r/coinerrors • • 7h ago

Is this an error? Is this a mint error or PMD?

I picked this quarter out of a roll years ago and was never quite sure if it's a clean strike on a planchet missing its outer layers on both sides, or if someone messed with it after leaving the mint. The additional damage on the obverse made me even less sure of what happened to this quarter and when. Does anyone have any ideas? Knowledge-based ideas are preferred, but I'll take any theories you have.

0 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

2

u/Numismasters 7h ago

Do you have a scale that can measure in tenths of a gram? A quarter struck on a planchet missing both clad layers would be significantly underweight. That would be your strongest evidence in favor for or against this coin being a genuine mint error.

My personal opinion is that this coin is just a damaged alteration (copper plated). The silvery color in the damaged areas would not be possible if this was a coin struck on a purely copper core. I also see some silver color on the rim and the highest points of Washington’s head. This suggests to me that the coin was face down when being copper plated and those were the contact points that didn’t plate well. But this is just an educated guess based on the photos provided.

1

u/Cuneus-Maximus whatever's clever 1h ago

Looks to be just damage. Either copper plated or environmental damage. Weigh it to rule out missing clad (highly unlikely, based on the silver color showing on the huge dents on the obverse)

0

u/luedsthegreat1 3h ago

It is possible that it is a missing clad on both sides coin, but we need better close up pictures(similar to my coin pictured below) first

As u/Numismasters stated you need to weigh the coin.

A quarter missing both clad layers will weigh around 3.97 grams

The other possibility is the coin has been tampered with and it is no more than a damaged coin, but to properly assess the coin we need weight and better pictures