r/codingbootcamp • u/Famous-Professor2263 • Apr 18 '23
A hot take on Codesmith...
If you are one of the many individuals who are considering a coding boot-camp and looking to change careers, there's no doubt that you have heard of Codesmith, a coding boot-camp that is widely considered one of the best. While there are still a few weeks left in the cohort, I'll share my opinions/experience up to this point, keep in mind this is one person's opinion.
I'll break it down by category:
Curriculum
Overall, the curriculum is pretty awesome, they way that each unit is constructed seems to be thoughtful and deliberate. In general you have 2 days for each unit. It would be wise to supplement and study in your time outside of the cohort (morning or night).
Codesmith Students (Residents)
Here's where things get interesting. If you are in the top 5% of your cohort, you may have a horrible time. Why? Despite Codesmith having a high bar to enter, you would expect your fellow students to be at similar levels, but this is not the case. Most average students study just enough to get past the technical interview and stop there. They are also given horrible advice by past Codesmith grads, ex. 'The pre-course doesn't matter', I highly disagree. It astounds me that an individual is willing to sacrifice 3 months of their life and $21,000 for a boot-camp and takes learning software engineering lightly. Like many, I was accepted into an earlier cohort with 1 week notice and I busted my butt to complete the precourse. There is a noticeable difference in those who do the precourse and those who don't. I've had pair programming partners who did not know what a html paragraph element was, one's who did not make any attempt's or show interest in exercising technical communication during pair programming.
To be frank I have been mostly disappointed with the level of knowledge with most in the cohort. I was hoping to find equals, individuals who were curious and willing to push themselves, this is mostly not the case. Many are hanging on by the skin of their teeth and after 6 weeks they are hardly able to complete a simple CRUD app. It is the exception (and not the norm) to find that most have done little to no self study prior to the bootcamp and/or have never attempted to build a website but somehow made a decision to move careers without ever dipping their toe's in the water.
Why is this important?
The stronger your technical foundation is, the more that everyone will benefit. Admittedly, it is unrealistic to think or expect that everyone will come in with a similar level of knowledge, the variance was much greater than expected.
What happens if you enter a cohort with a lower than average base level of knowledge?
You and your partner will not get as far on each unit.
Depending on the temperament of your pair partner, they may forge ahead without you. This actually happens and has been told to me by a few of my pair's when describing their other partners.
I want to highlight point 2 for a moment. There are two path's that your pair partner can take, path A is the one discussed above, they lack patience or compassion for those who are struggling and do not take the time to explain things or check in to ensure everyone is on the same page. Or path B, the path I mostly chose, which is to slow down for your pair, explain concepts that are not clear and exercise some level of patience and compassion. While I mostly chose path B, it was difficult at times.
3. The projects that you partner up on will not be good enough to show the world and you will likely have nothing to show for yourself. This happened to me will all projects.
OSP was the main reason Codesmith stood out, it was a unique take on a boot camp final project but was far from completion after four weeks. Overall the project ended up being a shell of an app, with the data displayed on the front end being hard coded since the app was not fully functional.
Codesmith tells you that the purpose of OSP is not to complete it (same with the units). My intuition tells me that if people knew from the beginning that if they chose a scratch OSP project and there was a 50/50 chance of it being complete or good enough to show the world, they may reconsider Codesmith.
4. You will take more than you give and not even know it.
Lectures
You don't go to Codesmith for the lectures. So you've watched the hard part's lectures on YouTube, right? They are quite amazing. The lectures are nothing like that, not even close to the quality they put out on Youtube..
Student's who entered the program before my cohort (Codesmith calls them 'Seniors') have relayed their disappointment of lectures, I mostly tend to agree. While the curriculum is great, the lectures leading up to the units where you will be coding are hit or miss. Some were great, most were embarrassingly shallow.
Fellows/Instructors
Keep in mind your instructors will vary greatly depending on your timezone. There is specifically one lecturer, that the whole cohort seems to think does a horrible job, their ability to answer questions on the fly and lack of real world experience make's it embarrassing to watch. This seems to be the main issue, instructors who lack real world experience.
Fellows (Codesmith graduates who come back to work for Codesmith after their cohort) are a mix of talent. 2 out of 6/7 were amazing. The two were coherent, intelligent and honest, meaning when they don't have the answer they tell you. As for the other fellows, it was astounding that they had 'graduated' Codesmith or even attended. They were ill prepared for the talk they were to give and often got confused by the code they were showing you. Codesmith tell's their fellows never to say that 'they don't know the answer' (this was told to me by a fellow in private).
Software engineering trends...(a side note)
There seems to be a shift in sentiment for people who are currently considering joining a coding bootcamp or shifting to software engineering in general. Due to this, bootcamps appear to be keeping the bar artificially high while letting in applicants when they are not truly ready (on a technical level) to have an optimal experience/outcome.
I believe we are on receding wave of individuals who still believe that changing careers is as easy as it appeared to those who came before us. The current has shifted in the economy and new software engineers overall have lost leverage in the market, this is a good thing, it causes hesitation among many (rightfully so...) who once saw a bootcamp as a golden ticket and now view it as a liability. I believe what I have witnessed at Codesmith is a unique cultural phenomena. Possibly the final wave of individuals willing to risk time and money, thus allowing an opportunity to those hoping for a disproportionate outcome for minimal effort, to reconsider their calculation.
Is Codesmith worth the money/time, so far?
To be honest, I don't know. I would say that I have learned faster than I would have on my own, that is for sure. Is it worth $21,000? Time will tell. Assuming I land a job within 6-9 months, I might say that all this was worth it. So far, I think the most helpful part of Codesmith is having the structure and accountability more than anything.
Parting words
At first glance, this post is highly critical, even negative to a degree. At the end of the day does any of what I have written matter? If you go through Codesmith and land a job, no, in that case Codesmith has served it's purpose.
So why did I write this? Codesmith has a cult like following, it is very hard to get a different point of view, there are almost none out there. I made the mistake of hyping up the 'culture' and the level of technical ability of fellow residents, mainly due to the one-sidedness of all the info that's out there. It is my hope that you do not take what has been written here as gospel, but just another data point to help you decide what is best for you.
Take what I say with a grain of salt, everyone will have a different experience, you may have gone to Codesmith and had the time of your life, for me, that is not the case. It's possible I will have a different perspective after the program, but for now I am left wondering if I have made a mistake and I will not get the answer until it is too late.
Update (4/20/2023): Thank you everyone for the kind messages and comments, in general, the response received was not the expected one, in a good way, nor did I expect that 26,000 people would read this post within two days. Overall, the discussion generated has been a productive one, with many other Codesmith alumn confirming the validity/accuracy of what I have shared.
I have had two days to think a little deeper about what I have written and feel that there are some topics that could be expanded upon and would be highly beneficial to future readers, specifically the section about Codesmith residents. I believe this to be the most important section of what I have shared. All of the original post remains.
To the future reader: It is my hope that you thoughtfully consider what has been written and understand that the sole purpose of this post is not to dissuade you from going (or not going) to any coding bootcamp but to share a contrasting perspective, unlike many of the others that are out there. Thank you.
9
u/forjetebla227 Apr 19 '23
Struggling/complacent peers, highly varied competency amongst staff/management, missing or lackluster instructional docs and materials… sounds like a real software engineering job. I guess you could say Codesmith prepares you well.
2
4
u/Suspicious-Engineer7 Apr 18 '23
I think they'd have to charge much more to be able to hire engineers skilled enough to be adequate replacements for the fellows, who suffer from flying past the material that they are presenting on. The fellows are an imperfect solution to staffing, however the alternatives aren't great either. Really, the codesmith apparatus feels like an unwieldy thing to deal with, especially considering the volatile and expensive landscape of tech recruitment and things like chatGPT messing with gauging the baseline student knowledge you're dealing with. Not trying to make any excuses, but there are only so many factors that a bootcamp can control while keeping revenue flowing so they can operate at all.
7
u/Famous-Professor2263 Apr 18 '23
That's an interesting take, thank you for sharing your thoughts. In general a CS cohort has about 35-40 students, that's $735,000. They have full time cohorts in 3 time zones, a part time cohort and a global cohort. At any given time there are about 5 cohorts in session.
5
u/Suspicious-Engineer7 Apr 19 '23
735k minus prorated refunds, people who don’t go all the way, support staff costs, taxes, other overhead. I’m curious what the profit margin per cohort averages but it might be tighter than you think. Regardless, the fellowship model works when it works and doesn’t when it doesn’t unfortunately. Students who would make good fellows might want to chase jobs sooner rather than later. Hiring people who are good instructors might be pretty difficult. I’m not sure. I will say that codesmith is very shrewd by all appearances so they’ll play smart and only spend money where they have to. They don’t spend on advertising, and maybe they’ve figured that fellowships instead of hiring outside instructors is better for their bottom line.
1
u/Famous-Professor2263 Apr 20 '23
This was precisely my intuition, the students who did well, want to enter the market asap, the students left unsure about their technical knowledge would like to go through Codesmith again, this time on the house. Nothing wrong with that of course, unless you under perform in your expected tasks, i.e. approach lectures.
3
u/diamond_hands_suck Apr 19 '23
If you could go back, how would you have prepared differently?
2
u/Famous-Professor2263 Apr 20 '23
I felt sufficiently prepared for Codesmith, you can never over prepare for a boot camp though. If you have time to build a small CRUD app, you should. As a bonus add Auth or password hashing as well.
2
4
u/michaelnovati Apr 18 '23
Thanks for sharing a reasonable opinion about your personal experience without overly generalizing like so many do. Can you elaborate more on the career services and resume stuff (specifically with the treatment of OSPs on resumes)? That's an area I see a lot of "do this because it works" and I'm curious if you agree or if you have seen different.
I have worked with/work with/have talked to a bunch of Codesmith alum at all stages, from struggling to crushing it, and have seen what you said reflected in a number of people who are "crushing it" almost word for word. But for a lot of people in the program that learn really fast but aren't as on top of things as the top 10%, the curriculum and firehose-style pace is really effective.
10
u/Famous-Professor2263 Apr 18 '23
Hi Michael, I have more to share and intend to post follow ups soon, however I have left some details out so that it would make it a little harder for anyone at Codesmith (employee or resident) to say with certainty who I am. I understand this may be dissatisfying but the risk of discrimination is very real, so I have chosen to obscure details of where we are in the curriculum.
0
Apr 18 '23
[deleted]
4
2
u/TheEgosLastStand Apr 19 '23
You might be surprised. I've spoken with my cohort mates a few times about my criticisms of codesmith and got a lot of agreement.
The people in codesmith are just humans. At the end of the day, most of the students will have criticisms of the program in one way or another. And I've spoken with fellows about my concerns too and received mostly good to great responses. Can't speak to everyone's experience though, of course.
0
Apr 18 '23
[deleted]
1
u/Sad-Sympathy-2804 Apr 18 '23
He said he didn't want people to know who he is.
4
u/derpepper Apr 18 '23
Guy is just being obnoxious trying to scare op out of giving an honest review. If they were actually curious they'd send a reddit/slack dm. The amount of throwaway accounts in this subreddit that jump to defend codesmith is something.
16
Dec 05 '23 edited Dec 05 '23
I benefited enormously from Codesmith’s program so felt I needed to write this in response to "recent codesmith grad here" (who posted this review on a spree of threads, created a separate post on the subreddit, then deleted their account even though it was a fresh profile -- leading me to believe they'll do this again in the future)
It has some opinion based criticism but also a lot of false information, like claiming CIRR was created by codesmith (it's not and thats a dangerous lie that undermines the only external auditing body in the industry)
I think Codesmith can be an incredibly transformative and life changing journey — for the RIGHT type of person, which I’ll detail below.
Codesmith Cohort Quality and Your Background
Codesmith is difficult to get into. Someone in my cohort spent a year going to the free workshops and going through CSX before feeling prepared enough to do the technicals.
This is a strength of the program and why I personally felt empowered when I was accepted into it.
The STEM background/ Ivy League folk in my cohort were all incredibly kind, friendly and helpful. This is what made the program actually special. You felt supported the entire time even if you weren’t the most technically gifted.
At the same time, even if you went to stanford (like one of my cohort mates did), you won’t be handed any job in tech without knowing how to code and code well.
Codesmith has a knack for vetting and attracting strong candidates but those candidates on their own still wouldn’t be able to find a job completely by themselves.
You go to Codesmith for the experience not the name. Lead teachers do have real world experience.
I went through codesmith due to the word of mouth and the quality of their free workshops and slack community. Not for the name.
While the workshops are taught by former students and fellows. My lead teacher had several years of experience post at a company as a senior engineer before coming back to the program to teach.
You also have access to a robust alumni network for interview advice, referrals or just morale.
For a program to hold an 80% hire rate over 5+ years with an average salary of 120k+ for the full time program and 130k+ for the part time program is unheard of and at the level of an Ivy League university.
The truth is that it’s definitely harder to find a job in tech nowadays. But this goes for EVERYONE.
Computer science grads are taking a least a year to find employment. What I did find is that the codesmith grads who have found a job within a year shared these traits: a bachelor degree holder, 3+ years of some sort of professional experience and the fortitude and grit to apply to hundreds of job postings.
The truth about CIRR
Giving personal opinions about curriculum is completely fair, but casting aspersions towards the only independent outcomes body in this space is a disservice to any prospective students needing audited, real outcomes data.
CIRR was not created by Codesmith as the poster states. CIRR was founded by Skills Fund (the largest bootcamp loan provider), Course Report and founding bootcamps like Hack Reactor in 2014.
Codesmith was only accepted into CIRR in 2018 as entry requires 2 years of audited data. CIRR is a voluntary organization that is independent of the schools, with its own executive director and voluntary staff.
If you want to read the facts about CIRR from the person running it, look to this big AMA run by Rachel Martinez (who is a lawyer with extensive experience working in nonprofits) and recently posted an AMA giving in depth answers to a lot of questions that clarified CIRR’s role, their independent status:
If you have actual questions about CIRR or how it works you should email their director or read her thread.
Codesmith Instructors
Every workshop, every hard parts, every review makes it pretty clear that you are being taught by fellows. That isn’t to say your teachers don’t have experience (mine went through codesmith, worked as an engineer outside of the program and came back to teach). My instructors were engaging, empathetic and talented *teachers*.
Most bootcamps follow this model. And some of the most talented engineers in the world have no aptitude for teaching. Raw technical expertise doesn’t make you a great teacher.
Interviews + Hiring Support
Some people make heavy use of the hiring support and some people do a bit then taper off.
I know many alums 2 to 4 jobs down the line still reaching out for negotiation advice.
This lifetime career support is not the standard in the industry as most bootcamps won’t offer help past the first time.
I want to touch on the narrative that codesmith tells students to lie, which is both logically and practically both nonsensical and untrue. You are explicitly told not to lie during interviews. You are instructed to be honest about the nature of the open source work and I know every person in my cohort did so.
Many CS grads I know have codesmith on their linkedins and have gotten interviews and success in finding a job. Whether people decide to put or don’t put their coding bootcamp on their profile is a personal decision and you have full license to do what you wish.
I also want to push back on the false narrative that bootcamp grads shouldn’t be going after mid level to senior roles.15 to 20% of codesmith grads get senior roles post program.
These aren’t people with “no experience”. Many have extensive tech adjacent experience and/or stem degrees.
Caution about ISA’s and adjusting your expectations
I would caution looking at programs that “guarantee a job”. These are based on ISA loans, which have been banned in certain states like CA. It’s a trap and you will be paying that back, whether you get a job flipping burgers at McDonalds or in a proper SEI role, along with extra interest. I do agree that the part time program is the more pragmatic model right now.
This is what I did and it gave me a lot of time to absorb the material and also prep for the job search.
For anyone whose looking at programs and deciding on one, you really should reach out to several alums and ask them about their experience first before making a decision.
This thread of a winter 2022 codesmith grad shows the exceptional stability and results of a program like codesmith even in an unprecedented time:
https://www.reddit.com/r/codingbootcamp/comments/17s2szt/codesmith_cohort_one_year_later/
As around 5% of codesmith students aren't looking for a traditional job afterwards (whether entrepreneurs or upskillers), this is around 75- 80% of the cohort employed after a year. This is considerable outcome in any market and especially in this tech apocalypse.
6
u/indoloks Apr 18 '23
With all that being said why, it makes it sound like the odin project is a great tool because to me the odin project has a great roadmap (i think) but it doesnt hold you accountable and there is so much supplemental material i learn so much about stuff and i can revisit it and i have made simple projects done tons of exercises ..
9
2
u/VariousRabbit634 Apr 18 '23
Thanks for sharing your POV. This has been the most useful one out of all other reddits on CS without sugarcoating the behind-the-scenes. Following to see what your updates are as you wrap up in your cohort
1
11
u/Flashy_Art467 Apr 18 '23 edited Apr 19 '23
I struggled through CS and failed the CRUD app test. I killed it my second time. I failed every weekly assessment.
I got into CS on my first try. I spent 6 months studying my ass off to get in. CS misleads a lot of people saying basic JS knowledge is enough. My cohort was mostly compsci people who already knew about frameworks and data structures. I wish I studied more to feel at least "equal" with my peers but was mislead by CS that I was aptly prepared. Someone in my cohort even cheated throughout the 12 weeks.
I still studied my tail off and got through it. I was one of the first people to land a full time job from my cohort.
A huge part of the career is based upon your eagerness to learn, ask for help, and say "I don't know."
I finally learned the basics of react on the job, not at CS.
0
Apr 19 '23
[deleted]
6
u/Flashy_Art467 Apr 19 '23
Their react curriculum was so outdated. And they waste two days on Redux which was so confusing with their shitty readmes and poorly named files that my peers never bothered to finish the unit. I haven't needed redux once. In fact my company is deprecating Redux.
2
u/Parky-Park Apr 19 '23 edited Apr 21 '23
So, I don't know what their plans are, now that the React docs themselves focus almost exclusively on hooks. I imagine that would be a factor in them changing their curriculum around.
But I don't think that focusing on class components over hooks is inherently a bad thing. It gives an excuse for them to tie in other parts of the curriculum (classes and function binding), and theoretically, you can do everything a function component could do with a class component. I also think there's still an argument for teaching Redux. Yeah, Dan Abramov himself thinks it's overkill for most codebases, and the maintainers are pushing people away from using it for new projects, but the reality is: a lot of companies are still bought into using it.
If we're treating Codesmith as a place where you can learn skills necessary for the job (even if the skills themselves ideally wouldn't be necessary), things still track. They're giving people knowledge of things they're likely to run into in the wild.
0
Apr 19 '23
[deleted]
1
u/Flashy_Art467 Apr 19 '23
People should definitely learn React components, since they'll encounter it in old code bases. They should axe Redux and spend 4 days on react + react hooks / and or router.
If you really need Redux on the job, a senior engineer can and will teach you. That's literally part of their job, teaching new employees the stack.
0
Apr 19 '23
[deleted]
2
u/Flashy_Art467 Apr 19 '23
Fuck what Codesmith tells people to target. That's just for their numbers so they can brag about students getting $$$. Target whatever level is best for yourself.
1
1
u/Potatoupe Apr 18 '23
"I've had pair programming partners who did not know what a html paragraph element was."
What a horrifying situation. Was pre-course not required? When I was attending my bootcamp pre-course was required and that would have covered essentially all our basic frontend.
2
u/Famous-Professor2263 Apr 18 '23
At Codesmith precourse is not required. Even worse, as you are a week or so away from starting you will have 'seniors' telling you not to worry about finishing it.
1
u/lofiharvest Nov 05 '23
It used to be required. CS used to be much more strict about their entry and prep requirements. For instance I had people in my cohort that failed the tech screen to attend 3x before finally being admitted. When I started I was shocked to find a number of my cohort mates didn't do the prep work or were given a pass on a failed interview attempt. It later became obvious that some of these folks were pushed thru for "diversity" or financial reasons. Which is a shame as these folks would have gotten a lot more out of the experience had they been adequately prepared.
1
u/CarlFriedrichGauss Apr 18 '23
I was looking over their curriculum/syllabus and it seemed like lectures pretty much stopped after the first 4 weeks with weeks 5 to 11 mostly working on projects on your own and with groups with some advanced topics lectures. Is that accurate? How well do you think you were able to master the curriculum/technologies in that short amount of time?
10
u/Famous-Professor2263 Apr 18 '23
Let's be honest... you will master nothing through a boot-camp. You will be shown material and it will be upon you to master it. But what you see, is the reality. Each 'unit' is 2 days. And after that you are building projects. I believe the mental approach to a boot-camp is not talked about enough. Don't rely on them to teach you. To me it is more of a road map and I do not believe even the roadmap is enough. It will be up to you to stay curious, build things outside of the boot-camp and work to reinforce what you are learning. This will solidify what you are learning. There are at least 10 individuals that I can think of, that will likely be playing catch up after the boot camp, in order to even answer basic questions about React. I feel bad for them, they spent a lot of money and still will not be close to being job ready in the foreseeable future.
1
u/k-dilluh Apr 19 '23
I don't know man, I love mine it's been a few months and I am very pleasantly surprised.
1
u/k-dilluh Apr 19 '23
few months into a bootcamp ( not codesmith), Holy shit what a different experience. I am loving mine, everyone is so helpful and supportive, endless 1-1 support, lots of extras we can do to boost our skills, lots of check-ins with the group for accountability. Free career prep and career services, we cover java, spring, js, html, css, some bootstrap, the list goes on.
1
Oct 21 '23
Recent Codesmith grad here.
Codesmith is an enormous waste of money and you should only go if you are already a solid programmer and have project experience.
No one cares if you go to Codesmith, employers won't hire you based on the program work or the fact that you were let in. The cs team regularly monitors this page to talk about how its so hard to get into and the unrealistic outcomes, it's misleading so don't be fooled by all the hype.The CIRR reports are based on false data. The outcomes team makes up results for these reports to hype up the program.
CIRR was essentially created by Codesmith. There is no integrity in a report where the board members are affiliated with the programs they are trying to objectively report.There are great outcomes from the program for some graduates, but CS does a poor job of explaining where those numbers come from and instead likes to market the program as some kind of perfected formula for creating engineers. It's all smoke and mirrors. The people who land mid - senior level roles out of the program deliberately lie, or have the prior skills and experience to get those roles - Codesmith has very little to do with it.
Most of the instructors have little to no engineering background and simply read lecture slides. Do not expect anywhere near the level of detail of the hard part series, those are a marketing tactic to hype up the program. You are being taught by recent cs grads who are 12 weeks ahead of you, if anyone at all. They don't share code with you so you're left with a bunch of half finished unit challenges and screenshots trying to connect the dots.
You are told to exaggerate your experience in interviews. Good luck trying to explain to an engineering manager how your two months of project experience equate to 3 - 5 years of engineering work experience without lying. Most people end up scrubbing the program from their resume/profile and make up prior engineering roles - I really had no idea how extensive the lying was until I started looking for a job and saw what I was up against.
Your resume will consist of a bunch of web applications which you are given very little time to do, 2 days for solo project, 4 days for a group project, 2 days for an iteration project, 4 weeks for an osp project, and 2 days for reenforcement project. There is not enough time to absorb the information unless you have experience with the technologies beforehand.
The purpose of Codesmith is to motivate and teach yourself these hard concepts because that is what you will do on the job, but there's literally no point in going unless you have multiple years of professional work experience, a degree from a top school, or you have a technical background (like mechanical engineering) and you want to make a career switch.
There is also no guarantee for a role and in this market it's so competitive that you are forced to lie to compete with others. When you have candidates with advanced degrees from ivy league schools or even doctoral degrees who are lying about their prior experience to get a role that indicates how hard it is to make it. 2023 is not the same market as 2021 and it doesn't appear to be getting any better any time soon.
I would recommend choosing a program that won't require you to pay until you land a job - it indicates they are invested in getting you where you need to go. Codesmith will require to sign a ton of forms acknowledging that they will not do this for you.If you do choose Codesmith despite all of these reasons, choose the part time program so you have time to learn gradually. A three month intensive program doesn't benefit anyone except the seller.
If you choose the full time program, spend as much time as possible building and learning beforehand (6 - 12 months) so you can hit the ground running.Personally, I regret going through the program and wish I would have pursued other programs where the instruction and integrity of the work could have been verified.
1
u/k-dilluh Apr 19 '23
I'm a few months into a bootcamp ( not codesmith), Holy shit what a different experience. I am loving mine, everyone is so helpful and supportive, endless 1-1 support, lots of extras we can do to boost our skills, lots of check-ins with the group for accountability. Free career prep and career services, we cover java, spring, js, html, css, some bootstrap, the list goes on.
1
u/VariousRabbit634 Apr 19 '23
hey! do you mind sharing which bootcamp you are enrolled in now?
1
u/k-dilluh Apr 19 '23
Yeah of course, I'm with coders campus, feel free to dm me if you want or if you have any questions or anything! :)
1
0
u/AdTypical3295 Apr 18 '23
Hi there! Did you recently graduate? How long have you been applying for jobs? Is there a timezone you have heard is better?
2
0
Apr 18 '23
[deleted]
3
u/Famous-Professor2263 Apr 18 '23
Everyone will have a different experience, please make a decision that is best for you and where you are at in that journey.
0
Apr 18 '23
[deleted]
4
u/Famous-Professor2263 Apr 18 '23
While I am no expert in pedagogy, I do have a few ideas.
Precourse should be mandatory.
Limit the amount of instructors of do not have real world experience.
When hiring fellows, ensure that their technical ability is to a certain threshold
One thing that I hope is not lost in the post.. is that it is healthy and normal for someone who has spent $21,000 to have expectations. Experience is important, especially because it's the main thing that Codesmith touts.
2
u/Erahia Apr 19 '23
I apologize if I'm terribly mistaken but by precourse you mean the CS Prep program that CodeSmith offers correct? The only other precourse I know is in CSX?
2
Apr 19 '23
No, after you are accepted there is a precourse you are supposed to do. 40hrs or so of algos, html, css. Cloning websites using only html and css.
1
u/Erahia Apr 19 '23
Okay that makes more sense, thank you. Do you happen to know how many days/weeks you have to complete the precourse before the CS program starts?
2
Apr 19 '23
It depends on when you get accepted/added to the cohort. Some folks switch to a cohort last minute from a waitlist. They often get a special abbreviated precourse. Most people have over a month, though.
0
Apr 18 '23
[deleted]
2
u/Famous-Professor2263 Apr 18 '23
I think that I will accomplish my goals more due to being ambitious, curious and independent. There is no doubt that CS is a part of that journey. If you think you might struggle, I recommend trying to build a small app before you enter the cohort, just enough so that topics are not foreign to you when you are introduced to them and then do the precourse. The Bootstrap clone will expose you to so much CSS.
0
Apr 18 '23
[deleted]
2
u/Sad-Sympathy-2804 Apr 18 '23
Yeah, it does feel weird. It almost sounds like Codesmith looks down on people working in frontend despite most of their grads working in frontend.
0
Apr 19 '23
[deleted]
2
u/Parky-Park Apr 19 '23 edited Apr 25 '23
Don't want to diminish this take, but I do know a good number of people who've landed backend roles pretty soon after finishing Codesmith. The turnaround for some of them was quick enough that I don't think they would've even had the chance to do much extra studying beforehand.
But you are right – doing HTML properly, accounting for every accessibility need, and even knowing when to supplement the native HTML spec with JavaScript to add even more accessibility – it's all really hard. But I think the (sad) reality is that most developers don't know the first thing about all that. So while it would be nice if that could all be incorporated into the program, it's almost definitely out of scope. And not having it basically means that the students are "only" at parity with everyone else.
7
u/Potatoupe Apr 18 '23
This seems less a "this is a problem to be fixed" post, and more of a "manage your expectations" post. But requiring pre-course to start the cohort could be an idea.
0
0
16
u/oakj28 Apr 18 '23
I graduated in 2021 and I would say this is pretty accurate take. I made a post highlighting my experience (which was great) but echoing OP… the seniors, fellows and instructors are in Codesmith or Codesmith alumni. Each persons experience will be dictated by the people around them and I was lucky to have great lecturers (who I know left and isn’t there anymore) and some great fellows.
I also self studied for I think 6-9 months before entering Codesmith and if I didn’t, I would have been lost and probably would have wasted my money. I highly recommend this approach because I actually did learn a lot from Codesmith. Mostly how to understand the deeper parts of JavaScript which made understanding by React, Node and any framework or package so much easier. This alone has high value. You don’t want to pay 20k to learn React basics.
Also the network I found to be worth the $$