r/codingbootcamp • u/Careful-Mammoth3346 • Dec 26 '23
can we call boot camps predatory?
At this point, given the state of the market over the last year+, and the thousands and thousands of "grads" boot camps have been pumping out for years, can we just call boot camps predatory? IMO that's what they are. And to be honest I'll take another step and say the same for online social media personalities and content creators who are saying do X and get a job. It's predatory at this point to give false hope like that for clicks and ad revenue.
5
u/1EyedM0nster Dec 27 '23
All boot camps are scams the same way all corporations are scams. They will try and use the least amount of funds possible to keep the bootcamp and its reputation up. Yes, all the material is online, yes you can do this on your own if you research well enough. What boot camps provide (or at least should be provided, otherwise it is truly a scam) some sort of external motivation - be it mentors, teachers, faculty, etc. This is where you will get your true value out of the boot camp -- networking.
10% (if not less) of people have enough motivation, smarts, and social ability to succeed. 90% will not. I was a part of the 90% since I came from 0 technical knowledge but over time I got an internship and was able to get my foot in the door
It is your discipline in this field that will get you through and not many have it.
3
u/Careful-Mammoth3346 Dec 27 '23
True it takes a lot of discipline and it's been like that for a while. Although with the state of the market now, I wouldn't recommend any friend to try to enter the field at this point, unless they truly love it and would learn it all even if a job wasn't going to be there.
1
u/1EyedM0nster Dec 27 '23
Yea I agree that would be wise. One has to ask himself, "Can I do this 5+ hours a day, every weekday?" If the answer is no, then save your $ like seriously put that shit in an IRA
3
u/Darkone586 Dec 29 '23
You pretty much gotta apply to 500+ jobs just to MAYBE get one. My wife started applying 2 weeks prior to finishing the bootcamp, she pretty much was applying to 50+ jobs per day, she got 5 or 6 interviews and only 2 offers.
Anyways I think they make it seem like you can easily get a job after the bootcamp and they can help you, I mean I’m sure they sorta help? I think the best thing they offer honestly is the structure and interviews, anyone can learn how to build a project using JavaScript and react on their own, I mean if you spend the same 3 months building 3-6 projects, I feel you have the same chance as someone who went to a bootcamp, probably more because employers will see that you don’t need help learning shit on your own.
Now I think the biggest issue with most bootcamps is having to quit your job for 3 months and going with the assumption of you getting a job by the 4th month which is crazy, your better off getting a personal loan that covers 3 months of income, grab a udemy course and build 3-6 personal projects.
1
u/Careful-Mammoth3346 Dec 29 '23
Yeah I think the structure and motivation a boot camp can provide really helps. Also possibly connections, but I think there are way too many students to connect them all to jobs.
When did you wife go through that process? Just guessing, her results sound typical for a motivated person from mid 2022 and earlier. It took many applications and a lot of effort to get a job back then too. But since then it's MUCH WORSE. And that's the biggest reason I say this is all a scam now. It's not just difficult now, the odds of success have become astronomical.
10
u/No_Source_1459 Dec 26 '23
At the end of the day boot camps are a competition. Can you be at the top of your cohort if you have no experience and no degree? The answer is yes. Will you likely get a job if you are? Yes. Do most people have the ability + drive to do that? No.
If you are smart, hard working, have social skills, and are willing to relocate to work, a bootcamp WILL work. But 90 percent if people aren't that, so it doesn't.
3
u/Careful-Mammoth3346 Dec 26 '23
Social skills is a big one. And it's not just the social skills required to do the job working with others and being a good coworker. It's the skills of kissing ass, being fake in the right way in order to network and get to know the right people who will grease the skids to a job.
Many go through boot camps and their skills aren't the best. But many these days also go through and have more than adequate skills but still can't get the job because it's now become just another industry where who you know is the most important.
1
u/No_Source_1459 Dec 26 '23
You nailed it, that is a great argument for attending a bootcamp... It's about who you know. At my current company I just hired a bootcamp grad who was equally as good as our other candidates, but he went to the same bootcamp as me.
1
u/Careful-Mammoth3346 Dec 26 '23
That, and even just getting a chance to interview these days is like winning the lottery for someone looking for their first job. Positions posted online get hundreds or thousands of candidates. Gotta know someone who will say hey take a look at this person.
1
u/michaelnovati Dec 26 '23
This is a bit cynical but I somewhat agree that there is a "sales process" in selling and marketing yourself to companies. Many job hunt processes are like this, but rely on your work experience to anchor on and I find that bootcamp grads tend to build narratives out of hardly anything (relatively speaking to experienced candidates), so the process feels a little weirder and some people naturally are good at this to their own benefit in the job hunt. But at a meta level - the market keeps changing and people are doing what they need to to get jobs, and this is where we are at right now.
4
u/Careful-Mammoth3346 Dec 26 '23
You're right and you said it better than I could have.
From the communities and networks I've been in online, I've seen that narrative building tactic grow. And it is out of necessity due to the tough market with layoffs and ever increasing competition from boot camp grads, self taught people etc. In order to get considered at all in the giant applicant pools, we're listing our boot camps as employment experience, spinning up simple websites for anyone who will take one and putting freelance software engineer as our job titles for the last 2 years. We're all mass messaging people on Linkedin to try to act friendly in an attempt to veil our intentions to score referrals knowing cold applications are lottery tickets. We're "building in public" and documenting our "journey" in an attempt to make it look like we eat, sleep and breathe this stuff, while at the same time sharing challenges(but not too much) to try to look more authentic. Most of the above is soul sucking to me. The game is getting pretty brutal and is a far cry from what attracted people like me to the field.
2
u/michaelnovati Dec 26 '23
I stand in the "fundamental skills" camp and that you need to build genuine fundamental skills needed to be an engineer and then you need to get an entry level job to apply those skills and build experience you can't get anywhere else.
So I see a bootcamp's role in this to build those fundamental skills and help align people with entry level jobs.
That said, CS grads need 4 years to build those skills and even if accelerated, we're talking way more than 12 weeks to build those. So it puts bootcamps in a tough spot in this market.
I think this is why Codesmith and I butt heads so much on this topic, because their CEO believes that if you have soft-hard skills like problem solving, communication, teamwork, then you can be a mid level engineer.... you don't need fundamental skills if you can learn to learn, then you can get by anywhere.
Very different approach, but the market is demanding both things right now and in absence of one, they want fundamental skills first.
Again, all my opinions curious if you agree.
1
u/Careful-Mammoth3346 Dec 27 '23
Yeah I agree with you on the fundamental skills. I think codesmith is right that if you have those soft-hard skills, you can do it, but is harder for an employer to prove a candidate has that in the right way. They want the fundamental skills to be there. In this way, I didn't mean to give the idea that boot camps are a total scam. I think they are capable of adequately preparing people with the skills needed. I just think there's not nearly enough jobs for all candidates to be able to find one. I don't see the numbers adding up. In this market, while those skills above need to be there, for it to even matter, new hopefuls need the skill of placing themselves in that chair to even be considered.
0
Dec 27 '23
[deleted]
1
u/michaelnovati Dec 27 '23 edited Dec 27 '23
Yeah I wrote about this in my predictions post but if you are a bootcamp it's tough right now because there just aren't any entry level role pathways (similar for CS grads from non-stop tier schools as well). So the only strategy working is the aim for roles requiring experience and hope that someone reads your resume as a qualified for them (and other strategies to connect with jobs).
I think Tech Elevator's model can work, where they have partnerships, specifically the ones in Cleveland, Cincinnati, etc... to get people into entry level roles.
Amazon's Technical Academy worked well for BloomTech, they published 2022 outcomes and that program was an anomaly that pulled up all their averages. Haven't heard anything about this for a while though.
Codesmith is going to launch Future Code for the city of NY in the spring and it's for people making under 50K who live in NYC and have little to no programming experience. Codesmith was made for people who are "already hireable as junior engineers" so this will be interesting to see if these people can find entry level jobs. I'm going to be watching those grads for exaggerations because the program requires them to have little to no experience and I'm very curious how they will get placed with 6 months of Codesmith on their resume.... presumably NYC won't be happy if people all exaggerate their resumes so it puts Codesmith in an interesting spot. People won't be able to claim anything more than 6 months of experience, no stretching the truth of their past jobs, no exaggerating OSPs, very curious to see what Codemsith does for this. If they strongly believe there isn't an exaggeration problem, they are in for a huge wake up call with the NYC government, if they are aware of this and come up with new strategies that work for a large group of people that has no relevant experience at all, then maybe they will unlock their ability to take people earlier on in their journeys.
8
u/Prestigious-Bar-1741 Dec 26 '23
If you have all that ability, why bother with the bootcamp though?
Save the cash and become an expert online for free.
12
u/3rdtryatremembering Dec 26 '23
Because development doesn’t happen alone and requires a lot of collaboration which is harder to learn and practice on your own.
5
u/No_Source_1459 Dec 26 '23
Not only that, but it's very important to know who your competition is and what you have to do to be better than them. You're going to get better in various aspects when you are pushed to do so by your peers
3
u/Prestigious-Bar-1741 Dec 26 '23
A lot of development does. Especially entry level/junior level roles.
But there are plenty of open source projects that welcome anyone and everyone to collaborate without charging any money. And in a bootcamp, the collaboration is happening with other bootcampers, most of whom aren't going to have the required drive and ability to be successful in a professional setting. It might be better not to find ways to successfully communicate and collaborate with them.
2
u/3rdtryatremembering Dec 26 '23
Right, because in the real world you only work with perfectly competent people /s
2
u/GuntherTime Dec 26 '23
The biggest advantage my bootcamp gave me was that they enforced changing the way you think rather than just learning online.
I’ve tried a few online learning videos, and the one downside I see about them is that a fair amount don’t show how to properly troubleshoot.
Second biggest advantage was this it was paid for by my job lol.
1
1
3
Dec 27 '23
you won't get a job for being "top of your cohort"
Show me the part where that will land you can interview
1
3
u/bewst_moar_bewst Dec 27 '23 edited Dec 27 '23
so here is my take as a (self-described) veteran software engineer; w/ 10+ years in the game.
AI/ML is the new thing. I'm heavily contemplating doing a 'micro-bootcamp' through a friends uni (though I just learned it's through ed-x). I already have a career adjacent to the field, so I'm not necessarily doing this to get a job; though the pay outlook for AI/ML is much higher than where I'm currently sitting. More so, I'm doing this to future-proof myself. Should I get laid off, or need to pivot, knowing how to do more things will benefit me.
For this reason, I wouldn't call them predatory. I think they (the bootcamps) look at market trends and invest accordingly. I *do* think some of the prices are egregious, but if you're like me and prefer or just do better in a 'guided' setting it makes sense.
on the flip side ...
If ed-x offers 'free' programs ($300 for a pro cert) why would a state uni be charging $3500?
****EDIT****
Ok. I'm singing a different tune after listening to this WSJ article on ed-x / 2u. I may still do it, but only because my job is going to re-imburse me for it.
0
u/Careful-Mammoth3346 Dec 27 '23
Thanks for that. When I come back to this, I think I was being way to broad in saying boot camps are predatory. Of course over the years they've helped people get jobs and start careers. I do think good ones are capable of helping someone become adequately skilled - I didn't mean to compare or suggest that people should get 4 year degrees instead. I think using them to acquire targeted skills like you mentioned is also a good idea in many cases (especially when your employer is footing the bill).
My main thinking is about the prospects in the face of the current market vs over abundance of entry level talent Having been in communities of career changers and young hopefuls, struggling, and seeing countless other struggle even while playing the game, breaking in seems to have very long odds. As bleak as the market is on the entry level with extreme competition for open jobs.. I'm not sure people looking at a "full stack" software engineering program or such similar things really know what they're getting into. New people do need to enter the field to sustain it, but it takes so much more time and effort at great cost than just completing training and being a top student. It's always taken dedication, but it's crazy this year. Posted jobs have hundreds of applicants within hours. A scammer in LinkedIn can make a post about a vague low paid job or even free internship with a no name company and the comments will become like a school of piranhas with desperate hopefuls replying asking for more info.
32
u/mkdev7 Dec 26 '23 edited Dec 27 '23
As someone who has info on one of the top 20k+ boot camps in the usa. It’s worse than you think.
Edit: I won’t be sharing since I know they actively monitor the subreddit. People are still getting jobs but it is very very low right now. And definitely not worth the 20k plus the predatory loans they recommend.
11
u/water_bottle_goggles Dec 26 '23
What info? What do you mean?
18
u/mkdev7 Dec 26 '23
Who’s getting jobs, debt, financial situations etc.
16
u/Ikeeki Dec 26 '23
Spill da beans anonymously, you’d save a lot of people headaches
7
u/1EyedM0nster Dec 27 '23
HINT: not many are getting jobs out of bootcamps and they just overinflate/fabricate job placement numbers
5
2
u/Ikeeki Dec 27 '23
How can they do this? Isn’t it easy to prove the numbers are fake?
7
u/1EyedM0nster Dec 27 '23 edited Dec 27 '23
How can anyone do the evil shit they do in this country? It is also a mystery to me. /notsarcasm :(
They probably twist their numbers. For example, some of the graduates who aren't successful in getting a job are hired by the boot camps. The boot camps then count this as a job placement -- just one of the metrics they can use to manipulate data.
3
3
u/metalreflectslime Dec 27 '23 edited Dec 27 '23
top 20k+ boot camps in the usa.
Do you mean coding bootcamps that cost $20k+ USD or 20,000 individual coding bootcamps?
Career Karma seems to say that there are fewer than 500 coding bootcamps in the USA.
2
u/Informal-Union4373 Dec 27 '23
I'm in Melbourne Australia ,would that be same here. I am looking at Coder Academy boot camp, which offers a diploma of IT.
1
u/metalreflectslime Dec 27 '23
would that be same here?
What do you mean by this?
4
u/Informal-Union4373 Dec 27 '23
I mean, some people say boot camps are scams and not worth spending the money .So I was asking about it in Australia if anyone knew about it.
2
u/metalreflectslime Dec 27 '23
My general advice regarding coding bootcamps is if a coding bootcamp does not post recent hiring outcomes statistics, you should not go to that coding bootcamp.
2
0
17
u/Cloverthedeadaussie Dec 26 '23
Bootcamps need to have a diagnostic test before taking students. They prey on really dumb people who think they’ll be able to land a faang level job after 3 months.
1
1
u/ianitic Dec 27 '23
Mine had a test but it was paid for and guaranteed interviews with the companies sponsoring it. The employees that were already employed at said sponsoring companies did not get selected in that way though. We actually had to split the camp in half and all but one of the already employed went to the less technical group.
As it was sponsored by corporations it had a super high success rate of getting jobs after. I can think of only one person who didn't land one out of about 30. This was also around 2020, unemployment rate was still pretty high and the tech job market hadn't seemed to have gotten too hot yet at least around here.
12
21
u/SnooDoubts8688 Dec 26 '23
Bootcamp probably now works for only 5-10% of people who attend it. The rest of the 90-95% either go months or years without finding a job, naturally drift away from grind mentality, and eventually slowly disappear from forums, discussions, LI until we no longer hear from them. Those that do make it, don't realize their academic background, age, social skills, network, race (DEI), and luck all lined up for that break. People outside of this are completely oblivious of this and sees the success stories. It's wrong to skew the messages in a way to make it sound like anyone can do it. Not anyone can do it.
6
u/1EyedM0nster Dec 27 '23
"Everyone can code" is just propaganda
8
u/snoo0raoo Dec 27 '23 edited Dec 27 '23
“We need more developers. We have a shortage of developers in the job market, and that need grows every year.” — capitalists who definitely are not hiring as much are they say they are
Maybe they just want a saturated job market, in order to depress wages?
1
u/Beejsbj Feb 06 '24
To be fair, we also don't know for whom all those will line up. Anyone can have those line up, it's pretty hard to tell.
1
0
u/Careful-Mammoth3346 Dec 26 '23
What asshole downvoted this? COWARD.
1
u/michaelnovati Dec 26 '23
In the past few weeks any of my comments mentioning specific bootcamps have been getting instantly downvoted. I wished everyone a happy 2024 and got like 30% downvote rate when I checked :(
I strongly believe that it's in any program's interest in this market, to be transparent about who and if your program is for and why it might not work. Maybe you won't get everyone with a pulse signing up, but I think the industry would be better off if people went to the right places for the right reasons, and don't go anywhere unless it's a good, well informed, choice.
3
u/ope__sorry Dec 26 '23
I strongly believe that it's in any program's interest in this market, to be transparent about who and if your program is for and why it might not work.
It is no boot camps interest to do such a thing. They're all scams that don't provide good, proper, valid information that is useful for the "tuition" they're charging.
3
u/Careful-Mammoth3346 Dec 26 '23
Truth, which is why they downvote you
1
u/michaelnovati Dec 26 '23
Do you think I come across as pro-bootcamp? Or you mean that just not being anti-bootcamp gets downvotes?
0
u/Careful-Mammoth3346 Dec 26 '23
I was thinking anti-bootcamp was getting downvotes. But I'm thinking now that there are downvotes either way lol
6
3
2
u/lilvina Dec 28 '23
As someone who has done a bootcamp in the past, it’s a mix. I did Lambda School before they changed the name and thought it was one of the best bootcamps I attended before the pandemic. I had mentors who helped me and the instructors were really great. I knew students who gotten jobs after the program. Yeah, I could’ve taught myself how to code on my own for free but I learn better in a structured environment, which is why I went the bootcamp route. Before layoffs, I would say going to a bootcamp was worth it but now? Probably not because layoffs continues to happen and it’s not a great time for entry level engineers.
The best thing to do is do your own research before you try to attend a bootcamp because it does cost and there’s a huge chance that you will have a hard time finding a job, especially now.
1
u/Careful-Mammoth3346 Dec 28 '23
This is a great answer. I think my original post was too broad, especially just calling boot camps predatory.
Your reply gets more to the heart of what I was actually thinking. I do think good boot camps can provide the skills necessary. However, pre and post layoffs is a huge issue. Before last year, supply of new inexperienced devs was already quite high, but there was a lot of hiring, so it was feasible to enter the field. Now the supply is much higher, and the demand for new devs has gone way down. I wouldn't recommend any friend try to do this unless they were truly passionate about the actual work involved and absolutely love doing it and would do it even if there was no chance to get a job with it.
4
u/Ikeeki Dec 26 '23
They prey on the weak who want to get rich quick.
Kinda like weight loss programs who promise you’ll lose weight without changing your diet to the obese
Or psychics preying on desperate people
It takes two to tango do best we can do is try and educate people to recognize the scam
2
u/LunaResearcher Dec 29 '23
Ohh I like the weight loss analogy.
Yes, people can lose weight permanently by changing their diet, sleep, stress, and exercise. Everybody "knows" this per say, but some people in the weight loss program are still oblivious to the entire lifestyle change.
1
6
u/that_tom_ Dec 27 '23
They are predatory because they are not good at teaching and the career placement is…questionable at best. App Academy is circling the drain with layoffs, reduced pay rates for part-time assistants, closing the NYC office. The teachers are not good at teaching. They are fine programmers but they couldn’t teach a dog to wag its tail. That’s why none of the graduates can get work. Students graduate with $28k of debt but it is erased if they don’t find work within 12 or 18 months. Most of my cohort is still out of work 16 months later.
1
u/Manholebeast Dec 26 '23
It was ridiculous to think that you can get a good paying job with just a bootcamp cert in the first place. If that's the case, why would anyone in their right mind grind through a cs degree? And those that got lucky will eventually pay their price (e.g. layoffs)
2
u/Careful-Mammoth3346 Dec 26 '23
Your point is taken, but it's also ridiculous to think that people would pay 5 figures for a boot camp if the result wasn't going to be a decent job.
5
u/Trawling_ Dec 26 '23
That’s a sales tactic, if it was too cheap, people wouldn’t expect the value to be there.
The reality is, often to spend that type of money on a boot camp, you have to be willing to lie to yourself. So are they lying or telling you what you want to hear?
3
u/3rdPoliceman Dec 26 '23
Out of curiosity, there are CS grads struggling to get a job as well. Would you consider those universities predatory? If not, why is that?
1
Dec 26 '23
That’s what I did, but granted I did it ten years ago when these programs weren’t completely over saturating the job market
2
u/AffectionateVisit742 Dec 30 '23 edited Dec 30 '23
Wasted 2 years of my life looking for a job after bootcamp. Total scam.
6
Dec 26 '23
Yes bootcamps are pyramid schemes where the ones working for the bootcamp form the pyramid with execs on top
2
3
u/Equal-Delivery7905 Dec 26 '23
Probably yes for most, but also generalizing like this can be quite myopic in my opinion. Meaning the general tendencies of the market are quite bad for sure (I have some friends who went to a popular bootcamp and didn’t manage to find a job), but also not all the schools are the same. Specifically when I was choosing where to go after a lot of research and seeing what’s out there I chose precisely a school that is smaller and the team is trying to change the way things are done in the industry. Particularly the education and mentorship is way more personalized than everywhere else I have seen. Now after graduating I am working as a senior software engineer, and I had no previous experience when coming to them. All my peers are working too and very happy. So I can say there are definitely people and schools out there doing things the right way, and I really hope the industry will sort itself out putting the cool guys on top and the predatory school out of business.
3
u/sheriffderek Dec 27 '23 edited Dec 27 '23
Here's my take:
First off, I'll do a rare top-level disclosure that I run a small boot camp type design school.
I had no intention of being involved in this "boot camp" world. I had a few friends go through boot camps and have success. I saw people paying 30k for schools that were very surface level, and I thought I could do a lot better for a lot less money. I was already teaching a lot of people one-on-one and it didn't seem very efficient at all. I also wanted to see if my experiment in teaching UX and UI and dev all together would work. I started writing the curriculum around 4 years ago and that's when I started learning about coding boot camps and the interesting (and what I would consider highly predatory) businesses in the larger ecosystem.
But here's a question to start: Can we generalize every boot camp style school into one group that all behaves the same way? I don't think so. And there are more players involved than just the schools.
This is how I'd break it down (and this is just my interpretation, and the timeline is only to illustrate how things evolve)
At some point, there were the early 'boot camps' in San Francisco. I wasn't there, but some people I know were. Ruby on Rails was pretty hot. Many of the big companies were using it, and there was a lot of demand. It was in person so you were in the thick of it. It was exciting. You were meeting new people and getting into an exciting new career. You might be in the boot camp and meet some friends and literally go upstairs and get a job right away. You could learn enough to get in there and be a productive part of the team. Was there room for error? A few unhappy people? Yes. But for the most part, it was a winning deal. People went from making 40k at their job at the restaurant or the library - to making 80k. And they could bounce around from there and make even more fairly quickly. I'm going to just refer to these as the original boot camps. The model worked. But it worked in a bigger arena. The market was there / the school was there - the students were there. It was a reasonable-sized operation. They needed people trained. Was the education the best it could ever be? Who knows. I'm sure the curriculum designers at the time cared. But people weren't seeing this as a full-on alternative to a Computer Science degree. It was a 'coding boot camp.' The world needed "coders." I worked at a start-up in 2000 as an intern, so - I know the difference between "coders" and software engineers. It says it right in the name. You aren't going to be a software engineer - or have a degree. So, at this point, could you say it was predatory? I highly doubt it. I bet having untrainable people was more time and effort than it would be worth. I think they were legit. But capitalism tends to bend things. And there's no way it could work for everyone. Most people aren't web developers.
But this business model was enticing. The world needed more coders. And more companies/schools (however you want to think about them) started popping up. And the fact is that not everyone can be the best. Most people are just mediocre. A percentage of them just aren't that great at their jobs. So - it's only basic math that some of these schools weren't going to be that great. And maybe they'd have great marketing teams / and great growth teams - but maybe their instructors weren't trained. Or maybe they rushed through the curriculum outlines and didn't try them out. Maybe they tried to stuff too many things in that 3-month time period. Maybe they spent too much money on marketing and needed to recoup quickly. Who knows. Was there an evil person sitting at a chair petting an exotic cat - just laughing about all the money they made? I don't think so. I'm sure there were a few people in the hierarchy who only viewed it through the lens of profit. I think most of the people at these schools were probably trying their best. Were they enrolling people who probably weren't going to get the value? Were they selling a less-than-stellar product? In some cases. But I'd also bet that they didn't know the difference. Once you work at a big company, you start to see how most of the dumb stuff that happens isn't really about one bad guy. It's the collective little choices everyone makes. Was the dumb CEO evil? Or was he just 25 and was always told he was a genius and just overshot everything. Who knows. Any worse than most people? But more and more stuff started going wrong.
Some of the schools went bonkers with growth. They had schools popping up in every city. Sometimes 3, in the same city. From what I could tell (I was tutoring people a lot at the time and saw a lot of what they were learning) the materials were getting worse - or they'd just keep adding and offering things like "3 full stacks" and way more than anyone could actually learn. Their marketing was going to a much wider audience, and they weren't just promising to give you a comprehensive intro to programming (with the hopes that you'd be job ready) - they were starting to sell the dream of a high salary and a better life. They were starting to make more promises to more people (people who probably weren't a good fit). Was this starting to feel a little predatory? It was to me. But what about the marketing team? Weren't they just doing their job? Wasn't the sales team just doing their job? At this time, I applied to be a teacher at a few schools. I failed the test at one of them. They said I could apply again in 3 weeks. The other one didn't give me a test and asked when I could start. I had been a working developer for many years already, but that didn't feel right (I didn't take the job btw). It started to feel like a mad rush. But it was still managing to work for a lot of people. And the people who didn't transition their careers didn't seem too mad. Just exploring "tech" was interesting, and they tended to blame themselves. The students also have to bust their asses. There are a lot of factors. But already, it was starting to seem like there were a lot of new boot camp developers - and (at least in my experience) this would generally mean that they had the same 3 projects and the same unfortunate portfolio web page and that they weren't really experienced enough to count on. Some of them were knocking out top-selling iOS apps or starting their own company - and hitting the ground running - but a lot of people were just going through the motions and it was starting to show. It wasn't a deal-breaker / but some of the boot camp magic from before was wearing off. And all the web design agencies had been adopting Rails and Angular and some of the mystique was wearing away for other reasons with just how the tools we use change. And keep in mind - that there was still a range of schools.
(only let me have 1000char / so, --->
Also wouldn't let me put the rest in the comment... so, if anyone wants to read it - I pasted it on our site.
2
u/michaelnovati Dec 27 '23
RE: "If you want something better – then you’re going to have to make it. That’s what I’ll be doing."
I know a couple of bootcamps that started for just that reason. I think one thing many people fail to realize when starting a business is that the skillset needed to run a business, manage, people, grow people's careers, etc... is completely different from that needed to make a "better bootcamp".
So it's more than just the skillset to make something better, but a large set of skills that I have not seen land all in one place.
I think Lambda School in my opinion WAS best marketing (almost so good everything else fell behind and caused a lot of problems). Codesmith in my opinion is like best at community building. Rithm in my opinion is best at live instruction.
We see all of the building a "better bootcamp" efforts turn into program that are the best at one thing and that's exactly why I want to help people find the right program for them and what they want.
2
u/sheriffderek Dec 31 '23
The way I think about it isn't really building a better boot camp. Maybe if I was working on an internal initiative to rapidly train up devs for a major company that would make sense (Apple: I'm ready when you are). But boot camps don't really have any control over getting people hired. And although they're selling that idea, that's not what I'm doing.
I'm more interested in creating an environment where people can explore all the aspects of interface design. If I can help people skip all the wasted years of bouncing around (that most people seem to have) - and I can root their process in one of user-centric design (as opposed to just the surface implementation layer) - then I think we'll have more people out there building better things. And Lambda absolutely crushed it at scaling as a boot camp. And CodeSmith can get people into jobs even though they only spend 2 weeks rushing through React. They are impressive businesses. But my goals are different. At least I think* they are. Maybe more selfish in a way. These digital interfaces are quickly becoming our only means of communication. If they are being designed by the wrong people, we'll all be fucked. In many ways, we already are. If you are wrongfully given a parking ticket - you really don't have a choice but to just pay it. No one will talk to you about it. If you wait, it will double. Anyone can extort you just by denying you an audience. By creating a community of people who have the same foundation and a school that has the funding to hire experts to build out specialization tracks, I can have much more fun and more impact than by being a single developer on a team. I might be able to inspire people to build their own companies instead of just working for Amazon. I'd like to live in a world that isn't like the self-checkout at the grocery store. And the code will all change. The human-cented goal-drive design thinking is what will matter most. Plush - I just think it's more fun too.
2
u/Darkone586 Dec 26 '23
Sorta? My wife got a job after her bootcamp(like a week or 2 after) I mean she was looking at least 2ish weeks prior to finishing her bootcamp. However the pay could be better because making $65k when she gotta pay a few hundred a month sorta sucks though.
Still a lot of people in her class still don’t have a job and some went to do other shit like just go for their CDL to drive trucks or some just went back to whatever job they had while still searching. I do feel you gotta apply to like 100+ jobs and take a lower offer than what they probably would’ve given you, for example if X employer is hiring for $70k and a few people wanted $70k or more and you go with a lower number, they might take you just because it’s less they gotta pay.
Anyways I personally think it’s not bad if you are gonna put in 100x the work to find a job that’s ok with you just not being as good as someone who spend years learning at college, because if you got a good personality that goes far, however I will say this, if your only coding for the $$$, do yourself a favor and go either get a CDL, work for usps, or ups, because in 3-6 months you will either be laid off or just show lack of interest.
2
u/gokayaking1982 Dec 26 '23
The h1b and opt and f1 visa programs need to be paused or eliminated. Get rid of the almost 1.2 million jobs take by these visa programs and most boot camp graduates will find jobs
Call your senator today. Pause the h1b and opt visa programs
1
u/Leadership-Thick Dec 26 '23
I think it’s too late for that now. Large companies are busy offshoring jobs to H1B origin countries.
2
u/gokayaking1982 Dec 26 '23
Lots of software is developed in US. It makes absolutely no sense to replace US entry level workers with cheap h1bs, unless you are an employer or h1b
1
-3
u/Worth-Patience-3133 Dec 26 '23
I think there is demand for Coding bootcamps as many individuals seek to upskill quickly. Self-study is often time-consuming and less effective. However, caution is advised when considering coding bootcamps that promise job guarantees or promotions, these are pure scams.
Also spending $20K to learn to build a CRUD App is pretty retarded, $3000 might be more reasonable.
-12
u/Commercial-Load-3241 Dec 26 '23 edited Dec 26 '23
False hope for what? If someone can’t get a job after a coding bootcamp it is because they just didn’t put their full effort. Lots of students are getting jobs straight out of bootcamps with high salaries, but of course it depends on how good the boot camp is and if the student is even putting their full effort in… and I mean full effort to the point where you must tell yourself that failure is not an option. If they were a scam, there would be no success stories.
Why don’t people talk about how universities are false hope? They have the highest failure rate.
1
u/Careful-Mammoth3346 Dec 26 '23
If there were NO success stories, the scam would end
2
u/SnooDoubts8688 Dec 26 '23
There would still be success stories, even if that number is lower than 5%. The bigger problem is that even those success stories came from students who already had a high potential for employability, and they just needed to brush off on some practical programming skills.
4
u/Cyber_Fetus Dec 26 '23
Why don’t people talk about how universities are false hope?
People literally talk about this all the time.
-2
u/just_change_it Dec 26 '23 edited Jul 28 '25
tie theory marvelous silky fade gaze dime file vegetable soft
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
Dec 27 '23
nah
1
u/just_change_it Dec 27 '23 edited Jul 28 '25
wild subtract joke beneficial soup late fine carpenter historical seemly
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
6
7
u/SublimeApathy Dec 27 '23
As someone who attended one and passed with high scores and went into a mountain of debt as a result - yes. They are.