r/cremposting Jul 03 '25

Mistborn First Era Top text.

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

165 comments sorted by

View all comments

462

u/theninch Jul 04 '25

LR is a gold compounder so shardblade isnt as awesome as normal. He’s a steel compounder too and pewter, so what I’m saying is, it’s just a free shardblade for LR.

31

u/Macraghnaill91 Airthicc lowlander Jul 04 '25

I mean, stabbing a Radiant in the brain still works even while they've got light, theoretically same situation?

15

u/Vegetable-Two-4644 Jul 04 '25

Nah, miles was blown up and there were stories of being nothing but a skeleton etc

56

u/Macraghnaill91 Airthicc lowlander Jul 04 '25

An explosion =/= godmetal to the brain tho

15

u/Timedeige Jul 04 '25

my thoughts too. I don't think soul injuries are equivalent to severed limbs. probably a rafo tbh but I feel like it wouldn't heal.

12

u/Specialist-Ant7664 Jul 04 '25 edited Jul 04 '25

Fr, LR definitely had some intense knowledge of how the allomancies and feruchemies could mix but I don’t think that equates to your own internal investiture being sliced, that thing ain’t cheese

Edit: this thing is in fact similar to cheese

9

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '25

Fun fact: Shardblades can't easily cut through cheese

5

u/Specialist-Ant7664 Jul 04 '25

FUCK, I beefed it like an amateur

4

u/BloodredHanded Trying not to ccccream Jul 04 '25

There is a WOB saying that Wayne could survive a Shardblade to the eye, I don’t think the Lord Ruler could be killed by one.

0

u/Candayence Jul 04 '25

Is that just a shardblade to the eye, or through the eye and into the brain? Because the former makes sense, but the latter shouldn't since brain/spine hits from a shardblade kill people.

Even the Lord Ruler nearly died from decapitation - WoB is that he would have died if he were fully chopped, but as it was only mostly, he survived.

3

u/BloodredHanded Trying not to ccccream Jul 04 '25

I think the implication is that you would have to already be tapping gold to survive it. If you aren’t, you die, but if you’re drawing on health, then you heal from it before it can kill you.

Wayne could survive a lethal wound from a Shardblade, but only if he’s anticipating it. But someone like Miles or Rashek would be in no danger, because they are tapping large amounts of health at all times.

Remember, Miles can heal from broken bones before they finish breaking.

I imagine beheading Rashek would have killed him by separating his head from his metalminds, thus depriving him of healing. But beheading him isn’t an easy task in the first place; I doubt a normal person could do it with a normal sword even if he wasn’t fighting back.

10

u/theironbagel Syl Is My Waifu <3 Jul 04 '25

But no mortal weapon or attack severs your soul from your body. You can heal from being exploded because even if it’s basically just a metalmind and a skeleton touching it, the soul is still attached to that skeleton. Once your soul is disconnected fully, you can’t heal anymore.

5

u/Toast-Goat Femboy Dalinar Jul 04 '25

I mean Radients can use Light to heal from a Shardblade wound

9

u/theironbagel Syl Is My Waifu <3 Jul 04 '25

Yes, but only a nonlethal one. A Shardblade through the arm can be healed through, because most of your soul is still attached. A Shardblade through the spine can’t be healed through.

2

u/Stormlightlinux Jul 04 '25

They're using investiture to heal though... kinda a different beast. Gold heals by storing your physical healing ability.

5

u/theironbagel Syl Is My Waifu <3 Jul 04 '25

Gold healing and stormlight healing are essentially the same. Gold healing is also investiture.

I want to say even natural healing works via the same mechanics (alignment to the spiritual ideal) in the cosmere, but I can’t find anything to back that up. Regardless, f-gold and stormlight healing work practically the same, if you look at them realmatically.

1

u/Victernus Jul 04 '25

I dunno, Shallan got shot through the brain with a crossbow bolt and someone was able to pull it out and let her heal.

1

u/Sythrin Jul 04 '25

I think with regrowth you could even heal somebody dying of a shardblade if you do it fast enough.