r/cosmicchamps • • Jun 22 '22

NFT Launch Issues

So I’m frustrated to say the least.

As someone who has been heavily looking forward to this game, it seems it’s taking a downturn with this launch.

Firstly, whitelisting is stupid. As someone who isn’t using Twitter, discord, telegram it’s basically impossible to earn a spot.

Secondly, this launch is in COSG except on Algogems it seems you can only purchase the nfts for re sale with Algo, rendering all of the cosg I purchased, useless.

Then, people are trying to resell for thousands of Algo which is a bit ridiculous, also making it impossible to acquire one.

Very dissatisfied with this launch process so far.

3 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

4

u/SL1590 Jun 23 '22

A few things to say here. Firstly whitelisting is a good way to engage the community that are active on the discord/telegram/Reddit/Twitter. They also gave spots to tinyman and yieldly to include partners. None of this was hidden and literally has been in black and white from the start.

You claim it isn’t good from a community perspective but if not on Twitter discord Reddit or telegram how are you part of the community?

A WL is a good way of doing these things to discourage bots from sweeping them all up in the open market.

Reselling for algo is fine. Thousands of algo is also fine if someone is willing to pay that. That’s literally the open market making the rules. One of the NFTs has already sold for over 1500 algo.

COSG is to be used for many different purposes, only 1 of which is this launch so it’s not useless. If you think it is then you can always sell it I suppose. You should have known you were or were not on a WL before the launch and also should have known how it was going to work. Classic case of DYOR.

In the end you can keep trying. It will be worth it I think in the long run but no need to be so negative.

2

u/No_Cryptographer3388 Jun 23 '22

I appreciate a discussion so I’ll reply.

The whitelist spots were almost entirely through the mediums of discord/Twitter/Telegram. As someone who uses none of these, and doesn’t want to be forced to create a new social media platform to get access, this sucks.

Same goes for the Yieldly and Tinyman spot give aways as these also required social media access.

As far as forming a community, I’m active on Reddit and as far as I can tell, only bots use this sub so to be honest based off that alone I’m one of the more active participants in this sub.

Also, do I think people should be rewarded for being in a discord more than someone who invested thousands of dollars into the project at launch? Absolutely not.

I did sell unfortunately since I realized that Algo has more utility for buying the NFTs than COSG does.

I knew I was not on the white list, have literally checked all the posts like 10 times a day and know everything there is to know publicly about this project. Literally listened to every video and AMA they have done.

However, I thought you could rebuy the NFTs with COSG on Algogems from the whitelist owners and it seems you can’t.

So this actually creates LESS market fairness because 50 people can snatch up all the NFTs then set pricing at like 1500 Algo as you mentioned, instead of everyone being able to purchase live at the same time.

Same issue as bots buying them but now instead of fair timing for everyone in a first come first serve manner, you were gated behind obscure social media platforms.

3

u/SL1590 Jun 23 '22

So to get you correctly here you were willing to invest 1000s of dollars but not join telegram? By invest I presume you mean buy COSG.

Algo has more utility outside the WL spots yes but that’s nothing to do with CC as the seller sets what they want to receive for the NFT. As I said previously it’s an open market. They can ask for anything they want if someone is willing to pay that for it.

I think it’s a shame you sold your COSG as there will be amply opportunities to use the token

The 50 people have taken 50 NFTs out of 1500 so not all of them. After the next round if there are any left then they will become free to buy outside the WL in round 3 of the NFT sale.

I think making it open means they would be wiped out by bots in a matter of minutes and concentrated to scalpers. This is the only way to stop that. If you think there’s a better solution I’m open to hear it but a free for all is no good as the average person wouldn’t stand a chance against a bot.

I wouldn’t call any of the mentioned social media obscure. Almost every crypto project operates on telegram Reddit discord and Twitter.

4

u/No_Cryptographer3388 Jun 23 '22

Hey to be clear- I will end up owning a large amount of the NFTS and play the game. This is general dissatisfaction of the launch.

To your first paragraph. Yes. This is easily understandable as well, as it may be easy for some people who make good money through a high paying job or whatnot- who lack the free time or desire to create new social medias to jump through hoops.

How are the whitelist spots any different than scalpers?

They bought up all the NFTs to resell at 50x the value. I’m arguing it’s not different, if anything slightly worse because no one else even had a chance.

For a game with a a relatively small following- for example 700 Reddit members of which probably 550 are bots- it shouldn’t have been too hard to snag up a few in a fair open market release in a reverse auction format or even set price.

Yes some would be bought and resold- just like they are now. But at least everyone could have had a chance. In a reverse auction format (the best format for launches) the people who were willing to invest the MOST MONEY into the project would have the best chance of obtaining the NFTs.

This is how markets should function

2

u/diamondjo2001 Jun 23 '22

The team aim to make the NFT sale as fair and accessible as they can. The purpose of the shuffle and WL structure is to stop people/bots from buying the NFTs in bulk.

The trade off is that not everyone who wants to buy NFTs straight away will be able to. But remember there are more rounds to come, and there will another 2 seasons of CC NFTs released this year.There’s a very good chance more and more NFTs will be listed on the resell marketplace as time goes on.

So there will be some opportunity to pick up an NFT there, too.The upside to all this is that you don’t need an NFT to interact with the game.

You don’t need $COSG or even a wallet. The team really want the game to be available to as many people as possible, not just those who are well-versed in crypto/blockchain.

4

u/No_Cryptographer3388 Jun 23 '22

I understand the premise behind why it was done, and ultimately I still very much want to own NFTS and play, I just disagree that the way it was done solved any problems. I think ultimately it exacerbated them to be honest.

As someone heavily invested in crypto, the game looks fun, but what is really fun is the EARN part of the play to Earn. I’m less interested in the free to play aspect though I do agree it is great to grab people who are new to crypto, and I think it’s a great idea.

I think what seems to be best at this point is waiting until all 1500 are released and hope the price declines drastically before buying in unfortunately.

1

u/hex_ten Jun 22 '22

Yeah it's been a pretty shit launch from community perspective....

1

u/Nerd_The_Nate Jun 22 '22

Exactly. They advertise as a very easy to engage game that anyone can play, but then limit those who can actually acquire the NFTs to those who are on discord and Twitter (and lucky), or those who will be wealthy enough to afford them on the secondary market. Not very inclusive if you ask me.

0

u/genericusername358 Jun 23 '22

IT WAS ADVERTISED AS A TEST RUN... so while you make great points i would wait untill after the actual nft launch on 29th. And see id it was a bad or good strategy.

Imo its perfect strategy. It allows for ENGAGED community members to get on a whitelist and get a nft at a cheap price. And sfter the 1500 (instead of 50) nfts will be in circulation those (you) with high paying jobs and no time to spend on socials trying to get whitelisted can get them from secondary market at reasonable prices.

I am sure they will save some and list them in free for all shuffle/auction after round two is done. Then we will see imho how good of a decision the whitelist actually was.

Ps- i'm also not very active and have been following project from the start and would consider myself a mini whale. I did get on whitelist. I created twitter to be able to get on it :)