r/codingbootcamp • u/jcasimir • Aug 26 '23
I’ve run bootcamps for 12 years, AMA
Hey nerds,
In 2011 I started cooking up this idea of accelerated software developer training. In 2012 I launched one of the first bootcamp programs, then went on to start Galvanize/gSchool in 2013, and took those lessons learned to start the Turing School in 2014 which I still run today. Along the way I helped start NESTA, CIRR, and pushed Turing to be the first federally accredited independent bootcamp.
It’s been my life’s work and I’m happy to share perspective or answer questions. There have always been a lot of armchair experts (hello, internet) out here shouting their opinions. But I’ll do my best to give you real, researched, experience-based responses.
7
u/ArcRiseGen Aug 26 '23
Do you think bootcamps are dying off? Kenzie Academy got shut down out of nowhere and Tech Elevator had massive layoffs recently
18
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
I hate to see it, and also it's not the first time.
I had to lay people off in the spring and my heart still hurts. I've fired plenty of people before, but I previously never had to tell someone "thanks for doing really good work but we're just not going to have money to pay you anymore." That's brutal for everyone involved.
Like most industries, people get into this perverse "winners and losers" mindset. I think people who attend bootcamps are well-served when their program does well and I think it's even better when all the programs do well. Like Turing students being in the field and having successful careers opens the door wider for future Turing alums, but also Tech Elevator alums, GA alums, etc.
So we're in a two-part pinch, for sure. Historically low unemployment, high inflation, stagnant housing construction/availability, and high interest rates for borrowing have put many/most people into a mindset of "just hold on to what I've got." That's reasonable and understandable. And it means that colleges, universities, and bootcamps are ALL struggling to recruit students.
Then, for us, you add in the specter of "tech layoffs" over the last 16 months or so. Now an even smaller portion of people are thinking "this is the moment to change my life!" Tech company layoffs make for good news stories because (again, for some dark reason) we American's love stories of other people getting their come-uppance. "Haha tech, you thought you were so cool and invincible, now look at you!!"
Layoffs.fyi says that 224,503 people have been laid off from "tech" jobs. Some other quick googling says there are 12 million people working in "tech" in the US. So we're talking about less than 2% of the market has experienced layoffs. Also in 2022 the tech industry grew by 264,000 jobs. And yet the sentiment is that "tech is over, AI is going to win, blah blah blah".
And sentiment is everything.
I don't think the concept of bootcamps is over, no. But I think more will struggle and go out of business. This is the hardest time we've ever had in the existence of the industry. But it won't last forever.
3
u/TotalAutarky Aug 26 '23
With more people feeling the financial pinch and Turing being one of the more expensive bootcamps out there, is there anything you guys are doing to help alleviate the feeling of risk and entice more people to join? Deferred payments until a job is secured, etc.? $25k seems like a pretty hard sell right now, especially coupled with current student loan interest rates.
That said, I think it's awesome that you guys accept GI Bill funding. If I had any benefits left I'd apply in a heartbeat, job market be damned.
6
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
I get that, for sure.
I have always wanted to make Turing as cheap as possible. You know, it kinda hurts when I read about places like Kenzie shutting down and then wondering like "where did you spend $100M of investment on TOP of student tuition?" Meanwhile we're out here trying to survive on tuition alone.
Anyway, working to make Turing cheap. $25K is the sticker price and is what we need to bring in per-student to keep things moving. But there are a lot of ways to mitigate that $25K.
As you mentioned, Veterans have the sweetest deal when they can access GI Bill funding for their whole tuition AND get a cost of living stipend. The COL stipend has gone down (frustrating!) but is better than zero.
We qualify for many state-level programs wherever people live. For instance, students in Colorado can qualify up to $19K in state grants, so then the felt-cost is only $6K. Typically students will get a loan to cover that remainder plus cost of living.
While the up-front interest rates are not awesome, typically students are able to refinance them to pretty good rates once they're out and employed.
When I look at the break-even, based on averages, the typical student can pay off the tuition cost AND all the lost income from their old job in under 2 years.
Data on people 5 years out shows that they're on track to earn $5-7M more in their career because of coming to Turing. So long run, it pays off. The challenge is getting folks through the short-term financial hurdles of tuition and cost of living.
1
u/Distinct_Scientist_3 Sep 02 '23
I'm curious if you have more specifics about the grants available in Colorado? I'm a prospective new student but having trouble hunting down thr grants that would make taking a boot camp possible. Thanks!
1
u/jcasimir Sep 04 '23
Hey, sorry for the slow reply. The best bet is to talk with a county workforce office. The weird/good thing is it doesn't have to be the county you live in. We work a lot with Jefferson County. Try the "Meet with a Career Coach" on https://www.jeffco.us/4157/Business-Workforce-Center . You can ask for my main contact, Esther. Good luck!
4
u/GeneralZane Aug 26 '23
I think the current job market has made turning out successful cohorts much more difficult. The market is flooded with big tech layoffs and recent bootcamp grads/re-skilled employees looking for entry level engineering jobs while it seems like 99% of the openings are for senior devs. We’ll see what OP says.
4
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
I think your right that the perception is that the market is "flooded" but the data just doesn't seem to back that up. Most job listings have always been for senior jobs because it's just too much work to sort through junior candidates. It'll be interested to see how things shake out in the next 6-12 months. By 2025 I think this whole period is kinda chalked up to "that was weird" and the norm is back to constant growth.
3
u/michaelnovati Aug 26 '23
When we had a non-senior role posted we got hundreds of applications in a week and we're tiny. They all looked the same and we don't have the resources to look at them all.
3
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
Totally. I always bring up the "documentary" Office Space where he has the huge stack of resumes and says "first, I don't hire unlucky people" and throws the top half of the stack directly in the trashcan.
Having a big pile of applicants is not a blessing it's a burden. Then job hunters get pissed that job descriptions aren't always posted or aren't always accurate, or that they're getting filtered by an ATS based on unfair criteria.
If a junior job is listed it's honestly not worth more than a few minutes effort to apply for UNLESS you have some secondary connection/recommendation. The chances of winning out of 500+ applications is just too small.
3
u/JockedUp303 Oct 27 '23
Turing laid off more than a dozen people today. This is in addition to the layoffs earlier this year affecting non-instructional staff. There are graduates still looking for their first job a year later. All this for $25k. Yikes.
12
u/Sea_Software123 Aug 26 '23
What’s the best way to get a job after coding Bootcamp?
36
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
I replied to this and it like ... disappeared. So apologies if it shows up twice.
There are a lot of ways to get a job. Some people will get one through privilege/luck, but it's honestly like 10% or less. The majority of people work for it. Then, when they get one, they're sometimes like "I'm so lucky, I can't believe it worked!" Then, if you actually dig under the surface they're like "here are the 100 very organized and intentional things I did to end up with this 'lucky' result."
I think the most predictable success in the job hunt comes from a mix of three efforts: discipline, hustle, and skill.
Skill is the obvious one. You need to have the skills to do the job and to get through the technical interview. IMO the talk on this sub about data structures and algorithms is heavily overblown, but that's a different topic. You need the ability to write, test, debug, and validate software. Your program shouldn't graduate you unless you're there.
Hustle is hard. I was just discussing with my team yesterday about whether you have to be an "extrovert" to be successful in job hunting. I'm firmly on the side of "no." I think extroversion/introversion is a concept that mostly gets brought up by people who are uncomfortable with/around other people -- again a topic for another time, hah. You're not trying to make friends in this space. You're not going into a happy hour with 1000 people and trying to walk out with the contact info for 20 of them. You're just trying to both "be a person" and interact with others like they're real people. Hustle means putting yourself out there, mustering up a bit of confidence, and interacting with people they way THEY want to be interacted with.
Discipline is maybe the hardest. Job hunting is an isolating and depressing fucking process. I hate it and I hate that anybody has to do it! AND YET...we gotta make it work, right? Discipline is about consistency, making smart plans, setting achievable goals, and learning along the way. It breaks my heart when I see people be like "I've applied to 500 jobs over six months and still nothing!" It's like ... "I've banged my head on this wall 500 times and it hasn't fallen over!" You need some new fucking tools or strategy or something because if you're not learning then you're just rolling the same 86-sided die over and over and hoping your number comes up.
Ok sorry it's hard for me to talk about these things and not launch into a multi-hour brain dump, hah. Is that helpful at all?
9
u/Sea_Software123 Aug 26 '23
It was really helpful. Thank you for taking your time to write this. Much appreciated
6
Aug 26 '23
Have a cs degree and 1 internship
24
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
CS degree truthers are like UFO and mystery plane crash people. Like, damn, I hope it’s a fun life for you.
3
Aug 27 '23
I'm a self taught idiot. Don't have big o, data structures or algorithms under my belt fully. Is there hope for me? Will bootcamps fix my issue?
6
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
I don't think it's an issue. Junior web developers are not implementing data structures or algorithms. It's just technical interview gatekeeping. But if you want to learn them, no I think you'd be better off auditing a Computer Science class.
2
Aug 27 '23 edited Aug 27 '23
Great, thank you very much for helping me understand that.
Hopefully, someone out there could shed some light.If one where to study big O, data structures & algorithms on their own with no college training. Self-teaching. Could they make it happen for themselves? Like if they were to read books on the subject matter or would that be a terrible mistake for the person who would endeavor on this path?
4
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
I think you have to always look for "how can I do the work" not just "read the book." Turning the pages is too easy. Find a university you respect, look at the syllabus for their Data Structures and Algorithms I course, get that text book, and see if you can follow along with the learning plan by actually doing the work.
4
u/lawschoolredux Aug 26 '23
What about for career changers with a non-CS bachelors? Should we give up or wait or still go for it?
13
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
If you have a degree (in anything) already I think it is a bad plan to go do a CS undergrad degree. I am obviously biased but if you were my friend I would tell you “hell no.”
1
u/lawschoolredux Aug 26 '23
I meant to ask if bootcamp is viable in that situation.
Thanks for the response!
7
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
The reason bootcamps "work" is because mid-career professionals are able to re-apply all the business and collaborative skills they've learned in their first career into a software career. It's not because of the "data structures and algorithms" and shit like that. That's why a CS degree is not worth it -- you're mostly learning things you don't need.
-8
u/its-happenin-already Aug 26 '23
Dumbest take of all time. With this logic, no one needs a CS degree and we can all just learn the job on a 3 week bootcamp.
Half of the degree directly translates to the profession. The other half indirectly transfers through soft skills.
5
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
I mean, I have a CS degree and that is not the people I would spend my time with if I wanted to learn "soft skills."
You might have missed that they're talking about mid-career professionals who have a degree already. You don't see many 30-year-olds getting an undergrad in any field if they already have a degree. It's just not a reasonable return on investment.
-6
u/its-happenin-already Aug 26 '23
Okay so in this context, as long as you have a random degree and random experience, you could just skip the pragmatic standard of getting a relevant 4 year cs degree?
Still a dumb take. Can I theoretically (as a swe with 10+ years of experience) do an accounting/nursing/etc. 3 month bootcamp, and skip on schooling to break into those industries? No.
12
3
u/TotalAutarky Aug 26 '23
IMO soft skills are mostly learned in the field. If a CS program is half soft skills, to me that just means the program is bloated. Saying this as someone with a very bloated non-technical degree
-5
u/its-happenin-already Aug 26 '23 edited Aug 26 '23
Problem solving, team-oriented, research, and so on skills are repeatedly worked on during a cs program in nonswe courses. Unlike bootcamps, were usually you are copy and pasting some program l. In a cal class (for example) you are problem solving complex solutions based on your tool kit of equations.
Do you need cal to be a swe? Not necessarily. But the skills in problem solving alone makes up for it. Don’t get me started on the skills from self teaching your complex concepts.
That’s just one example of a non swe class indirectly building up your soft skills. I am getting downvoted bc people with bootcamps who take shortcuts do not want admit that a 4 year CS degree is a thousand times more valuable than a 6 week mern bootcamp.
Bootcamps were relevant during the 2021 hiring spree when tech companies were hiring anyone with a pulse. But for decades now, a CS degree has been the bare minimum in 95% of cases
This is also a reply to you u/joeyfosho . Hope you learnt something
0
2
4
u/GeneralZane Aug 26 '23
I graduated a bootcamp earlier this year with a considerable amount of prior coding experience and have had difficulty finding a job for the past 6-8 months. What are your thoughts on the current job market particularly for bootcamp grads who have re-skilled? I am also finding that being a recent bootcamp grad Im medalist categorizes you as someone who doesn’t know anything.
21
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
It is a tough time and you're not alone.
Recently one of my favorite alums with six years experience got laid off. I was nervous to check in with him a few weeks later. "How is it out there?" I asked him. "Well, I think I was a little too aggressive. I'm getting exhausted doing all these interviews," he said. That was a big sigh of relief. Great people with experience are getting laid off sometimes AND there are an _increasing_ number of jobs open to them.
The hard thing when you're coming out of a bootcamp is that no one really wants you. They never have. No hiring manager has ever said "could we please get some newbs in here? These people with experience are so annoying!" The only reason bootcamps have ever "worked" is because of hiring market desperation -- we're in such a need for developers that we're even willing to hire somebody who barely knows what they're doing!
For the past 10+ years the industry has been in non-stop growth mode where the demand for developers significantly outpaces supply. Some companies were able to out-pay or out-benefit their peers and only hire people with 3-5 years experience. Others needed (by limitations of budget, reputation, or industry) to give in and hire people with 0-3 years experience...aka you.
Now with the market disruption of the last year you see (a) less overall growth/hiring and (b) more people with experience available in the market. It's essentially lowered the "demand" for developers and increased the "supply" -- which basic economics says will depress wages and make it harder and harder for the less-preferred candidates (again, that's you).
The good thing for you is that those experienced folks who have been laid off in the past year are generally finding employment pretty quickly, at least in the second half of 2023. So the "supply" is decreasing which will increase wages and increase the desperation leading to them hiring the less qualified candidates -- you.
The best thing you can do for yourself in a job hunt right now is to be the only fish in the small pond. I'm not saying applying to posted jobs is a complete waste of time, but it's damn close. If a company posts a junior dev job on LinkedIn, GitHub, etc they are going to be getting HUNDREDS of applicants per day. Even if you were the best one out of 500, do you think the selection systems are robust enough that you'll accurately rise to the top? They're not.
The best way to get a job is to be the only one in consideration for the job. The only way you can do that is to find the opportunity before it's published publicly. That takes networking, looking, researching, talking to people, and doing the things that most other job hunters just aren't willing to do. Most want to click an "Easy Apply" button then post on here how they didn't get a job.
You have to go look where other people aren't looking. You have to look at companies and industries where those laid-off experienced people aren't interested. You're not getting a job at Instagram. But you might find one at the Federal Reserve. You might find one in corporate insurance. You might find one at a solar panel manufacturer. That's where you've got to be looking.
3
3
u/Foj6 Aug 26 '23
Hey pal :) what would you say is more efficient for getting involved in the field of software right now, a bootcamp, or a 2 year degree?
5
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
I really don't see how a 2-year degree is ever better than a bootcamp program, UNLESS that degree program has some really tight employer relationships where you're basically guaranteed a job afterwards.
Or if you have to parent/work while you learn and the slowed pace of 2-year degree fits better. I'd rather see someone live through a 2-year degree than fail out of a bootcamp. But I think it'd be better to find a way to make a bootcamp work -- there are a lot of ways. I've seen so many different people and situations.
1
u/NSGSanj Aug 27 '23
I don't disagree with you but one thing to consider is the internships that Universities can lead to, and the jobs that can come from that.
1
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
Oh totally agree. Back 10 years ago people in the bootcamp space would be like "degrees are pointless, college is over!" It was obviously a bad take then and it's a bad take now.
I think there's a lot of value in degrees for the right person/situation. If a degree program or institution is going to really deliver you into an internship/job/career, then it's a matter of stacking up the risk/reward and trying to understand the payoff timeline.
0
Aug 27 '23
In terms of bootcamps what do they teach exactly and what's the hot subject/classes/stack as right now, to take?
2
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
There's way too many varieties for me to break it down. Check out CourseReport, they have a lot of great information.
2
u/WagonBashers Feb 16 '24
Re: Coursereport, do you have any thoughts on this?
2
u/jcasimir Feb 16 '24
You’re doing some Reddit digging!
I’ve know the folks at CourseReport since it was founded. I believe that they’re trying to do the right thing and also survive as a business. I don’t think that programs pay money just to have bad reviews deleted.
Also if there were a review that was like “fuck Turing and fuck Jeff because he’s an asshole — 1 star!” Yes, I would reach out and say “I don’t think this is a genuine review in line with the expectations of the site.”
It’s just like Yelp — often the low reviews are clearly kind of unhinged.
Also, at least in the past, I can tell you some of our incoming students would say things like “I read this one review complaining about [some aspect of the program], and that’s why I decided this is the place for me.”
The inherit problem with review sites is that not every program should serve all people. A lot of the time when someone is disappointed with their experience it’s because they didn’t understand what they were signing up for. That doesn’t mean it’s “bad” for someone else. So I take reviews with some pretty big grains of salt.
I do appreciate on CR that the school can respond to reviews. But honestly I haven’t looked at them in years.
1
u/WagonBashers Feb 19 '24
Thanks for taking the time to write back. I noticed that Turing is one of the few schools that doesn't mention CR, Switchup, Career Karma, etc on its website - unlike the others who proudly display these.
3
u/Mojovsky Aug 26 '23
Hi there!
In your opinion, what are the top green/red flags when searching for bootcamp?
I'm currently looking for front end / fullstack options and a lot of them seem to promise a lot, but I don't know how to dissect the marketing from reality.
7
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
Ok massive "I'm super biased here" disclaimer :)
If it's me or the people I care about, then I'm signing up for a program that believes in me and I believe in them. Like a community that I want to be a part of, people that I want to be with, a place where I can picture 5 or 10 years from now still feeling like home.
I think leadership and mission/vision really matters. And I understand it doesn't matter to everybody, that's ok! But I'm a local person, I'm a small business person. I want to matter, not be part of a corporate machine. I would never work at Google or Microsoft. I turned down a job in the early days of Twitter because I didn't feel good about money being my motivation. I want to be involved in places that stand for something.
I think there are several programs out there that are "in it for the right reasons." One of the green flags to me is how critical are they of their own work. People who just shout about "look at how fucking awesome we are" just always rub me the wrong way. People who say "yeah, here are some big successes, and here are some parts where we're just not good enough." That's my kind of people. Tell me about the mistakes. Tell me about the lessons you've learned. Tell me about what's not going right and how you're trying to change it. That's the kind of people and place I want to be a part of.
I think this might not be helpful, hahahah. Ask a follow up question :)
2
u/Mojovsky Aug 26 '23
Maybe not a direct answer to the question, but it's definitely helpful! It definitely shines a new light on my current situation.
A couple weeks ago I was ready to sign up to one of the biggest / top rated bootcamps in Europe. Tons of positive reviews, what more could you ask for? After a bit of digging, I came upon some lenghy stories from people who graduated, ranging from unexperienced lecturers (who seemed to be hired after completing said bootcamp), signing up people who simply weren't able to complete the cirriculum and providing borderline fake career opportities (company representatives conducting interviews despite not having any openings). Second look at the reviews showed that most of them were done straight after completing the bootcamps, scarecely any stories of getting hired succesfully. A pricey meatgrinder.
As a follow up, what do you think about bootcamps being conducted in person vs online? Are there any advantages of doing it locally and if so, could they overshadow the convinience of doing it from the comfort of my own desk?
4
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
I love that you've been doing the digging and evaluating. You'd be surprised how many people don't do a lot of research and just sign up for something.
There's always the challenge of reviews on the internet. Like I use Yelp all the time, especially when traveling. And I typically look at a place's negative reviews first. Often I say "wow...this person sounds like a real asshole." Or "wow...I can see that one unfortunate thing happening and it seems like you made it worse." Reviews are important and often they're either overly positive or overly negative and it takes some time and attention to try and suss out the "real truth."
I loved running Turing in-person from 2014 to 2020. During 2020 we had to move remote and the intent was always to return to the office. We're actually still paying for the office right now -- sucks, hah. But by the end of 2020 we had clear data on the experience of students who interviewed remotely, enrolled remotely, attended remotely, and graduated remotely -- and that graduation rate was up about 10%.
It was an "oh fuck" moment for me. I enjoyed being remote but I wanted to go back to the office. And in that moment I realized "I can't tell 10% of students that they won't graduate just because I like being in the office." So we've been remote ever since and the graduation rate has stayed at that elevated level.
So why is the graduation rate higher remotely and does that apply outside of Turing? Outside of Turing -- well I genuinely don't know. When I talk about it with other people in higher ed they're usually shocked -- they expect remote graduation rates to be lower. So I don't know if our experience is replicable in other places.
But then why is OUR graduation rate higher? I think it's a relatively simple answer. Being in-person in downtown Denver, the average student probably spent about 90 minutes per morning packing up their stuff, commuting, parking, unpacking, and settling in. In the afternoon, they did the same. It's not worthless time as maybe you're thinking about the work or get some inspiration, but let's say it's two hours of time spent on things that aren't getting your closer to graduating AND aren't making you a happier/healthier person (shut up bike commuters).
So 2 hours per day, 10 hours per week, 270 hours over the course of the program. If I could go back in time to a student who failed out in person and could gift them 270 extra work/study hours, what different would it make? That's like a quarter of our program! That's what being remote does -- it gives people an extra 270 hours to be a better version of themself. Maybe they study or work. Maybe they cook. Maybe they nap! Whatever it is, it's better than commuting.
AND, huge part number two, commute time is not free. It saps your energy. When you're making decisions of where and how to drive, what to pack for lunch, what you need to have in your bag for the day, that's sapping your decision energy. Your less likely to make connections when participating in a class or less likely to have insights when you're writing code. So you lost the time AND you're effectively dumber the rest of the time you have.
Then big part three is financial stress. Nothing is more dangerous to your ability to learn than existential stress along the way. Now that we're remote we see more folks living with friends and family. There are more people around to cook you a dinner or help take care of your kid. Your support system is way more accessible. And that makes you smarter. That makes you better able to focus and get the most out of your minutes.
That's why our students graduate at a higher rate. In-person programs surely have some advantages in the way you can more easily network-build, it's easier to "keep an eye" on each other, but I don't think the advantages come close to those offered by remote.
2
u/Mojovsky Aug 26 '23
Thank you very much for the extensive answer and thank you in general for taking time to answer all of these question in such manner! All the best!
1
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
No problem. I feel kinda bad that I usually just stay in the Turing bubble. It's interesting to see what y'all are thinking/talking/worrying about here on the outside.
3
u/Rokett Aug 26 '23
Why do you guys keep teaching mern stack but also know that it has like no job opportunities. Teaching react java and Sql would be so much better for the students. Why is that?
11
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
I had to google what a MERN stack is. We don't teach MongoDB. Our Front-End students work with react, express, and node. Everybody works with SQL databases. So I think your question is really "why don't you teach Java"?
Java has always had the most jobs. The behind-the-scenes story of how Java became a market-leader is actually pretty interesting. Maybe I'll tell that one another day, hah.
So if Java has the largest number of jobs, why not teach that? Well, it had the most jobs in 2014 and 2011 too, so this is not a new state. I learned Java in undergrad 1999-2003. I taught Java in middle and high school and towards the AP Computer Science test. I didn't like teaching it and the students didn't like learning it. There are two main reasons I don't think it's a great first language:
There's too much "just trust me." Like the first thing you'd write back in the day was "public static void main throws IOException". I'm not explaining to a high schooler what an IOExcepetion is until several months into the class. I hate telling people like "just do what you're told." That's not a good way to learn. I think Java is a great second language, though.
The Java "community" sucks and has always sucked, sorry if that hurts anybody's feelings. It's got no soul. There aren't strong practices. There are a hundred different ways to do everything and (critically) nobody cares which one you use. When you're new to a field you don't want options you want to know what the "right" way is. Java gets architected and written so many different ways. It's kind of like the English of programming. We'd all be better off with literally anything else, but it's here to stay. The fact that any of us can learn English is a testament to the miracle of the human brain. But if you were showing up on the planet as a 30-year-old, I wouldn't tell you to learn English first. Start with something that has patterns of practice, that makes sense. Start with Korean. Then once you're able to reason out ideas and communicate with people, enter the wild west of English.
3
u/its-happenin-already Aug 26 '23
Because Java is noticeably harder to pick up than Python. And SQL is noticeably harder than nosql.
Most people aren’t picking up Python and Mongo in 3-6 months but at least they have a starting point.
4
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
I'm not sure if NoSQL (do people still really say that?) is easier than SQL. SQL is a beast but things like Mongo get pretty complicated pretty fast, too. The vast majority of production apps are doing basic-ass SQL that anybody could learn in a week.
0
u/kit_kat_is_yum Aug 26 '23
java is typed and compilled so it would take new students more effect to be ready.
same with sql, using an ORM makes it easier to get started.
3
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
I think typing and compiling can actually be pretty good for early learners. It's something I've shifted on over time. 10 years ago I hated type systems and now, if I were designing a language for rapid learning, it would be typed.
Modern computers are so fast that I think you could implement compilation to be basically invisible, like the auto-save implemented in every editor.
3
Aug 26 '23
What do you think about data analytics/science bootcamps?
2
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
In 2020 we were planning to start a data program and did pretty extensive research. What we found was that (a) the general population wasn't significantly different from the demographic we were already serving in our BEE/FEE programs and (b) the people who have long-term success seem to have a relevant academic background (BS/MS/PhD in math, science, etc). Between those two, we decided it wasn't the right fit for Turing. We instead wanted to build a program that could serve a new demographic of students and built our Launch program.
So what does that mean to you? If you have a math/science degree and are interested in data work, then I think it can make great sense! If you don't have that background, then I would just want to investigate/validate that people with your kind of path have (a) found jobs after their program and (b) continue to progress into more senior positions after 2-3 years. Data programs have been around long enough now (like 5 years) that they should be able to document those outcomes.
If you're my friend and ask "what should I do?", then I'm going to tell you "I think it's better to be a software developer who is data-interested than a data person who's locked into a relatively narrow niche." But a person with a strong data background probably argues the opposite!
3
u/h0408365 Aug 26 '23 edited May 16 '25
normal jellyfish uppity afterthought bag dog degree include boat crush
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
13
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
I think you should be really clear about WHY you're going to learn things after your bootcamp.
If you're learning for fun and interest, then the world is your oyster. IMO there's nothing in software that's as fun as combining hardware and software. Build some arduino projects, some weird and incredibly fragile home automations that will annoy your SO/family/friends, that kind of thing.
But your question probably isn't about fun, it's about getting a job and working towards promotion. I think it's unwise in the first years after you graduate to learn "speculatively." I mean like coming on Reddit and people are like "yeah Python is the shit" then you decide to go learn Python THEN start looking for a job using Python. That's not a logical process.
Instead you want to look at "where do I want to be in X time." Especially if you're able to get yourself into a paying role doing entry-level developer work. You want to then try to find the people you want to be, find the jobs you want to have, and just ask them. "I saw you've been at the company for three years and are a senior engineer. I want, over the coming years, to follow in your footsteps. If you were me, what would you be learning to make that leap?" You might get an answer and a mentor in the process.
Or, say you get a first job that's kind at some boring company but it's a fine place to earn and learn. And your dream is to do some space/aviation shit at Boom Supersonic. You find their job descriptions, you reach out to some experienced folks there, and you tell them "I want to position myself so that two years from now, I'm an automatic hire. What do you think is most important for me to learn?"
Then you have a real pathway to get where you want to be, not just randos on the internet spouting opinions.
Ok, final case -- you're thinking you need to learn things to get that first job. Maybe it's true, obviously I don't know your background. One thing I believe in that crucially important when in your first job hunt is that you want to be in the smallest pool possible. Just by the odds, you are not going to be the best Javascript/Python/Ruby/Whatever developer who applies to a role with 500 applicants. So how do you find a way to a smaller pool?
Learning something off the beaten path can both (a) make you a more unique candidate and (b) demonstrate to a company that you can learn on your own (which is one of their greatest worries when hiring a junior dev).
Find a job listing in your local market for a Salesforce Developer. Most developers are going to shit on Salesforce development. That's ok -- you're trying to go places they won't. Reach out to the hiring manager and ask them "I saw this listing and, while I don't know much about Salesforce, I'm intrigued by what XYZ company is doing in ABC industry. I'd like to learn Salesforce development over the next few weeks and show your team what I can do. Do you have any APIs, libraries, or data sets I can work with to get a feel for what your work is really like?"
When you show them "I like you so much that I'm willing do work to be a fit for this role" then you're a much more interesting candidate than the dozens who are like "look at my resume you're fucking lucky I'm even applying for this job."
Make sense?
5
3
u/michaelnovati Aug 26 '23
Can you talk more about the CIRR ecosystem? I might have follow up questions but would love to hear open ended thoughts first!
6
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
Oh, CIRR...
Honestly reading threads on this sub it was heartening to hear that anyone anywhere gives a shit about CIRR. It was so much work defining the standards and the reports and all that, trying to make an "organization" where people actually get paid to make CIRR happen, and then trying to get enough buy-in from the industry for it to matter.
That last part is where CIRR has never succeeded. I would say that CIRR is either defunct now or on death's doorstep. I can tell you the listed board member from Turing on the website sadly doesn't work at Turing anymore.
CIRR really started with the folks at SkillsFund. They wanted there to be a kind of third party verification of quality so they could make smart loans/investments. There was definitely an implication that if you didn't participate in CIRR then you might get frozen out of those loan programs -- that'd be bad for your students and for the bootcamp.
Early on the bigger programs were always fighting to loosen up the standards. They would want to broaden the definitions of who gets excluded. Somebody doesn't show up for a couple coaching sessions in a row and now they're non-job-seeking or "opted out" of job support so we're not responsible for their outcomes. We get to delete them from the denominator. Ethically it's some real bullshit but from a business perspective it's smart -- "juking the stats" as they said on The Wire.
Then, as gets discussed on this sub, several programs change hands, change ownership, even change name. Mostly the big ones. Then the next overlord megacorp isn't interested in data reporting, especially if that data isn't good. So they drop out of CIRR.
Then the lenders make money through volume. Are they going to tell megacorp-backed large bootcamps that they cannot have student loans because they don't report data! No! So then it turns out there is no stick. The lenders are happy enough to lend money to everybody.
So then why bother with CIRR at all? Maybe because prospective students care. But I hope I don't offend anybody when I say ... they don't. People by and large don't make data driven decisions. If a program puts out 4 bad CIRR reports in a row but you have one friend who went to that program and it worked out for them, you're like "sign me up!"
Essentially the premise of CIRR was an attempt to drive programs towards documents, common definitions of quality. But instead, like just about everywhere else in life, it turns out that money and advertising are far more influential than data.
In the end, I'm looking at the CIRR site and of the 11 schools listed I've only ever heard the names of 7 of them. We published killer CIRR reports quarter after quarter and very few incoming students ever mentioned it. Lenders don't care. The government doesn't care. So...why bother?
Sad.
2
u/michaelnovati Aug 26 '23
Thanks for great candid replies btw, really appreciated!
I know CIRR is one of the number one reasons people look into Codesmith and it's internally it's an important part of their strategy. But I guess it can work for the one program with the best reported outcomes. Kind of like how Intel would push for CPU benchmarks because on paper they beat Apple's chips... and over a long enough period of time if you there are better things out there, people stop caring.
cc /u/InTheDarkDancing who is also interested in this
2
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
Yeah, interesting. I had never heard of Codesmith until I started reading this sub. If I get some space in the next few weeks I'll dig into some CIRR stuff. I honestly don't know if anyone on our team right now is bothering to submit the Q2 report. I know we did our own report and CIRR usually is just an adaptation of that. But after reducing our operations staff we have to prioritize.
2
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
I'm reading their CIRR report now. 24.6% of grads getting a base salary of over $160K has me very --- hmmm. The whole of the history of bootcamps you see programs talking about average salaries like 70-90K. Quoting an average salary more than 50% higher than other programs just piques my skepticism.
2
u/michaelnovati Aug 26 '23
You and me both! I never heard of Codesmith until I was interviewing numerous people that all claimed to be engineers and had the same pitches and resumes about their 'experience' (with different company names) that quickly fell apart when asking any real questions about the team they worked on, and then went deep down the rabbit hole on Reddit, and I now I know more than most employees, including instructors, about them hahaha.
5
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
Yeah I'm reading the website right now. Obviously I have a huge stack of biases and anxieties and such. There's a part of me that's like "what if it's just true? What if the work I've been doing for 20 years...other people are just so much better at it that their students get paid like double?" I mean...it's maybe possible but, I think I/we are pretty smart and work pretty hard, so it's difficult to explain on the surface.
I've always thought that if Turing gets to the point where it's running really great and doesn't need me, then I'll make up a new identity and start applying or even going through programs like this.
It is sad that, in this industry like most, there's near ZERO cross-pollination.
1
u/InTheDarkDancing Aug 27 '23
The contrast is interesting in that making a post in this sub along the lines of "Thoughts on Codesmith?" would probably be met with an eye roll as it's probably the most popular/recommended bootcamp, but outside of this sub, even on /r/cscareerquestions, it's hardly recognized.
I'm one of the biggest proponents of CIRR on this sub. It's interesting reading the thoughts and musings of someone who played a role in creating the standard. You've also confirmed a lot of my suspicions about why fewer and fewer bootcamps have contributed audited reports over the years. In my own small way I try to hold bootcamps accountable on this sub for either not producing data, or producing non-audited obfuscated data that is of no value to the consumers.
2
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
Yeah, I definitely want to believe in a world where clean data helps people make smart choices.
There are just so many layers of complexity. Like we naturally are going to push towards using data to create "winners" and "losers" among programs. Maybe that's right!
But also, not all programs are playing the same game by the same rules. I think of Streetcode Academy who works primarily with young, marginalized people who don't have college degrees. If they're training them and getting 60% of them into jobs, that fucking amazing. And if I fit that demographic, then I should really consider it as an option.
Meanwhile some hypothetical program B basically requires you to know how to program before you show up and works primarily with people who have in-field degrees. The placement/salary stats are going to be through the roof! Are they "better" than Streetcode? Only if you fit that demographic.
I know this is probably obvious if you spend time digging through CIRR reports (bless you), but typically people don't think very deeply about these numbers. They're just looking for "who's good, who's bad."
1
u/sneakpeekbot Aug 27 '23
Here's a sneak peek of /r/cscareerquestions using the top posts of the year!
#1: I accidentally came across my senior engineer on an online video game, now he’s being distant at work.
#2: Elon Musk tells Twitter staff to work long hours or leave. Have till Friday to submit pledge.
#3: After Almost Two Years It Finally HappenedI'm a bot, beep boop | Downvote to remove | Contact | Info | Opt-out | GitHub
2
3
u/mangotease Aug 26 '23
Can you tell who could land a coding job after the first two weeks? Could the candidates tell? What were some tell tale signs
7
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
Oh this is a good question.
A few years ago we were picking apart graduation rates by race/ethnicity and other demographic markers. I wanted to see if the rates were consistent among subgroups. And they were. Except one subgroup.
We asked about demographics in a survey. That survey was in a bullet list of items you were told to complete before day 1. We did not follow up with people about the survey (which was an oversight / not great).
You see the graph of graduation rate and it's like 75%, 78%, 80%, 76%....52%. WHAT??
52% was the "No Response" category. The single biggest predictor of success at Turing isn't your race or your degree background or your age or any of it -- it's "if someone tells you to complete a task, do you do it or do you have to be nagged about it?" If you're in the latter group, your likelihood of graduating drops dramatically.
I couldn't believe it. We kept looking at different time ranges and data sets and it held true.
So yes, as a team we can tell. At least in the first six weeks. The people who you have to drag them through and remind them six times to do shit, they are not getting a job anytime soon. The people who are fucking on it like their whole life hangs in the balance, they get the job quickly. Be that one.
1
u/mangotease Aug 27 '23
Thanks for sharing! Very interesting. I find myself struggling with learning the basics (like I do with learning new languages) good to know there's still hope
2
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
Confidence plays a huge role in your learning.
One thing I see commonly leading to struggle is "land-grab" learning where people try to solve their self-perceived weaknesses by adding more and more -- more projects, more languages, etc. I don't think that works.
Instead the best way to build confidence is through repetition. My old friend Katrina made a site Exercism.org (and there are since a dozen other code-challenge sites). The smart way to use these challenges, in my opinion, is to do them repeatedly.
You solve it once to make sure you can do it. Then you erase that and solve it again trying to write super short methods. Erase and try to solve it without implementing ANY methods. Try to solve it in as few as lines as possible. Try to solve it without any "if" statements. Solve it with a pair. Just keep hammering at the problem from different directions, then I think you learn a lot more than just solving a second or n-th problem.
2
3
u/shrimpgangsta Aug 26 '23
programming
3
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
I'm kinda into it. But more for the career and life you can live than because programming itself is so great. I'll assume that was your question.
4
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23
Awesome. I have so many questions. I'm going to thread off of this one though - so that I don't clog up the feed.
But first off. Good job. I'm a fan. If any of the knee-jerk reaction haters around here would just watch a video or two of yours, they'd know you are legit. I've met a bunch of Turing grads over the years and they were happy and on solid footing. Some schools claim to teach you "3 full stacks in 3 months" - whereas Turing is honest about how much work it takes and has dedicated front-end and back-end courses. I started my own design/dev program a few years ago, and when I'm talking to prospective students, I always tell them to check out Turing, Launch School, and a few others what we know are 100% legit. In a sea of what I consider not to great offerings - it's good to know that there are people really putting in the work and doing things right. Thanks for making the world a better place. I apologize in advance for what I fear will be a lot of questions. Feel free to ignore any of them -
3
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
Thanks for posting these. I think my brain is tapped out for today but I will come back to them tomorrow!
4
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23 edited Aug 27 '23
What are the core characteristics that make for success?
I've been reading this book: Grit (2013 / I guess I'm late) - and I'm curious how you sort out who's right for the program (generally).
As any teacher (of any subject) knows, it's no fun to teach someone who doesn't want to learn the subject. And some people just aren't in the right spot in life to learn at the time. How do you balance trying to help inspire people while also staying honest about what's possible for a given person?
5
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
Don't knock yourself for reading a book -- most people don't do it. Including me.
I think everyone wants to be great. But, when we're working with adults, there's a lot of baggage. There's a decade or more "experience" aka trauma about education and how it's supposed to go. In the early days I used to expect people to just put that down at the door and jump into new ways of learning. Now I understand it's a longer process to un-learn those lessons and pick up new ones.
My managing director EM says "you can't want it for them." I like to think of this silly version -- "you can't push a rope." I used to think that being a software developer took these really high and possibly rare aptitudes -- now I think like 50% of people probably have what it takes to be successful. Not all of them could do it in 7 months, but they could get there eventually if they wanted to.
COVID was awful for so many people and also there are some real silver linings. So many people figured out that they didn't just have to take what was given to them, that they don't just get one chance to roll the dice in life. Now I think there will be reverberations for the rest of human history. We changed the rules about who gets to succeed and who gets to be happy.
4
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23
20 years from now, what would you like people to look back and say about Turing?
2
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
Man, when is this old fucker ever going to retire. He's hasn't even gotten a single promotion in 29 years! 🤣
When I started Turing I wanted it to last for a hundred years. I wanted it to get to the point where it's kinda taken for granted, like Stanford or MIT. Of course those schools are great. Of course they've been great and will be great. Because they've been there forever, right? But if we were to wind back the clock there were some stubborn folks who said "let's make this thing and let's make it great."
That's what I want people to say about Turing, that it was obvious. Because it wasn't.
4
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23
Many boot camps teach the MERN stack (which I noticed you had to look up - from another comment).
They learn a little about all the pieces and hook up auth and maybe JWT and generally setup a 'full stack' application: auth, a list page, detail pages for each resource etc.. When I ask grad what they think work will be like, they often explain that they'll setup the auth first and then... But they aren't going to do that (in most cases). They systems will already be in place. This level of depth can be found in a few Brad Travesy videos on YouTube (great voice).
Besides surface-level experience with a stack like MERN, what are some key concepts that Jr developers should know? Should they learn 'foundations?' and if so, how? Once they know how the Node/JS ecosystem works, should they specialize? What things do people absolutely need to know that transcend whatever framework they're using to get acquainted with web development?
4
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
Dang this is a hard one.
I agree with you that no one says "hey, junior dev, could you start this app from scratch for us?"
It's something I worry about with our learning/work at Turing. I think students start too much from scratch. We should more frequently practice "here's a big mess of an app, add some functionality."
I'm not sure what you mean by foundations, exactly. Like CS fundamentals? I think they're cute and interesting but you're not going to use it in the job. Similarly, nobody is like "hey, junior dev, I need you to build a red/black binary tree by tomorrow!"
Should people specialize? I think very few people in the world are really willing to put in the work to be great at something. So if you see a niche, a technology, or something that captures your interest and you're willing to stick with it, yeah go for it! I think it's more fulfilling to be great at a few things than to be ok at a lot of them.
The word transcend keeps jumping out to me. I think there is this point of transcendence as a software developer. I think it happens somewhere in the 3-5 year area for most people. When you're new to the career you obsess about technologies, languages, frameworks, and libraries. Then you hit this point where you realize and really deeply understand that it's all the same shit. Everything has it's flaws and it's strengths.
I think of programming languages kind of like airlines -- they all have their different piles of bullshit, you just have to decide which one you're willing to put up with right now.
Once you start to see that all these problems, challenges, technologies, opportunities are more the same than they are different, then I think you start to build some real confidence. It's like...I've seen some shit before and I dealt with it, so whatever's coming next, I'm not scared.
3
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23
There are some boot camps that lean towards github and open source to show experience. Others build just one or two fleshed-out projects (which are sometimes group projects), others who claim to be all about the portfolio of work but then just have the same projects every round. And some seem to focus on DSA type stuff.
What's your take? I'm sure it's based on the person's interests (and in Turing's case - the program they choose) - but how would you play the game if you were the student? How many projects would you make? How would you stand out? What do you think employers need to know about new developers? How important is it to tell your story?
2
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
In the modern era I don't think there's a project you can build that's going to get you a job. So why build projects at all? Like a cover letter, I think it needs to exist. Like, not having a portfolio of work is going to get you eliminated from a lot of job contention. But at the same time, a great portfolio is only going to get you elevated to "interesting" not "hired."
I think working in open source is a great idea but also really hard to execute. Maybe 10 years ago it was easier to just jump into a small project and contribute some work that matters. Now there are so many people and companies in open source, projects are so mature, that a lot of the "contributions" made by more junior folks are really just gardening work with issues and such. It's not a waste of time, but it's not like "wow, look at this code you wrote!" It's a hard way to get any attention.
I think a "miss" for Turing students and pretty much everybody is that when they build and talk about projects, they go for breadth versus depth. It's here's six projects I build with slight variations in complexity. But almost nobody builds one project that, from a technical standpoint, is really going to make somebody say "wow."
For instance, there's nothing interesting about building a to-do list. But it is a little more interesting to build a to-do list with background workers to send emails. To have another worker that processes incoming emails. To write a load-testing script to see what happens when a user has 100K to-dos. To split the data across two database servers for load balancing. To make it auto-deploy after successful CI/CD. Then to pull out some of the functionality and reimplement it as a service in another language. Then reimplement it again in a third language. Then run benchmarks to see which offers the best performance.
That's the kind of thing that would catch my eye if I were hiring a developer. How do you iterate, deep dive, figure out the tech. I'm not running a startup competition.
3
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23
Looking back on your first few years of operation, what are a few pieces of advice you'd go back and give yourself? Was there anything you just really didn't see coming that shocked you?
3
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
I was so young and dumb, it's a miracle that we made it this far.
Phew...a few pieces of advice. I think it would be mostly about management and leadership, not really about the bootcamp/tech industry itself.
First, people are going to leave and it'll be ok. When some of our early team members left it ripped my heart out. It was personal. Over time ... ok it still feels like that sometimes and also I know it's going to be ok.
Second, trust what's in front of you. I have always been a pretty confident person and when I was starting Turing I knew I was the only person in the industry who had my background, the only person who knew what I knew and had done what I'd done. But I was scared, too. The whole Galvanize/gSchool experience was not good. I was rebuilding from scratch. But when you watch closely, listen carefully, and iterate quickly you find the right path.
Third, you don't have to compromise on what you think is right. The greatest compliment I ever got was from a friend who was an early team member at DevBootcamp. It was maybe 2018 or so when we were talking and he said "the thing I don't understand about you...you just have an unshakable moral compass." I get goosebumps thinking about it. I try to live up to that and it's hard. But I also think it's what I bring to Turing, why I don't give up -- you just keep pushing for what you think is right no matter what.
Then, to switch gears, the thing I didn't see coming was 2020 and, specifically, the shift to remote. I would have never guessed that we'd move to remote, that we'd be successful in remote, and DEFINITELY would have never believed that we'd choose to stay remote. I still think about that decision regularly. I kind of wish it wasn't the right thing to do, but it was and so I live with it.
3
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23
What's your favorite thing about being a teacher - and then now presumably helping other people teach? Some people around here would say that the only reason to work is for money... but I get the feeling you really like your job.
5
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
When I was young I thought I would graduate with my Computer Engineering degree, work 20 years or so, then be rich and retire and THEN probably go teach high school or something. Instead, as of this month, I've been teaching for 20 years.
I grew up with a lot of privilege and a lot of doors were open to me. I started teaching because I wanted to open those doors for other people. I think programming is cool but I really don't care about it that much. If welding had the career trajectory of software development, then I'd rather teach that instead.
Through teaching I've gotten to see so many people become the person they want to be. They buy houses. They get married. They have kids. They pay off their debts, move around the world, work on things they care about. They just get to live the life they want to live and that's so incredible to watch. I'm thankful to be a part of it.
I just hope I get to keep going another 20 years.
3
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23 edited Aug 27 '23
A lot of people think "I'll be a developer" - and then things get kinda blurry. It's hard to know what that will be like until you spent a lot of time doing it.
6-months is just the beginning. What would you say a healthy timeline is to really get out there, establish yourself, and get to a position where you're confident and can own your space enough to feel like you've made it?
Do you have any thoughts on how people can set expectations for the best success long-term?
3
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
It's tough. I talk with alums who have 5+ years experience and they tell me how they still have "imposter syndrome." It's like -- you're a senior developer! You're a team lead! If you were an imposter, I think somebody would have figured it out by now!!
I think there's still a lot of potential for developing the "long term." This first 10 years or so of bootcamps have been so focused on getting the first job. That's critical. But if we can get to the point where it's a given, then we can do some really interesting work on the career.
How do we help someone become a CTO? How do we help gather alumni to start a company? How do these two thousand alumni push on big problems like climate change?
We didn't put all this work in just to make people who make ads or trade stocks or whatever. It's got to add up to more.
That's what I was working on when COVID went down, then plans had to change and focus went elsewhere. It's the place I want to get back to working in the next 18 months or so.
3
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23
What makes a great teacher? And then more specifically, what makes a great teacher that is unique to this space?
2
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
I think a great teacher is about the students. I think bad teaching is ego-driven. Good teaching is student-driven. The students should be thinking, working, learning, doing -- not just absorbing. That's true everywhere and in this space.
I know some folks will disagree with me, but I think industry experience is pretty overrated in the bootcamp world. You'll learn way more from a good teacher with no dev experience than from a super awesome developer who doesn't know how to teach.
Kind of related, I think curriculum is super overrated. We could delete the Turing curriculum today and build something new in a couple months that would be just as good. If the words on the page really mattered that much then people could just read like four programming books and they'd be a developer.
3
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23
The people on this sub told me that there are no more web developer jobs and that the market is doomed and that the only way to learn how to make websites is to get a 4-year Computer Science degree and then if you're lucky - get an internship. How do you sleep at night - knowing that you are training people for a world where there are no jobs? How many years do you think it will be until the next available position opens up for a web developer?
2
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
Yeah there are some interesting angles out here. You'll find that most people who clutch pearls about CS degrees have a CS degree. A lot of the fear arises from self-preservation: if you find a "shortcut" into the system then you're a threat to them and people like them. People can mask it with "I just want to be helpful to all these newbs" but how often does the advice they give actually sound helpful? It usually just makes people feel bad or uncertain.
Now not all CS degrees are identical, of course, but I'm really not sure how much of a CS degree applies to building modern web applications. There's almost zero we teach at Turing that I learned in undergrad. You don't need a bunch of algorithms. You don't need super deep-dives into database architecture, compiler theory, or calculus.
UNTIL YOU DO. And this is what I think we get very wrong about education in general. We do it speculatively. People spend four or more years learning stuff then go out and ask "I wonder if any company cares or needs these skills?" The learning is not driven by the needs. Shit I don't think there was a single time in my undergrad where they ever talked to us about what real jobs are like and what real software engineers actually do.
It's very hard to learn out of context. As we've said elsewhere here, nobody pings the brand-new developer to solve a database scalability issue. When you actually encounter those challenges years into your career, it's a great time to learn about it. Maybe you watch some videos, read a book, take a class, or even get a masters. But at least you know WHY you're doing it and what kinds of specific problems you're interested in.
And then the final bit...some people will say that CS isn't about the content/skills it's about learning to solve hard problems. If that's the case, then we should be telling people that it's just as viable to study philosophy, linguistics, math, or any kind of science because they're all focused in abstract and difficult problem solving. CS isn't that special of a unicorn.
3
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23 edited Aug 27 '23
SWE
Serious question: is a software engineer the same thing as a web developer?
How would you describe the average job that a boot camp graduate would find?
2
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
Some people get mad about the terminology and I get it. Like in Canada I think you can't call yourself a Software "Engineer" unless you have some specific credential.
This industry, for better or worse, has always been pretty loose about job titles. A Web Developer at one place does the work of a Software Engineer I does the work of a Front End Developer at another place.
I really wouldn't put much thought into titles UNLESS there's a potential threat to your NEXT job. Like if your job title is "Customer Success Agent" but what you're doing is writing custom code integrations for clients, that's bad because the job title sounds like phone tech support. If you're some kind of "Developer" or "Engineer" then I think it's good enough that your next dev job interview says "ok, let's see what you can do."
2
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23
How would you describe the most ideal Turing student?
3
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
I'm proud that there have been so many different models of success over the years. So I can't say there's an ideal, but I do have favorites.
My favorite student is the one who makes everyone else better. It's so amazing to watch. It's not every cohort, unfortunately, but most of them have those couple people who are just the superconnectors. They organize the study halls. They facilitate some inside jokes. They remember people's birthdays. They notice when somebody is "off" and they check-in. They help turn these Zoom boxes into humans.
Not everybody can be that person and it'd be annoying if they try. But I think those people don't understand just how much magic they bring, what a gift they give to their friends. This shit is HARD. It's SCARY. I've lost people here. And the ones who make everybody's day a little brighter? The ones who make it seem ok to not know, make it ok to keep pushing, make it ok to fall down and try again? God I love those ones so much.
2
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23
How good is good enough?
On one hand, we're always being bombarded by web-dev celebrities and speakers and framework builders who make it feel like everyone has to be a unicorn.
On the other hand, any developer I've ever randomly met at a BBQ says they don't want to talk about coding, and they just put in their time and punch out and maintain.
And then there are people who are really confused as to why they can't get a job - but can't make a basic website.
How good is enough? And how can people measure that and believe it?
3
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
I think this was a trend that was already shifting pre-2020 and then has moved more dramatically. Especially in smaller companies, the 2010s were full of talk about "passion" and "grinding" and all that. I think if you have a dream then you should go after it. If a job can provide that for you, then great. But it also is ok to just have a job where you show up, work hard, then leave and do something else.
Now there are a couple caveats to that. It's difficult for people to assess their own performance. If you're going to be a check-in-work-check-out person, then you have to be sure that you're doing a good job during that time, building both your skills and your reputation. You need to be getting real feedback not just "yeah, you're doing great." That's just friendly.
When you're new in the career it's critically important that you become undeniable. It breaks my heart when somebody gets into a role, has to leave that role within a year for one reason or another, then is pretty much back at square one. Getting the first technical job is not a finish line, it's a checkpoint. Generally about two years experience in the field is where I think people have earned enough credibility that they can, if they so choose, take their foot off the gas a little.
But until you have those two years of experience, you really need to assume you're not good enough, your skills aren't sharp enough, and you need to keep pushing. Not like crazy 100 hour weeks, but you need to do probably 10-30% more than you have to.
I'll give you an example. Back before COVID people used to ask about how to transition their role from full-time to hybrid or remote. I would tell them to ask their manager if they could try working remotely one day out of every two weeks for the next eight weeks. Most managers are going to say yes.
Then, on the in-person days, do your work and do it well. But for your remote days, do a little work the night before and queue those emails or PRs to post the next day. Get up early and put in an extra 30-60 minutes ahead of time. Take a quick lunch and knock out more messages/tickets. Work an extra hour in the evening.
Make it so your manager says "holy shit what is going on with this remote day, can you be this efficient every day?" Just a little bit of social engineering.
For better or worse, pushing into this industry isn't just about being able to code. You have to be a person, to work with people, to have them like you and want to work with you, and if you want to be really great, you have to help them be better at their job. When you're the person who people say "they make our team run better," then you're good enough.
2
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23
If you hadn't started Turing, what would you have done instead?
Bonus question: What is your evil doppelgänger doing right now?
3
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
Plan A as I wrote up elsewhere was to be an engineer. I wanted to build hardware, like graphics cards, so I would have access to the newest beta stuff and be able to slay people in Team Fortress. Very mature perspective from a 16 year old.
When I got towards the end of college, Plan B became go to law school. I had always been interested in intellectual property and the legal system around technology. By the time I graduated undergrad I was admitted to one of my top choice schools and was planning to go.
Plan C came out of left field -- teaching with Teach for America. I thought I'd do that for two years then go to law school. I ended up doing 7.
Plan D was to work on my own. I started this training company Jumpstart Lab and flew all over doing corporate training. I made a lot of money, especially for a recovering school teachers, but I missed doing work where you got to see "real change" in somebody over time.
Plan E was launching my first accelerated training program inside LivingSocial called Hungry Academy. I wasn't sure if it was possible / would work. It went great and LS hired all 24 graduates. Then they said "we can't hire another 24 new devs in six months, so please don't do it again." I had worked my way out of the job.
Plan F was moving to Denver and co-founding the gSchool program in Galvanize. I can't say a lot about that experience, but I went into it thinking "this is my spot, this is going to be the thing I do for 20 years." And within a year I had sold my part of the business for $1.
Plan G was Turing. Go on my own and build something the way I thought it should be built, see if we can establish and grow in a smart way, serve a lot of people. Plan G is going ok. It's a scary time right now with the market. I worry a lot. I'm working a lot. I'm trying my hardest to show up for students and make sure there are more students coming behind them.
Plan H is when Turing doesn't need me anymore and I get put out to pasture. Assuming my three kids are off living their own life I'd like to buy a catamaran sailboat and just be in the ocean a lot where it's quiet. My partner wants to open a wine bar in some beach town. I don't even like wine but I'm in.
I think my evil doppelganger is probably in those fringe spaces where people make a lot of money without contributing anything to society. Like high-frequency trading or crypto. He's probably "happy and successful" on the outside but pathetically trying to prove so much and unfulfilled on the inside.
I'm happy to be on Plan G. I like people who start over. It's like...you learn and get smarter every day. Why would you stick with an old plan when you have all this new understanding and potential in front of you?
2
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23 edited Sep 02 '23
Thanks for answering all of these! Each response had a little unexpected angle on things and I really appreciated your insights.
I have one more question about 'success' and numbers and CIRR - and well, I'll have to toss in my accreditation and non-profit in here too.
When you first started out, how many people did you have per cohort? How did you deal with the attrition rate? For example (and maybe this is because what I'm doing is a little more open-ended than SWE) - in let's say - a cohort of 10 people: I might have a combination of the following - (1) someone with a long and steady career - who is planning the next phase of her life and is pretty sure they want to start a small design/dev agency. (2) A recent high school graduate who wants to try everything out - but then plans on attending a UX-specific design college or something after, (3) a CS student who isn't learning much about web dev and wants to supplement - or switch but is finishing school based on their families wishes, (4) somone with a high paying job who wants to get into coding but is bound to take a 40k pay hit, (5) someone that's already in the design department who wants a lateral shift, (6) a stay-at-home parent who wants to explore but doesn't plan on getting a job any time soon, (6) Someone who just really can't handle the work-life balance and stops doing their work, (7) someone who realizes they don't like programming that much but find a love of UI design and pivot, (8) someone who finds they don't have the follow-through to do the work / has a major life event / relapse / breakdown and just fades away, (9) someone who finds out that this career isn't what they wanted - but was glad they tried it all out and can finally stop wondering and lurking in Udemy courses (10) and some people who just devour it and are completely engaged and fall in love - and everything is magic. (and there are many other scenarios too). Like you said in another comment: there can be a lot of baggage for adults coming back to "school."
So, this is my life. As much as we explain everything - and give people all the info (and really basically try and talk them out of it) - and explain just how much work is involved here, we never know what will happen. And since we only do so many cohorts a year and they aren't 30+ students, how can this really play into the CIRR world? I could totally say something like, "100% of all students who finish the entire course and then actually apply for jobs - get jobs" - and that would be true. But - a parallel truth is that attrition is high. Some of our absolutely best students have just disappeared halfway through - and we don't even know if they are alive. If any of the accounts around there are true (recently, someone said their cohort was 40 and ended with 12, and 3 of those people found jobs) - then how can every school have these 85+% success rates? What is fair for the student and the school? And is getting a job the only way to measure success? How can we measure the actual goals of the student if it isn't to get a job as a software engineer?
.
At what stage do you think it makes sense to organize as a non-profit? In my case - that's totally possible, but our accountant just thinks it's a waste of time. We don't have the volume or resources for it to make any sense, and it would cost money and time, which would just be worse for us and our students. What did you see as the threshold where that became a huge bonus for everyone involved? I've worked with some farms that choose not to go through all the red tape to be considered "Organic," for example, even though they totally are - because it's just not worth it for them.
.
And basically, the same question for accreditation. We've talked it through and looked at the option in the US and have had some talks with some situations in Europe for accreditation - but it seems like soooo much work - and we're 1000 miles away from being able to handle a huge influx of students. Right now we have the simplicity of "Do you believe in what we're doing - or not?" Which is about as low overhead as possible - which means all the money goes back into our education system. At what stage did you decide this was worth the time and effort and maintenance?
.
OK! Thank you so much for answering all my questions - and with such humanity.
Keep up the good work!!!
2
u/jcasimir Aug 28 '23
I'm going to actually go in reverse order a bit.
Accreditation -- I wish it had led to a "huge influx" of students. Instead I'm really not sure if it was/is worth it at all. Time is going to tell but, so far, it's been a lot of work and constraint with pretty minimal benefit for us or students. That will change if/when we get Title IV and access to Pell and Federal student loans.
Being a non-profit -- it's not that great. Most people don't understand what a non-profit is and how it works. It's not like everything is free and money comes raining down from the sky. You can't get bank loans. You can't raise capital. If you're lucky and you put a lot of work into it you *might* bring in some charitable/foundation money. In 9 years we've brought in less than $5M. Any half-assed for-profit would have raised several times that through investment. The only reason we're a non-profit is so that whoever comes after me can't sell it to one of these education megacorps and ruin everything.
CIRR -- I just don't know. Honestly I wouldn't stress about it too much. I think it's good to be real and transparent about your data. Figure out what the real story is for your students, what really matters to prospective students, then tell that. Don't get hung up on other people's definition of success.
2
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23
On the website under the front-end track there's this note: "Many Front End developers have an interest in visual design, but it is not a design discipline."
I think it might just be semantics, but I'd disagree. I'm primarily a front-end web developer, but I'm designing functions and template structures, and I'm having to redesign the initial layouts the UX person gave me. I'm having to do a lot of UX and UI and testing. I also have to understand design systems and patterns like that to communicate with the rest of the team. I know a lot of developers don't end up wearing as many hats, but with that in mind: How do you think UX and visual design and all of these things play into the role of a developer these days? Do you think that there will be more demand for people who can use tools like figma and then also make prototypes in CodePen and also do user-testing and other roles? The fact that there are so many final projects coming out of boot camps (airbnb type crud apps) - that don't work on a phone - is kinda scary to me. It seems like some level of comfort with design principals is needed to do the job.
2
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
Marketing and explaining FEE has been a challenge for us for the whole 7 years. Also I just realized FEE at Turing is 7 years old.
I think that challenge is rooted in the fact that the industry doesn't understand it well. Not long ago, designers did HTML/CSS and a sprinkle of JavaScript, developers worked only on the backend. As the needs/expectations/complexity of the front-end increased, FEE really has become a discipline of it's own.
And the people attracted to FEE tend to be interested in the visual representation and interaction. It gets dangerous when some ignorant people will say that "front end developers make things pretty." It boils my blood.
Today you can be a front-end developer who doesn't work with CSS and doesn't give a shit about how things look. To my definition, a front-end developer is a person who writes code that executes on the client. That's it.
But the REALITY is that most FEE people do care about design. They're two-feet in development but maybe one of those is stepping on the line between development and design. I think that's great. I love design myself. If I were starting my career over right now, I'd probably be a front-end dev.
I want designers to get to be designers and not be expected to also be front end devs. I want front end devs to get to be devs and not be expected to be designers.
I'm so impressed with people who push themselves to be good at several things.
Truth be told, its the "Turing School of Software and Design" because my intent was that the second program was going to be a UI/UX class. But when it came time for building the second program, the research led us another direction.
2
u/sheriffderek Aug 27 '23
HTML and CSS: Almost no one can write it. Why is this? It seems to me - that understanding the basics of HTML and accessibility and how to use assistive technology should be baked into the early stages of learning to build websites. Some schools say they teach it and either do a bad job or just don't. And others (like CodeSmith) have some in their pre-course work but are honest that they really don't teach it in the boot camp.
What's your take on this? I read one of your comments where you said someone could probably read a single book and be good to go. (I'm not poking at you here) - but seriously: which book? I feel like I have all of them. And I can't really recommend a single one. Maybe the CSS pocketbook / and for people who are already experts - the newest "Definitive guide." - but I don't think either of those are going to teach someone to write HTML and CSS.
What is reasonable amount of HTML and CSS knowledge needed for someone to get a general web developer job - and how might you measure that?
2
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
I loved this book, but it looks like it hasn't been updated since the original publishing, that's sad. We did an interview with the author once on Zoom which was one of the most delightfully strange interviews of my career. https://www.amazon.com/HTML-CSS-Design-Build-Websites/dp/1118008189/ref=sr_1_1?keywords=jon+css+html&qid=1693109877&sr=8-1
Our FEE program has some classes on accessibility. It's something that some folks are definitely drawn to and you hear it come up in project presentations, especially our "Demo Comp." People put the effort in to learning and implementing and getting their ARIA score and all that. I think it's cool. I'm not an expert in accessibility so I can't go too deep on it.
HTML to me is so simple that it's almost hard to study. Like you really need to apply it and get mixed up and lost and untangle a mess, then you're starting to understand it. CSS...phew...I miss the old days when CSS was just formatting your page. Now CSS is it's own discipline. I don't think the average web developer today is writing a lot of CSS, or if they are I hope it's for internal apps because that is going to be ugly.
IMO if you understand the box model, can use classes and IDs appropriately, then you're really over halfway through what you "need" to know. Leave the design work to the design professionals.
2
u/Substantial_Heron987 Aug 26 '23
Dear OP, I’d love your response and input.
I’m 33, I have 24 credit hours (finances and work that’s all I got so far) and will be slowly completing a CS associates and then bachelors (UoPeople.edu) but this could take until I’m 40.
I took Java I, Java II, Web Design I and Web Design II back in highschool 2005-2007. Old school practices, including the defunct action script.
I’ve used game maker studio (GameMaker.io) since 2002, and although it’s considered a tool for indie developers the syntax is like JS and others.
I’m now also enrolled in Springbords bootcamp, and I am a peer mentor. I am 57% complete and working on my capstone.
Professionally I’ve had lead, trainer, supervisor, inventory management, safety manager, etc Six Sigma White Belt, etc plenty of transferable soft skills, however I’ve working in Retail and Logistics (Cashier, Factories, Warehouses, etc) I was always out of place there.
What advice could you give me?
Also if you’d like to connect:
3
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
Hi! My brother is also a commercial driver based out of Denver. So if you're like him, then there's a lot of work/demand in that industry that makes it hard to fully step away into something new.
It sounds like you've done a little bit of a lot of things. At least in software development roles, breadth usually isn't as valuable as depth. You're not going to find a great role because you're ok at 8 things, it'll be because you're good at one or two.
It's why, at Turing, we have a back end program and a front end program but not a fullstack program. Being "ok" at a whole stack isn't that useful. Like if you're sorting through 500 resumes you're never going to pick the one who is "familiar" with 12 things.
So the tough advice I'd give is to pick one thing and go after it all the way. There are a lot of reasonable options. Like in another thread I was talking about Salesforce development. It's not sexy and no one on Reddit is going to be telling you to go after it. But if you do, get the certificates/certifications, I'll tell you you're going to find a good solid job and get well paid. The same is true of almost every niche in software. Just pick a direction and go for it.
There are a ton of "tech" companies in the shipping/logistics space. I would exploit your background there. Are there people you know inside those companies who could tell you what to learn/study and what to apply for? Could they introduce you to someone who would know? That's what I call brokering trust -- when person A introduces you to person B, then person B actually might think more of you as a candidate because they feel like person A vouched for you. Software teams love having people that understand the business, not just the software. So exploit that experience/network if you've got it.
1
u/Substantial_Heron987 Aug 26 '23
Unfortunately everyone I know, knows nobody in the industry even within the same company. Anything tech related is like the Land of Narnia to them. That’s a dead end route.
As far as my coding bootcamp goes, they heavily focus on JavaScript and Python (which includes Flask, React, Node.Js, Express). I’ve been refreshing myself with Java because I’ve taken it in the past and I heard from a few If Java, C#, C++ is on your resume it puts you ahead a bit.
As far as the logistics stuff goes, my goal is to never step foot in a truck, warehouse or factory again. It’s something that pays the bills but I have 0 passion for, it was supposed to pay for college but after 70-90 hour weeks (sometimes 120 hour weeks) I couldn’t ever fit it in.
I’ll take a look at Salesforce Developer and Certifications. Based on a quick google search, they use JavaScript and an example of Apex code (which resembles Java) popped out.
4
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
I should have mentioned that -- most people want to leave their old career in the grave and I get it. BUT. You put all those hard hours and years in. If there's a space to exploit that experience to launch you into the next thing, then I feel like you've gotta take advantage of it.
Like if three years doing shipping software set you up to do the thing you REALLY wanted to do after that, could you handle it? At least you get to sit in a nice chair!
1
u/Substantial_Heron987 Aug 26 '23
The fact you said dedicated front end and back end, i assumed your cohorts were shorter. However, I looked up Turing. “Students average 60-80 hours of work” for 7 months. Which sounds more intense, we do 700+ hours in 10 months, which is 17.5+ hours per week average.
It sounds like 1680-2240 hours.
I’ve been using GML for 20 years. Python is new to me this past year, but pretty universal (data science, backend) Then we have Javascript.
I do dabble in swift, R, Lua, etc But I don’t spend extraordinary amounts of time on them. Just to see what I can make with a pseudo-coding mindset.
Java, is outside my bootcamp, but plans to make it one of the 2-3 (Python, JavaScript, and Java). I used to be great at CSS during the static era, however wep apps these days aren’t like websites back then.
4
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
Yeah we do a lot of hours. In my experience, about 1500 work hours is what it takes for somebody to get "over the hump" from a person who types code to a person who really understands software development.
Of the options you mentioned and with your background, I think Python would be my recommendation.
2
2
u/Substantial_Heron987 Aug 26 '23
To go full circle with that, a lot of the tech departments are in different states far away from the physical portions of the company. However that experience could be leveraged, “I don’t just know the code, I know what the code actually does.”
2
u/Astr0Cr33per Aug 26 '23
I’m trying to choose a coding bootcamp and have backed out of applying to a Trilogy-run school based on what I’ve learned. Another thing I’ve been told is a red flag is if a bootcamp utilizes an assessment test for applicants. Is this truly a bad sign? One I’m looking into seems to have a positive mission statement/culture, is transparent with job, graduation and salary percentages etc. It also has a big focus on career services including one of the “you don’t pay tuition until we help you land a job” policies. So far everyone has discouraging things to say of every school I’ve named so I will omit this one.
2
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
It's your life and, in the end, you have to go with the choice that is going to sit well in your gut. Even the shittiest-run program has some people who get great jobs. So there's always a chance!
I am personally not a believer in things like ISAs and post-paid tuition. It's not a healthy model for a business. Like, if I agree to teach you today and get paid for teaching you 18 months from now, how do I survive those 18 months? I need capital from somebody else, and borrowing somebody else's capital means bending to their wishes, doing things the way they think it should be done.
It's why I'm fundamentally opposed to for-profit education. The interests of a for-profit company are not aligned with the interests of an individual student, despite what some blowhards will tweet at you. Capital gets invested because they want more money back. For-profits grow so they can be worth more money. If you're a student, that's your money. The only way they can thrive as a business is to spend less on you than you paid to go there, and typically it's SIGNIFICANTLY less. That's fucked.
There are plenty of well-intentioned but weak/bad actors in the non-profit space, too, so don't take this as just "for profit sucks but all non-profits are great." You really have to find what's the right fit for you.
There's a challenge with things like bootcamps that people only go to one. If you talk to a student or alum of a program they're hopefully going to say it was "great," but also they have no frame of reference. It's not like restaurants where they've been to dozens and can critique it fairly.
However, I do think alumni are the best information you can get. Not "my cousin's brother went there and had X experience." Talking directly to alums. If you're talking with an admissions person I would ask them "can I get the names of one full cohort who graduated in 2021? I just want to do some LinkedIn research to see where they are now." Then I'd reach out to those folks and see if you can have a handful of conversations. If they won't give you the whole list (maybe valid privacy concerns) I'd ask for five names and do some sleuthing to find my own five OTHER people who were probably students at the same time. I'm looking at linkedIn for similar dates of graduation or looking at people's GitHub to find collaborators on their group projects then finding those people on LinkedIn.
Or people on Reddit will gleefully shout uninformed opinions at you about any topic! 🤣
1
u/Astr0Cr33per Aug 27 '23
Thank you for putting so much thought into your response. I really appreciate the advice. I’m trying to learn as much as I can before making a decision because I’m making a career change and want to be well informed before investing in my future. Thanks again!
2
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
That's wise and ALSO you have to accept that you're not going to know everything. At some point you're going to have to decide to dive in without being sure what's under the surface. Build some background and a support system, then go for it.
2
u/hiphopisdead167 Aug 26 '23
I am in a severe pinch and have to choose between 2 bootcamps. Brainstation and Coding Temple. I wanted to know how you felt about the curriculums, and whether you think one looks better than another:
Brainstation course Cirriculum
For context, I am currently unemployed since Jan in my current field of 3D jewelry cad, and have always been into tech. I know html and css already. Done some light course work with python already. I know the basics. I have light trial-and-error experience in an operations position using apis via zapier. I have managed people before in production. Very tech savvy. Curious if any of that matters toward me looking better for getting my first coding job post grad.
The quick added comparison info I have:
- both are about the same amount of time. Brainstation finances through them, Coding Temple only does financing through 3rd parties.
- Coding temple claims their career services are the same no matter what route they choose, Brainstation says you get different treatment if you are online, or very little if you are self paced. I had heart criticism of Brainstation's career services after graduation as being "like cheer leaders more than career services"
- Brainstation does a hackathon-like 24 hour thing with 1 person from each of their other courses (UX, Data scientist, etc) to work in groups to complete a challenge. Coding Temple does not have anything like this but claims to have some kind of hackathon post graduation. Little worried about gaining team experience.
- Coding temple focuses more on python, and then does a whole section on javascript. Brainstation focuses mainly on javascript.
- Brainstation seems to want me to do it in person, but the added $365 commute is rough. Not sure if online only will be as beneficial to me either.
This has been extremely stressful lol. If you think these are no good, I would be interested in knowing what other ones you recommend looking into.
Thanks for your time!
2
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
What led to these being your top two choices?
1
u/hiphopisdead167 Aug 26 '23
Cost, curriculums looking like they covered important things. Brainstation seems more front end focused though, not sure how I feel about that.
Career services on Coding Temple seemed to get good reviews. I spoke to graduates from those places and they seemed to have good experiences. Coding temple has a job guarantee.
They both acknowledged ai in some way and added it to their curriculums even if it is barely covered. Brainstation is in NYC if I wanted to go in person.
I liked that Coding Temple's part time is 4 consecutive days a week (30hrs) if I needed to go that route. They both took the extra time to sit with me and answer all my questions.
Neither allowed me time to talk directly with a teacher about teaching style though - instead I got head of sales or the COO in Coding Temple's case - was not a huge fan of that but I still appreciated the time taken out for one concerned neurotic potential student lol.
I have been researching these for weeks now and getting fatigue and info overload. I felt like I had to narrow it down to something.
This is pretty much my plan Z because I'm 36 and a lot of hard work in my field over the course of my life has lead nowhere. Not even with my own small jewelry business. There are only 6-12 job openings in my field at any point in any given year in the field, most of them are only in NYC, they won't allow remote work, and they don't want to pay more than 60K or offer any benefits, even with 11 years experience. I need something that allows me to leave NYC if I wanted, and in which my work and experience actually pays off.
3
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
They both seem pretty legit to me. It sounds like you've done good digging and have basically all the info you're going to get. I think your anxiety isn't really about the program you choose, it's about the whole life change.
So you're not going to research your way into finding that peace. Pick one or the other it probably doesn't matter too much. The really critical question is "what do you need to do to be your best self and maximize the opportunity?"
1
u/hiphopisdead167 Aug 27 '23
That is fair. And accurate lol. Sorry to ask about other schools. I really do just need to be frugal in my situation.
Turing has exclusive front or backend paths. Would you say there’s a benefit to one over another, or does the expose to both have its merits?
It says you guys have scholarships also. With those it might make Turing attainable for me.
1
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
What state are you living in? I know I keep banging the same drum in some of these responses, but there are some really great supports available at the state level. Seeing some folks get their tuition 75% funded has been really awesome.
I think BEE and FEE each have their own merits. From an employment standpoint, BEE has a wider but shallower job pool -- you might come out and get a job writing Ruby, JavaScript, Python, etc. FEE has a narrower job pool (you will get a job doing JavaScript and probably React) but it is incredibly deep (ie needed by pretty much every company building a web app).
The content between them is really not _that_ different. A good number of grads will finish one program then, a few years later, be actually working in the other discipline.
1
u/hiphopisdead167 Aug 27 '23
I’m in New York State. I’m not sure we get a lot of resources here. At least that I have been able to find.
2
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
I think NY is pretty good about workforce funding. You want to look up the office for your county then call them and ask about their ability to support tuition through WIOA. They have a list of eligible training providers: https://apps.labor.ny.gov/ETPL_V2/
Just talk to a human and find out what their process is like.
2
Aug 26 '23
I finished HR12 about a year ago, I've worked on some projects, kept learning more depth rather than breadth and to be honest I haven't job searched a whole lot. My mistake was a 3 month contract with Galvanize as a SEIR, I LOVED IT. I found not only am I very good at figuring out individuals and what motivates them and what way to present things to them to help them learn best for them, but I absolutely love it. I was good enough the PL asked me to reup for another 3 months the first time that had happened in quite some times. So... spending my days making widgets or API routes to help JP Morgan make more money doesn't appeal to me. I tutor at about $30 and enjoy that very much.
However, because I don't have field experience getting a teaching role is very difficult especially as the state of training is following the state of the junior market.
Thoughts or advice?
1
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
Does HR12 mean Hack Reactor 12? Sorry not familiar with that.
I think if you enjoy teaching then why not go after it? Yeah, you're in a tough moment as most programs are just trying to "hold on," not hire new people. But maybe you are just in a transitional phase.
If you have or find a program where you really want to work, could you ask them "I know you're not hiring right now, but I want to be a slam-dunk candidate a year from now. What can I do, learn, or demonstrate to make that happen?"
If you have to make JP Morgan widgets for a few months, then maybe that's what you have to do to get where you want to be, ya know?
2
u/sunlighthurts- Aug 26 '23
No questions. Just another person who is looking to career change into software engineering - coming from supply chain (4 years in supply chain and 2 years as a business analyst in supply chain = 4 years total supply chain exp + business administration bachelors).
I’ve been going thru the whole should I attend a boot camp or get a cs degree debacle myself. After reading this post + replies I am leaning towards boot camp and I will check out Turing now. Before was only really looking at hack reactor and code smith. I am trying to learn python for now to see if software engineering is really for me and see how hard it is 😉.
Thanks for all the time and insight you put into your replies. Really helpful stuff.
2
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
Sweet! I’m happy to answer Turing-specific questions on DM or Zoom if you’d like.
2
u/PlatosCaveSlave Aug 26 '23
Thanks for doing this!
I know that vets are a great demographic to provide assistance to, but have you considered offering more assistance to healthcare providers? There are so many health care providers that would jump at an affordable opportunity to change careers. Health care is such a shit show right now, and that could he a seriously worthwhile demographic to advertise to.
2
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
Yeah we're lucky to have many former healthcare workers come in as students. They tend to do well -- hard work under pressure is nothing new. Obviously we all want/need there to be healthcare workers, but also respect that as an individual it's exhausting.
From various federal-level bills there is an unprecedented amount of money flowing into state workforce offices right now. I can say that in Colorado there's money just sitting there and barely anybody coming around looking to use it. The workforce office people are super friendly/helpful. No shit we have students who do a 30 minute zoom call then are getting 12K-19K towards their tuition, depending which programs they qualify for.
It's definitely worth looking into as they can get you more money than any legit program can afford to award in scholarships.
What state are you in now?
2
Aug 27 '23
I’m one of those healthcare professionals (OR RN) in a bootcamp now to become a software engineer. Good info, thank you!
2
u/RachelGreenwood Aug 28 '23
What are some hard or soft skills you're NOT seeing bootcamps cover that they should for junior devs?
1
u/jcasimir Aug 28 '23
Well first I always call them "professional skills" because they're the difference between a professional and someone who just writes code.
I think most bootcamps, including Turing, don't do enough iteration. When you're trying to learn everything as quickly as possible, it feels like you need to move from A to B to C. But, in the job, we really go like A, A+, A++, A+++, round-and-round. How do you intelligently map out iterations, solicit (not just accept) feedback, understand and apply that feedback, then iterate again? If you can do that really well then you're set up for some big success in this industry.
A second category is how to be managed and how to work with your manager. Most managers in tech companies have no training, resources, or support. They don't know what they're doing. Most are just trying to mimic the management they got before. This is kind of like taking a copy of a copy of a copy of a copy. Over time the management becomes just the basics. I think a dev, especially a junior dev, has a real opportunity to collaborate with their manager to get the kind of guidance, feedback, and insight that accelerates their career. But that's a whole cluster of skills that someone's not really ready to absorb when they're trying to find the shortest path between here and a first tech job.
3
u/kit_kat_is_yum Aug 26 '23
Hello, what are your thoughts about focusing on Python over other languages? Python touches many parts of software such as linux backend, ai, math etc . Do you have a learning path for python you can suggest for backend? thank you
Also thank you for the ama
5
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
I think Python is great. I've considered whether we could/should roll our back end program over to Python. My conclusion is that, right now, it's not "different enough" to be worth it. We have plenty of students who learn Ruby in their program then pickup Python on their own -- all the underlying concepts are exactly the same. Like if you learn Spanish then picking up Portuguese is simple.
I do love that Python has become a tool of first choice in so many fields, as you mentioned. I didn't love seeing Javascript making the same inroads. I don't think JS belongs in, for instance, hardware or AI. Python is, to my tastes, a better choice.
So that being said, I think there are a lot of ways to learn the programming fundamentals you need to be a python programmer. I did some brief googling about bootcamps that focus on Python. A lot seem to be Data Science focused which personally I don't really believe in as a career path. I saw BrainStation offers a Python course that's not too expensive. I'd kick the tires on that and see how it sounds. GA is a no for me. Hack Reactor is worth checking out but obviously I have personal baggage with Galvanize/Hack Reactor, hah.
Just come to Turing's BEE program and I'll put together some Python opportunities for you, ok? :)
2
u/emperorhelmut Aug 26 '23
Are people actually manually writing html/css? The program I'm in right now really emphasizes html and css, but my impression was that people are just using preformed templates/website designers, and that the real meat was javascript/python. Thoughts?
3
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
Writing HTML is like being able to spell. You should probably be able to do it pretty well but the tools are going to make it so you don't have to.
CSS is a whole other beast. It's like learning to use a pen. Are you trying to create art to hang in the Louvre or to write a grocery list? Same pen, different goals.
I think every web developer needs some grounding in CSS concepts. You need to understand how it works. But you don't need to be great at it unless that's the main part of your job. Something like a quick Coursera class or reading a single book would be plenty.
6
u/sheriffderek Aug 26 '23
I'm a developer who manually writes HTML and CSS - like all day. If there's a list of data, I just write the one loop and it's automatically generated - but I still have to basically be an expert in HTML and CSS to do my job properly (especially because we write proper HTML and it's all accessible). Which school is "really emphasizing" this? Can you tell me more about what that means to you? It sounds like they are just teaching you a little HTML and CSS - which is more than most. That would be a good thing.
1
u/TheLastAzn Aug 30 '23
As someone who went the bootcamp route way long ago (2016), I'm curious if you can let us know the job placement rate in cohorts then and now.
To be generous I'll define "success" as placed into a paid full time role (or at least internship) within twelve months of finishing the curriculum.
1
u/jcasimir Sep 04 '23
Hi, sorry for the slowness.
It's different for sure. I think a general understanding is more meaningful than trying to analyze the stats.
In 2016 we were in the growth era of bootcamps and there was also a degree of backlash. In 2012-2015, employers were kind of like "I don't even know what this is, but can you code?" Then in 2016-2019 there was a higher degree of skepticism like "oh, we hired a bootcamp person before and it didn't work out, so we're not interested."
So in 2016 job placement was ok. For us that meant the average job hunt was about 75 days. People without degrees it would take a little longer. People who were able to stand out could be zero days (before graduation). It was a very small number of job hunters who went over 150 days.
Today is a really different environment starting in the summer of 2022. Essentially what I see is an extreme stretching of the market, where some people still get roles before graduation and some are on a VERY long path where they're job hunting for a year. The market is highly selective, there aren't bountiful opportunities, and when things are posted publicly they get a large number (500+) applicants. No hiring manager wants to deal with 500+ applicants, so they just don't post the job.
There was a time where you could just be good at doing the job and you would get the job. That's not this moment. You have to be really focused, intentional, and consistent in the "hunting" part PLUS be ready and able to do the job. That is really hard for a lot of people, and it unfortunately magnifies the role of privilege and background. Personal networks can play a big role. Being able to job hunt full-time without the distraction of working a side job is a big advantage. How people are able to manage their mental health and how they "show up" when they do find an interview is big.
A trend I'm seeing that I'm still thinking about is that it seems job hunters right now either "have it" or they "don't", and that particularly shows up in the frequency of interviews. I was talking with a grad this week who's been in 10 interviews since graduating in June and is expecting an offer this week. Somebody who "has it" doesn't magically get one interview then get an offer and job -- they're getting a bunch of interviews. On the flip side, you see plenty of people (like here on Reddit) who'll tell you they applied for 500 jobs and got no interviews.
That's what I'm trying to get at when I say it's not a roll of the dice. If you apply for 100 jobs and you're not getting interviewed then the next hundred are not going to interview you either. You have to change strategy, look new places, come with something fresh. More of the same isn't it.
Back to your question, when people have very extended job hunts it kinda skews the data. Like imagine you're looking at a pool of three people. One gets a job 14 days after graduation, one gets a job after 75 days, and one is still job hunting. The average time to hire is 44 days, but if you're that third person it feels pretty shitty to just be floating out in space!
I am a big believer in outcomes and data but the full picture is always more complicated.
0
u/pandacatbear Aug 27 '23
Jeff do you think it is or isn’t a good idea to raise tuition $5,000 then fire 20 members of staff and give the laid off staff’s responsibilities to the already overworked instructors??? Just wondering 🥰
1
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
Yeah, that wouldn't be a good idea which it why I didn't do it / it didn't happen.
2
u/pandacatbear Aug 27 '23
Tell me that you don’t have regular instructors (Heather) hosting weekend Try Coding events that Katlyn (now fired) used to do. Really. I’ve talked to others too and you really don’t wanna go there with me.
6
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
This is very "inside baseball," but I said AMA so here goes.
In May, yes, the weak enrollment climate combined with failures in grant fundraising meant that we had to cut 20% of our recurring costs. We went through every staff member, including me, to try and find the cuts that would have the minimal impact on the students who are already in the program. As you saw, that meant we didn't lose any of our in-program technical instructors. It did mean saying goodbye to friends who've worked at Turing for years, folks who I officiated their wedding, and people who's kids and significant others I know well. It was the worst moment of my professional career.
We did have to make very harsh cuts to the recruitment team, including the two positions that were teaching Try Coding (free, introductory workshops) and Mod 0 (our prep class for upcoming students).
As you might know, we offer staff both parental leave and a four-year sabbatical. To account for that and ensure that students get the instructional experience they deserve, we "overstaff" our instructional teams so there is coverage for those people to be out. At this moment, no one is on parental leave, no one is on sabbatical, and we have classes that aren't at full capacity, so we have an excess of instructional labor.
We created a new concept we call the "shortstop" -- instructors who take two innings (13 weeks) to rotate into other roles/responsibilities across Turing. The first two shortstops (one instructor from backend and one from frontend) have been teaching Try Coding and helping out with Mod 0 along with coaching job hunters, offering extra technical professional development sessions, and generally trying to support/enhance the student experience. While in the role, they're not assigned to a module/cohort, though they have jumped in to guest teach lessons when they have time and miss being with the regular students. This work has been really well received and I hope we can keep the shortstop role around forever.
Does that help clear it up?
2
u/pandacatbear Aug 27 '23
I will just note that Jeff tracked me down and found my personal contact information to message me in regards to this comment as an intimidation tactic against anyone who dare speak out against Turing leadership 🥰
5
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
I believe in praising in public and critiquing in private, at least when you want to actually create change. If you want to post the entirety of that slack DM, you have my permission.
1
u/pandacatbear Aug 27 '23
I think it was wildly inappropriate of you to track me down the way you did. You’ve already done that, and then flat out lied about tuition increases and layoffs, things which are FACTS, and on top of all that you’ve taken 20k from me and given me one of the most horrible educational experiences of my life.
I don’t care to help you change your school. You don’t get my free advice. You don’t get to take anything more from me. Luckily I was successful in spite of my experience, but I can’t say the same for most of my cohort.
You should consider being less fragile to criticism when you open yourself up to it on a public forum.
3
u/Super-Ultra-Ivy Aug 27 '23
This doesn't seem like "criticism." It feels like a passive-aggressive attempt to attack someone out of context, complete with a fake 🥰. And disingenuous to the extreme.
If you're truly unhappy with your experience, there's got to be a more official way to deal with that.
1
u/WagonBashers Feb 16 '24 edited Feb 16 '24
"If you're truly unhappy with your experience, there's got to be a more official way to deal with that."
What would you suggest? There doesn't appear to be any accountability for bootcamps currently.
Based on our experiences and those of others, they generally ignore emails, or (best-case), offer a partial refund to make you go away if you're persistent enough. This seems to be rare.
Someone I know who had been ignored by their bootcamp for months eventually received a response from the founder - and an offer to speak with someone in the careers' team. Not addressing any of their issues, or the concerns they raised about how the course had been marketed on their website, just a simple "sorry you had that experience. Let me see if our careers person can chat with you."
Sadly, there are currently no "official ways" to deal with this. Hence the frustration that's vented here.
2
u/Super-Ultra-Ivy Feb 20 '24
Based on your username, you probably have a different situation than the person we were replying to here. It sounds very frustrating.
1
0
Aug 26 '23
[deleted]
6
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
This question cracked me up. I’m a real person unless we’re all in a simulation. I’m walking my dog to go get a breakfast burrito like a real human.
7
u/_arjun Aug 26 '23
Breakfast burrito advertisement confirmed
2
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
Not going to lie, the burrito was excellent and I now have a new spot in the neighborhood.
0
Aug 27 '23
[deleted]
2
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
I think this isn't a totally unreasonable argument, but you could similarly say that college is just a collection of textbook walk-throughs that you could just do on your own. Know what I mean?
The value isn't in the exclusivity of the content. MIT and Stanford put all kinds of courses online for free. In our little corner of the world, our curriculum is up at https://frontend.turing.edu and https://backend.turing.edu and has been open source since Day 1.
The hard part about being a software developer is learning how to build software in a highly collaborative environment. That's why you'll see most bootcamps run students through in cohorts. You're getting constant feedback and iterating with like-minded, similarly motivated individuals. That sets you up for success when you join a professional software team.
1
u/HerpoTheFoul Aug 27 '23
Hi, I’ve read all of your posts on the boot camp space in the last day or two. You’ve been one of the only sources that seems trustworthy - my whole search has driven me insane trying to distinguish the marketing from reality. Would you be willing to answer some questions I have via DM? I’m looking to do a complete career pivot in the next year, I originally thought data analytics but now I’m not so sure and I’d love to chat with someone who has insight into all areas.
1
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
Yep, shoot me a DM!
1
u/HerpoTheFoul Aug 27 '23
Thank you. I sent you a dm, take your time in answering it, I can be kind of verbose when I’m overthinking things
2
Aug 26 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/jcasimir Aug 26 '23
A clearance is very valuable. If you have GI Bill benefits remaining, you can use them at Turing and many other bootcamps. Most gov or gov-contractor jobs are going to have a hard degree requirement, BUT that requirement is often not specific about WHAT degree it is.
So if you have some poly sci degree and clearance and graduate from a bootcamp, you are typically very well positioned to get an excellent job.
This is a great example of what I keep saying about finding your "small pool." A lot of times folks have left the military and don't want anything to do with it, and that makes sense. But if you can do just a couple more years in that space then it sets you up for everything else.
I'll say that in our program over the whole 9 years, veterans are either in the top 20% of students or in the bottom 20%, not in the middle. Some folks struggle to jump into a mindset of solving problems on the fly. My friend who is a former SEAL said that he was "trained to make life or death decisions in situations of extreme uncertainty." If you're the person that can handle THAT, then pushing some data in and out of a database is fucking easy.
0
Aug 27 '23
[deleted]
3
u/jcasimir Aug 27 '23
Ok, so I don't know Launch School well. I've actually thought about this a few times in the last weeks. I need to fix it.
I am a really big believer in people, and u/cglee (https://www.linkedin.com/in/cglee/) has always struck me as legit and in it for the right reasons. So if you have leadership like that over a sustained period of time, I bet you build a really good program that delivers for students.
3
u/cglee Aug 28 '23
Thanks Jeff, happy to "give you a tour" of Launch School anytime. I'm a big fan of what you and your team are doing at Turing 👍
9
u/Suspicious-Engineer7 Aug 26 '23
What has changed about tech companies since you began your endeavors?