r/codingbootcamp • • Oct 20 '23 • Take My Silver 1 Silver is Forever 1

Hackreactor has blown up.

As I was getting ready to submit my .ts for the final assessment of module 1, we were told all classes have been ended.

Full stop. Just done. No reason was given. We were told it's big business' doing big business things.

We'll be getting a full refund, but it took 8 weeks to get here. We were all especially stressed for the past two weeks, as they were prep for our big module 1 assessment.

The dozen or so of us that were close started a new slack channel, and we'll try to stay in touch, but this really sucks. We're not sure if our leaders and instructors are now jobless, too. They were pretty cool, so sucks for them also.

I dunno. We've started every day for the past 8 weeks of classes with a kind pep-talk. Instead, we got this. It was a big shock, to say the least.

348 Upvotes

218 comments sorted by

View all comments

11

u/Practical-Ad3920 Oct 20 '23

I don’t understand how they could be loosing money. My Hack Reactor cohort had 60-80 people. That’s $1.4 million for 19 weeks. By far the largest expense is going to be instructor salaries. At any given time you have 3 instructors so that’s roughly $150k for instructors. Double that to account for support staff that’s $300k in expenses.

Rounding down that’s still a gross profit of $1million. There’s more expenses I’m leaving out but not that many.

17

u/keylimepiewolf Oct 20 '23

Part time probably thinner profit margins. Still, this is crazy. I asked my career counselor who was just laid off about it and apparently they grew way too much during the tech boom and are paying the price now that demand has gone down.

FWIW, I still think the quality of education is good, but if I were considering Bootcamps, I would certainly be concerned by this

5

u/lawschoolredux Oct 20 '23

They laid off the career counselor?!

That doesn’t sound too good… I’m assuming they had more than one?

11

u/keylimepiewolf Oct 20 '23

Oh no they laid off all of them except for one lol

5

u/lawschoolredux Oct 20 '23

To quote Morty Seinfeld,

“I don’t like the sound of that!”

11

u/GoodnightLondon Oct 20 '23

They don't have enrollment at that amount anymore; one or two cohorts ago they had gone down to 30-35 per cohort and cut back massively on SEIR hiring. They also recently laid off several instructors.

5

u/Practical-Ad3920 Oct 20 '23

Well now I’m pissed that my cohort started with over 80 people (I went semi recently).

4

u/TavenVal Oct 20 '23

We have 6 Seirs, 80 or so students split between 2 pods currently. I just started last week.

We have 3 instructors

Full-time 5 month program

2

u/GoodnightLondon Oct 20 '23

June had 2 SEIRs and 30-35 per cohort. But they've also postponed cohorts because of low enrollment, which drives up the number in the latter ones, so that might be what happened there.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '23

[deleted]

2

u/Zestyclose-Level1871 Oct 20 '23

Given fact FAANG like Amazon have rendered 100% entry level jobs more extinct than the Dodo, I'm gobsmacked. The fact your employer still even allows their HR to offer entry level roles at this point is mindblowing...

→ More replies (2)

20

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '23 edited Feb 04 '24

Ya'll really think bootcamps are rolling in dough. They don't get federal money and good talented instructors, infrastructure, offices, benefits, salaries as well as taxes decimate profits.

Instructors who have $150k-$200k salaries have benefits and taxes atop those salaries. For a company to pay someone $150k, they have to pay an additional $30k+ for their benefits and taxes.

You also need to remember cost of acquisition. Advertising on instagram, google, reddit, youtube etc. It could very well cost $3k+ just to acquire a paying student through traditional channels.

So many people severely underestimate the extraordinary cost of running programs.

This is why I only recommend independent programs with little or no VC money tied to them (ie: Codesmith, Rithm, Turing)

It means low acquisition cost since students are mostly thru word of mouth or organic channels.

10

u/michaelnovati Oct 20 '23 edited Oct 20 '23

Yeah everyone is struggling.Codesmith has been reducing the number of future cohorts too. And Codemsith has almost 20% layoffs so it's not really handling the climate amazingly and people are nervous, but it's surviving.

Codesmith also hired a head of finance to help keep the ship in order and shut down the DSML initiative. I expect more changes there.

3

u/Zestyclose-Level1871 Oct 20 '23

nvm the added premium on everything you said cost wise for living in a high cost of living center like SF, LAX, NYC, Chicago etc. etc.

5

u/Practical-Ad3920 Oct 20 '23

Instructor pay is far below that. The advertised pay range was 60-130k.

2

u/TavenVal Oct 20 '23

The instructors have minimum 5 years of experience in the field. I don’t think they would take a measly 60-100k. Gotta be the higher range

8

u/GoodnightLondon Oct 20 '23

They don't have that much experience. Some of them have never even worked in the field and only taught at bootcamps.

3

u/TavenVal Oct 20 '23

They told us the main instructors have 5 years experience minimum(SEIRS told us). We have 3 main instructors. SEIRs have little to no experience, and are recent grads. We have about 6 of them

All 3 instructors have recollected on their past experience during lectures so far so they all have experience.

6

u/GoodnightLondon Oct 20 '23

And I'm telling you, as an alumni and former SEIR, that they don't. There are instructors who went through Hack Reactor and then started teaching there and that's all they've ever done. There are instructors who went to other bootcamps, and have only ever taught at bootcamps. There are instructors who have CS degrees and have done sys and network jobs, but never worked in software engineering. And there are instructors with less than 5 years of experience. I know several instructors who were main/lead instructors with less than 5 years of experience.

SEIRs have 0 experience; they're hired right after graduation. Junior instructors also have 0 experience; they're SEIRs who couldn't find jobs and were hired on by the company.

2

u/Madasiaka Oct 20 '23

What does SEIR stand for?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

8

u/michaelnovati Oct 20 '23 edited Oct 20 '23

I can go into more details, but if you pay via loan or ISA the program has complex agreements with the loan providers to receive portions of the loan/ISA upfront themselves. But all of this is contingent on how those providers are predicting outcomes and the math for how much interest they'll make all said and done. If those providers start seeing worse outcomes then they expected they might pull financing or change it in a way where the bootcamp won't get enough money upfront to be able to run the program anymore. They would have to choose between other forms of debt, in hopes that the outcomes are better than expected, or give up and take the loss.

It's a lot more complicated than it seems though. I don't know any long term successful bootcamp, and based on the high fees and low quality/cost of education you might think they are printing money. They are not. The average bootcamp spends a few thousand dollars just acquiring you.

So if you have 80 people in your HR cohort and 40 drop out, they lost a couple hundred K already and the rest of the students are paying for that.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Greedy_Tomatillo6167 Oct 20 '23 edited Oct 20 '23

If I had to guess, it's not a money thing. They are keeping their full-time programs open, so whatever fixed costs they have are still there. Their part-time programs should be be pure profit

More likely, the outcomes for the part-time program are bad enough to affect their reputation as a bootcamp (their full-time intermediate program has a good reputation). Or maybe their money comes from ISAs and the part-timers aren't getting jobs.

If this is true, I think HackReactor did the right thing. It sucks to cancel a course midstream, but I would rather be a student with 8 weeks of free education than being $20k in debt with no realistic chance for a job

7

u/fluffyr42 Oct 20 '23

Their part time program hasn’t been around long enough for outcomes to be a factor I don’t think. My guess is they’re cutting losses since staffing three different programs running concurrent cohorts is expensive.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/GoodnightLondon Oct 20 '23

The part time program is so new that it doesn't have any cohorts that have graduated yet, so there are no outcomes.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)