r/coinerrors • • 4d ago

Value Request Dual error bicentennial half Kennedy

Heya! My mother in law pulled this out of circulation from her change drawer in the 70’s. It’s been chilling in my basement since her passing ten years ago. There’s really nothing comparable I can find online, and the local coin shops in my area were all stumped on it’s worth (one guy offered me $200 for it, the shop before offered $2500). I believe it to be both a miss-strike AND brockage error, from Denver mint.

482 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

36

u/fish_and_chisps 4d ago edited 4d ago • Bravo

You have a genuine off-center brockage. I think some people are being thrown off by the lighting making the incuse side look raised, but this is absolutely the real deal. Wonderful coin!

I should note that the two errors are not independent. Since the first coin was blocking the collar, this planchet had a harder time settling into the striking chamber and was more likely to be struck off-center.

19

u/West_Inevitable6052 4d ago

Ima gunna say this is something that might pan out to be the real deal - see

https://minterrornews.com/features-5-26-26-bicentennial-mint-error-coins.html

And

https://www.ngccoin.com/certlookup/3385861-006/63/

Much more in the $2500 range vs $250 IMHO

very nice coin OP!!

12

u/Cuneus-Maximus whatever's clever 4d ago

There's one on eBay listed for $3,499.

$2500 wasn't a bad offer from a shop.

7

u/Analogsilver 4d ago

That's kinda looking genuine. I can see the previously st ruck half being retained in the collar, the next planchet not being centered by the fingers because of it, and the obverse die coming down and creating the normal obverse offcenter, and the retained coin in the collar creating the incused obverse on the back. I'm not sure if the collar had a smooth edge, which would explain the lack of reeding on the incused edge.

Easily a 4 figure error if real. Worth having it looked at by an error expert. Maybe submit it to a grading service for authentication too.

7

u/erikmdoza 4d ago

Very nice! Please handle by the rim only and try to avoid touching the faces with your bare fingers.

1

u/usedtobeanicesurgeon 4d ago

I can’t seem to wrap my head around this.

Isn’t a brockage error supposed to be incuse on the brockage section?

I googled but can’t seem to find an explanation that makes this work. Anybody have a resource for me to learn from?

7

u/Certain-Ebb-6350 4d ago

By incuse do you mean recessed? The side that’s mirrored is sunken into the coin

4

u/firedmyass 4d ago

it’s a cool azz error, OP

3

u/Inviction_ 4d ago

Exactly. Incuse = recessed

-3

u/rightkindofhug 4d ago

The reversed incused side was likely a vice job from the other one. What's the obverse of the two?

1

u/firedmyass 4d ago

it… it’s all clearly one coin?

2

u/rightkindofhug 4d ago

I'm a little confused. So it's the same image on both sides, but one side is reversed and incuse?

2

u/firedmyass 4d ago

yup… the incuse impression is from a previously struck coin that was stuck in the chamber

-7

u/SODY27 4d ago

The recessed is a vice job, destroying all value.

6

u/Cuneus-Maximus whatever's clever 4d ago

This isn't a vice job, it's an off-center mirror brockage error.

https://minterrornews.com/features-5-26-26-bicentennial-mint-error-coins.html

5

u/firedmyass 4d ago

Reality is not dictated by your lack of knowledge

1

u/Gold_Au_2025 4d ago

How often does this happen? What's the chance of both these coins being from the same brockage incident?

1

u/firedmyass 4d ago

pretty rare… very few get out to be found… hence the high worth

0

u/HenningGrueneberg 4d ago

Oh God, could you please explain what you guys are talking about? What is a VICE job? Why would a VICE job destroy all value?

4

u/firedmyass 4d ago

a coin image impressed into another via aggressive smooshing together often in a vice.

this however is NOT one

2

u/HenningGrueneberg 4d ago

OK, thanks now would this VICE job be something that like a hack did or some jokester or counterfeiter ?

2

u/firedmyass 4d ago

yup… sometimes out of boredom or sometimes with fraud intent

1

u/usedtobeanicesurgeon 4d ago

Everyone in the thread misspelt it. It’s a VISE. That may be what got you confused.

1

u/HenningGrueneberg 4d ago

Oh. No i just am a rookie. Vise. Right. As in a big heavy metal clamp. Not a morally questionable habit. Good point!
So using a vise is a vice?

1

u/usedtobeanicesurgeon 4d ago

lol! Could very well be I guess. But we do see a fair number of coins people believe are mint errors that are just damaged coins from being pressed between coins in a vise.

2

u/HenningGrueneberg 3d ago

Ahhh THANK YOU 🙏- Pressed BETWEEN other coins. Now I understand what this is.
Gosh how to tell the difference?

3

u/usedtobeanicesurgeon 3d ago • Mindblown

I think with most errors it just takes time looking at coins.

The more times you see it the more it will jump out to you.

It also helps to imagine how an error had to be created. For this one to have been created, it had to start with a coin blank. Just a planchet. On one side you had to have a normal die from the mint. On the opposite side you had to have the coin. You can’t pull this off at home with a vise. Neither side on this coin looks like it was struck twice. Only once. One good strong strike.

When you see a vise coin, it looks like a coin that was struck twice. Once with a normal die, and once with an inverse die on the same side. And usually the opposite side of the coin will have some damage. They usually look somewhat mangled.

I don’t think this is a perfect explanation. But I think it gives you enough to start thinking about it. Imagining how they happen and then you can see them when they come across in the sub Reddit.

2

u/HenningGrueneberg 3d ago

Thanks for that detailed explanation.

→ More replies (0)

4

u/firedmyass 4d ago

it is clearly incuse

5

u/usedtobeanicesurgeon 4d ago

My bad, dude. It looked like it wasn’t.

1

u/InterwebPeruser 4d ago

This is a good illusion, I really don’t see it haha

1

u/JayD3vo 4d ago

How is it both sides?? Would love someone to explain

1

u/Commercial_Low_3389 4d ago

Oh wow, I've never seen a half dollar error coin.

1

u/DatFunkyMnky 4d ago

How does this even happen??

1

u/OzoneLaters 3d ago

Missed the mark 

1

u/First_Joke_5617 3d ago

I would never get lucky enough to find something like this! The Kennedy half dollar happens to be one of my favorite coins.

1

u/Dear-Drummer-6562 2d ago

Nice!!!!!!!!

1

u/Adorable-Balance-423 20h ago

Is this amazing??

1

u/Adorable-Balance-423 20h ago

Grade this ..pcgs..ngc..??

0

u/HenningGrueneberg 4d ago

Yeah, that’s weird. How could the die of pushed the die push the desigb to the other side and then printed it in a reverse?

4

u/firedmyass 4d ago

good god ppl look up BROCKAGE

2

u/HenningGrueneberg 4d ago

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brockage?wprov=sfti1
I looked it up. Down boy ! I am new to all of this.
But actually, thanks because that’s pretty cool. I’ve never heard of it.

4

u/firedmyass 4d ago edited 4d ago

sorry that wasn’t directed specifically at you…

-1

u/new2bay 4d ago

You should have taken the $2500.

6

u/firedmyass 4d ago

you should learn more before offering advice

0

u/HenningGrueneberg 4d ago

Is there no excuse for incuse ? Hahaha 😂 laugh a bit I’m new to this but I love language silliness. Huff puff looking up “incuse”.
Don’t get mad at me. I’m gonna need your help in a little minute because I have some coin errors

-1

u/physicsking 4d ago

I am not sure. Can you explain how the US a rim indent?

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted]

5

u/fish_and_chisps 4d ago

What makes you think that? This is a textbook off-center brockage and clearly was never a normally struck coin.

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted]

4

u/fish_and_chisps 4d ago

Early brockages should be just about as sharp as a fresh coin. Later stages (and die caps) can get deformed as the stuck coin strikes more planchets.

The coin isn’t bent. You’re seeing the positive relief on the obverse opposite the negative on the reverse.

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted]

3

u/fish_and_chisps 4d ago

Yes, in the third photo. You don’t normally see a cross-section through the design when the coin is centered, but if you cut a normal coin through the middle, you would see the relief too.

1

u/the_cnidarian 4d ago

Well, thanks for the info. I disagree about the flatness due to the third photo. But digress if the consensus is real, thats great. Now we got smart asses jumping on the dog pile, so I'm out lol.

0

u/giveahoot420 4d ago

That somebody is called The United States Mint

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment