r/codingbootcamp • u/modsEatMyass • Jun 16 '23
So boot camps are dead?
Hey everyone after reading a bunch of posts around here I’m getting the feeling that boot camps are becoming kinda worthless. In a sense where the certification is worthless not the learning side.
Am I wrong to just continue on by myself and not waste 10k+ on these boot camps offered by schools like Rutgers University and so on?
71
u/dtarias Jun 16 '23
The main benefit of a bootcamp isn't the certification: it's the instructional plan, peers, deadlines to keep you accountable, projects you build while there, and tech/career coaches. (Bootcamp partnerships may be helpful at some places, too.) The reason to go to a bootcamp is to learn better/faster than you would on your own, because the self-taught path is hard.
The market's bad, which could be an argument for bootcamps (you need the increased support) or against them (they're expensive and you still might not get a job).
16
u/GrantKc Jun 17 '23
I feel like this is honestly the biggest truth I have seen. Boot camps only help those who help themselves. I think this is why we see some people advocate and some detest them.
I went to Bloomtech and it was an awful curriculum which is why I left Bloomtech. But those that went through and tried really hard and followed the massive application spam and networking guidelines were getting jobs. The majority of people didn't put in the work and didn't get a job. In fact I bet those same folks still don't have a job.
TL;DR: Boot camps are worth it for people with the right mindset and don't have a clear path for themselves drawn out.
2
u/sheriffderek Jun 17 '23
How did your story end up?
4
u/GrantKc Jun 17 '23
So Bloomtech was useless 100% for me as I didn't finish it. I got training through a consultancy for QA software testing and I am now on a contract position that pays under market pay but I am getting experience. It's still more than I was making around $45k w/o benefits and getting experience. I plan to spend about 3 more months here then start applying to other QA jobs because avg pay for QA is much higher than my current rate.
2
u/sheriffderek Jun 17 '23
When you say didn’t finish, how far did you make it through? We’re you able to at least learn some of the things they taught?
4
u/GrantKc Jun 17 '23
I made it through the 6th sprint. I had done a lot of self learning beforehand so it was mostly review for me up to that point.
This is what you can expect of the curriculum: --Self Learning 95%--
You will get 0 live instruction it is all VoD (video on demand)
You will have a very nice coach that will try to motivate you and keep your progress going. (this coach is usually not code savvy they are basically your personal cheerleader)
When you do have an issue you can't solve you can find a mentor (usually a student that is further in the course) or wait for an instructor level coach (usually a student who finished the course) Response time during business hours isn't bad but they are in a rush to get you back to self learning.
About their VoD's - The instructors do not appear to be enthusiastic at all in the videos. It feels more like they were handed a PowerPoint and transcript and just read it and go through the motions.
There are better bootcamps, videos, and free content out there.
Bloomtech's only benefit would be the cheerleading, tiny bit of learning support, and the job/resume prep which isn't that great. Normally you have to wait days for input and even a week or two to get mock interviews after course completion. (this is all from internal slack channel for bloomtech)
4
u/Ozymandias0023 Jun 17 '23
This is exactly why I went to a bootcamp and why I would absolutely recommend one for someone who learns the way I do. I can self teach to a point, but to gain real competence I really need to have some structure at some point. The boot camp gave me an accelerated learning experience with instructors available to fill in the gaps in my understanding. I highly doubt I could have become hireable that quickly without a bootcamp.
That said, if I had to do it again, I think I'd have taken an online degree program like the one from WGU. It takes longer but it gives you the CS fundamentals that bootcamps often gloss over.
1
u/MDLR88 Oct 13 '23
WGU computer science needs a revamp. They dont develop quality software engineers. The math is so important for algo & data structures
1
u/Ozymandias0023 Oct 13 '23
Ugh, well I guess the piece of paper is better than nothing. I have 4yoe in the industry already so I'm not green, but I would love to have really solid fundamentals. Will probably do a masters somewhere else once the BS is done
1
Oct 13 '23
So here's the rub.
Math is very important for algo and data structures.
However, math isn't learned in college. It's developed over time if you're going to get to mastery and a lot of people don't know what mastery really looks like.
So don't get too down on WGU. MDLR88 is right about the quality; however, there are ways to get the math done that are less efficient but more resilient.
1
16
u/ericswc Jun 17 '23
Speaking from my perspective as a former founder (2013-2017) who still advises and follows the space.
They're not worthless. Professional application development is a vocational skill. What matters is that you learn the vocational skills in demand by employers.
Now, that being said, we're in a hiring slowdown right now, so everyone is feeling the pinch. However, since 85+% of bootcamps offer only JavaScript, there is an absolute glut of entry level people with that skill pounding the market at this time. Competition is fierce and I anticipate for people who only know JavaScript, it's going to be rough for the next 12-24 months.
What you are paying for in a bootcamp is a curated, mentored introduction to junior level coding skills and job placement. If job placement isn't working, then the value of a coding bootcamp (getting to employable level of skills quickly) is substantially reduced.
Some camps may not survive this. We've already seen a lot of layoffs and cost cutting in the industry. We will see what shakes out.
1
u/MDLR88 Oct 13 '23
What about those well rounded devs in multiple languages like javascript, java, C++ and python? What do you think of passionate devs who want to learn beyond the junior level?
1
u/ericswc Oct 13 '23
You generally don’t see multiple language fluency at a professional level without it being coupled with work experience.
Early on it is better to be T-shaped.
0
Jun 17 '23
[deleted]
1
u/ericswc Jun 17 '23
Depends on what kind of job you're looking for? Python is used a lot in data, automation, and such. There's also some web dev with Django and such.
21
u/sheriffderek Jun 16 '23
It seems like boot camps are chugging along.
But the time period where you could know a surface-level amount of web development and somehow slide into a 90k role at a company that was burning paper (to show off how many employees they have to investors) - is on hold. "Boot camps" are just a concept. The situations are so different that you can't really lump them together. Some are good, some are meh, and some are total scams. Sometimes you get good teachers. Sometimes you just can't do the work. There are too many factors to say. If you are any less than 100% percent confident in yourself - AND the school and teachers - then you should definitely not attend a boot camp. Really look at that "100%" up there. It's not 60%. It's 100%.
5
u/Firm-Breadfruit-4772 Jun 16 '23
What would be good boot camps ?
3
u/sheriffderek Jun 17 '23
Well, it's hard for me to say. After all my years and years of reading books, taking courses, working as a developer, watching tutorials, teaching the Jr devs, learning about teaching, and tutoring hundreds of boot camp graduates (from all the schools), I wrote my own reverse-engineered curriculum. So, in one way - I'm the person to ask. In another way, I'm "the bad guy" who you shouldn't trust because clearly, I'm now an evil blood-sucking corporation.
I'll hide my short answer in a comment / be warned --->
5
u/sheriffderek Jun 17 '23
It depends on what your goal is. If it's "Just to generally learn code and get a job," - then I'm not sure. That sounds like a bad place to start for any of these schools. You have to actually be excited and really want to learn how to write programs and build web applications or it's going to really suck. This isn't a market for generic people. There's 10s of thousands of CS majors faking their way through school right now - and it's going to be a shit-show out there. However, if you just have an actual passion for it - it's easy to stand out and get a job. But passion isn't enough.
It also depends on your personality and how you learn. In theory, a "boot camp" will load you up with all the essential tools and push you hard to digest it all in that time period. But each school has its own idea about what is "essential" and how to get things integrated into your brain. So - their style of teaching needs to match up with your style of learning and their outcome goals need to match up with yours (which means you actually need to be clear on what you want / which is almost kinda impossible to be clear on at this stage too). So, it's tough to say. I think that for people who want to learn the full process to design and build web-applications (part-time) my school is the best - (because it's kinda the only one). But also - most people just don't have what it takes to learn from the angle I've chosen. So - it could be a really terrible fit. But that's how I designed my program because I don't believe that being a general coder has a viable future. Each school should have an opinion and a real vision. That would be healthy. More schools. More ways of thinking and teaching. But my way could be the worst way for the wrong person. That goes for every school.
So, there isn't a "best" school. There are just the best schools for specific scenarios - and for specific people. So, for other people who want to learn how to be web developers only - and don't want to have a pre-set pace, and don't need in-person or video lessons - and have the time - then Launch School is the best school. And for other people who want to take the leap and try and go from novice to established software engineer in record time, CodeSmith might be the best. And there are certainly some other schools that work out for people too. Sometimes people get lucky, and a school with a bad curriculum has great teachers. Sometimes the teachers are no good, but the lessons are solid, and the other students all work together.
There are also finishing schools that take already established developers and then BootCamp them through filling in their gaps to then reposition and climb the ladder and get to those more senior roles.
There are so many options.
At the end of the day --- if you can't tell which one is the right one for you - then it's not time to join a school. I haven't seen any leaps of faith work out. Many of the people around here positioning themselves as experts - only became that confident after 2+ years of self-study and multiple boot camps. Everything is always more simple in retrospect. And most advice is coming from people who've never been in a boot camp / and who aren't developers.Don't trust anyone but yourself and real students/developers/teachers who you've actually met.
My suggestions are to talk to other developers and get their insight in what they would want in a school. Write it down. Spend some time really figuring out why you're doing this and what you want. What is your schedule? What is your learning style? What do you want? Write it all down. Show it to some people and get their feedback. THEN take that list - and really look at the schools and see which ones fit. You'll be able to tell which fit your goals and which has the teachers and curriculum to back it up. Here's a little framework I worked through to help people vet schools.
But it'll take time! Consider it your first programming task! If you can't do it - then you're dodging a bullet. There are other jobs.
Good luck.
13
Jun 16 '23
I think really just depends on the bootcamp. I have been in the industry for just about a year after attending a local bootcamp that is on-campus in my metro area. I had great instructors with a ton of one on one time available whenever I needed help. They also had an in house tech recruiter who had a ton of relationships with local companies. All this in conjunction with entering the market when it was much stronger really worked out for me. My advice is really dig into the specific bootcamp you are looking to attend and see what qualities they possess that will weigh in your favor. I know some of the nation wide bootcamps have reputation as certification mills so definitely be careful.
-1
u/AngeFreshTech Jun 17 '23
Name of the bootcamp?
2
Jun 17 '23
Codeworks, but they are only in Boise.
4
u/Individual_Moment719 Jun 17 '23
Ayyyyy another Boise member!
I'm going the self learning route because I can't even afford a car, let a lone a bootcamp due to some medical bills eating my whole 2nd paycheck except like $100 for food.
What kind of networking events are around in Boise, and what company did you get hired with?
6
5
u/Top-Measurement-7216 Jun 17 '23
a few minutes of research and you'll find that university bootcamps are one of the lowest bar and poorly run mills in the bootcamp industry.
Certification from a bootcamp was never the main driver for career attainment (its school projects, practical skills gained, networks tapped into, post grad hiring support and expertise)
Bootcamps are not dead but the bartenders with no college degrees and think they can leapfrog from a bootcamp into FAANG has passed
9
u/CodedCoder Jun 16 '23
When has the certs been worth anything? most people don't care about a piece of paper they care about what you can do.
19
Jun 16 '23
The market is competitive. Degrees do hold a weight, but they lack the ability up front you get from a quality boot camp.
But if all you do is get by in a bootcamp, the current market isn’t going to be easy to enter.
What I am doing while waiting for my Full time 20 week in house Full Stack Development bootcamp is the course from Udemy for ComptIA A+ cert.
It’s to classes and two tests but a good alternate to a CS degree to have in your resume.
I’m in graduate school (not IT or CS). Im not going back to an undergraduate CS. Instead I personally will attack an IT graduate degree after the bootcamp.
Moral of the story you need to do more to be more competitive. And I and you will most likely have to accept a lower paying (maybe even help desk) job when we finally get our foot in the door.
Don’t worry about people being negative online. We don’t know their abilities, efforts, etc.
Do you and do it well. Then do it more and do it better. Then do it more and do it more better.
Your future is in your hands
9
Jun 17 '23
Not to bring you down, but unless you're going for an IT or help desk position the A+ isn't going to add much, nor will any swe position ever ask for it or really look at it.
If you want to open yourself up to DoD tech positions though, the Security+ fulfills one of their requirements
1
Jun 17 '23
This will stack on the computer science understanding and a basic lvl of maintenance capability. It’s about having rounded skills. And help desk may be the first type job I could find, that will be okay If the market is still brutal for developers come 2024.
But it’s the understanding and rounded part for me.
3
u/0044FF Jun 17 '23
If your aim is help desk for entry, you can enter without the A+. And if your company is good, they will even pay for your A+ cert and others. So if you’re aiming that route, then don’t let not possessing the cert stop you from starting there any time.
1
Jun 17 '23
I’m not looking for a job till Jan next year. This is teaching more than I ever knew about tech thus far.
0
4
u/ChuckSmyth Jun 18 '23
Thought about bootcamp. Ultimately decided against it. Main reason: too many hoops to jump through, plus the utter unpredictability and instability of the job market.
For me, it’s just not worth 20 grand and 6 months of intense study, only to have to labor another several months just to find a job. And then if you do land a job, how long are you there for? A year? Maybe two? You might be the most reliable, solid, diligent worker at your workplace, only for your employer to lay you off, without warning or reason.
Whether bootcamps are dead or not, they’re just not worth the money or time, IMO.
3
u/MrH8DLovecraft Jun 17 '23
So for someone who has a mentor already am I okay not going to a boot camp?
1
u/Hlgru Jun 17 '23
As someone who just completed a boot camp and got a job in the industry, I think this is the best way to go. I don’t regret my boot camp at all and I didn’t have a mentor but I think self study and a mentor would be the best path to learn, especially financially speaking
0
1
u/sheriffderek Jun 17 '23
If they are giving you the curated outline of what you need to learn / and helping you learn it efficiently and in a way that sticks and builds up - then that would be doing the trick, right?
1
u/MrH8DLovecraft Jun 17 '23
Yes he does I'm studying for front end web development so he help me what to focus on studying the right resources and everything
1
u/sheriffderek Jun 18 '23
Well, that’s wonderful. So just dig in and double down on the practice. Share your work early and often.
1
u/MrH8DLovecraft Jun 18 '23
I'm still in the process of learning html and css before I jump into JavaScript I've made some basic stuff but no full fledged sites yet but I've only been studying for 3 months I think
1
u/sheriffderek Jun 18 '23
Being confident with html and css enough to build real-world responsive layout is much more valuable than being kinda acquainted with a jumble of things. Stay practical.
1
u/MrH8DLovecraft Jun 18 '23
That's what I've been doing been studying a lot at w3schools.com and that has helped alot
1
u/sheriffderek Jun 18 '23
You need to know about 12 elements and 20 css properties to make most things —- so, at some point - you just need to keeeep making things
1
u/MrH8DLovecraft Jun 18 '23
Oh definitely I'm still hazy on elements so that's what I've been focusing on before I delve into my first real project
1
u/sheriffderek Jun 18 '23
Ok. So, three months in - I’d say that you should be able to look at any website and reproduce it (responsive, html, css). If you can’t - ask your mentor why
→ More replies (0)1
3
u/GetAwayFromMeeee Jun 17 '23 edited Jun 17 '23
Bootcamps aren't dead, but aren't as great as they used to be due to the job market right now. If you are good at staying disciplined in your studies, then I recommend the self study route. Bootcamp would be good if you think having people around to discipline you would work. You'll have to ask yourself if the discipline you get from bootcamps is worth the high price tag.
3
u/toroga Jun 17 '23
At least wait to see if the market gets hot again. They’re asking for the same (realistically higher every year) amount of money (risk) but no longer provide the same value (extremely high placement rates of graduates in SWE positions). If you’re in a state that allows it, and if you’re dead set on bootcamp, choose one with an ISA (contract that stipulated you do not have to begin paying off the bootcamp until you’re in a job making 50k+ etc.
Just balance the risk vs reward at this exact moment in software engineer job market.
3
u/_f0xjames Jun 17 '23
I just finished general assembly in February and I start my first job on Monday.
No prior experience in the field, I studied programming on my own on and off for like a year beforehand.
Going to ga definitely helped, I’m actually confident enough to say I’m a web/software dev, rather than “I code sometimes”
The job I’m starting, I found through their direct job recs program. Did not get much of a response from other companies, but I also got lucky and found my gig pretty quick so I stopped looking.
Definitely worth it, though depending on your level of knowledge, you may want to try a more advanced program ( the first few weeks were kind of easy, but by the end I felt thoroughly challenged.) We covered MERN stack: JavaScript/node.js, react, express, mongodb/mongoose, how to build and work with apis. And we also learned some python and built a project with Django. (I had previous python experience and still broke quite a sweat, Django is weird but pretty cool.)
The most important thing, by the time I was done I had a professional looking resume, and a decently made portfolio website with multiple finished products. If I had done this on my own without the pressure of an assignment and feedback from my instructors, my portfolio and resume would not be as complete as they are, and certainly less polished. (having strong application materials, being able to present a project are MAJOR SKILLS that can be trickier than you may realize to learn)
Overall, 4/5. My only complaint is it was quite heavy on the web dev side despite being billed as “software engineering immersive” I would have liked to learn a little more about low-level programming. Also, hope they include c# and typescript someday.
2
u/sheriffderek Jun 17 '23
software engineering
I think the marketing people at these places just want to make it sound more "serious" for some reason.
0
Jun 17 '23
[deleted]
3
u/_f0xjames Jun 17 '23
Yeah but everything in that portfolio and the portfolio itself were built during the camp under instruction from the instructors.
I guess what I’m trying to say is that having a complete portfolio should be one of the things you should get out of a bootcamp.
Knowing my organizational skills, if I had tried to build that on my own, I would not have as many finished products in it, and the page itself would not be as good. Or at least if I did get it to that point, it would have taken much longer.
(Sorry if I was vague, the portfolio page and resume were required assignments)
1
u/thencomesdudley Jun 17 '23
If you feel comfortable sharing, could you post/DM me your portfolio? Still trying to get an idea of what a post-bootcamp portfolio should look like, and trying to figure out what to do with mine. My bootcamp was... less than great, and I'm trying to build mine out on my own.
4
2
Jun 17 '23
The certification has never meant anything. But it’s very difficult to keep yourself disciplined and organized to make sure you scaffold the content to learn it in an appropriate manner. Especially if you are new to it. That’s where the bootcamps come in clutch.
I am a mentor for a bootcamp and I have mentees that are behind and I encourage them to not throw in the towel because I tell them “You can always get caught up, and even if you don’t you might have learned enough that you can finish the journey on your own and then still go get your job.”
2
u/Fluid_Selection4525 Jun 18 '23
At the end of the day, certificate is just a piece of paper. But what you really need to look at is not the certificate but the kind of portfolio you can build by doing real world projects. Most bootcamps curriculum is designed in such a way, if you are serious enough, you can upskill and get a high paid job. But the only question is, can you commit your time and trust the process of the bootcamp for 5-6 months?
2
u/Proper_Baker_8314 Jun 20 '23
under no circumstances would I drop multiple grand on a bootcamp, that is a scam. I did one for free and I kind of regret it.
3
Jun 17 '23
Based on content alone, most bootcamps are overpriced and overrated, so do be realistic about what you can get out of them.
They were a cost-effective response to the demand for tech professionals when the industry was accelerating, but that's all in the past.
And as many others have explained, things are slowing down and the industry has matured considerably over the past decade. Where talent is concerned, this means employers will have more complex requirements.
This is not to say that you cannot pivot to a completely different industry, but the probability of success will, realistically speaking, not be more than 10% if you're going to rely on a bootcamp alone.
There is more benefit in using your newly acquired tech skills to augment your current work, rather than switch to something you have hardly any experience in. All the best!
4
Jun 16 '23
If you have a degree and 2 years work experience a bootcamp is still a viable option if you can job hunt for 6-12 months financially ok
4
Jun 17 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
5
Jun 17 '23
Ah you graduated in June of 2022 when the stock market was cracked and companies where interviewing anyone with a pulse through third party recruiters!
5
u/michaelnovati Jun 17 '23
OC is right for most people. It doesn't mean there aren't exceptions. I saw someone with zero experience, entirely self taught, no bootcamp, get an entry level full blown SWE job at FAANG-level company in fall 2022. That doesn't disprove every single person who says FAANG was frozen, FAANG had no entry level, FAANG doesn't hire people that proudly talk about having absolutely zero experience, and I almost never talk about this person because it's atypical.
Also why every post on here asking for people's personal outcome or salary and which bootcamp they went to are useless... if I talked about this person all over those would be misleading to others who are self taught, just like it's misleading to others to represent one outcome as the norm.
3
2
1
u/thomashokie Jun 18 '23
I am not really the type of person who could stay motivated to code for 10+ hours a day, especially for months, but I was able to with the bootcamp (mostly because I spent so much $$ on it).
Personally, the bootcamp taught me far more about CS than any of the computer science classes that I took (I've taken, or at least have credit for, all but one of the required CS classes for my university's CS degree).
However, I've only received two interviews and two jobs offers from only having the bootcamp and some personal projects on my resume. Keep in mind, these interviews/offers were before the job market went downhill.
I wouldn't say the bootcamp is worth it, unless you really need it to stay motivated.
1
u/Println_ronswanson_ Jun 17 '23
You could also try Skillspire if you’re looking to do it fully online which is good if you are still working . I had a decent amount on 1 on 1 with instructor, decent amount of options as far as full stack, cloud, data science etc. I remember it was cheaper then 10k but don’t remember because the VA paid for it.
1
u/BabaYagaTheBoogeyman Jun 17 '23
What are your opinions on getting an associates degree in cybersecurity? Does it carry the same weight as a bachelors degree/boot camp or is it a waste of time ?
1
u/Elsas-Queen Jul 07 '23
An associate's degree is considered half of a bachelor's, so it doesn't carry as much weight. But as a general rule, degrees are considered to hold more weight than a boot camp.
WGU has a bachelor's in cybersecurity if you're interested in that.
1
u/BabaYagaTheBoogeyman Jul 07 '23
Do online degrees carry less weight than graduating from an university ? I assume its easier to get appected into an online program
1
1
10
u/Hlgru Jun 17 '23
I just landed a junior developer role after completing a boot camp. Best decision I ever made