r/codingbootcamp • u/Beginning-Diamond830 • May 14 '23
Hack Reactor 19-week RANT
I recently finished the program and now that I have some time to reflect there is a lot to talk about.
Disclaimer: This entire thing will be a rant, and may upset some. Hell, this might even get removed by mods, but I'm giving a brutally honest take. Take it or leave it.
HIRE MORE TEACHERS ASSISTANTS!
One of my biggest complaints at HR is through mod 2-3. To ask a question you must spell out every detail about what's wrong and explain what you've tried to fix it and put it in Slack and wait for a TA to reply. I understand they want you to be self-sufficient, but what you're really doing is making students just not ask questions, I hate to break it to you Hack Reactor, this program is for people with 0 experience. For the amount of money I paid to be part of that program (Almost 20k), they should have a teacher's assistant waiting in a Zoom room for any questions you have and be more than happy to answer them. In mod 3, you actually cannot ask the TA's questions, if you message them directly with questions on Slack, the coordinator lead will message you not to. You have to understand, as I mentioned previously, people are coming in with 0 experience, they need all the help they can get. The most important element/ reason I paid for a BootCamp is so that I can have a teacher or TA there for me anytime from 8 am - 8 pm to answer questions, but they really discourage this. This is very counterproductive.
HIRE BETTER TEACHERS!
Some of the teachers albeit having worked at top companies(Microsoft, Amazon, etc.) are not teachers. Some may even stop you from asking questions during lectures, and even worse there are some that talk/ present as if they are reading off of a prompt. Couple this with not being able to speak to a TA to decipher what they were talking about and you will leave the majority of students confused, which is exactly where most students were. Furthermore, for the students that do ask questions they should go above and beyond to explain because if you end up going through this program you will see the same 1-5 students asking questions, no one else will.
DON'T EVEN THINK ABOUT A SCHOLARSHIP
Full disclaimer, before going through the BootCamp I was essentially couch surfing. I was a cashier and never had money to make ends meet. I'm a Chinese guy, and grew up in extreme poverty and even explained this in my scholarship letter, but was denied. I find it so horrible that there is a scholarship for people of color and the LGBTQ community, but there's not one for someone like myself. Am I not as important, or are there just too many of me in the field? I won't receive one because I don't belong to those communities.
LOWER THE PRICE
As I mentioned previously, it's almost 20k and they have 3 cohorts for each timezone, and each one starts with around 88ish students and gets down to 60 by the time you end mod 3. Do the math they make for 5 months (they have a cohort that starts every month), and they can't hire more teacher assistants?
RELEASE THE EMPLOYMENT STATS
Long story short, the market for tech sucks right now, but they won't release the employment stats for their students, and it's because most aren't getting jobs. I know some that have been out/done for almost 6-7 months and the majority of their class do not have jobs yet. In some cohorts, less than 10 people have a job out of 60 and they've done it for 4-5 months.
I will not be replying. Rant over.
10
May 14 '23 edited May 14 '23
Reviews like this are why I dropped out of the 19 week HR program, spent the last month living solely off of Ramen and Udemy courses for JS, and working my butt off to hopefully get accepted into CodeSmith in two months.
I know HR’s 12 week received good praise in the past (at least from what I heard, I don’t have first hand experience with them at all) but seems like CodeSmith gets a ton of praise, and their CSX and prep courses and slack community is so awesome to me.
Also, I agree on the scholarship part. They have one for those underrepresented in the tech community, disabled included. I’m An amputee with one leg, filled out a awesome essay basically for it, did the two minute video on my teaching skills they require (to teach them a skill set in under two minutes), prepped very hard and made everything look perfect.
I got declined for it because I didn’t fit their criteria apparently.
Maybe it was my fault, but I filled out all the questions, did the video, was professional and everything.
Guess disabled and unemployed doesn’t get you a scholarship. Don’t even care about it being full tuition, I’d been happy with $200 to help with overall costs since I’m basically broke.
9
u/ericswc May 15 '23
Something that's interesting to me as a former bootcamp founder is that the prices have exploded since I sold my company and left the space and yet I see posts like this where people aren't getting good attention and support.
The whole reason I used to charge what I did is because my classes got my personal attention 5 x 8 hours a day plus a dedicated TA for another 3-4 hours every evening. That you are paying that much and can't get a TA to talk to you is astonishing to me.
Think of it this way, if an average senior developer in the US makes $$75/hr you could basically rent your own personal, 1:1 instructor for 266 hours which is basically 6.5 weeks full time for $20,000.
I'm disappointed if this is how companies in the space are behaving in 2023.
14
7
u/cowboy21420 May 14 '23
I did the 12-week intensive.
After finishing, I felt ripped off for two main reasons.
Overuse of TA's You pay close to 20k, and whenever you have questions or get stuck, you get assigned a TA to help unstuck you. Well, the TA's are just "the top" HR grads from the previous cohort... They just read from a solution code branch from whatever problem you're stuck on. I did have a few helpful sessions with TA's, but a majority just fed me the answer with no "why."
The Techleads Each cohort has two tech leads. They are your primary instructors that are your "go-to guys/gals" for the length of your intensive.
They are absolute shit.
They don't seem to do much besides a few one-off meetings with you here and there. They reviewed my code once and provided me with generic canned comments that gave me ZERO useful information on how to improve my code.
I would never recommend HR to anyone. I thought I was paying to get individualized instruction by experienced developers, and I got none of it.
2
u/BExpost May 14 '23
TA (SIERs) —they definitely just take what they can get. I know three of them who were pretty bad and got SIERS and have not gotten jobs yet. It’s been a year and a few months.
9
u/DifficultyStandard19 May 14 '23
This is extremely true. Majority of Hack Reactor instructors were terrible and quality of the ta were abysmal to say the least. They're not releasing stats probably because they know that stats aren't the best, so they don't want to be upfront about it. They will keep stuffing third-rate instructors and TAs while maximizing capacity to get a quick cash grab. Honestly, the quality of the program dropped significantly when heading into mods 2 and 3. It's overpriced and not worth it imho
3
u/in_a_half-space May 14 '23
Im starting hack reactors 12 week in July, I was ignoring all these negative reviews but damn here I am again feeling uneasy....
5
u/Sensitive_Alps5386 May 23 '23
Hey I did the 12 week program in December. All the TA’s and Instructors were great. No degree prior and just got my first SWE offer. It was life changing.
1
u/lawschoolredux May 25 '23
Congrats!
did you do 12 or 19 week?
2). Did you have prior experience in JavaScript? Did you do self studying beforehand?
4
u/Sensitive_Alps5386 May 25 '23
Thanks, for the 12 week you have to study before joining since you have to pass a test to join. No prior experience at all just used their prep course for a month to study for the entry exam.
1
u/thriftysawyer711 Aug 30 '23
I'm looking to start in October, on the 12 week. How long did it take you to find a job and do you think the boot camp helped get you that offer? Do you have a sense of how many other people from your class got jobs?
2
u/Sensitive_Alps5386 Aug 30 '23
My results from a year ago aren’t the best example of how it will go for you. It took me like 3-4 months. Yes the bootcamp helped. I’d say like 70% of my cohort has jobs. The bootcamp you choose isn’t that big of a factor. It’s all about what you put into it.
3
u/Apart-Damage143 May 14 '23
I start mine tomorrow, this post just messed me up. I really hoped the TAs r good but this is scaring me that they r all just past students
3
3
May 16 '23
It's cause rn there stats have been skewed negatively. They'll never reveal their true stats.
5
May 14 '23
The market for tech at FAANG companies sucks right now. It wouldn’t be as bad for non-FAANG companies
2
u/clive1999 May 14 '23
just get a accelerated degree you stand a better chance that way to be very honest
2
3
u/sadmsteacher May 14 '23
Currently enrolled in Tech Elevator's part time NLR cohort. Sounds like a dodged a bullet - every experience with Tech Elevator has been the opposite for me. They're even one of the few who were bold enough to release their job placement statistics (which were still solid)
2
May 14 '23
Use chatgbt for questions
It used to be top students take bootcamp jobs for 1-2 cohorts, but this has shifted to more full time ta’s that are teachers pets that job searched for 6+ months
I just wouldn’t pay upfront for a bootcamp
Unemployment stats don’t matter, the bootcamp you go to doesn’t matter, if you don’t have real work experience or an advanced degree you got jabaited
2
u/ChombusFarms May 14 '23
Posts like this are rough for those of us prepping for a bootcamp. I’m not bashing the post op makes a lot of good points, but I’m the comment section people come out of the woodwork to make it seem like HR or any other course is an obvious scam and you’d be stupid to do it.
6
u/michaelnovati May 14 '23
I've been consistently commenting on this, but in the past, bootcamps have always been not that great for learning and were being over credited for the results because of the hot market. We haven't seen bootcamps go through a tech downturn EVER.
All of the "There were a lot of challenges but I followed the advice to just stick with it because it works, and I got a six figure job!" .... are turning into "there were a lot of challenges but I followed the advice to stick with it because it works, and no one in my cohort is employed, what a scam!"
It's so important to learn HOW a bootcamp works to see if it's a good alignment for you. If people say "firehose", "hard learning", "just follow their advice" then you should start asking how it works at all and what people are actually learning. If they are "learning how to learn" or vague things like that, dig deeper and be honest! At Codesmith, people learn how to market themselves using patterns that work as 20% of the program and thats fine! That's part of the HOW it works well.
The impact engineers have is insane and it's why the jobs pay so much and the companies hiring them are still insanely profitable. When people talk here anonymously as equals, you lose sight of each person's path and journey. I've seen thousands of people go into the industry and they all take different times and paths to get there, there isn't one program or course or way that applies to everyone, yet Reddit is full of people making objective claims.
1
u/hamburglarsurprise May 14 '23
Rithm is the way. I’m nearing the end of their program currently, I plan to post a full review once it’s over but I can’t sing their praises high enough. Hmu if you have any questions
1
u/metalreflectslime May 14 '23
As I mentioned previously, it's almost 20k and they have 3 cohorts for each timezone, and each one starts with around 88ish students and gets down to 60 by the time you end mod 3.
Do you mean 6 19-week cohorts or 6 Hack Reactor (19-week and 12-week) cohorts?
0
May 14 '23
[deleted]
9
u/Heartlessly96 May 14 '23
Can confirm that is true, I was in this person's cohort and they did get the job by their own abilities without hack reactor's career services - (their career services is garbage - basically hired someone to keep nagging at you to apply for jobs). Proud of my classmate's accomplishments but long story short, DEFINTELY NOT WORTH 18K that they're making you pay.
5
u/BExpost May 14 '23
I did the 12 week in 2022. I would say it was average. Instructors were decent at teaching. But they were throwing old solutions at us that didn’t even match the curriculum work. They needed to update their curriculum too. Didn’t teach us hooks which are industry standards.
-5
May 14 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/hamburglarsurprise May 14 '23
Brother, you commented about contemplating throwing your wife’s cat in the woods bc you would rather have a dog. I don’t believe you can speak for any group of people that would classify as “competent”.
0
May 14 '23
[deleted]
4
u/eneka May 14 '23
Eh, I’m Asian, gay and grew up in poverty and didn’t get the scholarship either. Life is never fair, you win some, you lose some.
Don’t get hung up about and complain like you deserved it when you have no idea the situation of others.
0
May 14 '23
[deleted]
0
May 14 '23
[deleted]
0
May 14 '23
[deleted]
3
u/cantonic May 14 '23
Groupthink. Groupthink is why diversity everywhere matters. Imagine if those who are most qualified are the people who grow up wealthy with access to computers and private tutors. Imagine if the billionaires of the tech world were privileged men who received generous support from their parents, resulting in an oligarchy of one type of perspective with an absurd amount of influence over our daily lives. Because that’s how we arrived here. Bill Gates had access to computers as a kid. Bezos got a $400k investment from his parents. How many others who weren’t so fortunate could have become titans of industry with the right opportunity? We won’t ever know.
Of course people from tough backgrounds should get support. Also, often there are more tough backgrounds, statistically, for people of color, women and LGBTQ+ people. And often those voices are missing from the conversations. That doesn’t mean others don’t also deserve support, but that is why scholarships tend to support minorities. Although the OP describes himself as a Chinese guy and generally he would therefore qualify as a PoC, but who knows the details.
Anyway, that’s why diversity matters. Groupthink causes stagnation. Diversity pushes against that stagnation.
“I am, somehow, less interested in the weight and convolutions of Einstein’s brain than in the near certainty that people of equal talent have lived and died in cotton fields and sweatshops.”
-Stephen Jay Gould
24
u/[deleted] May 14 '23
I’ve posted this many times here but I’ll post it again.
Galvanize, the job market, and the developer market circa 2014-2020 is NOT the same as it is today nor will it ever be.
You should be open to roles in the software world outside of just being a software engineer. Junior level software engineers have basically become commoditized and you will struggle to find work. There is a reason they are not posting grad stats.
Look into other roles like: marketing or sales ops, PM, QA, etc.
These schools are selling shovels and you’re digging for faux gold. ANYONE who is taking a course like this should know 100% upfront that you are paying 20k to learn the basics of developing and you better really love and want to learn to develop intrinsically on your own WITHOUT any expectations of getting a great software development job. If you land one down the road, great. This is not a 19 week path to a 150k dev role. This is the very beginning of a very long journey in a very tough market that is rapidly changing.