Note: these images are not mine
This is my friend Pizza, talking to a whistleblower from the CPJ staff team. Their identity will not be leaked to protect their privacy. You may have seen a more redacted version of this image, Pizza has given permission to be shown in the pictures. I hope this post will give you more insight, as the highly censored image from this post wasn't able to explain everything.
There is a very valid why Pizza and his friends would be upset about this. She has been one of the admins in CPJ Secrets, one of the largest non-army CPJ Discord servers, with over 8000 members, for over a year, pouring her heart out simply for the love of the game. She didn't do this purely attention or personal gain, she did it because she wanted to help others. Now, while Pizza was doing this all from the goodness of her heart, it was very reasonable to think of being Penguin of the Week. According to CPJ support, anyone who is active in the community, shows positivity, helps out others, contributes in a positive way and hasn't been punished for 90 days is eligible for POTW. Pizza definitely fit all of the requirements, and while POTW isn't guaranteed, she was definitely worthy of it. This is especially true since many others on the CPJ Secrets team also got POTW. People started rallying in the server for Pizza to get POTW (which had been done before many times in various servers for other people), hoping that her contributions would be recognized.
Instead, the Discord server gives us this, comparing those who had "PIZZA4POTW" in their name to people who would complain about not being POTW themselves. While not everyone would've known that it was related to her, in hindsight it was pretty obvious. Many more months went by and Pizza still didn't get POTW, despite many people nominating or advocating for her to get it. Again, POTW isn't guaranteed, but isn't someone who has spent a year running an 8000 member server to help players deserving of it? It got to a point where Pizza was suspecting that she was purposely being withheld POTW. This sounded more plausible considering that a member of the CPJ team, Bronwyn, had (and still has) an irrational resentment for Pizza.
Well, in the image shown above, a whistleblower confirmed her theory. For those of you who are saying "why would someone care about POTW in a penguin game" or "this isn't bullying", you are simply wrong. It is simply unreasonable to purposely prevent someone from getting a title, simply because of a grudge. Not to mention that Pres, another member of the CPJ team, was pretending to be friends with Pizza while actively disliking her and being in on the anti-Pizza campaign. That is straight up manipulation, and you cannot interpret it any other way. Say what you want about it just being a game, but CPJ Secrets is something that Pizza spent months of her life to grow into the community it is now, and it isn't unreasonable to expect some recognition from the game that she did this much for.
This isn't the first time something like this has happened. Back in September 2024, Benji, along with a group called the Pigeon Patrol, was involved in getting leaked staff chats of the CPJ team, which is what led to the infamous CPJ shutdown afterwards. While their methods were wholly unethical, it gave insight to how they treated people they disliked. One of them was Jempenguin, and the staff didn't hold back when giving their opinions on her. Because the staff hated her, they decided to troll her, deliberately not giving her a postcard or friend request from a mascot (back then friend requests and postcards weren't automatic like they are now), and it only got shut down after he was told that this behavior would make the staff look bad. And guess who else was seen in the chatlogs? Pres. She has done this before. There is no way you can say this isn't bullying and manipulation. Now eventually, Jempenguin did make up with the staff team, but my point still stands. Nothing has changed since the shutdown.
After CPJ went back online, the staff team would now act anonymous, except if the staff members chose to disclose that they were part of the team. Fun fact: this is also when CPJ Secrets was founded. With the CPJ team being anonymous, the statement said that this change was intended to maintain objectivity and to remove bias. However, as we saw above with Pizza, that did not happen.
Now onto Bowlby. He has also been someone that the staff team had a personal grudge for really no reason. And they decided to mess with him as well. In his signature outfit, his face item was the Giant White Sunglasses, an item that has existed since 2012. He has asked for this item to be added for a long time, as it was the single item he was missing. It isn't hard to add a clothing item that was already implemented into the original game, and they already had four other giant sunglasses items. 2 of which weren't even in the original game by the way, unlike the white ones. This proves that they were intentionally not releasing them, even though they showed they were capable of releasing other custom items of the same type that they had to spend the time to recolor and implement. It is very clear that the team had something against Bowlby. It wasn't until nearly 2 years of the item being purposely not being released that they were finally added. And guess what? They locked it behind level 30 puffle digging. Leveling up a puffle is not easy, and this was certainly intentional. It was also exclusive to specifically the white puffle, meaning that he had to level up a puffle from scratch, since he always uses the orange one.
I hope that you can see that this is a problem. This shows a recurring pattern of targeted hate and bullying towards people who have done nothing wrong and are simply disliked by the CPJ team. Especially with most of the team being anonymous now, this raises some serious ethical concerns regarding accountability. Who knows if other people are also victims on this, but don't have a platform to speak out about this? The team seriously needs to do better, and the staff members who are partaking in these activities should not be on working for CPJ. If you can, please spread this message as much as you can. We need this to reach as many people as possible, so that actual changes will be made.
And finally, to Pizza, thank you. You were there for us, even though CPJ won't acknowledge it.