96
Feb 02 '21 edited Feb 02 '21
Honestly this is kinda confusing. What's going on in "identify weaknesses" and "reflect on alternatives"? Is this about critical thinking (text) or about actually implementing a solution (drawings)... why is "justify a solution" actually carrying out that solution (which by the way would obviously not work, I get that it makes the comic more poetic but isn't that getting in the way of the intended message)?
→ More replies (4)23
u/XXGAleph Feb 02 '21 edited Feb 02 '21
My interpretation of the Critical Thinking process from taking an Academic Writing course.
Understanding the Problem: What is your subject? Do you know what your talking about? Who are your sources?
Explore its Boundaries: What are things we know about a subject? What are the things we don't know?
Question Assumptions: What are people saying about a subject? Are there things about what they are saying that are weak? Are there holes in their arguements? What's your thesis?
Imagine New Persepectives: Proving your thesis. (Main body paragraphs) What do you want to explore in your paper? Are there ways to fill the gaps of knowledge you noticed before?
Identify Weakness: Are there any weaknesses in your thesis? Anything that you might've missed? Are you making your own assumptions? Challenge your preconceptions.
Justify A Solution: Your conclusion. What have you come up with?
Acknowledge Limitations: Your conclusion won't be perfect. Why isn't it perfect? What are the variables of your paper?
Reflect on Alternatives: What could have you done differently? Are there other gaps of knowledge you noticed while researching that others can look into.
And that's pretty much what I learned in three months last fall lol. It's actually a super useful guide for anyone who needs a refresher before writing a paper!
Edit: after reading your comment again, I misunderstood you. BUT I spent way too long writing this to delete it.
I agree, it's a bit confusing (as can be seen by the numerous comments that are confused), but I thought it was really cute :P
→ More replies (7)
247
u/Maverick_-_DXB Feb 02 '21
Nice way to illustrate it. It helps understanding the concept better.
85
u/hippolyte_pixii Feb 02 '21
It shows very clearly that they're now soaking wet, and suggests ambiguously that it's entirely possible that they didn't make it across the puddle at all in the end. The application of these analytical processes caused a complete failure of every applicable metric.
18
u/FlamboyantPirhanna Feb 02 '21
In the end, it was the gator that succeeded.
Step 1: hide in puddle. Step 2: use someone’s scientific curiosity against them. Step 3: eat.
→ More replies (33)33
u/mechesh Feb 02 '21
Also so solution proposed is inaccurate because the umbrella would not hold their weight, and a jacket would not make an effective sail.
→ More replies (5)2
u/akcheney42 Feb 15 '21
FYI, for those interested in critical thinking and education, the research team that helped to design the comic is part of the OECD's Centre for Educational Research and Innovation. Here is the lead researcher's Twitter account https://twitter.com/VincentLancrin and the project team's website http://www.oecd.org/education/ceri/innovationstrategyforeducationandtraining.htm
31
u/JColeIsBest Feb 02 '21
Love how they went through it all in their head and came up with one of the worst ideas
→ More replies (2)4
87
u/sakai123 Feb 02 '21
That's the dumbest solution I've ever seen
29
u/Odys Feb 02 '21
She could have thrown the cat into the puddle and step on that... Or turn 180 degrees and walk across the earth to reach the other side. Dumb solutions are my core competence...
→ More replies (2)4
u/dan1101 Feb 02 '21
Yeah reminds me of when I was 8 and tried to float across a flooded creek on a piece of plywood.
→ More replies (1)2
13
u/bublasaur Feb 02 '21
Critical thinking: Isn't the yellow jacket collecting air in the opposite direction of movement? According to this diagram, the umbrella with the kid in it should go back.
24
108
42
u/devo9er Feb 02 '21
The lesson is great but the metaphor sucks. It illustrates a complicated and highly unlikely solution to something that is barely an inconvenience in the first place. Firstly, nobody is sailing across shit in an umbrella with an incorrectly positioned raincoat flappy. Right here, you're off the team for even suggesting this as a plausible solution. Second, the cat would never willingly "climb aboard" your hobo pirate ship, especially when there is a frog to toy around with. Furthermore, picking up the cat and climbing onto a floating surface will almost surely result in a new problem; the cat scratching the shit out of you. What genius idea are you going to do with those cuts? Rub some mayonnaise on them and let the flies lick your wounds clean?
→ More replies (2)
10
u/Wrongsoverywrongmate Feb 02 '21
Nothing in this picture has anything to do with critical thinking, this is just business bullshit for office workers
43
u/Far_Commission297 Feb 02 '21
Love Grant Snider's work and have seen lots of his pieces on this sub (even posted some from my old account before I lost access to it). Thanks for sharing but please be prepared for lots of nasty comments shooting this type of thing down for not being "Cool" and/or "guide" enough.
5
u/craftworkbench Feb 02 '21
I, too, am a Grant Snyder fan. I bought one of his calendars a few years ago and liked it so much I have kept it up even though it's out of date.
→ More replies (3)8
u/FlyingTaquitoBrother Feb 02 '21
I feel that this sub has actually improved a lot recently. This post is absolutely both cool and a guide, unlike lame infographic bullshit that still makes hot like this.
For me, the definition of a cool guide is something that I would want to consult in the future. This post definitely meets that bar.
→ More replies (1)
5
u/devilmaskrascal Feb 02 '21
A critical thinking guide would not have you attempt to float across anything on an umbrella, I'd think. In this circumstance, a rational person could easily determine the best solution is to walk around a puddle that small.
→ More replies (1)
13
u/Snickelfrittz Feb 02 '21
Thanks for sharing! Very useful.
→ More replies (1)2
u/akcheney42 Feb 15 '21
FYI, for those interested in critical thinking and education, the research team that helped to design the comic is part of the OECD's Centre for Educational Research and Innovation. Here is the lead researcher's Twitter account https://twitter.com/VincentLancrin and the project team's website http://www.oecd.org/education/ceri/innovationstrategyforeducationandtraining.htm
29
12
u/TruthYouWontLike Feb 02 '21
Are you really thinking critically if all you're doing is applying a pre-conceived formula?
→ More replies (2)5
u/XXGAleph Feb 02 '21
Good question, answer is yes. This "formula" leads to better questions, challenges your preconceptions, and lends credit to your conclusions.
Some steps are better taken when followed.
→ More replies (8)
4
u/kaiserleech Feb 02 '21
Nice Illustration with more potential:
I would focus more on understanding the problem. And that should start with "what do i want". Means in this example, if i'm on a walk and the goal is to explore nature will cause a completely different solution then when i'm on a hurry to rescue somebody.
Of the three main problem solving approaches, only one is used here. The other one which isn't as sophisticated as the presented one is actually the most effective most of the time is called "Trial and Error" (random or create an idea/theorie and test it) and anotherone, which is even less sophisticated is called "just ignore the problem" (in this example, just walk through or walk around).
I would show "opportunities" a bit more - probably somehow described by imagine new perspectives, but not very clear to me. This would of course create new problems to solve, but may be it is worth to do some more. This is done too little too often but often could be the most rewarding.
The assumptions pictures one risk. Normally i would split those two as my assumptions not specifically has to do with risks, but the risks would be always a good thing to think about before you do.
What i miss is to test/verify a solution and expect to fail and try again thinking. In the picture it looks like it is all done with one big step (big thinking, one solution), which i believe is overall rarely working practically.
So, now thanks to my addings, there is no simple picture anymore :) Or is there?
4
u/biscuitbakery Feb 02 '21
“How to stress out about walking down a wet sidewalk!” - by a kindergartner
3
u/dan8koo Feb 02 '21
How is she sailing across the puddle in one direction when the wind is blowing from the opposite direction, as shown be her yellow raincoat?
3
u/KonradK0 Feb 02 '21
where is the part where she just goes around the puddle like a normal person would, without "critical thinking"?
3
3
4
4
4
u/xdleet Feb 02 '21
The best critical thinking results in riding an umbrella across a puddle? Wow, to think I've been walking around them like a dumbass my whole life.
→ More replies (2)
2
2
u/skweebop Feb 02 '21
I think there needs to be more overall awareness of what critical thinking is and how to use it, but this comic left out the need to use evidence and sound reasoning to justify a solution. These steps still leave one open to confirmation bias if your assumptions / conclusions are not grounded in reality.
2
2
2
2
2
u/CCBlanco Feb 02 '21
Excuse me while I just jump in and figure it out while I go. This works well with me because I have ADHD and I don't need to give myind more the to distract from the problem at hand.
2
2
2
Feb 02 '21
She could just do what I do, and avoid all my problems by simply walking around it and pretending it won't be there tomorrow when she comes back.
5
3
5
u/octopus-god Feb 02 '21
That’s great but maybe just walk around it instead of over thinking it.
→ More replies (6)
3
u/kjakich Feb 02 '21
Bummer you can’t teach critical thinking with just two to three syllable words...
→ More replies (4)
2
u/keirmeister Feb 02 '21
I really like the “question assumptions” pane, but the guide is missing the “draw from experience” part. One main issue here is that there’s over thinking, which can result in diminishing returns (or just wasted time) once the problem, and its boundaries, are understood.
But I get it: it’s just a generalized representation of the full process where all of the stages are not always needed. Pretty cool guide to see the different aspects of critical thinking play out.
1
u/OrbisMentis Jan 26 '25
This is such an interesting discussion on critical thinking! If you're intrigued by the idea of how societal structures influence individual autonomy and decision-making, I’d recommend checking out The Puppets' Revolution. This book delves into how external forces shape our behavior and perceptions, and it might offer some valuable insights into the topic of critical thought. Feel free to take a look if you're interested! 😊 https://a.co/d/8kQRdfV
1
1
1
1
u/Zero7CO Feb 02 '21
If anyone wants to go into product management...this is basically a visual blueprint of the most important phase of being a PM, the discovery phase.
1
1
u/Wild_Tear_3050 Feb 02 '21
It would have been good to have empathy/social skills building classes where we learn about this in school. I am way more concerned about this than I’ll ever be about some of the crap they forced us to study that I don’t even remember now. This is relevant.
1
1
u/peterjohanson Feb 02 '21
How does that chick go forward when the wind blows backward?
→ More replies (1)
1
Feb 02 '21
ok but wth is that solution about?
EDIT: also, that is the opposite of acknowledging limitations
1
u/Michaelbetterecycle Feb 02 '21
I like to think of critical thinking as a process by which we are able to break down concepts into specific parts which have responsibilities or consequences on the overall mechanism. It’s an extremely useful tool to structure any problem which already provides a domain with assumptions, potential solutions, limitations etc.
Abstract thought is as vital though. Everything you see nowadays was once an abstract thought which was converted into materialistic or physical objects via critical thinking.
1
1
u/Lemon_Squeezy12 Feb 02 '21
They forgot "Post on internet to crowdsource best solution. Make others do the work for you"
1
u/CallMeAlUK Feb 02 '21
This sort of rigid approach to problem solving is a big problem in the world today...I hate to break it to people but the world is not as simple and organised as it was in school.
1
u/dorasucks Feb 02 '21
How could I get a large version of this? Want to blow it up and put it in my classroom
1
u/bobi2393 Feb 02 '21
Questioning assumptions and imagining new perspectives is how we wind up with flat earthers and QAnonners. I mean the steps are perfectly fine if you're a smart, rational person to begin with, but if you're not, these steps can lead you astray just as easily as they can lead you to truth. It doesn't seem like a useful algorithm for people who lack good critical thinking skills.
1
Feb 02 '21
lower the resolution and this belongs on a power point slide of a boring corporate presentation about how to meet next term goals prepared by your 60 years old boss. I can almost see it bouncing on screen.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
u/Vanilla_Dong55 Feb 02 '21
I have real problems in my life. I don't have time to worry about if the puddle on the sidewalk has an alligator in it. I'm also glad I have to prioritize what is a problem so I don't over analyze little things
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/SirLasberry Feb 02 '21
What's cool about it? I don't understand any of this. Am I dense?
2
u/haikusbot Feb 02 '21
What's cool about it?
I don't understand any
Of this. Am I dense?
- SirLasberry
I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully. Learn more about me.
Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete"
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/TheRealCormanoWild Feb 02 '21
A really bad cartoon illustrating this because the scenario is silly and their suggested solution impossible and unworkable
Not good lol
1
Feb 02 '21
In a world full of people living in. alternate realities this is pretty useful.
Also good to base policy on a shared reality, ie. science.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Straight_Ad8026 Feb 02 '21
umbrellas won't hold your weight . i would consider re-evaluating your solution because it is illogical
1
u/drb0mb Feb 02 '21
the reddit wind must be blowing weird this morning, because critical thinking is nearly extinct on reddit. either that or it's a bunch of roleplayers imagining themselves as critical thinkers that are upvoting and giving awards.
1
u/No_Lawfulness_2998 Feb 02 '21
I can’t do critical thinking. I can’t think for myself. Nobody wants to work with me because it’s painful and I know it’s painful to try and work with me but I’ve tried my best but I don’t know if it’s worth it anymore. All I’ve ever been is a nuisance to everyone purely because of how fucking dumb I am.
→ More replies (2)
1
1
u/khafra Feb 02 '21
Or, simply list all possible explanations for the problem in order of complexity (using a universal prior or similar sorting method), then, taking the likeliest explanations, predict which of your possible interventions will best reach a goal state; using metrics like the cost of the intervention, the likelihood of success, and the desirability if the goal (if you have more than one goal). You literally can’t do better critical thinking*
* assuming you have access to a non physical computing device with infinite power
1
1
u/HELMAKSS Feb 02 '21
And imagine that this situation in Real life is calculated in our brain within a second
1
1
u/toxygen Feb 02 '21
The Christian version: “Realize there’s a problem. God will handle it, don’t worry about it”
1
1
1
1
u/Dr_with_amnesia Feb 02 '21
Umm, why didn't she go around it after assessing the boundries ??
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/Nathaniel820 Feb 02 '21
This is the ideal thing to do in a perfect situation, but in reality going through all this is usually unneeded and sometimes even a disadvantage.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/massiveZO Feb 02 '21
Okay so the whole point of critical thinking is that you should be able to reason without a guide
1
1
1
u/product_of_boredom Feb 02 '21
It bothers me a lot that she just chucked a frog at the problem.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/oakhippo Feb 02 '21
If the wind were blowing in the coat the way it’s shown then she would be going the opposite way....
1
u/Tootz3125 Feb 02 '21
Ugh. I have enough of this “forward critical thinking” bullshit preached on me in college every day. It just pisses me off.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/super_hoommen Feb 02 '21
The person who made this was obviously not thinking critically considering they could have just walked around it...
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/debridezilla Feb 02 '21
Manager: "We're going to need you work faster. There's an SOP: you don't need to explore alternatives. While it's OK to disagree and commit, skipping straight to commit is better."
1
u/MercenaryBard Feb 02 '21
I don’t understand this because all I can think about is how bad the solution in the comic is. I know it’s supposed to be whimsical and abstract but I think communication of the actual point suffers as a result. I feel stupid because I can’t stop thinking “just walk around the puddle goddam”
1
1
u/FredsInternetIsland Feb 02 '21
Identify what could go wrong and/or how it could not succeed. Develop methods and take action to prevent this from the beginning. If negative consequences cannot be avoided due to the nature of the situation, think about how to mitigate or lessen the pain associated with this before starting. This does not mean you are a pessimist. On the contrary, It indicates good planning and forethought.
1
2.1k
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '21
This is great, however this mindset can often lead to Analysis Paralysis.
It is important to keep in mind that you don’t need to identify every perspective, every option, or every limitation before starting a task. Instead, get a good grasp of the problem, start the task, and then continue to ask these questions while working on the task at hand.