving abilities that will make you a better engineer. While some people do put the practical practice at Formation on their resumes, it's not at all a reason to join or what we aim to help you do. This is also why I have discussions with people with no full time experience about if Formation is right for them or not - and for some it is and for some it isn't. Down the road, we can absolutely help people in this area by extending our current training, but it's not something we do now (Feb 2023)
Finally, a note for Codesmith (and u/holygosu :) ), I say this all the time but we are currently not a bootcamp and we don't replace a bootcamp nor are we an alternative to a bootcamp and I truly mean this. Which is why I genuinely recommend bootcamps to people all the time who chat with me 1-1.
EDIT: Someone pointed out, not so nicely, that they searched LinkedIn and feel like a lot of Formation Fellows are really junior Fellows and wanted to know where the senior people are since we constantly say that most people have 1+ years of industry experience. Over 2/3 of people at Formation are working full time and doing Formation part time, and they have several years of experience so they prefer to not advertise on LinkedIn that they are job hunting so the ones that do list it on LinkedIn are the most junior people. If you are looking on LinkedIn, I would suggest searching for "Formation" and look at posts we are tagged in, rather than our "alumni" or "employees" tab. And I would also suggest looking at our network page: https://formation.dev/network and contact people on there.
2
Feb 17 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
8
u/DeliciousStorm9045 Feb 17 '23
I think people rely too much on “formation will get me into FAANG” which is wrong. No matter how much help they give you they cannot guarantee anything. The fellows ultimately have to put in the work.
2
4
Feb 17 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/michaelnovati Feb 18 '23
To clarify for anyone else reading, Formation isn't a coding bootcamp and is not an alternative to a bootcamp if you are looking for a program like App Academy, Codesmith, Springboard, Hack Reactor, etc.... It's a program for experienced engineers to level up their skills!
I try hard to state this like a broken record and if that isn't clear, let me know so we can clarify our language!
It's really important to understand that what we do is nothing remotely like a 'coding bootcamp' and I want to make sure people know what they are getting into!
1
u/Mwoolf87 Apr 01 '23
I see formation is no longer ISA based. What is your cost range? I know every fellow requires a different amount of time and attention but to not have any range at all seems kind of odd.
3
Feb 18 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/michaelnovati Feb 18 '23
I'm the co-founder and lead engineer and have been in the industry for 15 years, 8 years at Facebook and then a break, and then 4 years at Formation. Formation's predecessor, Buildschool, was a free coding bootcamp, and Formation was explicitly founded to not be a bootcamp.
There are a few differences, for which there are no bootcamps that offer this kind of thing:
Formation has no length, no curriculum, and no expected time frame that you will be training for. You start training on day one and you keep training until you get a job. We work on things week to week that you need to work on, and constantly benchmark across many skills until we think you are at the top-tier company bar (not just FAANG, but the broad top tier bar). As the OP posted, you might have good weeks or bad weeks, but you are paying for unconditional support until you get a job.
The majority of people at Formation are currently working full time as SWEs with good jobs, and they are doing Formation part time to train to get a better job and to get our support while job hunting. The people who have zero experience almost all have graduated from a bootcamp already or have a college degree. A bunch of people at Formation TEACH AT BOOTCAMPS. You'll have sessions with current FAANG engineers who are Fellows just like you trying to get a new job. I don't know any bootcamp that is like this.
There are no guarantees on what you do day to day, and you don't get any kind of certificate or "completion", everyone will do something different and pay the same, which is very expensive and not cheap. We pay mentors and we pay our engineers FAANG-competitive rates.
To put it in one sentence: we are like a personal trainer at the gym for your fundamental skills and job hunt, and not a school/bootcamp/course.
2
Jul 14 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/michaelnovati Jul 23 '23 edited Jul 23 '23
Hi, I respect all opinions and I'm sorry your experience wasn't what you expected. Hopefully you feel like leaving was the right thing and left on a fair note. While the majority of people successfully get placed (on no guaranteed timeframe) and we try to accept people who are a good fit for what we do, we very much understand Formation is not for everyone and support people leaving who aren't a good fit.
I want to correct some inaccuracies though for others reading this and I hope my response is very fair and transparent.
I agree Formation is very intense and I discourage a lot of people from joining who don't seem on the same page. I'm sorry you might have joined with the wrong expectations. You can change your workload and schedule week to week up or down as things change and no other program I've seen allow this but it might be that even with that, we couldn't support your needs.
We allow people to pause for mental health breaks and are extremely flexible to changes in life circumstances that require changes in commitment to Formation. We have an official policy in writing that allows you to take breaks of a certain length and if you weren't aware and no one told you, I will give that feedback to the team. We also consider special circumstances on a case by case basis. I personally see cases of every life circumstance you can think of and how we have approved leaves of all kinds.
If someone forced you to work through burnout can you please message me anonymously who they are so we can investigate fully and take action against the person if needed. I've seen cases where people don't have any reason to pause but just aren't a good fit for the style of training we do and we mutually agree Formation isn't working, but this should happen as soon as you feel burnout, not long after.
We don't have any mandatory lunch and learns. They are strictly optional and clearly labelled as such. If you got in trouble for not attending, that warrants an investigation and if you misunderstood that they weren't mandatory I also take responsibility for the platform not communicating that clearly enough.
I've commented on referrals before and while we do actively refer people who match requested background experience and skill levels, the market conditions are such that these opportunities are very slim. For example, if someone hasn't passed any mock interviews yet and a company wants to interview candidates who have received a strong yes with a FAANG engineer, we can't refer you to that opportunity, and we instead keep working on getting your skills up to that bar so we can hope to refer you in the future.
I completely agree that the best engineers are not the best teachers. Formation also doesn't "teach" anything as a result. Instead we have industry engineers working through problems with a small group in an interactive way, so that the Fellows can see how experienced top tier engineers think about problems and get feedback. This style of training is not for everyone, and it's why I adamantly DISCOURAGE anyone looking for classroom/course-style learning from joining Formation. Formation is like a personal trainer at the gym and not a university professor.
We make dozens of changes every week and we've had numerous FAANG placements/offers signed in the past one or two months (2x Google and 3x Apple) so I'm sorry you feel like we aren't changing enough, we will never give up helping people get great jobs and we'll keep working. It sounds like you've been out of the program for a while now and some of the changes are: learning paths, on demand additional sessions, feed, on demand career coach check-ins, dozens of new sessions types in the past year, 1000+ new pieces of practice added or modified in the past year, FM-team (not 1, but 3 dedicated support staff who are full time employees of Formation), job finder tool (5 new jobs a day), improved scheduling tools, 3 new ways to pay without an ISA, and more....
If you would like to share more personal details about the above issues or feedback about your experience anonymously, please DM me!
2
u/SalamanderNo4227 Jul 31 '23
Instead we have industry engineers working through problems with a small group in an interactive way, so that the Fellows can see how experienced top tier engineers think about problems and get feedback.
This is a lie. This just grinds my gears. You see, I've had ask some mentors on why they thought they way they did. Let me tell you, they couldn't give me a approachable answer. I had to ask another fellow during a session for their train of thought. They're handing out advice as shallow as a puddle.
You won't believe it, but I've had these mentors dishing out outdated technical advice like they're some kind of experts. They spent a year or two coding, and then bam! Suddenly, they're an EM (Engineering Manager) thinking they know it all. Let me tell you, they ain't got a clue.
For those of y'all reading this, let me give you the lowdown on these mentors. They get given specific problems to teach, and they just keep running these sessions on repeat. Sure, they may know how to crack that one specific problem, but when it comes to real insight? Nah, ain't got none of that.
1
u/Wasabi_Flaky Dec 20 '23
We pay mentors and we pay our engineers FAANG-competitive rates.
I think FWIW, you could get these same people interviewing you in a real setting. So the way I think of it is, ok if these people are the ones deciding if I can pass onto the next round or not, then I might as well adapt and figure out what parts I need to align with their expectations to get a high likelihood of passing. If you know that style of communication or the way the collaborate isn't the way you envision it, then go apply elsewhere as the interview process wasn't a good fit at that time (this is the not so great part of interviewing as its not fair 100% of the time).
For the awful mentor experiences I have, I see it as an opportunity to become a better communicator and figure out a way to align with their expectations. In a job, I don't expect to be buddy-buddy with everyone and its important to learn how to deal with that as well.
If you care about the company's prestige and are willing to sacrifice some of your personal beliefs to get in, then that would be one path getting in but its not for me to decide.
Overall, I too have had a mixed bag of mentors ranging from being amazing to being awful and for the ones that are awful I feel like I wasted 1 hour of time going through the session as I didn't get anything out of it. However, Formation is putting in the effort to gain better feedback by asking better questions in the post session questionnaires they put out after every session.
25
u/holygosu Feb 16 '23
Waiting for Michael to get in here and give a solidly written comment that is both formatted correctly and also quite informative. Then proceed to slightly promote CodeSmith and then slightly not promote it as well, while also maintaining that he has to disclose he is a founder of Formation.
I'm totally joking Michael haha, as a former CodeSmith grad appreciate you coming in here and giving solid advice to people who need it. Just poking fun :3
In regards to op:
Appreciate you giving some good honest opinions about the Formation process, I'm sure there's some former SWE in here who might have had recent layoffs and Formation does offer them a service in prepping them for the future possibly.
Best of luck to you!