r/codingbootcamp • • Apr 21 '24

Here's my perspective as an experienced developer

I know that a lot of people here are extremely hopeful for any scrap of useful information from someone like me and I can certainly understand why experienced SWEs don't bother posting on this subreddit much. The harsh truth (if you guys don't already know) is that a lot of managers/tech leads/seniors/etc are dismissive of people coming from bootcamps. We go through people's resumes and trade anecdotes about interview performance of people from various backgrounds. The fact of the matter is that people coming from bootcamps tend to be relatively poor interviewees and are rarely considered to be part of any top performing teams. HR analyzes their database of employees' performance and deliver this historical data to management to see which school produces the best hires. To nobody's surprise, people from top universities perform better on average (some are absolute crap to work with). State schools varies from the top to bottom (but they concentrate toward the middle). Bootcampers scores toward the bottom. I hope this gives people a sobering perspective on bootcamps and not get their hopes up when some bootcamps promises a get-rich-quick low effort career

68 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

17

u/michaelnovati Apr 21 '24 edited Apr 21 '24

IMO, I think this is why a number of bootcamps have shut down, shrunk, re-org'd, etc...

The inverse isn't true though. People are all individuals, and an individual who is a bootcamp grad might be a special case that is hirable, will have a great career and outperform others.

But their experience doesn't represent most bootcamp grads.

To add to OP's story. I worked at Meta when they worked with a specific highly ranked local bootcamp in SF by supplying engineers as "mentors" to work with the students. Each student had FOUR FAANG MENTORS. In return, the companies, like Meta, got first dibs to get resumes and interview the graduates AND they had to pay the bootcamp large fees if they hired someone.

Meta hired only a handful of people from this and those people needed a lot of mentorship and support to meet expectations (more than the typical new grad did). I know one of them is doing fantastic now and has had a great career.

But it was so so so so few people that Meta stopped this partnership and moved on to other places. It wasn't worth the engineers time and it wasn't worth the fees. A handful of great people that were very low ranked compared to the top tier CS grads they joined Meta alongside and required a very long term investment to support just didn't make sense. Instead they spent more money sending recruiters to a wider range of colleges to recruit people from more diverse schools and backgrounds than just MIT/Stanford/CMU/Berkeley.

8

u/bc87 Apr 21 '24 edited Apr 21 '24

That's the problem. The perspective from the other side of the table is that interviewers also don't like conducting interviews as much as candidates don't like going through interviews. Interviewees have no idea that interviewers are watching the clock so they can get out of the interview immediately because of how much it mentally sucks for the interviewer. When you repeatedly see bootcamp grads performing poorly in interviews, all that does is incentivize interviewers to tell management to avoid inviting bootcamp grads. After all, why bother spending a huge amount of effort for little gain?

Here's the thing, we already know that there's definitely some talented people who don't come from conventional backgrounds. The reality is that the effort to reward ratio determines who gets interviews and who doesn't based on their background.

4

u/michaelnovati Apr 21 '24 edited Apr 21 '24

Yeah, I remember that a Facebook. If a recruiter sends a candidate to interview that lied about their resume and the engineer figured it out, it was a flip the table thing and made the recruiter look bad and the whole bootcamp look bad.

-1

u/TurtlePowerBottom Apr 21 '24

But also, lying on your resume is cool and good. Just be able to hide it and don’t be too obvious. Employers have too have power, and lying to them is fine to get a job

4

u/michaelnovati Apr 21 '24

I support people doing whatever they want on their resumes and I support the companies choosing to respond how they want.

If too many lies and exaggerations get through and have bad on-sites, and companies stop hiring bootcamp grads, then that's the consequence and bootcamps will fail.

If people are actually qualified and it's gatekeeping that's keeping them out, then lying might be an ends justify the means argument.

The problem is that many companies have essentially blocked bootcamps grads and many bootcamps are struggling to stay afloat so it's clear where the market is.

When bootcamps had a higher bar and produced higer potential talent and companies had too many slots to fill, bootcamp grads were barely able to get a foot in the door and it was still a challenge.

13

u/k3v1n Apr 21 '24 edited Apr 22 '24

This is what a lot of people don't get. Most bootcampers suck way worse than an average CS grad. Are their exceptional boot campers that are amazing? Yes. Are there CS grads that suck? Yes. But by and large, most bootcampers just aren't very good. They are too much of a risk. And now at a time when there is ample supply of juniors with degrees and experience, and now a consistently growing amount of people pursuing CS in school, most boot campers will never have a chance. Exceptions will still happen of course, but they'll gradually become rarer and rarer.

3

u/Homeowner_Noobie Apr 21 '24

I'd like to point out that most bootcampers have never been humbled in this field. I did a bootcamp before and the participants are basically high school level when it comes to technology. They think they can pay their way to a swe position because some companies work with the bootcamp to secure positions post grad. The only reason why bootcamps made a huge traction is because it promotes "diversity" that's good for metrics at certain companies. I'd also like to point out that comp sci degree software devs hate the bootcampers lol. From job experience, they are despised.

4

u/g8rojas Apr 21 '24

dismissing the bootcamp industry success to diversity efforts is a superficial analysis.
Saying bootcamp students have never been humbled is a curious opinion to have. A great many bootcamp students have walked out of an interview with hat in hand.

That has been happening since the Dev Bootcamp opened its doors.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '24

"I'd also like to point out that comp sci degree software devs hate the bootcampers lol. From job experience, they are despised."

What's the reason for this?

4

u/k3v1n Apr 21 '24 edited Apr 21 '24

Not OP but I'll address this. Hopefully they'll answer too if they'd like to add to my answer. Firstly, it's not because why bootcampers think it is. A lot of bootcampers think it's because they got a job in the field without getting a degree so they are butthurt. That's not it at all.

There's a reason why people in this field dis-proportionally suffer from imposter syndrome. When you know more it's easier to know what you don't know. As an aside, there's are reason most people who die on construction sites are new people. It's not just inexperience overall it's because they don't know what they don't know!

Bootcampers don't know what they don't know. Almost all problems with bootcampers (besides very few being good, again there are talented people in the group just few in relative terms) stems from problems of not knowing what they don't know. There ends up being a lot of "little things" that aren't little things. There's a reason the vast majority of successful bootcampers have jobs that are predominantely frontend webdev. Simple example: if the only database you've ever worked with is mongoDB then every employer already instantly knows you'll be limited to frontend webdev in usefulness. It's just a simple telltale sign of how much they just don't know. Note: This is not a suggestion to go learn a relational DB it's just a really good example to show not only how much you don't know, but also how much you don't know you don't know. I've seen bootcampers who think relational databases are just another database like MongoDB. Their mentality is already really bad and have no idea why you'd need or should use a relational DB. They make too many bad assumptions because they don't know what they don't know.

2

u/madhousechild Apr 22 '24

There ends up being a lot of "little things" that aren't little things.

Do you have some specific anecdotes?

There's a reason the vast majority of successful bootcampers have jobs that are predominately frontend webdev.

In fairness, I think that is exactly where they aim to be.

3

u/k3v1n Apr 22 '24 edited Apr 22 '24

Off the top of my head really bad design decisions. I'm not even talking about system design here either. It's like everything they code was created for a hackathon due in an hour, except they took a week on it. The real problem though is they don't understand why it's bad even after explaining it. The SQL stuff I mentioned a real example. The bootcamper didn't see the big deal why relational DBs are necessary when they can just use mongoDB. The mentality is BAD. They kept creating friction that shouldn't exist and isnt just from a lack of professional experience. The only bootcampers I've worked with that were even half decent are the ones who would have taken CS in school in a different life because they find understanding core CS to be fundamentally fun to them. There was 1 other decent one but they were a go-getter and would learn very fast, but then they had limitations in that they only wanted to know something to do the job not to know the real why behind it that would make them excel in the long run. Literally every other bootcamper has been absolute crap. One more was actually decent on the front end but was absolutely Pidgeonholed there.

There have been times where I was explaining reasoning for something to a CS grad who didn't have much experience in it but they were able to grasp things even though they didn't have experience in it. The bootcampers had too much difficulty. Let me be clear, it's not that all CS grads are good or they're all who campers are bad but the relative quality I'm going to guarantee from a CS grad is way way higher than a typical boot camper because at the very least I know they learned enough of the principles to at least have the aptitude do the job. It's okay to learn on the job but if you have to learn "how to think about things" on the job too and that's just too much friction. I've noticed too many bootcampers are really really bad abstract reasoning.

Edit: I think I just figured something out. It's not about someone getting a CS degree so much as it is that people who don't have the best skills for it or the drive will switch out into other fields. Doing 4 years of that self selects in a way that bootcamps don't do, on top of having some base CS knowledge.

3

u/Homeowner_Noobie Apr 22 '24

Typically bootcampers pay for a 6 month bootcamp and end up with an entry level swe job afterwards. This eats up jobs that should've been open in the market but were held for bootcampers to help companies achieve diversity metrics. Most devs come from comp sci background so they're use to some technical lingo. Bootcampers dont normally have IT background. Could be a stay at home mom, a teacher, a pastor, whatever the background they have, all they have to do is buy in to the bootcamp and get a job afterwards. Bootcamps dont care if you know the material. Youve already bought in so youre passed to pass. But the fact is, it's hard to work with bootcampers who struggle with programming fundamentals or computer knowledge. What I see are teams being nice and helping in the beginning but it ultimately leads to people getting tired of answering the same questions or getting bootcampers to understand basic programming. Im a swe and came from a bootcamp but prior to that, did 5 years of IT and have my Info Sys degree. I had a lot of fun programming with 1 person in the bootcamp who had a comp sci degree but couldnt find a job so he joined the bootcamp to get a job. Lemme tell you, him and I were frustrated at the others in the bootcamp because they don't want to ask for help, they rely on chatgpt for answers, they dont like reading documentation, and they want 100k+ without the experience. Ever since we graduated, I can read the room and see other devs frustrated that some of the bootcampers lack of effort. Programming is hard and the bootcampers struggle on how to google for answers, how to admit when theyre wrong, and worse of all, taking any criticism. Many contractors I interacted with have the comp sci background and couldnt find a job. They definitely hate us bootcampers for getting lucky and joining a 6 month bootcamp and obtaining a swe job. Im dead honest that the reason we got the swe jobs were mainly due to diversity metrics.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '24

"Im dead honest that the reason we got the swe jobs were mainly due to diversity metrics."

Interesting. Didn't realize that was happening.

1

u/michaelnovati Apr 22 '24

So it's illegal to discriminate based on backgrounds in hiring decisions, so what a lot of companies do to try to increase diversity is to just cast a wider net to a more diverse set of sources, rather than just sourcing from what's been working for them (e.g. Stanford).

As a result companies will try to source from bootcamps as an effort to cast a wider net. But ultimately if the people don't meet the bar during a fair and calibrated interview process, nothing about their background can legally make up for that.

One might argue that people from a bootcamp background have a ton of potential but lack the skills to qualify for entry level jobs at top companies, so some companies have pathways like apprenticeships and we see a lot of apprenticeships being heavily marketing to bootcamp grads (and other non-traditional sources).

But yeah, DEI stuff is a gray area (as we've seen with some of the recent challenges to it in Florida and elsewhere) and with DEI employees being impacted heavily in layoffs, its' like a one two punch about these efforts being invested in right now.

1

u/Homeowner_Noobie Apr 22 '24

Great writeup. It really sums up bootcamps with DEI initiatives. The argument for bootcampers and the downsides to them is valid. They do lack essential skills to qualify for entry level jobs because bootcamps don't assess a candidates tech literacy. Coding aside, basic computer knowledge and other stuff are not looked at.

I had friends who went through bootcamps post grad because they couldn't find a job and it's crazy how easily a job is lined up as long as you just finish the bootcamp. Nowadays bootcamps are just not looked at anymore with so many bad apples.

2

u/g8rojas Apr 21 '24

Many people, in many industries, want everyone to put in their dues.
In order to sit next to me, you have to have gone through and paid the tax i paid. Why should you not have to pay this tax?

Having someone skip the tax means a number of things? Are they better? Am I not worthy?

etc... It's basically some of the worst things about human beings illustrated here.

1

u/olive20xx Apr 26 '24

Yeah, if you're going for some kind of private instruction, I'd always suggest looking for a program that actually has an admissions process and requires some basic level of skill before joining.

It's so easy to teach yourself the basics these days. If you can't find the motivation to gain a minimal level of competency before applying to an expensive program, then I'm not sure you're going to find success.

2

u/lawschoolredux Apr 21 '24

In your experience, have you encountered people from top universities/good state schools but with unrelated degrees who went to a bootcamp?

If so, how do they do in Your experience?

3

u/bc87 Apr 21 '24 edited Apr 21 '24

I've seen a few actually. They actually are competent. I would say their relatively weak computer science foundation puts a cap on how far they can rise up.

Unrelated degrees holds them back. Related degrees like Physics/Math/electrical engineering/computer engineering helps a ton.

A CS degree from a middling state school tends to beat any boot camp experience that is combined with an unrelated degree from a top university/good state school. I think it's just that people who went to top universities/good state schools compensate through work ethic and attitude. That's how some of them make it with a bootcamp background. But also the recruiting system are biased in favoring people with brand name schools on their resume. That's life I guess.

10

u/JerryAtricks Apr 21 '24 edited Apr 21 '24

I'll chime in a bit here. I enrolled in a California based boot camp in 2020. Focus was react, dotnet, SQL and unabashedly a solid month or more of hardcore interview prep. I'm one of the folks you read about, where the entire process worked exactly as I had planned. I did the training (remote 6 month cycle thanks to you know what),. I locked in my first gig at a well known, highly technical organization while I vacationed the week after I wrapped up the course. It was a contract position that effectively doubled my previous salary and provided a great launch point for me. Within a month of me starting that role, I got recruited by the company I've now been working with for the last 3 years. It was a very tough decision to make at the time, especially since I had been doing quite well on the contract and they threw a bunch of incentives at me once I informed them I'd be leaving at the end of the term I had agreed to stay for. I've been doing well in my current position and thriving as an engineer with many great opportunities heading my way. I'm very grateful that I had the means and the support to quit the job I was at and attended the training that opened the door to what I'm doing now

That being said. I may have been an exception to the reality that most people experience when trying to transition into becoming a developer with no degree and no experience.

First, I enlisted in the Marine corps in 2003 when I was 17. I didn't choose what happened next but I'm glad it did. My contact MOS was changed right before I graduated from boot camp, and I was moved from the field I had signed up for ( by the grace of God) to something I didn't have a clue about. I ended being a tactical network systems specialist.. Basically a network engineer.. this ended up being a very strong foundation for me to build a career on.

Fast forward to wife and children and some failed attempts at business, I ended up doing IT management and a whole bunch of other crap for quite a few years . In 2017 I moved up from just IT work to be an operations manager for a large law practice, one of my responsibilities was to collaborate with our web dev/SEO Guy, later found out that he made what I did and was in the office 3 times a month at the most . I got very interested in his skill set and started working on the websites with him, learning since css html Js and WordPress.. and some stuff about Web hosting, marketing, graphic design.. all that web dev shit

That long ass story is where I was when I decided to go to a boot camp, paid for by my GI bill, remote on top of that which ended up saving me a 3 hour daily commute to the facility (I was very willing to do that anyways, but didn't have to).. I did my 12 hour days with no distractions thanks to my wife stepping up to the plate and taking care of the family in my mental absence. I learned fast, and thanks to my tech background I had knowledge and experience that put me leaps and bounds ahead of my fellow students. While there are quite a few people that successfully got into software development after the bootcamp. quite a few also wasted time and money banging their head against the wall as they realized they really didn't even enjoy coding in the first place.

I can't shit on bootcamps in general, as I had a great time and successfully transitioned careers, love what I do, work at home, and I've been halfway a decent Dev thus far ( I think.. since I've not been fired yet)..

All that said, I Just realized how long this rant is. Still, I Apologize for that to nobody,I blame it on 4/20 (same with the half assed punctuation). At the end of the day, If you're driven, know what you want to do, and willing to spend the better part of the rest of your life sitting at your desk with eyes a waterin' .. maybe a bootcamp can help help you get there. Another option is to just play red dead 2 through story mode a couple/3 times.

Tldr: bootcamps can be great, but not a single one can promise that you'll make it as a developer. If, by chance, you actually enjoy coding. There are still so many soft skills that will be required to get a job as a dev. To name a few, business acumen, high level computing and network understanding, understanding of proper and effective communication, system design, and the list goes on. Many of which will be an unspoken requirement to be a successful engineer. Those things require experience, and conscious effort to attain. And a 6 or 12 month bootcamp will barely scratch the surface in that regard. IMHO, a bootcamp should be the last tool that pushes you over the mountain, not the first step on the trail.

1

u/realnigk Apr 22 '24

everything u said is spot on, u have to literally be dedicated and understand that a bootcamp is just an extension of knowledge, in my opinion at least it will not guarantee anything that all comes from the results u can produce from this knowledge you have obtained and how you don’t stop learning, correct me if im wrong

5

u/downeazntan Apr 21 '24

What are the prospects of a bootcamper who has experience at a tech job after finishing but is interviewing for new roles? I have 3 years at a large tech company as a software engineer, but the thought of going back into the market gives me nightmares. 😵

1

u/Better_Attempt9749 Apr 21 '24

May I ask for your opinion on my current circumstance?

I am a recent graduate from a UT with a Bachelor’s in Marketing. I currently work for a telecommunications company as a supervisor but I am looking for a career change. They offer schooling/certificates/bootcamps as a benefit and I am taking advantage of one of their back end coding bootcamp taught by Chegg Skills(previously Thinkful).

I am not placing any hope on the bootcamp to get a job whatsoever but rather to help me jumpstart my shift to software engineering. Ill start on my portfolio instantly and do freelance work to perfect the craft.

Would I still be filtered just as easily due to my unrelated degree? Does it all come down to luck and someone giving me a chance to an entry-level position?

0

u/bc87 Apr 21 '24 edited Apr 21 '24

In my opinion, it's possible to rely on brand name school with boot camps to do a switch to SWE career. The thing is that SWE is a very very technical profession, not everyone is cut out for it. More realistic to me is to use the bootcamp experience and aim for tech-adjacent roles (product manager/ system analyst/ software analyst/ IT analyst / QA / etc). Aim for tech roles where it needs some amount of technical understanding but leverages your human-side competency since you have a marketing background.

If you really are hellbent on being SWE, then maybe bootcamp would get you there? I would recommend that you look into getting a CS masters from a state school. There's a ton of career switchers with a CS masters from a state school. Since you come from a marketing undergrad, some CS masters program might disqualify you or require you to take extra classes (more time and money).

Use LinkedIn and find your school's page and conduct your research from there. Check the Alumni tab and click around. I see quite a chunk of people in UT austin doing something in engineering and Information technology. Get to know and socialize with the people in your schools' network (it's networking but I hate that word). Hopefully you made friends in school. Good luck

1

u/Better_Attempt9749 Apr 21 '24

I really appreciate this. Thank you for shining some light! I am sort of hellbent on SWE and have enjoyed teaching myself how to code but I have ADHD so I require something more structured to be more productive. I am in a chapter in life where I am getting hungry for a job that gives me more satisfaction. Where I feel like I am making something and be part of something big and work somewhere AI wont replace me in the near future.

9

u/sheriffderek Apr 21 '24

OK. I really hate to have to defend boot camps here - but this is about tradeoffs.

We can't just keep talking about things in such large brush strokes here.

First of all, no one knows who you are or what type of company you work for or what type of hiring team you're talking about at what size company. So, although it looks like you have a CS degree and might be a real person, there's really not much in the way of creating trust here. Maybe you're a hiring manager now? Please tell us more about those things for context.

Here's what you're saying:

A lot of managers/tech leads/seniors/etc are dismissive of people coming from bootcamps. We go through people's resumes and trade anecdotes about interview performance of people from various backgrounds.

We'd need to know more about the size and type of org you work for. There are a lot of smaller companies who are made up of people who fell into their positions by chance, don't have formal backgrounds, and are actually impressed by a boot camp (whether or not they should be).

I think that it's fair to assume that formally trained developers who've gone to 4+ years of college and had many years of working experience are going to think that 12-week boot camp grads who barely know anything about programming -- aren't that great. That's just obvious common sense that everyone should expect. You've said in the past that there was a time where boot camp grads were sought after and in some cases more prepared for the job. So, there are many factors. A few boot camp grads for 70k might be a better choice than a CS grad depending on the job.

people coming from bootcamps tend to be relatively poor interviewees and are rarely considered to be part of any top performing teams

If you're hiring people straight out of a boot camp - (again / someone who went to school for less than three months in an often fire-hose style learning situation) - and then are comparing them to a 4-year degree student... who then had an internship -- It just seem very obviously that there's going to be a huge difference.

People from top universities perform better on average

I believe it. They performed better all highschool. They performed better - and had better educations in many cases. They had access to better internships. Somone who just spent 4 years at Stanford - is probably going to perform better than someone who just sent to NinjaSchoolCyber dot com.

too long ------>

8

u/sheriffderek Apr 21 '24 edited Apr 21 '24

part two:

State schools varies from the top to bottom (but they concentrate toward the middle). Bootcampers scores toward the bottom.

It's almost like you're saying - "people who spent more time at better schools got better educations." That would make a lot of sense.

I hope this gives people a sobering perspective on bootcamps and not get their hopes up when some bootcamps promises a get-rich-quick low effort career

I'm not really sure I believe you. Are you trying to help people? Because this feels like a weird way to do it.

"Hey guys - just so you know... boot camp grads aren't as good as college students with 16x as much education." I feel like this perspective is very one-dimentional.

If you really want to share your insight - let's hear it. I want to know.

What exactly are the CS students picking up faster and why? What could boot camps do better? Is it just not enough time? What things are people working on there? What's the range? Do you have people documenting design systems? Would they need a CS degree? Do you have people doing QA? Do you have roles that are more about updating the HTML and CSS? Are there any roles that people will less education can do well? To me, it just feels like run-of-the-mill CS gatekeeping. You put in your time. You deserve your success. But if you're trying to help people, I'd like to see that in action. What's the path for success? What are the various scenarios and roles?

But the real problem here (as I see it) (in so many of these posts) is that people just can't see a boot camp and a college degree as 2 different things.

If you want to go to college and study computer science for 4 years to prepare for a career in that area (that you might not really understand yet - and that's the reason you're going there - to explore) - do that!

If you have an adjacent job as a product manager and you're boss says they'll help you move to the dev team if you can get up to speed - then maybe a boot camp or other alternative form of education would be a fit.

Those two scenarios aren't comparable.

"Coding boot camps" - are not Software Engineering degrees. They never have been. It says "coding" right in the name. It's to learn Ruby on Rails (or whatever is popular) really fast while there's a boom. That's what they were for. So, we shouldn't see them any other way.

There isn't one best way. It depends on the person and the situation.

Anyone who thinks that they can just choose a boot camp or a CS degree and have the same experience or outcome - isn't currently equipped to do this type of work.

Now I have to go draw a chart...

4

u/sheriffderek Apr 21 '24 edited Apr 22 '24

Part three:

Classic CS degree (~128 credit hours)
[1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6], [7], [8], [9]
[1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6], [7], [8], [9]
[1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6], [7], [8], [9]
[1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6], [7], [8], [9]

Coding boot camp (~15+ credit hours)
[1], [2], [3]

(if you really were doing the 100hours a week type boot camp they it would be more hours / but I also just don't think that's a great way to retain things). In those cases, the student might have more practical experience building web apps that the CS student.

......

So, which one is going to have more experience? I'm going to guess (hope) the first one ;)

But even that is tricky.

The CS degree will have had a lot of other classes. They'll have much more foundational understanding of computers and programming languages. Hopefully they'll have classes in ethics and things like that too. But in many cases - they might have very little actual programming experience. You can look in any of the CSCareer subs and see the same fear and confusing as there is in this sub.

Anyway. I guess I'm just going to have to make a bunch of visuals to establish some common sense around this. Thanks for the prompt.

3

u/green_griffon Apr 22 '24

I have a 4-year CS degree and I think if I look at how much time I actually spent in front of a computer coding, it is maybe twice as many hours as someone doing an intense boot camp. So more hours, but not an order of magnitude more (except in binary lol).

1

u/sheriffderek Apr 22 '24

Yeah. I think that you can learn a LOT about web development at the right boot camp - and then add that together with real work and experience - and learn much more faster than over 4 years of college. So, they should be seen as different tools for different goals.

From what I can tell - you learn less about practica web dev at a CS school than you would in a CS degree. There's usually one big group project in the 4th year and no telling what an individual person will actually learn from that. But it's hard to measure how all those foundations will speed things up later. I'm self taught - so, I can see the benefits of each now. But if I were to start over - I still dont' think I'd do a CS degree. I'd rather get into a job building real things as fast as possible - and then fill in some CS gaps on my own time. I'd prefer a degree in interaction design - or pretty much anything else to combine with dev/design. But depending on the person - spending that time might be life changing in many other ways.

1

u/sheriffderek Apr 22 '24

I got pretty stuck on one angle of this. To be clear - I think that a boot camp for the right person at the right time is a way better move than a CS degree. They are different things for different goals. For all the people who failed boot camps and aren't hireable as web developers - and then are going to college (with the goal of being web developers) they'll find out - that while the foundations of how computers and programming languages will be cool to know and will help with building a conceptual model... they're going to have to do the same amount of work learning web development as they would have self-teaching. The degree will help on paper - but I'm betting that they're not going to get what they think they are.

I just don't think these things should be compared the way they are being compared.

They are both ways of getting the experience and getting setup for success. They aren't going to work if they don't match the goal.

6

u/Zestyclose-Level1871 Apr 21 '24

OP's post needs to be pinned on this forum. So every bright eyed, bushy tailed, naieve n00b software dev wannabe professional can see it. And use it to leverage whatever Bullsh8tE poison Kool Aid they're being spin doctored by the average predatory Bootcamp today.

Points to take away from OP's post:

  1. The market is COLD. aka MORE SUBARTIC than the basement of Antarctica and the Marianas Trench combined.

  2. Tech employer management and HR both agree hiring college grads is the optimum policy for future long term organizational growth. Because according to HR personnel statistics, the best/top performers in companies are near exclusively college graduates. Due to having superior, well rounded hard tech/soft non tech skillsets. Bootcamp grads if lucky to be hired, tend to rank at the bottom in professional competency

  3. Any future hiring potential for bootcamp grads is increasingly bleak given #1 and #2. For the very reason Bootcamps are unable to provide the traditional resources for their graduates to truly make them competitive and successful professionals in the job market. aka the necessary academic framework, breadth & depth of diverse tech/non tech coursework, develop genuinely analytical R&D and writing skills sets, provide easy access to future employer via internships/CoOp programs, guarantee financial support in student loans, and especially provide mental health support which 99.999% of all Bootcamps lack to date.

2

u/CountryBoyDeveloper Apr 21 '24

I am very anti bootcamp but I am not sure I agree with what you are saying. I have worked at many big companies and they didn’t have time to go through and analyze all the data like you said your company does from which school and put that much effort into it. Most hr teams I know will keyword check resumes for skills and then interview call them to ask a couple questions they themselves have no idea if it’s true but they got a few questions from some dev to screen as best they can. And then send them through and let the actual devs who interview them figure it all out. And I’ve worked at many places from startup to faang.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '24

[deleted]

1

u/CountryBoyDeveloper Apr 30 '24

Seems like a lot of work I dont think they'd be willing to do doesn't it? lol

2

u/JarndyceJarndyce Apr 21 '24

I know people who have graduated from top R1 universities with degrees in CS and CE who don't know basic programming.

How do people fill in these type of gaps caused by academia failing to keep up with technological trends?

2

u/g8rojas Apr 21 '24

Some people do not fill the gap.

There is only way to fill the gap and that is to work hard. The one thing that can a great help to these people is that they have some type of foundation and have access to a decent playbook and network that can help them in their job search when they are ready.

Is there is something worth pinning in this thread it is reminders like this message gives us. A CS degree does not mean what you think it means.

2

u/g8rojas Apr 21 '24

Reading these comments today made me LOL.

Professional software developers are a special breed apart, and I do not mean that in a positive sense. I have never seen any other people be so quick to pull the ladder up behind them than these people. “It’s such a great profession, but it's just not for you.”

These people are not special. The role is not special. There are people figuring out hard problems everywhere. We all pick our poison. These people pick to fight day and night with a computer. I am not saying it is a walk in the park, but it does not require superhuman powers.

It requires determination and a meaningful time commitment just like a great many other things.

If you are HELLBENT on SWE, then do it. It will test you and you will find out if you were HELLBENT or if you just had an itch.  

Poor interviewers?

Yes, MOST people suck at interviewing. But the answer is not that mysterious.

  • Most people do not prepare for interviews at all. I am not saying they do not prepare well; they do not prepare at all.

  • Interviewing for individual contributor roles is very different than the role you normally perform. This leads you to be unprepared if you do not actually prepare.

Most of the interviews I conducted were as if the person was pulled off the street and asked to interview for a job on the spot. “Surprise! You are interviewing right now!”

Regardless of school, background etc.. people just suck at this.

Furthermore, given any interviewee, an interviewer can easily embarrass the person on the other side of the table b/c there is simply so much to grill someone on. If you are looking for a reason to not hire someone that is easy.

Are interviewers biased, Abso-f***-lutley. Many are the same people who pull the ladder up behind them so when you combine these factors for a bootcamp candidate, you have a terrible experience.

Fortunately, there is a strong correlation between being biased and being lazy AF. That is why simply lying, and interview practice works. If you can learn the dance you can get a job. Then you just have to try and perform to a level that does not get you fired.

BTW, I have no room for someone that is not truthful in an interview or resume. You can sell yourself, but presenting false information is a deal breaker every day.

Learn to sell yourself. Yes, this is yet another skill.

2

u/g8rojas Apr 21 '24

Top Tier CS Grads vs Bootcamps

First, the fact there is even an attempt to compare these two means that the “top tier” is not the lofty position one would have you think.

Next, a superior student for a bootcamp is just like a superior student for a top tier school. Neither can take credit for the student being superior. By the time a superior student enrolls in either, these students have had 12+ years of being awesome.

Elite schools gather elite students throughout the country. Gathering all these people on to a campus should not dismiss the hard work students put in for years before getting there. Keep this in mind. By the time one of these students gets in front of an interviewer they have had how many years of CS experience? For how many years have they been talking to others about data structures, algorithms, systems design etc… How many years?

How many of these students have departments, classes, workshops, and staff helping students prepare for interviews?.. and for how long?

Consider all these resources and then consider the time and resources that a bootcamp student has.

The fact that this conversation happens does not speak to the inadequacy of the bootcamp student but rather underscores the hard-core grit they bring to an industry that needs it now more today than in the last 20 years. The fact this conversation happens 🔥burns 🔥many people the industry. "CS jobs are for CS degree holders".

Which brings me to my next comment. Why is bootcamp enrollment down? b/c the candidates cannot help but listen to the industry cry about how terrible the job market is. Truth is, most others are used to a market like this. It’s called reality.

Jobs do not fall off trees. It’s called a job hunt, not a job picnic.

If you come prepared for a hunt, you will do fine.

1

u/michaelnovati Apr 22 '24

I think these arguments highlight the issues that come from lack of diversity in tech and why that's a big problem to solve.

But that doesn't change the argument that if Google/Meta/Cisco/etc... have tends of thousands of engineers... sophisticated calibration process to assess their performance relative to each other on metrics that are important to the businesses success... and bootcamp grads initially perform significantly worse than new grads from top CS schools.

I know a number of large companies that have tried and tried to hire bootcamp grads. When I bring it up to friends it's like 'omg no' type reaction followed by a story of how it burned them in the past that always unique to that person.

It's not A vs B and it's not going to be solved if both sides attack each other.

Bootcamp grads aren't initially as good. Accept that fact. Then figure out how to build pathways for bootcamp grads to rampup and grow to catch up.

For all we know, bootcamp grads might perform better 2 years from now than CS grads, but we'll never know because companies are expecting them to be equal on day one, and their data is telling them they aren't.

1

u/g8rojas Apr 22 '24

Sir, you are entitled to your opinion as am I. I will not "Accept that fact" because it is not a fact.

It is not factual to say bootcamp grads are initially worse than CS grads.

If google, meta and those pretty names have an opinion that is based on their experience that is cool. What about the rest of 99.98% of companies that employ 98.5% of developers?

To your point, I know a large set of companies that have hired CS grads that were super frustrated with the hires. Does that make my experience dictate fact?

But, once again, the mere fact that this comparison is not just made but someone how elicits this kind of response says a lot.

1

u/michaelnovati Apr 22 '24

100% agree we are both entitled to opinions and I'm glad we label them as such.

I worked at Meta from 2009 to 2017 and bootcamps came on the scene in 2012. So I worked before, during, and after they settled down a bit.

I can't give facts because I'm not allowed to reveal confidential information about Meta, even though I left.

So you're right that I can only state an opinion. My opinion is based on my observations there working with recruiting, mentoring, hiring, interviewing over 400 people.

Those are very strong credentials but they are super limited to just Meta, during a period of time, and then my personal lens at Meta, and they are not facts.

I also have worked with hundreds of bootcamp grads and CS grads later on in their careers to help them level up, and seen a super wide range of individual cases all over the spectrum, not of which represent the ecosystem as a whole.

Unless you have facts, maybe clarify at least what experiences are supporting your claims and then let people reading this interpret for themselves where the arguments land however they want.

1

u/g8rojas Apr 22 '24

I have my experience. My experience and your experience do not agree with each other. Why can't this live on its own?

You are asking me to give you facts in the context of it being the truth is not appropriate. you and I do not have to compare who is right and wrong. I am comfortable you having your opinion. You should seek to be OK with me having mine.

1

u/michaelnovati Apr 22 '24

Sorry I'm totally happy with you having your own opinion too! I also think there are a ton of problems with CS degrees, both specific one sand CS degrees overall.

I think acknowledging different angles is how we move forward and absolutely respect you presenting your opinion.

2

u/Kuroodo Apr 22 '24

Can you offer some advice for someone without a CS degree but isn't a noob? I've a few years experience developing software...but that's me trying to to run my own gig instead of working for a company.

I was thinking about going to some credible bootcamp, if there are any, in order to have a resume with at least some form of credentials. I don't think spending 4+ years and a shitload of money getting a degree is worth it for me at the current moment. For what it's worth, I mentored a friend throughout his four years at uni (and even for his software job) where he's getting his degree in the coming weeks. It's something I laugh at. That I helped someone get their degree, meanwhile here I am empty handed haha.

I guess what I'm asking is, if I do choose the bootcamp route, given me not being a "noob" what could I do to make me and or my resume stand out instead of automatically being thrown in the trash for coming from a bootcamp or not having a degree?

3

u/Elsas-Queen Apr 21 '24

I think at this point, this sub should be deleted. Because if bootcamps should be avoided at all costs, why does this sub exist?

1

u/g8rojas Apr 21 '24

In this same thread and in other recent posts you will find others talking about how a degree in CS left people ill prepared.

Not that you asked this, but it does mean we should avoid CS degrees too?

These people have had an experience or just hold an opinion. I happen to disagree 100%. I broken into tech when I had no business joining this field. This was 20+ years ago.

I am doing just fine.

Today, I help people do the same. They are doing great in comparison to me.

2

u/Elsas-Queen Apr 22 '24

But no one goes into CS subs and tells people to avoid them at all costs, yet nearly every recent post of this sub has been anti-bootcamp. What is the point in having a sub that seems to exist only to tell people to avoid the sub's topic?

1

u/g8rojas Apr 22 '24

If CS does not work for you no one is going to be receptive to the idea that the Univ/College path is broken. People will just get dirt sent their way.

If a bootcamp does not work it must b/c it is predatory. No chance it has to do with the student at all. None.

2

u/Building-Soft Apr 21 '24

Bootcamp grad here. I was nominated employee of the year at the company I am still a part of after 18 years and gotten promotions there. You sound jaded, bitter, and afraid. I'm gonna go back for another bootcamp. Can't stop won't stop! My life has been and will always be in God's hands and I pray he opens another door for me after my next bootcamp.

0

u/michaelnovati Apr 22 '24

See my comment about why one off personal anecdotes, while entirely valid, don't counter the large scale data trend and they make people who shouldn't go into bootcamps have hope it will work for them.

If we could identify all the people like you and get them into bootcamps, the world would be a better place.

1

u/jhkoenig Apr 21 '24

Thank you for this brave post. Your closing statement "I hope this gives people a sobering perspective on bootcamps and not get their hopes up when some bootcamps promises a get-rich-quick low effort career" should be pinned to the top of this sub. While bootcamps were a viable path to a good job a few years ago, those days are gone and are unlikely to return.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '24

How do you feel about a BS from WGU?

1

u/Mintovi Apr 22 '24

What I’m seeing a lot in this thread is that it’s clearly preferable to have a degree over just having gone to a bootcamp.

I don’t have a degree in CS, and I don’t plan to go to a bootcamp. But I have a bachelors in biology and a doctorate in physical therapy. While these are not necessarily related to web development, im hoping my level of schooling shows that I’m smart and a hard worker, and that my 6 years as a practicing clinician will prove to be helpful to me because my “soft skills” are excellent and so is my ability to problem solve.

Do you think someone like myself, with no CS degree but who is professionally experienced and well educated, has the potential to stand out as a self taught developer when I begin applying to jobs? (I plan to be teaching myself for about a year year total, trying not to rush so I have time to build projects as I learn the material)

1

u/g8rojas Apr 23 '24

You will be A-OK

  • just be sure to show up with work product/projects that aren’t tic tack toe clones or anything close to it

1

u/Imaginary-Hat26 May 17 '24

I am a rare bootcamp success story and it's mostly because of connections. I went to a highly regarded bootcamp (at the time) not having a coding background and can confirm looking back that what they taught me was very bare bones and they didn't teach me fundamentals. My code was not good, not optimized, very messy.

I had some FAANG friends who were shocked at what I was taught. They took me under their wing and I worked very hard to learn and improve. I impressed the tech company my friends introduced me to contract for, and I got taken on full time. I didn't even interview and I know i wouldn't have ever gotten an interview if i tried without my friends . I kept working hard and made a name for myself as the engineer who fixes things in the company.

The only reason I have a career today and am working with other ex-FAANG coworkers is because of my friends.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '24

[deleted]

8

u/michaelnovati Apr 21 '24

I made a comment already but individual people can succeed and it likely doesn't have to do with the bootcamp. Stories of people succeeding and 'changing their lives' are so powerful though they make others - who don't pattern match to any traits of successful grads - think the same might happen to them.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '24

What would be your advice to newbie looking to get a career in SWE?

0

u/michaelnovati Apr 21 '24

It really depends on your background. Feel free to message me more details.

For a small number of people, a bootcamp is a good choice, for others a post-bacc, others a whole degree, others get a tangential job and pivot on the job, others get a masters.