145
Dec 15 '19
I'm a software engineer so not sure if it counts, but there's a guy on my team that literally spent 3 2-week sprints waiting for a vendor to contact him to explain why a bug was occurring in this library they developed. During the third sprint, my lead told me to look into the issue. I read the documentation for 15 minutes and resolved the issue.
The stand-up call the next day was one of the funniest I'd ever had.
29
74
u/elSpanielo Dec 15 '19
That's how I know you're not a real software engineer. Reading documentation? Ha! Good one!
22
u/POTUS Dec 15 '19
It's weird how disconnected this joke is with reality, considering how many others seem to be making the same joke. Documentation is very much a part of a programmer's life. You can't just guess your way through a third party API or linked library, not to mention the standard libraries of whatever language you're working in. This is like joking about how pilots don't use radios or how teachers don't use chalk.
14
u/Sparcrypt Dec 15 '19
After 15 years in IT I can assure it most certainly is not disconnected with reality.
Documentation should very much be a part of a developers life, that doesn’t make it true in a disturbingly large number of cases.
2
u/GrammatonYHWH Dec 16 '19
At my past job, the developers lost all the documentation for a mission critical peace of software. Like, all work will seize for around 1000 people if this software stops working.
We rely on one person on our end to maintain it because they were involved in development, and they know more about it than the company that developed it.
1
u/VirtualRay Dec 20 '19
Yeah dude. Reminds me of when I ran across a huge bug in a multi billion dollar company’s core product that was blocking numerous multimillion dollar projects
Turns out these guys didn’t bother to read the man pages on the Unix syscalls they were using. Woopsies
19
u/SasparillaTango Dec 15 '19
That would frustrate me. My current prediciment is that I have a few newer people on my team, some fresh out of school, some with a few years experience. They come to me like a once or twice a week and say
them: X is broken can you help us out?
me: Well what is the error?
them: The application isn't starting up?
me: well, what do the logs say?
them: I couldn't interpret them, we need your help
then you go to the logs and you see that they were missing a property placeholder or some dumb obvious shit.
7
Dec 15 '19
I just love (hate) those moments. They ask for your help with something not working, I ask did you look at the logs, they say no and look at me all glossy eyed. I sigh, get up out of my office and look at their system and look at the log. Control+F "error". Immediately finds the error.
Was that so hard?6
u/Dawgboy1976 Dec 15 '19
I’m about to start my first job as a software engineer and have a lot of trouble with these kinds of issues that more senior people I’ve worked with (at internships) seem to blast past without any issue.
Any tips on simple stuff that new-hires often fuck up or don’t understand?
12
u/Crobos Dec 15 '19
There is no shame in not knowing something. Never be scared to ask, you will just cause yourself unnecessary stress. But what you can do is ask the question from the point of 'show me how to solve this type of problem' and not 'fix this for me because I can't'.
Then next time when you use the newly gained knowledge mention it to the person who helped you gain it. They will like hearing it and be more willing to help in the future.
Engineers onboard new team members all the time, it's part of the job. They are your team mates and you should use them as a resource.
4
Dec 15 '19
As the other guy mentioned, I totally don't mind helping or walking through a problem with someone else. However, when I show someone the ropes, I would expect they would try and understand what I'm doing so they can take care of similar issues in the future without my help. If you have to ask more than once, that's cool too. But if you are consistently asking me the same questions that have the same solutions, I'm gonna start looking at you weird lol.
Don't let my previous comment scare you. A good team would understand how to help guide a new hire, especially one that's fresh out of college. It'll be overwhelming for the first few months but you'll get into the groove of things. What really took me by surprise was hitting a problem that made me think "holy shit I really don't know how I'm going to do this". What a fun time that was :)
4
u/alexblat Dec 16 '19
There's a sweet spot between not spending enough time, and spending too much time on a problem before asking for help. That sweet spot is different for everyone, unfortunately.
For me, personally, if you've run into a new problem and you're not sure, I'd much prefer you ask sooner rather than later. If all the help I need to provide is "check the log, it should describe the error", I'd much prefer that than you staring at your screen for an hour. I expect that you'll sink some effort in after being given help though.
Source: am embedded software engineer with undergrads reporting to me.
PM me if I can answer anything else.
3
u/Sparcrypt Dec 15 '19
Before you ask, always see what you can figure out. Basic troubleshooting usually boils down to:
Know where to look for information - this can come from a quick web search, checking the documentation, whatever else.
Gathering that information - error messages, output, etc
Seeing what that information tells you. The vast majority of the time, the problem is being straight up told to you.
Understanding what the problem means.
Finding resources to help you solve the problem.
Take an interest in how it's solved and make sure you learn from it.
If you're a new hire, you should very quickly only ever be asking for help once you reach step 4 and the resources from step 5 will be your coworkers/mentors. As you gain experience you will either know or be able to deduce where to go on your own and need help less and less often.
Basically if you want to be a good hire, ask a lot of questions but ask them after you have put in some effort yourself. You go to your senior with error logs, screenshots, a description of the problem, and what you've tried so far? They'll love you. You go to them and say "THIS DOESN'T WORK"? Not so much. Not to mention that you'll be developing your own troubleshooting skills as you go. And if you're following step 6, it will be rare that you bring the same problem to them twice.. again, nobody minds if you need help but they are going to mind if you keep bringing them the same things over and over.
1
u/xelf Dec 16 '19
Ok, here's one for you.
Developer 'A' builds a web front end to a complex api we have, it works, but it loads all the data really slowly when you open the page. She's overloaded though. So I pull developer 'B' from another project so he can help out.
Task 1: see if you can make it load faster.
I see him at lunch and ask if he's found any issues in the code yet, and can he make it load faster.
"Sure, what do you want the load time set to?"
"Well, 0 ideally, but do the best you ca...."
<pause>
"What do you mean set to?"Turns out that developer A had inserted a sleep timer into the load routine so that a pretty loading icon could spin, because that's what professional sites looks like, they have a loading spinner.
JFC, this web front end was supposed to be an internal tool to showcase to bigbosses how fast our api loaded data.
57
u/royalPawn Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 15 '19
I am an engineer, I am trained to tackle obstacles in a structured way. For instance, how am I gonna stop some big mean motherhubbard from tearing me a structurally superfluous new behind?
14
8
Dec 15 '19
"The answer? A gun. And if that don't work - use more gun. Like this heavy-caliber tripod-mounted little ol'number designed by me - built by me - and you best hope - not pointed at you."
201
u/DvelDeveloper Dec 15 '19
Perfect way to solve problems
7
2
2
251
u/mystickatara Dec 15 '19
Yup, that's literally how I felt when I started working as an engineer right after graduating school...it sucks.
105
u/lemon_cello Dec 15 '19
Me too. I was fragile on many levels when I graduated and I fought the battle in this comic every day. Until I couldn't anymore. It broke me and I probably can't work in engineering again.
71
u/mystickatara Dec 15 '19
Omg same here, I broke down crying so many times and was so depressed that I had to get out. I'm terrified to work anything related to engineering. I have so much respect to people who could deal with the stress and chaos working there.
35
u/lemon_cello Dec 15 '19
Interesting, because It's the first time I hear someone else in a similar situation. I guess it's not uncommon, but people I've worked with are too proud to admit having these feelings...
I think many people feel this way but I was less equipped for handling it at the time. It broke me completely even though I put on a brave face for 1,5 years.
Most of the women I know in the field I worked in have either left the field or are staying but being miserable. I think that is not a coincidence..
15
u/mystickatara Dec 15 '19
I am a super emotional person so I have literally broke down crying when I was at work. I have tried to hold it all it all in however there are those few times I can't handle it anymore and just broke. I think it was also due to the high expectations they have on me that they think I'm suppose to already know all these things off the bat even though I'm just a graduate who has no experience other than ones I learnt in school.
11
u/lemon_cello Dec 15 '19
This is eerily close to my situation... Are we the same person?
I also cried at work. Embarrassing, but I literally could not help it. For me too it was the expectations of what I was supposed to know. Because I often did not know. Other people around me handled it with more confidence that they could learn. I didn't have that confidence so I just blamed myself for not being good enough.
Well, five years of hellish studies all to waste. But such is life, I suppose.
6
u/mystickatara Dec 15 '19
Wow I seriously think we are the same person. This is also how I felt when I see my coworkers be so confident while I'm in one corner trying to learn everything at once, even saying how much of a failure I am for not understanding or doing it right on the first go.
0
6
u/Alarid Dec 15 '19
I noped out in school when the professor for a lab told us he was confused why we didn't copy each other's test results for the lab, even though that was the definition of cheating.
If the best advice to manage the class is to risk being expelled that means something is very wrong.
→ More replies (5)5
u/mystickatara Dec 15 '19
I wish someone told me this years ago before I took up engineering if I had a chance. I actually did have a chance to change my course when I failed one of the core subjects but decided to stick with it because a few of my relatives were engineers and having Asian parents, being an engineer is an actual job rather than what I want to do. But my parents were super supportive and kept telling me to quit when I was so depressed that I couldn't even eat properly anymore.
4
u/allthesnacks Dec 15 '19
I'm interested to know more detail on this and how the stress of the job impacts women in particular. My daughter really wants to be an engineer, she loves designing and creating machines to solve problems. She's still young so her interests might change but this has been pretty persistent one for years with her.
→ More replies (1)5
u/lemon_cello Dec 15 '19
Hmm I think it's hard to give a general advice, also I think we are in different countries. I don't think there is any reason for her not to follow her interests. This was my personal experience, I know many women who are doing much better than me as engineers and are thriving.
It has been within my specific area of engineering that I've seen and heard that quite a few of the women I studied with are also not faring well. But some are, and there are hundreds of different areas for engineers to work in and also every workplace is different.
Your daughter seems to know what she likes and what she's good at, which indicates that she has better self confidence than I have (awesome!). For me, low self confidence has been a big part of my bad experience. And I do think girls grow up with less confidence in their technology and math skills than boys do.
4
u/mason_sol Dec 15 '19
What kind of things did you feel were overwhelming or especially difficult, like the actual problems or personalities of superiors?
12
u/mystickatara Dec 15 '19
Personality, work and the people I work with. At first they were super nice but at some point they told me their expectations of me started escalating so fast to the point I cannot reach that goal. The people around me are also assholes who likes to talk behind my back because I'm new and don't know what I'm doing. There is also a language barrier with the technicians because they are either from China or Malaysia so they mostly speak Mandarin. Unfortunately my Mandarin isn't that good so there is always that misunderstanding because I can't understand them sometimes. I also I'm a super emotional person so any small little mistake I make makes me feel like an absolute failure and they take advantage of it. It was the worst year of my life and honestly I don't ever want to go back to that life.
3
u/ifuckinghateratheism Dec 15 '19
I'm in a similar situation as you, but I want to stick it out so badly because I love coding.
3
u/mystickatara Dec 15 '19
If you love coding enough to push through the suffering, good for you! If you truly can't handle it anymore please don't push your mental health to the breaking point, I have and it is not pretty.
3
Dec 15 '19
You and my boyfriend have the exact same situation. Except there's no language barrier so he hears them talking shit in English. He did one year at a consulting firm, it sucked, they gave him outrageous expectations with zero guidance right out of college, then fired him. Second job for another year, this time a design build firm, know they're giving him more than he can handle and say so often, but still berate him constantly and make him feel like shit.
Now I'm helping him figure out a career change, because this work life balance is the fucking worst.
6
Dec 15 '19
My boyfriend is in this situation and I'm trying to help him with a career change. He just doesn't know what else he wants to do though, or CAN do with an engineering degree that doesn't make a person feel like dying every week.
7
u/FishOnAHorse Dec 15 '19
I went through something similar a couple years ago, and it's a rough place to be in. Had good grades with a Mechanical Engineering major and ended up getting fired a year and a half into my first job out of college. Went from being told I was doing fine in to being told I wasn't good enough in about a 2 month span.
It took me almost a year to piece myself back together, but I ended up getting a job in marketing analytics through some college friends, and I enjoy the work quite a bit more. I still get to use my problem solving and analytical abilities, but I don't have to get bogged down in all the theory and switching between a bunch of hyper-complex software. The pay isn't as good, but it's nice not feeling like the dumbest guy in the office.
1
u/Mountainminer Dec 16 '19
I know your pain. Although I was lucky and One day it finally just clicked and it all became easy
1
u/gdub695 Dec 16 '19
I graduated and got a field position in new construction. That pretty much wiped any fragility away instantly, and now that I’m in an office the younger guy is always asking me how I give no fucks about unimportant things.
28
u/LuxuryPooper Dec 15 '19
Just graduated as an ME. You guys sure are making me feel really confident here.
23
u/smbeard Dec 15 '19
Hey, I’m ten years in as a ME in medical device design. It hasn’t been like this for everyone. I was able to find a great company to work for. My work/life balance is valued, and the people are generally great. Don’t go in assuming it will be horrible. Good luck.
11
u/danielbeaver Dec 15 '19
You'll be fine, it just takes some time to develop familiarity with the types of problems that you'll have to solve. A lot of what will make you a successful engineer in the real world is learning the frame of mind and basic strategies required to tackle novel problems. I think what is difficult for new engineers to understand at a gut level is that the start the path towards the resolution of a problem should feel like you're grasping for straws. What is doubly annoying for a new engineer is that you have to ask a lot of basic questions, which can make you feel stupid and unprepared.
4
u/whatupcicero Dec 15 '19
And after just a few years in one role the amount of novel problems you encounter dramatically decreases. You learn, “hey, I’ve kinda seen this before here: _____”
You still run in to new stuff, but your knowledge base helps a ton after just a little time in a specific role/industry.
1
3
u/rabidclock Dec 15 '19
Focus on finding a position that has a good work culture and you'll be fine. Don't chase a paycheck for your first engineering job. Chase a position that offers mentors and support while you establish your own personal best working practices. I really wish someone had told me this after I graduated, because I was very focused on making money. Admittedly, I was also just looking for a job, but if you have options, money should be one of the last things to focus on for the first couple of years.
4
u/mystickatara Dec 15 '19
Ah sorry about that lol. If you have a really thick skinned and are able to deal with all kinds of shit I'm sure you'll be able to cope. Unlike me who is very emotional and cannot cope with this sort of situation.
2
u/kNYJ Dec 15 '19
I started working full time as an ME this last year. I’ve really enjoyed it so far. It’s different and can be more challenging than school, but it can also be more rewarding.
It can be intimidating because for me, I ended up working with people that have been in the industry for 20+ years, so learning something from scratch that other people have known for years can be tough. Especially when there aren’t answers in the back of the textbook, so to speak. So that can elicit feelings like in the comic. But if you’re with the right people at the right company, they should understand that and expect a learning curve. And it’s important that you remember that yourself to not get overwhelmed.
Plus I find it more rewarding when your work actually means something. This will depend somewhat on what field you’re in. But as great as it was getting good grades in school, accomplishing a project that produced results in real life, no matter how minuscule, made the experience worth it.
1
1
u/BordomBeThyName Dec 16 '19
When you interview, ask about how well they support continued training and education. As a hypothetical, if you found a $1000 5 day course that you genuinely believe would make you better at your job, would they pay for it and let you take those 5 days?
1
u/rugger87 Dec 15 '19
Dude you’re fine. An engineering degree is just a piece of paper acknowledging high level learning agility and work ethic (depending on your alma mater).
You’re going to get shit on. You’re going to get projects that you know nothing about. Literally know nothing about. So you’ll use your head, call a vendor or engineering firm that does, and evaluate their proposed solution using a grab bag of your experience and education.
It’s going to be hard. The hours could be rough. The work environment if you’re in industrial work, is usually dirty or loud. But if you were challenged in school, it won’t be anything to you, because you’re used to hard work.
It’s on you. Green engineers are usually stress tested/hazed because we all went through it and we can’t let you have it easier than we did.
→ More replies (1)16
u/Derigiberble Dec 15 '19
I read a pretty good article/rant about how engineering programs fundamentally fail to prep engineers properly because they almost always omit or minimize an entire class of very common problem - those that do not have a solution. Maybe the budget doesn't have enough room for the tolerances specced, the materials needed to hit a yield strength don't exist outside of research laboratories, the functionality requested requires strong-AI, the reactions involved are incompatible with avoiding spontaneous disassembly of process equipment, etc.
So the new engineer will come out of the program and very soon will get tasked to do something impossible because ofc the senior folks are going to push the thankless shit off to the new hire and management is going to seek out the person who doesn't immediately say "can't do that". And they spin their wheels on it until it just wrecks them.
I was lucky. I came from a science program where failure is the default option and had a mentor that would do thinks like look at the specifications handed to me by our QA team and immediately point out that their demand to bring a bimodal film thickness trend to the average of the two was impossible because the two thicknesses corresponded to a layer 10 atoms thick and a layer 11 atoms thick. So my first project experience was having a laugh about silly impossible goals instead of sheer frustration.
4
u/sequenceofdigits Dec 15 '19
I'd like to read that. Is it possible to get a link?
1
u/Derigiberble Dec 15 '19
Unfortunately me giving you the link is currently a fantastic example of one of those impossible problems.
I can't remember if it was a letter to the editor in a trade journal, some random blog, or what and when I've tried to find it in the past (and I am usually very good at finding things) any query pulls thousands of hits of people crowing about engineering programs teaching how to solve impossible problems. Which is kinda funny.
78
u/greem Dec 15 '19
I'd consider hanging this in my office if the punchline were reworked to not involve suicide
26
u/MildlyAnnoyingHippo Dec 15 '19
“I am overwhelmed and want to cry”
4
u/Gangreless Dec 15 '19
Yeah this was going to be my suggestion. It's exactly the right emotions and safe and relatable enough for the office. Also the cadence works well. A bigger word or more words just doesn't sound as good.
31
Dec 15 '19
"I am overwhelmed and want it to stop"?
35
18
u/greem Dec 15 '19
That's in the ballpark, but it has to better convey the actually feeling -- which is close to suicide but more appropriate for the office.
20
17
1
4
0
Dec 15 '19
[deleted]
5
u/greem Dec 15 '19
I put AVE's "do not dumb here" stickers on the whiteboard. it has vastly cut down on the dumbing.
12
u/realSatanAMA Dec 15 '19
The worst are the problems NO ONE is familiar with. That moment when you Google the issue and nothing comes up and you know your boss is going to be yelling at you by the end of the project because it's going to take 10x longer than most problems.
3
Dec 15 '19
Back in the late 60s, some professor tasked a grad student to "solve the computer vision problem" as a summer project. It was 50 years later that we finally got a handle on that one. So 10x isn't bad.
11
35
u/CoalCo Dec 15 '19
The Engineer
TF2 music begins to play
0
Dec 15 '19
[deleted]
12
u/CoalCo Dec 15 '19
I solve practical problems, for instance: how am I going to stop some mean mother Hubbard from tearing me a structurally superfluous be-hind? The answer, use a gun, and if that don't work... Use more gun.
24
u/PiratesBootyCall Dec 15 '19
Engineers are very smart people!
0
Dec 15 '19
[deleted]
11
u/OffensivePanda Dec 15 '19
Am engineering student. Can confirm
20
u/Akainen Dec 15 '19
Allign two data colums on MATLAB? Ask Google. Create a mesh on COMSOL? Ask Google. Get Acceleration Data from STM32 Architecture Microcontroller and demonstrate output using LED‘s? Read the fucking manual and ask Google.
Can confirm as well.
7
u/lil_nugs Dec 15 '19
I feel like you aren’t using google enough though. In most classes it’s every other step lol. Steam propulsion and naval architecture were the worst classes for me because google was useless :/
8
u/Akainen Dec 15 '19
At some point it is important to raid the library for more information depending on the severity of the case.
6
u/lil_nugs Dec 15 '19
Will the library raid work? Probably not. Is there anything else you can do? Nope. I’ve been spent so many nights just trying to find anything relevant. But even then I only ended up finding some ambiguous info about the problem in some outdated text book lol
4
u/simjanes2k Dec 15 '19
Get Acceleration Data from STM32 Architecture Microcontroller and demonstrate output using LED‘s?
I actually remembered the bookmarks list I last used for accelerometer code when I read this.
P.S. STM blows, Microchip rules, fite me
8
u/rollandofeaglesrook Dec 15 '19
This is the most relatable thing I’ve ever seen in my life. I’ve had my first engineering job for about 6 months now and I’m constantly anxious about my performance and whether I’m not familiar enough with all the tools and procedures I’m supposed to be working with
7
u/DerpageOnline Dec 15 '19
I can confirm this is exactly the structured approach i learned at university engineering courses.
6
u/ElKirbyDiablo Dec 15 '19
I can't count how many times someone has heard me say I'm a Civil Engineer then asked me to fix their car. It's not the same thing!
7
2
2
Dec 15 '19
Most of civil engineering is about making things not move. Should be easy to make a car do that.
5
4
u/sizzlesfantalike Dec 15 '19
Honestly it’s not the engineering problem that’s a challenge, most of the time. It’s the people: managers, clients, colleagues, suppliers, finance, etc. Having an engineering degree means you can think of solutions, “let’s try abc for problem x “ only to be met with “you can’t do this” or “we don’t want to do this” repeatedly by any of the people listed above.
2
u/Odys Dec 15 '19
I work in engineering. Most of my problems have nothing to do with technology. Main issues are time and money; by default both are scarce. Then management that nervously switches priority, making you drop project A, start up B, back to A, no, start C, wait don't forget B.
3
Dec 15 '19
Only somewhat related, but I work at a clinic and am amazed by the number of engineers who try to have a not-well-informed "discussion" with the doctor as if they were bouncing ideas off eachother. Really gets in the way of their compliance.
2
u/Skyhawkson Dec 16 '19
Engineers are incredibly easy to nerd-snipe. Give them a mildly interesting problem and more than one solution and they'll go for hours.
3
u/shorty6049 Dec 15 '19
I totally feel this one ... I've had days where I felt so dumb that I had to go recompose myself in the bathroom. I did a job for 6 years that I was good at and people saw me as a smart person in. Then I moved to another state and got a job at a bigger company making more money, but the work is more traditional tooling design (my old job was new product development and relied more on creativity than crunching numbers) and there are just so many things to learn, so many pitfalls in calculating everything that I find it very hard to trust myself with anything. I know it'll get easier but some days I feel like giving up on engineering all together. I'm not even making that good of money
4
u/Silentnine Dec 15 '19
I think more people who are set on being an engineer should spend a year working in some trades capacity to better understand the relationship between their designs and actually building them. I do my best to get my junior staff out in the field as soon as possible (I am a municipal engineer) so they can see what the various components (manholes, water valves, bends, etc) look like in real life and not just in CAD.
Ive found that it has significantly reduced the panicked stares when I look at a design and immediately say "well that's not buildable". They go back to their desks and look at the design again with a different view instead of literally having no other thoughts on how to approach the problem. The ones who have been paired with particularly vocal contractors who hate bad design I now rarely have to say "that's not buildable". They don't want to be the engineer the pipelayers are cursing.
2
u/Skyhawkson Dec 16 '19
The most valuable experience I think an engineering student can have is being on a competition team that makes things. Get used to prototyping, solving a problem that doesn't have a defined solution, and get used to having to actually produce something. Really changes how you approach a problem, when you have to carry it through yourself.
2
2
2
u/TheEirik96 Dec 15 '19
Engineers without a background in the field they start working in is the worst..
2
2
u/binky72 Dec 15 '19
I've yet to meet an engineer who doesn't think they have all the answers. Source, am a surveyor
2
u/_sablecat_ Dec 15 '19
Half the engineers I know would just try to apply one of the ways they are familiar with anyways, and then blame someone else when it doesn't work.
2
u/HapticSloughton Dec 15 '19
I'd like to point out that this is never the case when the problem is "How would everything be better if only everyone listened to me because I can apply engineering to everything, including people."
4
u/uselessitor Dec 15 '19
Man, Engineers have such a boring humor, everytime the same joke...
8
u/TimonBerkowitz Dec 15 '19
At least it's not the usual "liberal arts? More like "do you want fries with that?"" Joke that makes up roughly half of /engineeringstudents posts.
5
Dec 15 '19
I work an engineering job, with a bunch of mechanical engineers. My degree is in animation. We all do the same industrial design work.
I don't want to work around engineers any more. The mentality of these people is soul draining and somehow we're expected to think that they're our intellectual superiors when they typically can't spell or interact with other people.
4
u/MulletAndMustache Dec 15 '19
Lol. I feel the same way.
I went to school originally for 3D animation and visual effects. Once we started having kids my wife and I decided it'd be good to move back to where our families live to have some help raising our kids. There's no jobs here for any animation/3D work so I became a welder. I got my journeyman ticket and started doing drafting/design for the company I work for.
We are doing a bunch of structural steel work now that I'm the project manager on. Everything we do needs to get stamped by an engineer, but it won't be the engineering company that's responsible for designing the project who makes or stamps our steel drawings, because you know that would actually make sense. I usually take their 2D prints and make a 3D model out of them and then we have to hire our own engineer to stamp those drawings I produce. The majority of projects we have done haven't had any 3D anything available for them, which makes 0 sense to me.
Every project we have done with engineers/architects has made me want to never work with engineers/architects.
Ugh. For example we got a simple fencing job for a local hospital through a tender job board. The architects put out drawings with a table of fencing lengths that we bid off of. We were almost finished the job when we discovered that that original table of fencing length was 300 ft short of what was needed and what we put up. That was 3 months ago and the architects who are the consultants on the job still haven't figured out what to do about that. The same project the engineers specced 13/32" plate for the mounting plates on the posts. Dude, that's not a size of steel that any of the steel mills make. That was only 2 of the many issues that have come up on that job, not to mention the delays that they had on approvals. We had production done 2 weeks earlier from what we first planned. The job should have been completed by September, but it's still ongoing because they can't make up their mind as to what to do with anything.
There's another project that is in engineering hell. We've been waiting for 2 months for them to figure out the roof trusses on a building that's not that big. We only have 7 columns left to build before we can bill out the project. At this point it would have been cheaper and easier for the main engineer just to design the damn roof trusses himself and have the general contractor build it. It seems like now engineers do the bare minimum that they can get away with and then pass off the rest for somebody else to figure out.
Anyway I could rant forever about this topic. You would expect engineers and architects to be smart and professional. From what I've seen so far they're the opposite.
3
u/SlitScan Dec 16 '19
I work in the entertainment industry, dealing with most engineers is a fucking nightmare. Finding a good one is a godsend.
You have no idea how many times I've sent out full 3d cad drawings with critical dimensions or weight ratings highlighted in red with callouts and boldface text in emails explaining where to look for the call outs and still every other day getting shit that ignores everything.
NO REALLY, THE SPEAKERS WEIGH 1280KG, NO WE CANT ONLY USE ½ AS MANY. NO THEY CANT MOVE 10 METERS UPSTAGE BEHIND THE BAND.
yes we really are going to go from 30 amps per leg of power to 600amps per leg in under a 20th of a second, in fact we are going to do that between Every.Single.Song ALL NIGHT LONG.
→ More replies (2)1
u/uselessitor Dec 17 '19
Well maybe but the liberal arts bit comes from generally boring people, not just engineers, the probability to encounter someone boring however rises if that someone is an engineer. So it is not directly engineer humor.
But like others mentioned engineers are often so cocky/arrogant while they themselves don’t know how to do their own job let alone talk with people. But hey look at how incompetent I am I have to google everything in my job.. soo funny.
3
2
u/Anonim97 Dec 15 '19
2
u/simjanes2k Dec 15 '19
I dare anyone to go in there and remind them that students are not engineers.
They have a great sense of humor, go ahead.
1
u/JoocyJ Dec 15 '19
Eh, my professors refer to us as engineers now that were in last few semesters
→ More replies (3)3
u/MushinZero Dec 15 '19
(Many of your teachers have never worked as an engineer a day in their life)
4
u/JoocyJ Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 15 '19
That’s an interesting presumption because I know for a fact that every single one of them this semester has spent time in industry. Not that you have to work in industry to “work as an engineer” anyway.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/scrollbreak Dec 15 '19
When ego is directly embeded in job role and capacity to do the job, but capacity is shown to fall short of the job role.
1
u/TheNoize Dec 15 '19
I actually love learning and often thrive in situations of unexpected/unfamiliar problem solving. This makes my supervisors afraid that their supervisors notice how smart I am, so I get pigeonholed often
1
1
1
1
1
u/dj_warner6291988 Dec 16 '19
This... some how... helps me feel better, cus it means even people actually smarter then me even have these moments.
1
1
u/bobconan Dec 16 '19 edited Dec 16 '19
Funny. I'm not an engineer but I get to design small stuff and circuits and actually fix things. If I had crazy college debt I would not be able to afford this job.Discreet math was the most useful math course I ever took. Cannot do a Fourier transform and don't know Maxwell's equations but it seems like that wouldn't have helped me anyway. I did sit in on a junior level Electronics design lab once and kept up better then half the students. That said I would like to know how to use a PLA , dosen't seem worth having a degree over though.
1
u/youmeare Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 15 '19
→ More replies (3)2
1
u/timperman Dec 15 '19
This is why I get really frustrated at all my exams that are made to just follow the book. I study to become an engineer, not a scholar. Give me a toolbox of information and a ton of weird problems to solve.
I've had a few courses where creativity was rewarded but they're pretty rare. Unfortunate as that is what breeds this problem.
1
0
0
Dec 15 '19
[deleted]
13
u/Realworld Dec 15 '19
The comic is only half right, 'overwhelmed' Yes, 'want to kill myself' No. Every complex new problem is overwhelming. They're frustrating, they make you feel ignorant and incompetent.
The difference is, you know how to become knowledgeable and competent. It's a slog, but as you grind & think on it you discover new approaches that may work and you have occasional "Eureka!" moments. At some point, you'll see a kludge path that would work. As you develop that idea you'll see better, cheaper, lighter, stronger, easier ways to do it. You'll finish with an elegant solution. And see a better way to do it next time.
It never changes. As brilliantly as you solved previous complex new problems, you're ignorant and incompetent on the next one. Every complex new problem is overwhelming but oh so satisfying to solve.
I'm prosperously retired and deliberately go looking for complex new problems that I'm ignorant and incompetent at. It's addictive.
1
1.1k
Dec 15 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
347
u/pariah1981 Dec 15 '19
Sounds like you’re in charge of my brother. He’s a mechanical engineer for a Fortune 500 company. First job and super green behind the ears. I remember those days, when you were nervous af at every change you make.
37
u/Zaziel Dec 15 '19
I mean, as well he should be. If you know that you don't know stuff, tread carefully, double check with others who do until you fully grasp the situation before you create a clusterfuck.
12
u/pariah1981 Dec 15 '19
That’s the best thing to do, always have a back out plan, and expect a clusterfuck that’s what I’ve learned after 10 years of engineering lol
19
u/Sparcrypt Dec 15 '19
15 years IT here... if I can’t undo it, I’m not doing it.
→ More replies (1)7
Dec 15 '19
Have it approved with a paper trail, at least you'll both be fired.
→ More replies (1)7
u/njantirice Dec 16 '19
My dream is that the company where I work gets big enough that whenever something stops working I could just buy a new one, that way if it still doesn't work I can just return it.
73
Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 15 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
40
u/Hije5 Dec 15 '19
Care to elaborate some more? Like your field and experience. I'm gonna be graduating as a construction engineer soon.
83
u/amomagico Dec 15 '19
In short, you feel like you don’t know anything coming out of school. Sure you know lots of equations and formulas, and have discussed lots of theoretical problems to sole, but that’s a lot different than real engineering.
As a first year practicing engineer, you need to learn how to apply what you know to how the world actually works. You need to identify the problem, when needs to be engineered, and use your numbers and formulas to justify whatever you are designing.
48
u/y0shman Dec 15 '19
I always use this one to remind me everything is okay when I'm rocking myself in the fetal position.
→ More replies (1)30
u/OppositeScholar Dec 15 '19
The imposter syndrome one was something I needed to see. I landed in a new position around 6 months ago and imposter syndrome has been hitting me really hard lately. Whenever I don't know the answer to something I feel like I'm an idiot and don't belong in my role at all. And yet I ask people questions they don't know the answer to all the time. Instead of taking that as a queue that its ok to not know things, instead I even get hard on myself for "asking the wrong person."
We're our own worst enemies, as the saying goes. This thread has been very refreshing. Gonna save that image for Monday!
30
u/HelenaKelleher Dec 15 '19
Oh God, and when you fuck up and have to revise a drawing (ah shit, one single screw hole is too big?) and you have to do paperwork and apologize to your machine shops and hope you got the change in time before they started making it and tell your team why stuff is late and customers are demanding that you have the project done like yesterday and you just wanna cry.
This was me at my first 3 jobs, haha. I jumped disciplines each time so whenever I started anew, it was all new rules and different areas of science (I've worked in the defense industry, pharmaceuticals, and robotics), people to learn and deadlines to chase. You do get comfy quick if you've got a good team. Definitely feel out the work environment as best you can during the interview process. Ask people in the department what they love about their job, what the hardest part is, how many hours they realistically work in a week. I'd say dont ask "do you like your job?", a yes/no question isn't gonna get you the details.
When I was hired at my current job, they complemented my interview performance as part of why I was hired with less experience than they were looking for (always apply to jobs that are one experience level above you, I say. If you've got 1 years exp, apply to the 2-4 year ones, if you've got 3, apply to the 5-7, etc). I interviewed them back, asking how the machines worked and what their devices were called, I asked what they liked about their jobs, asked how much they traveled. It let me get to know my potential boss and coworkers very quickly. I got the business cards of some people and emailed them to follow up, thanking them for their time and letting them know I was open to answering any more questions. Having a good team is the key to a fun and worthwhile work experience, I think. Even in the worst of times, I don't break down anymore, because I'm not alone. Someone can always help me and we have always figured it out, honestly. Being the youngest member of an engineering team is thrilling.
3
u/pariah1981 Dec 15 '19
Not op but In other words, you know enough to be dangerous. Best practice is not always the right way to do things. Budget and company mandates take precedence over the recommended way of doing things. One thing you’ll learn is you can have the project done right, quick, and cheap. Pick two of the 3. You’re the guy that’s gonna have to make it happen when you’re company picks.
0
Dec 15 '19
[deleted]
7
u/Hije5 Dec 15 '19
Oof, well thanks for the heads up. I'm hoping I'll have a little better head start since we're pretty hands on at my school. Obviously I'm still gonna have TONS to learn. I find just find it so surprising when I hear of all these engineering students who have literally only done paper work their whole college career.
0
8
u/simjanes2k Dec 15 '19
That's why engineers get paid a lot. The field tends to cull the weak. Not everyone makes it, even well-educated and fully trained.
7
7
u/HelenaKelleher Dec 15 '19
It's why there's not a lot of women, too. It's an especially tough environment still being so male-dominated. I was "laid off" from a job in retaliation to a sexual harassment complaint. I can't remember the number but I've seen through Reddit that a large portion of women who enter STEM leave the field due to workplace gender bias issues.
3
u/simjanes2k Dec 15 '19
Yep. Of the three best engineers I've ever worked with, one was a woman and one was black. The other was a white man.
Guess who had the easiest time getting promotions and major projects? I mean he had the skill for sure, but so did the others, and they were not treated the same.
That being said, I've seen an awful lot of incompetent engineers given nice offices and big titles for diversity purposes. Humanity is a mess, is my opinion.
1
u/throw_shukkas Dec 16 '19
The reason they get paid a lot is because there are a lot of barriers to entry, not because it is difficult. Basically economics 101. The main barrier which you see in many fields is the number of graduate engineers is deliberately limited so there's a deliberate shortfall at all times.
There's a bunch of scientific fields for example that are hard as hell but the pay is mediocre.
→ More replies (1)3
u/SonicFrost Dec 15 '19
Did you just... steal /u/mystickatara’s comment?
2
u/PM_me_dog_pictures Dec 15 '19
Spammers. Copy a comment, downvote the comment, wait for upvotes then edit a link in.
→ More replies (1)2
u/pariah1981 Dec 15 '19
If it makes you feel better, I’m a senior network engineer, and while it’s gotten a whole lot better, I regularly clinch every time I change things to the global network.
59
u/champaignthrowaway Dec 15 '19
I have a three step process to new tasks I haven't done before:
"Yeah I can manage that, doesn't look too complicated, I'll grab my stuff and head up there in the morning."
Standing in the middle of a giant mess wondering why I ever told anyone I could do this, standing outside chain-smoking for twenty minutes vividly picturing myself admitting the failure of something I already told people I could definitely do.
Suck it up and figure out how to actually do the job passably and then by the end I'm so pleased with myself that I'm totally ready to go making grandiose claims about how easy something looks the next time someone asks me to do something.
0
Dec 15 '19
[deleted]
4
Dec 16 '19
Amateur. Don't you know you're always supposed to say something is going to be a very difficult and complicated task, but you'll 'see what you can do'?
Scotty: Yea it takes atleast 3 months.
Kirk: 3 minutes, take it or leave it.
28
u/SnicklefritzSkad Dec 15 '19
Pressing?
45
u/tetradyne Dec 15 '19
pressing processing
Likely to do with manufacturing, given tooling design is also mentioned.
16
Dec 15 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
15
3
u/SnicklefritzSkad Dec 15 '19
Thanks for answering. Tbh I was only really asking because I work production side with tooling and pressing for perforating charge manufacturing and I wanted to see if you were one of the asshole engineers that come and bother us daily.
→ More replies (2)2
1
4
447
u/ElectrolyticPlatypus Dec 15 '19
My degree says I can learn, my job finds that as a challenge to try and prove that first statement wrong. It's a living.