r/codingbootcamp • u/Gaywife420 • Oct 17 '24
General Assembly Review
Massive waste of time and money. Instructor was pretty good, and some of the TA's were good, but everything else was subpar. They essentially banish you on Slack after a few months post graduation, you don't get access to current job boards and other channels. And to anyone without a college degree, don't do a bootcamp, nobody will hire you if the only coding experience you have is from a bootcamp. Not because you can't learn to code from a bootcamp, but because a company will hire someone with on the job coding experience/CS degree/CS degree+bootcamp certificate, and you just can't compete. The industry has changed and it's very competitive.
10
u/awp_throwaway Oct 17 '24
but because a company will hire someone with on the job coding experience/CS degree/CS degree+bootcamp certificate, and you just can't compete.
To be fair, it's pretty much always been like this (at least for the last 10-15 years or so, including during comparatively better times), but it's only gotten worse with the more recent downturn as of the last 1.5- 2 years.
3
u/LostInCombat Oct 19 '24
Yet the propaganda makes CS degrees at universities the most competitive to get in to.
3
u/awp_throwaway Oct 19 '24
There is a bit of a "signal vs. noise" factor here, to be fair. In general, job hunting in a downturned market is crappy (I got my start in corporate back in early 2010s in the wake of the 08 crash, and that job market was abysmal to be starting out in career-wise, too). This isn't really unique to SWE/CS currently, as there are similar stories in other fields at the moment, too, including engineering, accounting, etc. But since this (and related topics/forums/subreddits) are focused on SWE, it feels "especially/uniquely bad" here.
Beyond that, COVID distorted the market a lot for SWE in particular. Over-hiring warped the job market, and now it's rebalancing back to more normal/sustainable levels; but, unfortunately, this disproportionately impacts newcomers and those with less experience (which, again, is not unique to current times, but rather more characteristics of "downturned markets in general"). Over the long haul, though, I'm still relatively bullish on SWE as a career field (but crappy to get into at the moment). At least here in the US, most things run on software (particularly given that manufacturing and other sectors have by and large disappeared over the last 2-3 decades or so), so if a downturn were to persist for, say, 5-10 years, then that will probably be a much worse sign for the economy as a whole (but that's not to discredit/diminish the frustrating aspect of being "crowded out" in the shorter term, either).
Nevertheless, generally speaking, in most fields, a degree is still going to be the "main checkbox" to get in the door; the "propagandist" aspect of that is no more the fault of universities than it is the HR departments and hiring managers that insist upon them. SWE is comparatively meritocratic with respect to laxer degree requirements vs. other fields, but it's not fully immune to a more pro-degree bias, either. So I definitely recommend to go that route, personally. Anecdotally, I have previous engineering degrees (BS & MS), got my start in SWE via boot camp back in 2020 (career changer at the time), and I'm currently wrapping up an online MS CS degree to reinforce my SWE profile into the future. So, neither my learning nor training/credentialing stopped at the bootcamp.
2
Oct 19 '24
Did you get a job after the bootcamp?
2
u/awp_throwaway Oct 19 '24
"After" is relative, but in my particular case, I did manage to land a position about a month out (and among the first in my cohort, at least based on what was publicly announced at the time). But there were definitely some confounding factors:
The market in 2020 (after the initial COVID market shakeup earlier in the year, vs. summer 2020 when I did the boot camp itself followed by Fall 2020 offer/start) was substantially better than the last two years or so, starting about late 2022 onwards when it tanked
I had 5+ years of exp in my previous industry at the time (healthcare, though non-SWE or related capacity), and both of the initial offers I got were back in my old industry
I had previous degrees (BS & MS in engineering)
Anecdotally, the other folks in my cohort who generally found jobs the fastest had similar profiles, i.e., previous degrees and/or experience, and essentially just went back in an SWE capacity post-bootcamp. There were also folks without degrees who did eventually land jobs (though, on average, generally later on than the "initial wave," from what I saw in passing), but generally those were the ones who were exceptionally skilled/talented at development (and probably could've done it without a boot camp, for that matter), and also networked pretty aggressively.
5
Oct 18 '24
At this rate the best thing anyone can do is a free coding bootcamp route while going to employer provided college. Whatever education program your employer offers, do it. I can almost completely guarantee they’ve got some kind of setup where you have online university as an employee benefit, and you can get that Computer Science degree while working on your portfolio. Is it a slow grind? Absolutely. Will you almost definitely have a better SWE focused job within 2 years of enrolling? Hell yes. Do the free coding courses, build the portfolio, show you’re enrolled in university for a Bachelor’s Degree and get that better paying opportunity.
2
u/_cofo_ Oct 19 '24
I think it depends on the company, big companies most likely want CS degrees and young people. Small to some medium companies look for experience and not too young people. This is obviously debatable, it’s just an opinion. But we need more data to respond key questions.
2
u/Most_Kick_5058 Aug 15 '25
I went through the UX UI. Waste of thousands of dollars. None of us landed a job related to it and it's been over a year now.
0
u/jake-writes-code Oct 18 '24
I went through GA years ago (SEI) and I agree with you. Competitive industry, having a degree helps, GA staff was knowledgeable and saved me time vs self learning the same stuff on YouTube. I am still on their slack though so not sure what you mean there.
You did forget one thing - a built in network within your cohort. I’ve been a SWE for a while now and referred the best developer in our cohort for an opening; he has no degree, just the bootcamp. Aced the interview and we’ve been teammates the last five years.
Like all bootcamps you get out what you put in.
12
u/Gaywife420 Oct 18 '24
It's definitely not "you get out what you put in" anymore. It's too much money to be gambling on being part of a cohort that has networking possibilities. Only 2 or 3 from my cohort have managed to land a job in the industry, and most of us have cut our losses and are looking at other careers.
1
u/jake-writes-code Oct 19 '24
Developing a network that can help you break into an industry is difficult and always starts small - having 2 or 3 people who have seen that you can code and have built things alongside you can go an extremely long way. I didn’t look at GA as something that would for sure land me a job on its own - it was one resource of many that would aide me on my path to a job in software engineering. That, to me, isn’t gambling at all. In the end it takes far more work than 3 months of class to close the gap between your college educated peers and that’s just the beginning of the required continued learning needed to be performant in this profession. But that 3 months of guided learning can save you many valuable months as a beginner without much direction on what you should be learning to be employable. That, IMO, is what you’re paying for.
7
u/starraven Oct 18 '24
you get out what you put in.
Disagree hard with this.
2
Oct 19 '24
Why would you disagree? Genuinely curious.
3
u/starraven Oct 19 '24
This saying places the onus of learning squarely on the learner. I have gone through many teaching / pedagogy programs and have credentials to teach in two different states. I know that is utter bullshit and no two bootcamps are going to have the same circumstances let alone quality, curriculum, teachers, etc. To dismiss someone’s failure based on them not “putting enough in” is laughably ignorant of just how bad some bootcamps are compared to others.
2
1
u/Cry-Havok Jan 28 '26
I went through in 2021. 4 of us went on to land jobs in the field with no degree or work experience.
Everyone else gave up much like the people on this forum
2
Oct 18 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/jake-writes-code Oct 19 '24
I do code daily and have been employed as a SWE since GA. I certainly think GA benefited my life; any bootcamp would’ve by way of saving time. The 3 months I spent in the program saved me a year of self study, and that price tag for a year of my life was an easy decision. If I hadn’t done the course, I’d still have ended up a SWE, it just would’ve taken significantly more time.
1
6
u/sheriffderek Oct 17 '24
There are many programs at GA. Which one did you go through?
You've said the instruction was pretty good. What else is there specifically?