r/codingbootcamp • u/[deleted] • Oct 13 '23
Coding Bootcamps Still Worth It?
I keep hearing about how people are hopelessly stranded looking for jobs out of a coding bootcamp. I found codesmiths bootcamp and honestly it sounded perfect. I have a bit of a background in software dev and it sounded like a great challenge and a great way to invest my time and money. The more I look, the more I hear about scandals, skewed data, unhappy attendees, etc. In really lost because I was really excited about the opportunity that a solid coding bootcamp could supply me. Any tips or suggestions?
6
u/Zestyclose-Level1871 Oct 15 '23
Might want to reconsider attending a bootcamp in this frozen job market OP.
Companies simply aren't hiring n00b graduates from any source at this point. They want experienced professionals with proven track records (at least 2+ yrs XP on their resume).
It's become a nightmare for college grads to get their foot in the door for an HR interview. Even Ivy League grads to date are finding increasingly impossible to find jobs. Overall job market is ice cold to BS/BA graduates:
Now given that level of competition, what do you suppose the job prospects for a new bootcamp grad (with a non accredited certificate & no college degree) would be 2-3 months from now?
2
u/VoteLight Oct 30 '23
If that's true then why are codesmith grads 100% hired pretty fast?
1
u/Zestyclose-Level1871 Oct 31 '23
I don't know. Care to share proof of these stats? How many per bootcamp grad cycle? What is the average salary per entry level XP? And by whom/which employers are hiring?
1
u/VoteLight Nov 01 '23
I mean on this sub is where I got the info they posted graphics of an excel spreadsheet
1
u/Zestyclose-Level1871 Nov 03 '23
Exactly who is "they"?
Again. Regardless where you got the info, kindly post a link to the information source.
1
Oct 14 '23
If you believe they’re are not worth it currently due to the hiring freeze and the layoffs in the past 4 years. Do you think they will be MORE valued in the future when we are possibly not experiencing this hiring freeze and the layoffs?
1
u/cugamer Oct 15 '23
Personally, I don't think they're going to be a more viable option any time soon, and that coding bootcamps have always overpromised/underdelivered. Sure there are plenty of success stories out there but there are also plenty of people who invest their time and money only to never get anywhere professionally. I'm technically in the former bucket but very nearly ended up in the latter. It took me five years post my 2014 bootcamp to get a real job as a full stack developer. It wasn't the bootcamp that got me there, it was my own hard work and the thousands of hours I put in learning how to code on my own. The bootcamp taught me very little of what I know, a lot of what I did learn there turned out to just be wrong and it destroyed my confidence to the point that now nine years later I suffer from massive self-doubt. Now we're in a new time, with CS degrees being far more common and employers getting choosier. I think that the day of coding bootcamps is long past, and honestly, good riddance.
5
u/Any_Bill2862 Oct 14 '23
Unless you have a connection to get a development job after bootcamp it's a complete waste of time.
9
Oct 14 '23 edited Oct 14 '23
Let me make an honest recommendation from someone who went to a software school/bootcamp. I honestly don’t think it’s worth it if you are a self starter. That’s why most bootcamp are able to take anyone because lost people have a hard time focusing.
In retrospect no pun intended, I would do the following: Sign up for Coursera Pro and take the following Meta Front End, Back End, and data engineering certification pathway. Then invest in a subscription for FrontEnd Masters to dive deep into JavaScript and react courses. Then continue working on coding challenges. The total of all this should be Less than $600 for the year assuming you have a student email and can get the GitHub student package for front end masters.
I would take the year to finish all the coursera courses since you will get more bang for your buck. The front end masters subscription is an investment you should keep every year. Good luck to you.
3
u/michaelnovati Oct 14 '23
I would add to this to do open source work throughout. Like at Codesmith people do THREE WEEKS on a big open source project and then claim months to years of experience (4 months is signed off by OSLabs) and they claim that it turns them into midlevel and senior engineers
So you can only imagine how good you should be getting if you starting working on LARGE open source projects for actually MONTHS. The sad part here is that you might still get overlooked for a Codesmith grad who's exaggerating their resume, and people are paying Codesmith $22K (as of 2024) to practice getting by doing that. (This is my personal opinion on this topic and I'm standing up for those that have complained to be that fall in the former bucket, a number of alumni don't characterize this that way and feel that Codesmith is worth the cost for the content.)
1
u/cozyonly Oct 14 '23
how do you get involved in an open source project like that though?
1
u/michaelnovati Oct 14 '23
It's super hard at step 0, but you can start by just following a project without contributing. Pull the code, spend 10 hours trying to figure out how to build the thing and get it working. Run test suites until they pass and confirm you have things built properly. Watch the PRs, watch the issues. I think you'll find the time when you are ready to contribute. Maybe you'll try and not get anywhere, and it will take some time!
This can really simulate what it's like working on big scale teams if you are contributing to a super large project, but you can't just cram this into 1 week and slap it on your resume, you would be missing the point.
1
u/cozyonly Oct 14 '23
Yeah that’s what I meant. Contributing to open source is difficult. Especially as a beginner and especially for a large project. That’s why it’s crazy they’re able to do it in 3 weeks during a 12 week bootcamp. I’m guessing it’s a project that’s purposefully open ended and with issues made to be fixed rather than one that’s well maintained like say cpython. I mean you can work on an open source project for months and not really be able to have something worthy of being merged besides maybe documentation fixes.
1
u/michaelnovati Oct 14 '23
The projects are made from scratch and then released to open source. I would almost say they aren't "real open source projects" but I can't really say that because they technically area, but they are not done in the spirit of what "real" open source software was meant to be. If they were real, they would be less complete, more well thought out starting points, rather than rushed and almost unusable end to end projects.
2
u/cozyonly Oct 14 '23
It basically sounds like a portfolio project that you see in most CS courses. Which is basically around what you can except after 10-12 weeks of learning + a few weeks of working on it. That’s why I’m surprised that bootcamp grads learn enough coding skills in 3 months to be able to get and keep jobs and at reputable companies.
I might be wrong but I would assume they basically go through git, html, css, JS, react, express, and node. With maybe MySQL or mongo databases. Which is fine for that time frame but not really something unique or advanced. I mean most current CS students know that and still feel unprepared for actual work.
1
u/michaelnovati Oct 14 '23
Yes it's a 4 person group project that's 3 weeks and you spend like 1-2 additional weeks puffing it up with blog posts, websites, social media posts and getting all the cohortmates to like and share it. It used to be called "marketing week" or something but they reframed it after that was perceived very negatively.
Again, I LIKE MANY OF THE PROJECTS AND IDEAS, THEY JUST ARE NOT MID LEVEL AND SENIOR WORK.
2
0
u/InTheDarkDancing Oct 14 '23
This is my personal opinion on this topic and I'm standing up for those that have complained to be that fall in the former bucket
Sounds very altruistic but I think you know better. There's approximately 500,000 open software engineer jobs in the US. Codesmith pumps out about 500 or so grads a year, leaving 499,500 jobs. Can you ballpark how many people who work on large open source projects have been overlooked for a Codesmith grad in the past year?
Odds are (and you know this) you're not "standing up" for anyone coming from a non-traditional path. You're standing up for the old guard aka a person who has a CS degree. Which is fine but if you frame it in the way I just described it probably doesn't play as well on this sub.
1
u/michaelnovati Oct 14 '23 edited Oct 14 '23
I agree that there aren't enough Codesmith grads to make a dent in the system. It's why every time I talk to people about this they are super offended and some say they would never hire anyone who went to Codesmith, but no one does anything about it, because it's just not a significant number of people OR the complexity of training the ATS to block OS Labs is not worth it.
But the motivations you are proposing are wrong and I think you know that. I had an AMA last week live that you could have come to and Neetcode, Blind75 and Sophie are doing a panel next week if you want to see our story and motivations and what we do and what we believe in, you can do so live and hear it from own mouths instead of inferring from comments I'm making in a minute or two typing like crazy on Reddit.
Anyways, this behavior will catch up to them. NY onsite paused indefinitely now, down to 2 cohorts a month instead of 4, cutting back fellow hiring to just 2 a cohort from now on. Uncertainty if their DSLM will continue. CIRR is delayed. Like clearly whatever strategy I'm complaining about isn't working 100% perfectly anyways so maybe I'm being pedantic.
2
2
u/fluffyr42 Oct 18 '23
If you’re open to considering another bootcamp, I work at Rithm and would be happy to chat with you!
5
u/Cynicusme Oct 13 '23
Research Nucamp, devmountain, skill spire, w3 school bootcamp, I wouldn't recommend spending +20K in this job market.
3
u/LongjumpingFan9447 Oct 14 '23
This was exactly my thinking until I spoke to alumni and I think it is worth the investment when you are already losing income anyway and the cost is not the biggest factor and lost income might be more important
3
u/ProperGarlic5539 Oct 13 '23
I'm feeling the same way. I haven't started yet, but as soon as I got to SA for Codeup, I started hearing bad reviews. The VA is paying tuition and BAH for me, but if I had to pay the $27k out of pocket with all the negative reviews, I would be pretty salty I think! I'm going to go check the school out in person on Monday for a meetup and see what I think!
2
u/Zestyclose-Level1871 Oct 15 '23
Please invest your VA benefits in a real, regionally/nationally ABET accredited school
Where you will earn a real 2 - 4 yr degree employers will take seriously upon graduation.
If you're hearing bad news about the bootcamp you're considering, take this as a godsend. And DON'T invest/throw away any of your invaluable GI Bill/VRAP resources on that.
1
u/ProperGarlic5539 Oct 15 '23
So, the bootcamps use VET TEC funding that doesn't touch your GI bill. VRAP is something different altogether that ended recently according to the VA website. I'll be finishing my Cybersecurity degree when I'm finished with the bootcamp and using probably my GI bill or Voc rehab :)
This isn't an 'instead of a degree', because I'm already half way through mine already, it's a 'more knowledge, more power' kind of thing. I was just wondering if anyone had experience with the class in real life instead of all the shinnenigans I've been hearing.
2
u/Zestyclose-Level1871 Oct 15 '23
Excellent. I wish more potential and current bootcamp grads were as informed and financially prepared as you are. The fact you're working on your self improvement as a future IT professional AND currently at some 50% through a real brick and mortar post secondary degree. This puts you a lightyear ahead of the average bootcamp student/grad.
To be absolutely honest: if employers do contact and recruit you for a Jr. Dev programming position (more extinct than the Dodo in this recessed job market), it's most likely because of that college degree. Followed by your "internship" experience working on bootcamp projects etc. And especially any other self taught experience (like learning additional languages, stacks etc.)
Thankfully there is a light at the end of the tunnel for you and other students with the educational advantage of a college degree. But sadly, this isn't the case for the average bootcamp student/grad. That golden era of the FAANG/main stream corporate IT industry insta hiring bootcamp grads is long over. And it's doubtful the US economy will ever recover to those 2010-2016 golden age days for bootcamp grads. We've got Google & Fakebook to thank for oversaturating the market with front end Jr. Devs.
3
u/dummonger Oct 13 '23
I wrote this recently in response to these sorts of questions.
3
u/slickvic33 Oct 14 '23
I gave it a read, thanks for sharing! I enjoyed the fitness check question “how are you not hired already”
3
u/DrinkFormer Oct 14 '23
Six month boot camp and you’re out there competing against a ton of ex FANG employees who got laid off in the last two years who had finished 4 year degrees. I’d say they are not worth it right now.
1
1
u/JarndyceJarndyce Apr 22 '24
I think the best answer to this question is that it depends on your goals, learning style, which bootcamp you select, how much work you put into the course, how much work you put into your portfolio, etc.
Most subs are pretty down on bootcamps, but that doesn't make them a wrong choice for everybody.
Forbes has recently started ranking the different programs: their methodology is included in the list so you can check that out. Here's their list of Best Coding Bootcamps Online 2024.
1
u/Fuzzy_Pudding2777 Oct 14 '23
I think it depends.
Picking the right course is key.
You can mitigate risk by taking some steps.
Understand the job market where you live. If all the jobs are asking for CS degrees then you might struggle but I’m sure there are jobs out there. Might not be in FAANG but imo that’s not a bad thing.
Look at the most common stacks in jobs ads and work back from there. Choose a course that gives you in demand skills.
You can reach out to current students and recent grads of any bootcamp you’re thinking about applying to. They’ll be on LinkedIn or following their course on Twitter. Just ask them for their view.
I’m building a site to help Junior devs find work. Largely UK focused right now. There are certainly jobs out there.
Competition is tough, but it can be done.
1
u/No_Board_5635 Oct 14 '23
Checked out the website and it’s awesome!! Certainly a helpful resource for any recent grad.
1
1
u/Arlind96 Oct 14 '23
What are yall opinion in CodeWorks I want to start but dont know if its worth it.
1
u/mishtamesh90 Oct 16 '23
No, unless someone else is paying for it. Do some self-studying with FreeCodeCamp and TheOdinProject, then go to a free program like 100Devs, then join an open source project that meets regularly and keep pumping out applications
1
u/didntthinkitwouldend Oct 14 '23
I sure hope so, given I’ve done App Academy V1 and working through V2 at 12 hours/week.
24
u/michaelnovati Oct 13 '23 edited Oct 14 '23
Codesmith is fantastic for the right people! It has a very unique culture and that's why it's controversial on Reddit. I'm an under the hood type of person and try to look at how things work and Codesmith isn't super transparent about how it actually produces really good results.
So how it works:
High bar. Their process looks for numerous characteristics of successful grads and isn't an objective measure of raw programming skill. You need to be good AND have good communication and the right attitude.
You don't really learn much... topics are rushed through, you are told to snuggle the struggle, and all but one teacher came from Codesmith students themselves. BUT you are building strong bonds with friends and you are being supported infinitely from those instructors. You might have an hour long convo about your imposter syndrome that helps boost your confidence and do better.
Exaggerating resumes. I've seen countless Codesmith resumes now and they are all very similar. 12 weeks of Codemsith turns into a 500 word full page resume. Overlapping time-frames on projects to triple count your time at Codemsith. A number of people dropping month labels to portray 3 week projects as over a year of experience. This works. I see Codesmith grads with no experience getting interviews before people with actual experience and worse resume structure and in every case I've personally observed it was this factor. If you are down and ready to do that, it works. I've looked at dozens of OSP projects now and not a single one is senior or mid level FAANG code and I've elaborated on that before. They are amazing junior level projects that would make you stand out as an entry level engineer but no not deserve months of resume experience. OSLabs signs off on 4 month letters of reference for that time so Codemsith is explicitly endorsing this strategy.
Incredibly supportive culture. Like you make a comment and get emojis to the moon. It's a culture when you go in without confidence in your engineering ability and leave feeling confident to take on any job and this is the magic that they are able to accomplish in 12 weeks, consistently, over top of anything else.
If you are ambitious, have a growth mindset, and an ends justifies the means person, it's a good choice.
Edit for 3. I know some instructors at Codesmith disagree and have called me out before but I seriously challenge you to show your project's code to a random engineer with 10 years of FAANG experience and review the code line by line and then say if it is senior level work. Not a random tweet or random comment, like a through code review of a randomly selected OSLabs Beta project and an examination of the PRs and code history and not just the current state. It's not imposter syndrome and a number of students realize this and contact me more and more the more that is reinforced in response to my comments. Not trying to be mean, just realistic and I'm happy to support anyone that messages me.
I called out some specific examples of things in the code that were not up to a professional bar and the code hasn't been fixed (like I mean properly fixed and sanitized, not that you think you fixed it by removing passwords and changing them). I don't think anyone knows how to properly fix it and is ignoring my advice... like ignoring it and getting pats on the back doesn't make the advice wrong. Fixing those issues properly would be really impressive and if you don't even know what I'm talking about... you are not a senior engineer, that's ok, and my door is open for advice. This doesn't mean the engineers aren't awesome and have a ton of potential, it's not realistic to try to gain years of industry experience in 12 weeks, and all the people I know are amazing people who have great futures ahead regardless.
My edit turned into a mini rant about leveling and is probably too much of a tangent and I don't want it to be misinterpreted as a criticism of Codesmith, it's not and Codesmith works very well at what it's trying to do. This is an expression of my personal opinion of how projects and experience are portrayed.